Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor

For those of us in Ohio who appreciate truly exceptional frozen treats, a visit to Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor in Andover, Ashtabula County, is an absolute must. Tucked away on Public Square, this charming local establishment has earned a stellar reputation for serving "really, really good ice cream" that consistently impresses even the most discerning ice cream connoisseurs. It’s the kind of place that, once you discover it, quickly moves to the top of your list for satisfying those sweet cravings, especially on a hot summer day. Bonnie Lee Creamery isn't just selling ice cream; they're crafting an experience that keeps locals coming back for more, time and again.

Our pride in local businesses runs deep here in Ohio, and Bonnie Lee Creamery perfectly embodies the quality and dedication we look for. Reviewers consistently highlight the exceptional flavors, noting how "perfectly balanced and true to their names" they are. This attention to detail, from classic combinations to unique creations, speaks volumes about the care put into every scoop. The consistent positive feedback suggests a commitment to excellence that elevates it above many other ice cream shops, making it a true gem in our community.

Beyond the fantastic flavors, the overall atmosphere and value contribute to its appeal. Described as "adorable, and affordable," Bonnie Lee Creamery offers a delightful setting where families can enjoy a sweet treat without breaking the bank. The fact that "many sizes are available" ensures that everyone, from kiddos to adults, can find just the right portion. For us Ohioans, finding a spot that combines delicious products, a welcoming ambiance, and great value is a win-win, and Bonnie Lee Creamery truly delivers on all fronts, making it a beloved destination for a sweet escape.

Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor is conveniently located at 54 Public Sq, Andover, OH 44003, USA. Public Square is often a central and easily recognizable area in many Ohio towns, making this location highly accessible for residents of Andover and the surrounding communities within Ashtabula County. Its position in a town's main square typically means it's part of a walkable area, and often serves as a focal point for local activities.

The accessibility of this ice cream parlor is a significant advantage for our local Ohio patrons. Being on Public Square suggests a prominent and easy-to-find spot, whether you're driving or enjoying a stroll through the town. While specific parking details aren't provided in the reviews, locations on public squares in smaller towns usually offer convenient street parking or nearby public lots. This ease of access contributes to the "must visit" status, as it's not hidden away and is simple to integrate into an outing or a casual drive.

Operating hours are also a factor in accessibility. While not explicitly stated in the provided reviews, local ice cream parlors typically operate during extended hours in warmer months to accommodate peak demand. Being a cherished local spot, Bonnie Lee Creamery is likely to have hours that cater to families and individuals looking for an afternoon pick-me-up or an evening dessert. The overall location makes it a pleasant and straightforward destination for anyone in the Andover area craving "really, really good ice cream."

Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor is celebrated for its exceptional ice cream and a focus on delightful flavors. While a comprehensive menu isn't explicitly detailed, the reviews highlight several key offerings and services:

• Premium Quality Ice Cream: This is their core offering, with a strong emphasis on "really, really good ice cream" and flavors that are "perfectly balanced and true to their names." This suggests a commitment to high-quality ingredients and careful preparation.
• Variety of Unique Flavors: Customers sampled and praised distinct flavors such as Amaretto Cherry, PB Brownies, Lemon Cheesecake, and Key Lime Pie. This indicates a creative and diverse flavor rotation beyond standard options.
• Traditional Ice Cream Scoops: Available in "many sizes," catering to different appetites and preferences, from a small treat for kiddos to larger servings for adults.
• Homemade Waffle Cones (Implied): While not directly from the reviews, external information suggests they are known for "Delicious Homemade Waffle Cones," which would significantly enhance the ice cream experience.
• Affordable Treats: Despite the high quality, the ice cream is noted as "affordable," providing excellent value for families and individuals.
• Kid-Friendly Options: The mention of "kiddos loved the O-O-Oreo ice cream" highlights their appeal to younger customers, with flavors designed to delight children.
• Seasonal/Rotating Flavors: The specific and unique flavors mentioned suggest that they likely have a rotating selection, encouraging repeat visits to try new creations.

Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor stands out as a top destination in Ohio due to several key features and highlights that are consistently praised by its delighted customers:

• Exceptional Ice Cream Quality: This is the paramount highlight. Reviewers use strong superlatives like "really, really good ice cream," and place it "at the top of my list." This speaks to the premium quality, rich texture, and satisfying taste of their product.
• Perfectly Balanced and True-to-Name Flavors: Customers emphasize that the "flavors in each one were perfectly balanced and true to their names." This attention to accurate and harmonious flavor profiles, such as Amaretto Cherry, PB Brownies, Lemon Cheesecake, and Key Lime Pie, is a significant draw.
• Delicious and Unique Flavor Selection: The presence of creative and distinctive flavors like Key Lime Pie (an "absolute hit!") and O-O-Oreo (loved by "kiddos") demonstrates a commitment to offering exciting and memorable options beyond the basics.
• Affordable Pricing: Despite the high quality, the ice cream is described as "affordable," making it an accessible indulgence for a wide range of customers, including families. This value proposition is highly appreciated.
• Adorable and Welcoming Atmosphere: The parlor itself is called "adorable," suggesting a charming and pleasant environment that enhances the overall experience, making it a nice place to relax and enjoy a treat.
• Suitable for Hot Summer Days: Explicitly mentioned as "A sweet place for hot summer days," highlighting its role as a perfect spot for cooling down and enjoying refreshing desserts during Ohio's warm months.
• Variety of Sizes Available: The fact that "Many sizes are available" ensures that customers can choose the perfect portion, whether it’s a small treat for a child or a larger serving for an adult.
• High Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty: The enthusiastic reviews, with customers declaring it a "must visit destination" and placing it "at the top of my list," reflect strong customer loyalty and a consistently positive experience.

For those in Ohio eager to visit Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor and indulge in their highly praised frozen delights, or if you need to inquire about their daily flavor specials or operating hours, here is their contact information:

Address:
54 Public Sq, Andover, OH 44003, USA

Phone:
(440) 841-1260

Mobile Phone:
+1 440-841-1260

As with many local businesses, especially those that might have seasonal variations in hours or rotating flavors, it's always a good practice for us Ohioans to call ahead before your visit. This ensures you have the most current information directly from the friendly staff at Bonnie Lee Creamery, making your trip as smooth and enjoyable as possible.

Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor is an absolute gem that is perfectly suited for us Ohioans, particularly for those in and around Ashtabula County. Its suitability stems from a combination of exceptional product quality, charming local appeal, and a commitment to customer satisfaction that truly resonates with our community values.

Firstly, the paramount reason is the ice cream itself. Descriptions like "really, really good," "delicious," and "perfectly balanced and true to their names" are not hyperbolic for this establishment. We Ohioans appreciate genuine quality, and Bonnie Lee Creamery delivers on that promise, offering flavors that are both innovative and incredibly satisfying. The consistent praise for unique options such as Amaretto Cherry, PB Brownies, Lemon Cheesecake, and Key Lime Pie highlights a level of craftsmanship that sets it apart from typical ice cream shops.

Secondly, its location on Public Square in Andover provides that quintessential small-town charm that many of us cherish. It's an "adorable" place that offers a comfortable and inviting atmosphere, making it ideal for a leisurely treat. This local setting, combined with the "affordable" pricing and "many sizes available," makes it an excellent choice for families seeking a delightful and budget-friendly outing. It’s the kind of spot where lasting summer memories are made, embodying the wholesome experiences we seek in our local communities.

Finally, the overwhelming sentiment from customers that it's a "must visit destination" and "well worth the visit" reinforces its standing as a truly valuable local business. For us Ohioans who take pride in supporting establishments that excel in their craft and provide a welcoming experience, Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor is a clear winner. It's more than just a place to get ice cream; it's a destination that promises a consistently delicious and enjoyable experience, solidifying its place as a beloved part of our local landscape.

Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor

54 Public Sq, Andover, OH 44003, USA