Carvel Ice Cream in New Rochelle: A Local Favorite for Custom Cakes and Classic Treats

Carvel Introduce

Welcome to Carvel, a beloved name that evokes feelings of nostalgia and joy for generations of New Yorkers. This particular location in New Rochelle, nestled within Westchester County, is more than just a place to grab a scoop; it's a community fixture known for its friendly service, classic ice cream treats, and a remarkable ability to craft memorable custom cakes for every occasion. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, this Carvel store offers a sweet and reliable experience that has made it a local favorite. It’s a destination where families come to celebrate milestones, friends meet for a quick dessert, and anyone with a sweet tooth can find something to smile about. From its iconic soft serve to its famous ice cream cakes, Carvel delivers a consistent quality that has kept customers coming back for decades.

The New Rochelle Carvel is conveniently situated at 233 E Main St, placing it right in the heart of a bustling commercial area. Its location makes it easily accessible for both locals and visitors. For those driving, there is often street parking available in the vicinity, though it can be a bit busy during peak hours. The shop’s position on a main thoroughfare means it's a simple stop on the way home from work or school, or a perfect treat after a day of shopping or running errands in downtown New Rochelle. Public transit options are also available, with several bus routes running along E Main St, making it a viable destination even without a car. Its accessibility is a key reason why it has remained a go-to spot for so many people in the community, providing a quick and easy way to satisfy a craving for something sweet. The central location also makes it a convenient pickup spot for large orders, such as custom birthday cakes.

The services offered at this Carvel location go beyond just serving ice cream. They specialize in a wide range of frozen treats designed to cater to various tastes and celebrations.

Classic Soft Serve: Enjoy the smooth, creamy soft serve that Carvel is famous for, available in vanilla, chocolate, or a twist.
Hand-Scooped Ice Cream: For those who prefer a firmer texture, they offer a selection of hand-scooped flavors.
Sundaes: Create your perfect sundae with a variety of toppings, from classic hot fudge and caramel to whipped cream and sprinkles.
Shakes and Malts: Their thick and creamy shakes can be customized with various ice cream flavors.
Carvelanches: A mix of soft serve and toppings blended together, similar to a Blizzard or McFlurry.
Novelty Items: Grab a Fudgie the Whale, a character-themed ice cream cake, or other classic Carvel treats to go.
Custom Ice Cream Cakes: This is a major highlight. The staff is adept at creating personalized ice cream cakes for birthdays, holidays, and special events.
Ice Cream Cart Service: For larger parties and events, they may offer catering services to bring the Carvel experience to you.
Online Ordering and Pickup: Customers can often place orders ahead of time for cakes and other items, making for a quick and convenient pickup experience.

What sets this particular Carvel apart from others, and what has earned it a loyal following, are its distinctive features and the quality of its service.

Exceptional Customer Service: As noted by a customer review, the staff here is often praised for being "super helpful and always so positive." This level of friendly and accommodating service makes a significant difference, especially when dealing with special requests like creating multiple gift cards or intricate custom cakes.
Specialization in Custom Cakes: While all Carvels offer cakes, this location is particularly known for its skilled staff who can create everything from the standard Fudgie the Whale to personalized birthday cakes that meet specific themes, like a race car. This personal touch turns a simple cake into a centerpiece for a celebration.
Reliable and Consistent Quality: The taste of Carvel soft serve is a timeless classic, and this location consistently delivers on that promise. Customers know they can expect the same delicious, high-quality products every time they visit.
Community-Oriented Approach: The willingness of the staff to go the extra mile, such as preparing 30 gift cards for a son's class, demonstrates a commitment to serving the local community beyond a transactional level.
Nostalgic Appeal: For many New Yorkers, Carvel is a trip down memory lane. This store maintains that nostalgic feel while providing a modern, clean, and welcoming environment for all ages.
Handling Large Orders: The store's capability to manage and fulfill large, complex orders, such as custom-themed cakes or multiple gift cards, makes it a reliable partner for events and parties.

To get in touch with the Carvel in New Rochelle, you can use the following information:

Address: 233 E Main St, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Phone: (914) 632-4592

Ultimately, the Carvel on E Main St is more than just a place to get ice cream; it’s a vital part of the New Rochelle community. It stands out because of its commitment to excellent customer service and its ability to handle special requests with a positive attitude. For locals, this makes it the perfect spot for everything from a quick after-dinner treat to a major celebratory purchase. The combination of classic, delicious ice cream and the genuinely helpful staff creates an inviting atmosphere that keeps people coming back. While there may have been some past issues with hours, the overwhelming sentiment from long-time customers is that this Carvel has evolved into a dependable and friendly neighborhood gem. It's the kind of place where the staff remembers you and your family, and where a simple trip for a cone becomes a pleasant and memorable experience. For anyone in the New Rochelle area looking for a sweet escape, a celebratory cake, or just a dose of nostalgia, this Carvel is a top choice, firmly cementing its status as a local favorite.

Carvel Vibe

Handheld Treats
Sprinkle Pop
Sprinkle ice cream pops are made with the original soft serve, dipped in a white bonnet® hard shell and rolled in colorful rainbow sprinkles. A classic carvel treat that brings the fun to every bite. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Crunchie Pop
Crunchie ice cream pops are made with the original soft serve™, dipped in a brown bonnet® hard shell and rolled in the iconic carvel chocolate crunchies (tm). they're a classic carvel treat that brings the crunch to every bite. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.

LTO/Featured
Mother Earth Ft. Mother's® Dynamite Dinosaurs™ Cookies
Indulge in the vibrant blue and green swirls of vanilla ice cream layered with mother’s® chocolatey dynamite dinosaurs™ cookies product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Mother Earth Flying Saucers
Vibrant blue and green swirls of vanilla soft serve sandwiched between two chocolatey wafers. product contains milk, soy, wheat."
Lemonberry Crumble Scooped
Beat the heat with a treat—Lemonberry ice cream layered with zesty lemon cookies and vanilla crunchies to make the ultimate summer scoop. Product contains milk, soy, wheat, Peanut.
Lemonberry Crumble Sundae Dasher®
Ribbons of blueberry, vanilla crunchies, and zesty lemon cookies are played between creamy Lemonberry soft serve for the ideal summer indulgence. Product contains milk, soy, wheat, and peanut.
Lemonberry Crumble Ice Cream Pop
Creamy Lemonberry Crumble ice cream coated in a white hard shell and rolled in vanilla crucnhies for the ultimate summer delight. Product contains milk, soy, wheat, peanut.

Ice Cream Celebration Cakes
Square Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Square ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft-serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Add Custom Message - please write your message in "Add a note" when checking out or give us a call.
Round Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Round ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft-serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Add Custom Message - please write your message in "Add a note" when checking out or give us a call.
Numbered Candles $3.00
Fudgie The Whale® Cake $40.99
Our famous whale of a cake with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then covered with fudge, crunchies, and whipped topping. Add Custom Message - please write your message in "Add a note" when checking out or give us a call.
Sheet Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Rectangular sheet ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft-serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Add Custom Message - please write your message in "Add a note" when checking out or give us a call.
3D Ice Cream Cone $35.99
Serves 8-10, it is not possible to write a message on this cake.
3D Race Car $35.99
Serves 8-10, it is not possible to write a message on this cake.
Stick Candles $2.00
Red White & Blue Cake
Layers of premium chocolate ice cream, chocolate crunchies, and vanilla ice cream. Topped with a patriotic trim. Product Contains: Milk, Soy and Wheat.

Ice Cream, Sorbet and Sherbet
Scooped Ice Cream
Our classic scooped ice cream in a variety of flavors. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Our classic soft ice cream available in a variety of flavors. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Ice Cream Quart $13.00
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a quart.
Sorbet Scooped
A sweet and fruity frozen treat that’s dairy-free but full of flavor. Add toppings for an additional charge. Vegan & dairy-free dessert.
Ice Cream Pint $10.00
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a pint.
Jolly Pops $18.19
Celebrate the season with Jolly Pops—a festive six-pack of our signature soft serve dipped in classic bonnet, featuring cheerful designs like Christmas lights, a snowman, snowflakes, and sprinkle-topped holiday magic!

Sundae Dashers
Strawberry Crunchies Sundae Dasher®
Ridiculously delicious layers of classic vanilla soft serve, Strawberry Crunchies, strawberrries, whipped cream and more Crunchies.
Chocolate Crunchies Sundae Dasher®
Ridiculously delicious layers of classic vanilla soft serve, Chocolate Crunchies, hot fudge, whipped cream, and more Crunchies.
Oreo® Cookie Sundae Dasher®
Layers of oreo® cookies, vanilla ice cream, and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Reese’s ® Peanut Butter Sundae Dasher®
Layers of Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups, Reese's® Peanut Butter sauce, vanilla ice cream, and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher®
Layers of vanilla ice cream, strawberries, and pound cake topped with whipped cream and strawberry drizzle.
Fudge Brownie Sundae Dasher®
Layers of fudge brownie bites, vanilla ice cream, and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.berries, and pound cake topped with whipped cream and strawberry drizzle.
Heath® Sundae Dasher®
Layers of Heath® pieces, vanilla ice cream, and caramel topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.
Mint Chocolate Chip Sundae Dasher®
Layers of chocolate crunchies, mint ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Bananas Foster Sundae Dasher®
Layers of bananas, vanilla ice cream, and caramel topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.

Sundaes
Ice Cream Sundae
Your choice of soft ice cream with 1 topping, whipped cream and a cherry included. Add toppings for an additional charge.

Shakes & Carvelanche
Shake
Hand-spun shakes are made with our signature soft-serve ice cream. Add whipped crem and toppings for an additional charge.
Carvelanche®
Our signature soft ice cream with your choice of mix-ins. Thicker than a shake, a Carvelanche® is best enjoyed with a spoon.

Dessert Packs
Chipsters 6-Pack $14.00
Soft serve vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies.
Flying Saucers® 6-Pack $12.00
Soft ice cream sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers. Served as a 6 pack for multiple people to enjoy.
Flying Saucers® Individual $3.00
Soft ice cream sandwiched between two flying saucer® chocolate wafers.
Deluxe Flying Saucers® Individual $3.50
Soft ice cream rolled in sprinkles and sandwiched between two flying saucer® chocolate wafers.
Deluxe Flying Saucers® 6-Pack $14.00
Soft ice cream rolled in sprinkles and sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers. Served as a 6 pack for multiple people to enjoy.
Brown Bonnet® Individual $4.50
Soft ice cream dipped in brown bonnet® and served on a sugar cone.
Brown Bonnet® 4-Pack $16.00
Soft ice cream dipped in brown bonnet® and served on a sugar cone.
Oreo Rounders $14.00

Beverages
Beverage $2.00
Water Bottle $2.00
Seltzer Water $2.00

Cake
Red, White, & Blue Cake $46.79
Small sheet. Celebrate the Stars and Stripes with a patriotic-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
8" Patriotics Seasonal Round $34.79
Celebrate the Stars and Stripes with a patriotic-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
8" Fall Seasonal Round Cake $34.79
Celebrate the season with an autumn-inspired classic Carvel® Ice Cream Cake. Each handmade cake features layers of rich chocolate and creamy vanilla ice cream with Carvel Crunchies® nestled in between.
8" Pumpkin Cake $34.79
Handmade with layers of classic chocolate and vanilla ice cream, this festive cake is decorated to look just like a pumpkin — complete with Carvel Crunchies™ inside. Perfect for fall gatherings, Halloween parties, or any autumn celebration.

Limited Time Offer
Toasted Marshmallow Soft Serve
Dive into the sweetness of caramelized toasted marshmallow with our original soft serve. product contains milk, soy, wheat.
S’mores Scoped Ice Cream
Toasted marshmallow ice cream brings the campfire flavor with graham cracker and ribbons of fudge in every creamy bite. Your favorite s’mores combo, scooped to perfection. . product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Reese’s Toasted Marshmallow Sundae Dasher®
Layers of creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve swirled with reese’s® peanut butter sauce and chunks of peanut butter cups. Topped with fluffy whipped cream and a final drizzle of rich, peanut buttery goodness. It’s the ultimate campfire treat in a cup. product contains milk, soy, wheat, and peanut.
S'mores Sundae Dasher®
Creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve layered with crunchy graham cracker crumbles and rich ribbons of fudge. Finished with whipped cream and a fudge drizzled – need we say s’more? product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Toasted Marshmallow Pop
This pop’s got it all. creamy toasted marshmallow ice cream with a snap of our iconic brown bonnet hard shell. It’s a crackly, melty, toasty treat on a stick. product contains soy, wheat.
Toasted Marshmallow Flying Saucers
Creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve tucked between two rich chocolatey wafers for a twist on your favorite campfire treat. product contains soy, wheat.
S’mores Sunde
Enjoy the sweetness of caramelized toasted marshmallow ice cream topped with graham cracker and rich fudge. product contains soy, wheat.
S’mores Shake
Toasted marshmallow ice cream, hand-spun with rich fudge and graham cracker topping. Product contains soy, wheat.

Carvel Details

Service options
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Carvel Photos

Carvel Location

Carvel

New York Westchester County New Rochelle East Main Street

233 E Main St, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Carvel Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 72 user reviews.

flavorsshakesprices

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I want to say the girl managing here is super helpful and always so positive. She happily made me 30 $5 gift cards for my son's class and the most amazing race car birthday cake. This did not used to be my "go to" Carvel even though I could walk here but it is now.
June 02 · Jenn
Showed up on a Sunday at 8:05pm. They have a big red CLOSED sign the window, but Google hours says 10pm.
June 22 · Jay M.
This was thee best 👌 Reese Dasher Thank you to who ever made this I ordered online and picked it up in the store, drove off and had to come back and leave a tip.
June 17 · bluz2316
Very friendly staff with a variety of delicious ice cream and toppings
August 07 · Kindra Sanders
My whole family loves this store. They always take care of us, they have a great variety of flavors, both soft serve and regular, and all the ice cream is made in the store. We have a child with a peanut/tree nut allergy, and they always will get his toppings from a fresh container to make sure they are allergen free. We can't recommend them enough, and are glad they are in our neighborhood!
December 02 · Matthew Polenzani