An Extra Scoop

Welcome to the heart of Monticello, Indiana, a place where the simple pleasure of a perfectly crafted ice cream cone is more than just a treat—it's a community tradition. Nestled in this charming town is An Extra Scoop, a local gem that has been delighting residents with its high-quality, hand-dipped ice cream and a truly unique, welcoming atmosphere. While some might consider it a "hidden gem" due to its humble storefront, for those in the know, it's a go-to destination for a sweet escape. This isn't just another ice cream shop; it's a place where every visit feels like a special occasion, thanks to the commitment to fresh flavors, friendly service, and a warm, community-focused vibe.

The philosophy at An Extra Scoop is simple: provide the freshest, most delicious ice cream possible at a price that makes it an affordable luxury for everyone. For many locals, the quality and value are so exceptional that it's become a staple in their weekly routine. This isn't your average grocery store pint; it's a meticulously crafted dessert experience that changes regularly, ensuring there's always something new and exciting to try. From classic favorites to inventive new flavors that rotate weekly, the selection is designed to keep you coming back for "just one more scoop." The dedication to quality is evident in every spoonful, offering a richness and depth of flavor that can only come from a business that truly cares about its product. It’s this passion that has earned An Extra Scoop a loyal following and a reputation as one of the best spots for ice cream in Monticello.

Beyond the delicious ice cream, the shop’s charm comes from its heartfelt commitment to the customer experience. The owner, often seen working the counter, is known for her kindness and genuine interactions, making everyone who walks through the door feel like a friend. This personal touch is a hallmark of the business and a key reason why it has become such a beloved part of the Monticello community. It’s the kind of place where you’re not just a transaction; you’re a valued member of the An Extra Scoop family. The combination of exceptional quality, diverse offerings, and a truly welcoming environment makes it a must-visit spot for anyone in the area looking for a top-tier ice cream experience.

---

An Extra Scoop is conveniently located at 230 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960, USA, placing it right in the heart of the town’s main street. While its location is central, it's worth noting that its modest signage can make it easy to miss for first-time visitors or those passing through. This is part of its charm as a true local "hidden gem." For those in the Monticello area, reaching the shop is straightforward. It is situated on a primary thoroughfare, making it easily accessible whether you're driving, walking, or biking. Parking is typically available along the street, allowing for a quick and convenient stop. The central location also means it's a perfect destination after a day of exploring downtown Monticello or enjoying the nearby recreational activities. Its accessibility for both residents and visitors makes it an ideal spot to satisfy a sweet craving without any hassle.

---

An Extra Scoop offers a wide array of delicious services to cater to every kind of sweet tooth. The menu goes well beyond a simple scoop, providing a range of options to create the perfect dessert experience.

• Hand-Dipped, High-Quality Ice Cream: The cornerstone of the business, featuring an ever-changing selection of flavors that are fresh and rich.
• Weekly Rotating Flavors: The shop keeps its menu fresh and exciting by introducing different flavors nearly every week, encouraging repeat visits and new discoveries.
• Creative and Unique Dessert Items: The menu includes inventive treats like "nachos" (a customer favorite), which are a testament to the shop's creativity and commitment to offering more than just standard ice cream.
• Take-Home Pints: For those who can't get enough, the shop sells its incredible ice cream by the pint, allowing customers to enjoy the fresh flavors at home.
• Hot and Cold Sandwiches: While the ice cream is the star, the shop also provides a variety of café-style food options, including sandwiches, to create a well-rounded meal experience for those looking for a savory option.
• Toppings and Mix-ins: Customers can customize their desserts with a selection of sauces, candies, and other toppings to build their ideal ice cream creation.

The diverse menu, combining high-quality ice cream with other food and dessert options, ensures that An Extra Scoop has something for everyone, whether you're craving a traditional scoop or an innovative treat.

---

What truly sets An Extra Scoop apart from other establishments are the unique features that make it a local favorite.

• Unmatched Freshness: The ice cream is consistently praised for being the freshest around. This commitment to quality and freshness is a major reason why many locals have stopped buying store-bought ice cream in favor of An Extra Scoop's products.
• Support for a Local Artist: The shop features local artwork on its walls, which changes regularly, providing a beautiful and engaging backdrop for customers and highlighting the talents of a community artist.
• Friendly, Personal Service: The owner and staff are known for their warm, welcoming, and friendly demeanor. This personal touch creates a comfortable and inviting environment that makes every visit feel special.
• Unique "Nachos" Dessert: A standout menu item that showcases the shop's playful and creative side, delighting customers with an unconventional and delicious treat.
• Affordable Pricing: Despite the exceptional quality, the ice cream is offered at a very reasonable price, making it a regular indulgence for many in the community.
• Community-Focused Atmosphere: The shop has a quiet and comfortable environment, making it a great place to relax, chat, and connect with fellow residents.

These highlights collectively create a memorable experience that goes beyond the product itself, cementing An Extra Scoop's status as a cherished community hub.

---

To get in touch with An Extra Scoop or to plan your visit, use the following information:

Address: 230 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960, USA
Phone: (574) 240-1083

---

For the people of Monticello and the greater Indiana region, An Extra Scoop is more than just a place to get dessert; it's a cornerstone of the community. Its suitability for locals stems from a deep-seated commitment to quality, value, and personal connection. In an era of large, impersonal chains, An Extra Scoop offers a refreshing, authentic experience that feels both homegrown and special. The hand-dipped, high-quality ice cream is reason enough to visit, but the regularly changing menu keeps the experience fresh and exciting. Locals appreciate the effort put into sourcing and crafting flavors that are not only delicious but also distinct from anything they can find at a typical grocery store. This dedication to freshness and variety has created a loyal customer base that views the shop as an essential part of their town's identity.

Furthermore, the shop's friendly and professional atmosphere, led by an owner who genuinely cares, transforms a simple outing into a warm social experience. It's a place where you can feel at home, strike up a conversation, and enjoy a quiet moment. This sense of community is amplified by the shop's support for local artists, adding a cultural flair that enriches the entire neighborhood. The affordability of the products means that this delightful experience is accessible to everyone, making it a perfect spot for a family treat, a casual date, or a solo indulgence. Whether you're looking for a quick scoop after work, a pint to take home for the week, or a unique dessert like their famous "nachos," An Extra Scoop delivers on all fronts. For Monticello residents, it's not a secret anymore—it's a beloved tradition, and for anyone lucky enough to discover it, it quickly becomes their favorite spot for a scoop and a smile.

An Extra Scoop

230 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960, USA