Byrne Dairy: Your Local Go-To for Ice Cream, Pizza, and More in Canandaigua, NY

Byrne Dairy Introduce

For residents of Canandaigua and surrounding areas in the New York region, Byrne Dairy at 201 West Ave is far more than just an ice cream shop; it's a quintessential local convenience store, deli, and a beloved spot for a wide range of quick, satisfying meals and treats. Byrne Dairy has established itself as a reliable hub for everyday needs and delicious indulgences, from its signature "Mighty Fine Ice Cream" to hot, fresh pizza and a variety of deli offerings. It’s a place where friendly faces, quick service, and a diverse selection of products come together to create a true neighborhood staple. Whether you're fueling up your car, grabbing a last-minute dinner, or satisfying a sweet craving, this Byrne Dairy location embodies the convenience and community spirit that locals appreciate in the vibrant New York landscape.

---

Location and Accessibility

Byrne Dairy in Canandaigua is strategically located at 201 West Ave, Canandaigua, NY 14424, USA. This accessible address places it conveniently within the city, making it a straightforward stop for both local residents and those passing through the area. The store operates with 24-hour availability, offering unparalleled convenience for early morning commuters, late-night snack seekers, or anyone needing essentials at any time.

The layout of the store is designed for ease of access, with the entrance to the ice cream shop typically facing the street, ensuring it’s easily identifiable for those specifically seeking a frozen treat. Meanwhile, the main entrance to the diner and deli section is located on the side, adjacent to the parking lot. This thoughtful separation helps manage customer flow, especially during peak hours. Ample parking is available for customers, further enhancing its accessibility. Beyond in-person visits, for those who prefer, Byrne Dairy also offers online ordering and delivery services through platforms like DoorDash, providing another layer of convenience for the New York community.

---

Services Offered

Ice Cream: Byrne Dairy is well-known for its "Mighty Fine Ice Cream" brand, offering a wide array of flavors in both hard and soft serve options. Flavors include popular choices like Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Mint Chocolate Chip, Cookies-N-Cream, Cookie Dough, and more unique options like Black Raspberry, Holy Cow, Espress-Dough, and Maine Blueberry.
Ice Cream Specialties: Beyond scoops, they offer a range of ice cream specialties including shakes (Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Chocolate Peanut Butter, etc.), flurries with various candy mix-ins (Butterfinger, Oreo, M&M's), sundaes (Hot Fudge, Strawberry Banana, Brownie Sundae, etc.), banana splits, ice cream floats, and even unique items like "Pup Ice Cream Cups" for canine companions. They also offer "Cookiewich" varieties, which are ice cream sandwiches.
Pizza: A significant offering at Byrne Dairy is its freshly baked pizza, available by the slice or as whole pies. Popular options include Cheese, Garlic, Breakfast Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Meat Lovers, Supreme, and Veggie Lovers.
Deli and Sandwiches: The store features a comprehensive deli, serving "Giant Deli Sandwiches or Subs" with a wide selection of meats (Turkey, Roast Beef, Ham, Italian, Pastrami, Corned Beef, Salami, Capicola, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Egg Salad, BLT, Veggie) and bread choices. Wraps are also available.
Fried Food: Customers can find various fried food options, including Chicken Tenders, French Fries, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Sandwiches (regular and spicy), and Cheeseburger sliders.
Breakfast Items: For morning commuters, Byrne Dairy offers a range of breakfast options like breakfast pizzas, hash browns, and breakfast sandwiches (Ham, Egg and Cheese; Veggie, Egg and Cheese; Bacon, Egg and Cheese; Sausage, Egg and Cheese) on croissants.
Beverages and Essentials: As a convenience store, it provides fountain drinks, frozen drinks, and various other beverages. It also offers typical convenience store items, including gas, an ATM, and lottery services.
Shelby's Donuts: Many Byrne Dairy locations, including this one, feature Shelby's Donuts, offering freshly baked donuts and cookies from Byrne Dairy's own bakery.

---

Features / Highlights

24-Hour Operation: The Canandaigua Byrne Dairy is open 24 hours a day, seven days a week, providing unmatched convenience for customers at any time of day or night. This is a significant advantage for locals with varying schedules.
Diverse Menu Beyond Ice Cream: While known for its ice cream, a major highlight is the extensive menu of hot food, including popular pizza (available by the slice), deli sandwiches, and fried items. This makes it a versatile stop for a full meal or a quick snack.
"Mighty Fine Ice Cream" Selection: The wide variety of Byrne Dairy's own "Mighty Fine Ice Cream" flavors, including both hard and soft serve, appeals to all ice cream lovers. The availability of various sundaes, shakes, and ice cream sandwiches further enhances the offering.
Friendly and Hardworking Staff: Many customers praise the staff, specifically mentioning individuals like Jean, Debbie, and Alex, for their hard work, attentiveness, and friendly service. The positive attitude of employees, even during busy times, is a recurring theme in reviews.
Cleanliness of the Store: The overall cleanliness of the store is noted as "sublime," contributing to a pleasant shopping and dining environment for patrons. While bathrooms might need more frequent checks, the general upkeep is highly regarded.
"Home Byrne" Feel: For former employees and long-time customers, the store has a "home Byrne" feeling, indicating a strong sense of community and loyalty cultivated over time. This reflects its deep integration into the local fabric.
Comprehensive Convenience: Beyond food, the store offers gas, an ATM, and lottery services, truly functioning as a one-stop-shop for many daily needs, saving locals time and effort.

---

Contact Information

Address: 201 West Ave, Canandaigua, NY 14424, USA

Phone: (585) 469-7147

---

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

Byrne Dairy at 201 West Ave in Canandaigua is an indispensable establishment for locals in the New York region, serving as a pillar of convenience and a reliable source for a wide array of products and services. Its 24-hour operation is a massive advantage, ensuring that residents always have access to essentials, hot meals, and delightful treats, no matter the time of day or night. This round-the-clock availability is a testament to its commitment to serving the community's diverse needs.

Beyond its extensive operating hours, locals benefit from the incredible variety of offerings. From a quick, satisfying slice of pizza or a custom-made deli sandwich to a refreshing scoop of "Mighty Fine Ice Cream" or a delicious breakfast item, Byrne Dairy caters to every craving. This versatility means that a single stop can cover multiple needs, from a morning coffee to a late-night snack or even filling up the gas tank. The consistent praise for the hardworking and friendly staff, like Jean, Debbie, and Alex, underscores the welcoming atmosphere that makes regular visits enjoyable and personal. Despite occasional minor service issues or concerns over specific food portions, the overall positive experience and the store's dedication to cleanliness contribute significantly to its high regard within the community. For New Yorkers in Canandaigua, Byrne Dairy isn't just a store; it's a dependable, friendly, and essential part of their daily lives, truly earning its place as a "home Byrne."

Byrne Dairy Services

All Day - Giant Deli Sandwiches or Subs
Whole Keegan $11.49
Can't decide? Try our delightful freshly-sliced roast beef on white Deli bread topped with American cheese, Hellman's mayo and tomatoes.
Whole Salami $11.49
Our beyond enjoyable Giant Deli Salami sandwich which features freshly sliced premium salami piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Whole Tuna Salad $11.49
Love tuna salad? You can't go wrong with this sandwich! Freshly made tuna salad on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy every bite.
Whole Corned Beef $11.49
Mix things up with the Corned Beef Giant Deli sandwich. Topped with freshly sliced corned beef, your choice of Deli bread, toppings, cheese and sauce!
Whole Ham $11.49
Looking for a classic? You won't go wrong with our Ham Giant Deli sandwich. Freshly sliced ham, Deli bread, your choice of toppings, and your favorite sauce!
Whole BLT $11.49
The BLT Giant Deli sandwich loaded with bacon, lettuce, and tomato is a Byrne Dairy & Deli customer favorite. Add your choice of toppings and sauces to make it your favorite today!
Whole Roast Beef $11.49
The Roast Beef Giant Deli sandwich features premium, freshly sliced roast beef, your choice of Deli bread, and toppings. Made just the way you like it!
Whole Turkey $11.49
A fan favorite, our Turkey Giant Deli Sandwich features freshly sliced premium turkey breast piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Whole Egg Salad $11.49
Our Egg Salad Giant Deli sandwich is a great choice. Go ahead and add your favorite toppings, choose your Deli bread and there you have it! The best egg salad sandwich out there!
Whole Capicola $11.49
The Capicola Giant Deli sandwich is made with our delicious freshly sliced capicola, on your choice of Deli bread topped with all of your favorite fixings!
Whole Chicken Salad $11.49
You can't go wrong with our delicious Chicken Salad Giant Deli sandwich. This sandwich features freshly made premium chicken salad piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Whole Veggie $11.49
Pile the veggies on any way you want on the Veggie Giant Deli sandwich! Your choice of Deli bread, and any cheese or sauce you want!
Whole Italian $11.49
Our Italian Giant Deli sandwich features freshly sliced premium salami and capicola piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Whole Pastrami $11.49
The Pastrami Giant Deli sandwich is packed full with freshly sliced pastrami, your choice of Deli bread, toppings, cheese and sauce to enjoy just how you want it!

All Day - Paninis
Turkey Club Panini $10.99
Our delicious panini bread toasted to perfection and made with cheese, turkey and crisped bacon.
Hot Italian Panini $10.99
Our delicious panini bread toasted to perfection and made with provolone cheese, salami and capicola.
Beef & Cheddar Panini $10.99
Our delicious panini bread toasted to perfection and made with shredded cheddar cheese and roast beef.
Southwest Turkey & Bacon Panini $10.99
Our delicious panini bread toasted to perfection and made with southwest chipotle sauce, pepperjack cheese, turkey and bacon.
Grilled Cheese Panini $7.99
Our delicious panini bread toasted to perfection and made with your choice of cheese!
Tuna Melt Panini $10.99
Our delicious panini bread toasted to perfection and made with American cheese and tuna.
Steak & Cheese Panini $10.99
Our delicious panini bread filled with shaved steak, cheese then toasted to perfection .
Ham & Cheese Panini $10.99
Our delicious panini bread filled with sliced Ham, cheese then toasted to perfection .

All Day - Salad
Antipasto $7.99
Arcadian Lettuce, Cucumber, Green Pepper, Tomatoes, Banana Peppers, Olives, Onions, Salami, Pepperoni, and Provolone Cheese. Your choice of dressing.
Chef $7.99
Arcadian Lettuce, Cucumber, Tomatoes, Green Pepper, Ham, Turkey and Shredded Cheddar Cheese. Your choice of dressing.
Garden $7.99
Arcadian Lettuce, Cucumber, Tomatoes, and Green Pepper. Your choice of dressing.
Chicken Cobb $7.99
Arcadian Lettuce, Cucumber, Green Pepper, Tomatoes, Chicken Strips, Bacon Crumbles, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, and a Hardboiled Egg. Your choice of dressing.

All Day - Sides
Utz 2. 8 Oz Chips $2.89
Sour Cream and Onion, Ripple, Salt and Vinegar, Honey BBQ
Chocolate Chunk Cookie $1.59
A classic favorite, baked fresh with chunks of delicious chocolate

All Day - Chicken Wings
Wings (20) $25.99
Buffalo Sauce (Mild, Medium, Hot), Garlic Sauce, BBQ Sauce
Wings (10) $15.79
Buffalo Sauce (Mild, Medium, Hot), Garlic Sauce, BBQ Sauce
Wings (5) $9.59
Buffalo Sauce (Mild, Medium, Hot), Garlic Sauce, BBQ Sauce

All Day - Fresh Wraps
Egg Salad Wrap $7.99
Our Egg Salad wrap is packed full with flavorful egg salad. Select your wrap, add your choice of vegetables and sauce and enjoy!
Chicken Salad Wrap $7.99
Pick this wrap and you wont regret it! You will enjoy every bite of our Chicken Salad wrap. Loaded with chicken salad and your favorite toppings.
Ham Wrap $7.99
Looking for a classic? You wont go wrong with our Ham wrap. Freshly sliced ham, your choice of wrap, toppings, and your favorite sauce!
Turkey Wrap $7.99
Looking for a classic wrap? You won't go wrong with our Turkey wrap! A fan favorite, featuring our freshly sliced premium turkey breast on your choice of a delicious wrap. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Capicola Wrap $7.99
Mix things up with the Capicola wrap. Made with our freshly shaved capicola, on your choice of wrap filled with all of your favorite toppings.
Corned Beef Wrap $7.99
The Corned Beef wrap is filled with delicious freshly sliced corned beef. You can't go wrong with this wrap! Select your choice of wrap, toppings and sauce.
Salami Wrap $7.99
Our beyond enjoyable Salami wrap which features freshly sliced premium Salami piled high onto your choice of wrap. Just pick your favorite cheese, toppings, sauce and enjoy.
Pastrami Wrap $7.99
Choose your favorite wrap, filled with freshly sliced savory pastrami and loaded with your favorite toppings.
BLT Wrap $7.99
You can't go wrong with a BLT. Select your wrap, filled with delicious bacon, lettuce and tomato, add your toppings and sauces and you're all set!
Roast Beef Wrap $7.99
Made with premium, freshly shaved roast beef. Your choice of a delicious wrap, and toppings. Made just the way you like it!
Italian Wrap $7.99
The Italian wrap features freshly sliced premium salami and capicola in your choice of wrap. Add your favorite cheese, toppings and sauce!
Tuna Salad Wrap $7.99
Be sure to try our tasty Tuna Salad wrap! Select your wrap, filled with tuna salad and your choice of fixings to go along with it! Take a bite and enjoy

All Day - Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $21.99
Combination of grilled chicken and mozzarella on top of a bed of ranch dressing, topped with crispy, crumbled bacon and even more ranch dressing.
Veggie Lovers Pizza $21.99
A classic cheese pizza with green peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms. Choose from our tomato sauce or our signature garlic sauce.
Meat Lovers Pizza $21.99
Our classic cheese pizza topped with pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $21.99
Made with chunks of grilled chicken, shredded mozzarella cheese, Buffalo hot sauce and bleu cheese.
Breakfast Pizza $21.99
A breakfast like no other! Scrambled eggs with shredded cheddar and mozzarella cheeses. Your choice of meat: Bacon, Sausage or Ham.
Supreme Pizza $21.99
A little bit of everything! Pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms and green peppers.
Cheese Pizza $13.79
Our freshly baked traditional favorite pizza, made with our signature crust, marinara sauce and premium mozzarella cheese. Select your favorite toppings for an additional $2.69 each.
Garlic Pizza $13.79
Our signature crust, smothered with our garlic sauce and topped with shredded mozzarella cheese
Cheese Sheet Pizza $27.99
Our freshly baked sheet pizza, made with our signature crust, marinara sauce and premium mozzarella cheese. Select your favorite toppings for an additional $3.99 each.
Breakfast Sheet Pizza $34.49
Scrambled eggs with shredded cheddar and mozzarella cheeses all on a crust flavored with our garlic butter spread. Price includes your choice of meat topping: Bacon, Ham or Sausage. Then add on any additional toppings for $3.99 each!

All Day - Drinks
Gatorade 28oz $3.69
Your choice of: Lemon Lime, Cool Blue, Orange, Glacier Freeze, Fruit Punch, Fierce Grape
Monster 15.5 - 16oz $3.79
Your choice of: Monster Energy, Monster energy ultra violet, Monster Energy Ultra Sunrise, Monster Energy Zero Ultra, Monster Ultra Paradise, Monster Energy Pipeline Punch, Monster Juice Mango Loco, Monster Energy Lo Carb, Monster zero sugar, Monster ultra strawberry dreams, Monster Rehab, Monster rehab Peach tea, Monster rehab wild berry
2 Liter Soda $3.89
Your choice of: Coke, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi or Mountain Dew
20oz Soda $3.19
Your choice of: Coke, Diet Coke, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi or Mountain Dew
Poland Spring 24oz Water $2.49
Poland Spring 24oz water
Smart Water 33.8oz $3.99
Every drop tastes pure and will leave you feeling refreshed.

All Day - ALLERGEN STATEMENT
ALLERGEN STATEMENT $0.00
If you have a food allergy, please notify us. Byrne Dairy strives to achieve the highest quality in cleanliness and food safety. Unfortunately, due to the nature of production, we cannot guarantee that our products are free from food allergens. Our products may contain cereals containing gluten and their products, namely, wheat, rye, barley, oats, and their hybridized strains; crustacean, fish, and shellfish derivatives; dairy and dairy derivatives (including lactose); egg and egg derivatives; honey and bee products (including royal jelly); peanuts and peanut derivatives; sesame and sesame derivatives; soy and soy derivatives; tree nuts and tree nut derivatives; seeds including cotton, poppy, sunflower, and safflower; and sulfates – added (>10mg/kg). Additional nutritional information is available upon request. 2000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs may vary. All prices subject to change without notice.

All Day - Half Size Giant Deli sandwiches or Subs
Half Keegan $7.99
Can't decide? Try our delightful freshly-sliced roast beef on white Deli bread topped with American cheese, Hellman's mayo and tomatoes.
Half Turkey $7.99
A fan favorite, featuring freshly sliced premium turkey breast piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Half Roast Beef $7.99
Made with premium, freshly sliced roast beef. Your choice of Deli bread, and toppings. Made just the way you like it!
Half Ham $7.99
Looking for a classic? You wont go wrong with our Ham Giant Deli sandwich. Freshly sliced ham, Deli bread, your choice of toppings, and your favorite sauce!
Half Italian $7.99
Our Italian Giant Deli sandwich features freshly sliced premium salami and capicola piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings, sauce and enjoy!
Half Salami $7.99
Our beyond enjoyable Giant Deli Salami sandwich which features freshly sliced premium salami piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Half BLT $7.99
The BLT Giant Deli sandwich loaded with bacon, lettuce, and tomato is a Byrne Dairy & Deli customer favorite. Add your choice of toppings and sauces to make it your favorite today!
Half Pastrami $7.99
The Pastrami Giant Deli sandwich is packed full with freshly sliced pastrami, your choice of Deli bread, toppings, cheese and sauce to enjoy just how you want it!
Half Corned Beef $7.99
Mix things up with the Corned Beef Giant Deli sandwich. Topped with freshly sliced corned beef, your choice of Deli bread, toppings, cheese and sauce!
Half Capicola $7.99
The Capicola Giant Deli sandwich is made with our delicious freshly sliced capicola, on your choice of Deli bread, topped with all of your favorite fixings!
Half Egg Salad $7.99
Our Egg Salad Giant Deli sandwich is a great choice. Go ahead and add your favorite toppings, choose your Deli bread and there you have it! The best egg salad sandwich out there!
Half Veggie $7.99
Pile the veggies on any way you want on the Veggie Giant Deli sandwich! Your choice of Deli bread, and any cheese or sauce you want!
Half Chicken Salad $7.99
You can't go wrong with our delicious Chicken Salad Giant Deli sandwich. This sandwich features freshly made premium chicken salad piled high on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
Half Tuna Salad $7.99
Love tuna salad? You can't go wrong with this sandwich! Freshly made tuna salad on your choice of Deli bread. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy every bite.

All Day - Hot Sandwich
Reuben- Whole Sandwich $11.99
Our specialty Reuben sandwich layered with tender corned beef, swiss cheese, Russian dressing and sauerkraut on toasted dark rye Deli bread.
Reuben Half Sandwich $8.59
Our specialty Reuben sandwich layered with tender corned beef, swiss cheese, Russian dressing and sauerkraut on toasted dark rye Deli bread.

All Day - Breakfast
Sausage , Egg And Cheese On A Croissant $4.29
Sausage, Egg and american cheese on a delicious croissant
Bacon. Egg And Cheese On A Croissant $4.29
Bacon, egg and american cheese on a delicious croissant
Ham, Egg And Cheese On A Croissant $4.29
Sliced Ham, egg and american cheese on a delicious croissant
Veggie, Egg And Cheese On A Croissant $4.29
Spinach, onion, green pepper, Egg patty, american cheese on a delicious croissant
Hashbrowns $1.29

All Day - Chicken Sand/Burgers/Fries
Spicy Chicken Sandwich $4.99
A spicy breaded chicken patty deep fried then topped with pepperjack cheese and served on a brioche roll
Cheeseburger Slider $2.99
Our Cheeseburger slider is topped with american cheese and served on a delicious slider bun
Chicken Sandwich $4.99
A breaded chicken patty deep fried then topped with American cheese served on a brioche roll
French Fries $2.39
Chicken Tenders $6.99
Mozzarella Sticks $5.99
Try our deep fried Mozzarella sticks and choose your favorite dipping sauce!

Byrne Dairy Details

Service options
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Byrne Dairy Photos

Byrne Dairy Location

Byrne Dairy

New York Ontario County Canandaigua West Avenue

201 West Ave, Canandaigua, NY 14424, USA

Byrne Dairy Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 102 user reviews.

gaspricespizzamilk

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Shout out to Jean, Debbie, Alex & all the team here at Canandaigua. They are hard workers who pay attention to all of our needs. When it comes towards food service, they serve with a smile, even when the pizza slices may not be up to par.The cleanliness of the store is sublime, although the bathrooms could use a few more lookovers every couple hours. In all, though, I'm happy to call this Byrne Dairy my home Byrne as one of its former employees 🫶🏼
July 26 · Bradley Ward
Is this really the slice of pizza I'm supposed to be paying $3 for? Kind of ridiculous, definitely need to work on portion sizes. Cashier gave the wrong slice of pizza. She gave sausage when it was supposed to be bacon. When asked to correct the mistake she rolled her eyes and was extremely rude. Stated "well we can't take it back" that's fine because all I wanted was a switch. I'm not going to pay another $3 for your employees mistakes.
September 15 · Bee
Fast, efficient and friendly staff
June 28 · ............
Every time we stop we are so impressed with the staff. They are kind and helpful. The sandwiches have always been excellent!
August 21 · Ellen Munger
Girl in deli was EXTREMELY rude. The 4 of us felt like we were burdening her when we wanted to order something to eat. She had to be pulled from the back to come up to serve us and was NOT happy about it. When we reluctantly started our order she went to see if anything we were ordering was in the "warming tray"... we said never mind and walked out!
June 26 · Jessica Ornce