Cake and Cone

Established in 1954, Cake and Cone has a long-standing history as a cherished local dessert shop in East Rutherford, New Jersey. This beloved mom-and-pop establishment has been serving the community for over 60 years, building a reputation for its commitment to homemade ice cream and friendly service. Originally operating as an ice cream stand, it has evolved into a go-to destination for anyone in the area looking for a high-quality frozen treat. The shop embodies a sense of nostalgia, offering a taste of a classic ice cream parlor experience that feels both timeless and comforting. This is a place where every scoop is made with care, and the focus is on providing a simple, yet profoundly delicious, product.

The core of Cake and Cone's appeal is its fantastic ice cream, both soft and hard-serve, which is made with love and the finest ingredients right on the premises. Customer reviews consistently praise the "creamy and delicious" quality of the ice cream, with one reviewer calling it "hands down... the best ice cream in the area." While the classic soft-serve is a popular choice, the homemade hard ice cream is where the shop truly shines. The menu features a wide variety of flavors, including fan favorites like Cookies and Cream, Nutella, and Cookie Dough. One particular flavor that garners rave reviews is the "Salted Monster," a delicious blend of salted caramel and cookies that is highly recommended as a "MUST try." This commitment to unique and indulgent flavor combinations, alongside classic staples, ensures that every visit is an exciting culinary adventure.

Beyond the excellent ice cream, Cake and Cone offers a full-service dessert experience. The staff is frequently noted for providing "super quick and good service," adding to the welcoming atmosphere. The shop's charm is enhanced by its physical layout, which includes a place to sit in the back. While some customers prefer to take their ice cream to go, the availability of seating provides a nice option for those who wish to linger and enjoy their treats. However, it's worth noting some customer observations regarding service during peak hours. One review mentioned a "long line and only one person serving," suggesting that the shop could benefit from having two windows open during busy times. Another reviewer noted a slight disappointment with the "butter pecan did not have many nuts in it," which points to potential inconsistencies in specific flavor recipes. Despite these minor issues, the overall consensus is that the quality and experience are well worth it, and the prices are considered "reasonable" for the high-quality product.

Cake and Cone is situated at 306 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA. This location places it in a convenient spot within the community, making it easily accessible for residents of East Rutherford and neighboring towns. Paterson Avenue is a well-traveled street, and the shop's position makes it a simple stop for those driving by. The shop is noted for having parking spaces, which is a great convenience, especially during busy hours. For those who prefer to walk or use public transportation, the shop's location is within walking distance of bus stops, further enhancing its accessibility. Its role as a community staple is reinforced by its location on a recognizable and central street, making it a natural gathering point.

Cake and Cone provides a comprehensive menu of dessert items, catering to a wide range of tastes with a focus on fresh, homemade quality.

• Homemade Hard and Soft Ice Cream: The primary offering, with a diverse selection of flavors for both types of ice cream.
• Specialty Sundaes: The shop is known for its creative sundaes, including popular options like the Fried Oreo Sundae and the Fried Nutter Butter Sundae.
• Ice Cream Cakes: All ice cream cakes are homemade with love and can be customized with a choice of two flavors and a personalized message for any occasion.
• Shakes and Malts: A variety of shakes made with your choice of hard or soft ice cream, along with classic malt shakes.
• Other Frozen Treats: The menu also includes Italian ices, slushies, and frozen yogurt.
• Unique Snacks: Customers can find unique fried treats like fried Oreos and fried Nutter Butters, which are a fun and decadent addition to the menu.

What makes Cake and Cone a standout establishment are its key features that have earned it a loyal following.

• Handmade Quality: The commitment to homemade ice cream and cakes ensures a superior product that tastes fresh and rich.
• Iconic Flavors: The shop is celebrated for its unique and delicious flavors, with the "Salted Monster" being a particular highlight and a must-try for new customers.
• Reasonable Pricing: As noted in a customer review, the prices are considered reasonable for the high quality and generous portions of the ice cream.
• Friendly Service: The staff is consistently praised for being quick, friendly, and helpful, contributing to a pleasant experience.
• Community-Focused Atmosphere: The shop has a charming, old-school feel and a seating area in the back, making it a perfect spot for friends and family to gather and enjoy a treat together.

To get in touch with Cake and Cone or to inquire about their menu and services, here is the contact information:

Address: 306 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

Phone: (201) 933-2589

Cake and Cone is a quintessential local treasure for the residents of East Rutherford. Its long history and commitment to quality homemade ice cream make it a beloved community institution. For locals seeking a delicious dessert, the shop's wide variety of handcrafted flavors, from classic vanilla to the famous "Salted Monster," ensures there's something to please every palate. The reasonable prices and friendly, quick service make it an accessible and enjoyable outing for families and individuals alike. While there might be occasional waits during peak times, the quality of the product is consistently seen as worth it. With its charming mom-and-pop vibe, seating in the back, and a strong sense of community, Cake and Cone offers more than just ice cream—it offers a place to create sweet memories. It's the kind of local business that New Jersey residents are proud to support and call their own, making it an essential part of the East Rutherford community landscape.

Cake and Cone

306 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA