Blue Moon

For generations of residents in Garrett, Indiana, and those throughout the surrounding regions, the arrival of warmer weather signals one thing: the seasonal opening of Blue Moon. Located at 4504 IN-327, Garrett, IN 46738, Blue Moon is far more than just an ice cream shop; it's a cherished local institution, a beacon of sweet and savory delights that has been serving the community since 1952. While it's certainly a go-to for frozen treats, Blue Moon has also earned a dedicated following for its unique hot food offerings, creating a diverse menu that appeals to a wide range of tastes.

Blue Moon's enduring popularity speaks volumes about its place in the heart of Indiana. It's a place where childhood memories are made, where families gather for an evening treat, and where the simple pleasure of a classic coney dog or a refreshing shake is savored. The anticipation surrounding its seasonal opening each year is a testament to its deep roots in the community and the consistent quality it delivers. While every establishment has its quirks and areas for improvement, Blue Moon's long-standing presence highlights its overall appeal and its success in becoming a beloved part of Garrett's local landscape.

This article aims to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Blue Moon, helping users in the Indiana region learn more about what makes this Garrett establishment a suitable and enjoyable stop. We'll delve into its location and accessibility, the variety of services offered, its distinctive features and highlights, and essential contact information, all to help you plan your visit to this unique local spot.

Blue Moon is strategically located at 4504 IN-327, Garrett, IN 46738, USA. Its position on State Road 327 places it prominently within Garrett, making it a recognizable and accessible destination for both local residents and those traveling through northeast Indiana. Being on a state road enhances its visibility and ease of access for customers from Auburn, Fort Wayne, and other nearby towns in the region.

However, it's important for visitors to be aware of the specific layout of the shop, particularly its drive-through setup. As noted by customer feedback, the shop is situated on a corner of a "super busy 4 way intersection," which can sometimes make pulling in a bit confusing, especially for first-time visitors. There appear to be multiple lanes for ordering, accommodating a potentially long line of cars. While this dual-lane system helps manage the often-high demand, new patrons should approach with a bit of caution to ensure they enter the correct ordering lane. Despite these navigational nuances, the consistent long lines of cars indicate that customers are willing to navigate the intersection for the beloved treats offered within.

It is also important to note that Blue Moon primarily operates as a drive-through or walk-up window service, with "no outside seating for this shop." This means that customers typically enjoy their treats in their vehicles or take them to a nearby park or home. Understanding this setup beforehand can help manage expectations for visitors planning their trip to this Garrett staple. The convenience of a drive-through, even with its unique entry points, makes it an ideal spot for a quick and satisfying stop on the go for Indiana locals.

Blue Moon offers a diverse menu that extends beyond typical ice cream parlor fare, combining classic frozen treats with beloved savory options. Here’s a closer look at what you can expect:

• Ice Cream: Blue Moon is, first and foremost, an ice cream shop. They offer classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and twist, as well as a "flavor of the week" to keep the options exciting. Portions are available in pints and quarts for take-home enjoyment.

• Milkshakes: A popular choice, their shakes are known for being "super thick." While one review mentioned minimal flavor, the thickness is often a highlight for shake lovers, suggesting a rich, creamy base that can be customized with various flavorings.

• Coney Dogs: A highly recommended savory item, the coney dog is a local favorite. These classic hot dogs are served with their "famous chili sauce." While one review noted a light amount of sauce, the option to add toppings like onion is available.

• Fried Cauliflower: This appears to be a signature item, even prompting drives from out of town. Despite mixed reviews regarding its consistency (some found it "burnt on half of the outside, yet somehow soggy/greasy on the inside"), another customer declared it "incredible" and a "must-have." Its unique presence on the menu makes it a distinctive offering.

• Other Savory Items: The menu also includes a range of other hot food items, such as hamburgers, cheeseburgers, crispy chicken, BBQ pork, fish sandwiches, grilled cheese, hot dogs, corn dogs, tenderloin, and an "Eclipse Burger" special. They also offer various baskets with fries and dipping sauces.

• Fries & Such: A selection of sides like French fries (shoestring and curly), onion rings, cheese sticks, fried mushrooms, zucchini, buffalo chips, and chili cheese fries are available to complement savory orders.

• Specialty Desserts: Beyond scoops and shakes, Blue Moon offers unique dessert creations like the "Upside Down Banana Split" and a "Tin Roof" sundae, providing more elaborate options for sweet indulgence.

• Pup Cups: For furry friends, Blue Moon even offers a "Pup Cup" – vanilla ice cream with a mini dog treat, showcasing their friendly and inclusive approach to all family members.

The combination of traditional ice cream treats and a robust savory menu makes Blue Moon a versatile destination for a quick meal or a satisfying dessert in Garrett, Indiana.

Blue Moon stands out in the Garrett, Indiana, area due to several distinctive features and highlights that contribute to its local appeal:

• Long-Standing Local Favorite: Operating since 1952, Blue Moon has deep roots in the community. This longevity signifies a consistent quality and beloved status that transcends fleeting trends, making it a familiar and trusted spot for generations of Indiana residents.

• Diverse Menu Beyond Ice Cream: Unlike many pure ice cream shops, Blue Moon offers a substantial savory menu. This includes "local favorite" coney dogs and the often-discussed "fried cauliflower," making it a versatile stop for a full meal or a snack before dessert. This dual offering broadens its appeal significantly.

• Famous Fried Cauliflower: Despite mixed individual experiences, the fried cauliflower generates significant buzz and is a reason some customers specifically seek out Blue Moon, indicating its status as a unique and memorable menu item.

• Fantastic Pricing: Customers consistently praise the "fantastic pricing," feeling that they get great value for their money. This affordability is a major draw, especially for families and those looking for an enjoyable treat without overspending.

• Efficient Dual Drive-Through: While the intersection setup can be tricky for newcomers, the presence of "two sides" taking orders suggests an efficient system for handling large volumes of customers, especially during busy periods. This helps reduce wait times, even with long lines.

• Seasonal Operation: Blue Moon operates seasonally, which often adds to its charm and anticipation. The limited availability makes its opening a celebrated event each year, fostering a sense of tradition and specialness for the community.

• Kid-Friendly Offerings: The presence of menu items like corn dogs, chicken strips, and especially the "Pup Cup" for dogs, highlights Blue Moon's family-friendly approach, making it a welcoming spot for all members of the household.

To plan your visit or inquire further about Blue Moon’s seasonal hours and offerings, you can use the following contact details:

• Address: 4504 IN-327, Garrett, IN 46738, USA

• Phone: (260) 357-5050

Given its seasonal nature, it is highly recommended to check their operating schedule, particularly at the beginning or end of their season, to ensure they are open when you plan to visit. Information regarding their current hours can often be found through their social media pages or by calling directly.

For residents across Indiana, and particularly within the Garrett area, Blue Moon holds a special place that extends beyond its menu. Its suitability for locals is deeply rooted in its long history, diverse offerings, and unique operational style, making it a truly integral part of the community fabric.

Firstly, Blue Moon's status as a local favorite "since 1952" speaks volumes. This longevity means it has served generations of families, becoming a consistent and comforting presence in their lives. It's a place associated with summer traditions, family outings, and simple pleasures, fostering a strong sense of nostalgia and community pride. For Indiana locals, supporting Blue Moon is not just about getting a meal or a dessert; it’s about participating in a cherished local tradition.

Secondly, the combination of traditional ice cream delights with a substantial hot food menu sets Blue Moon apart. This versatility means it can satisfy a wider array of cravings, from a classic shake to a savory coney dog or even the famously debated fried cauliflower. This makes it a convenient one-stop shop for a full meal or a quick snack, catering to diverse needs within a single visit, which is highly valued by busy local families. The "fantastic pricing" further enhances its appeal, ensuring that quality treats and meals are accessible to everyone.

Lastly, while its drive-through setup and busy intersection might present a minor navigational challenge for some, the consistent long lines are a clear testament to its popularity and the willingness of locals to embrace its unique quirks. These elements, rather than detracting from its appeal, often contribute to its character and identity as a beloved local spot. For anyone in Indiana seeking a taste of local history, great value, and a diverse menu that goes beyond expectations, Blue Moon in Garrett is an essential and suitable destination, offering a genuine slice of small-town Indiana charm.

Blue Moon

4504 IN-327, Garrett, IN 46738, USA