A Local's Guide to Carvel Ice Cream in Middletown, NY

Carvel Introduce

For many New Yorkers, the name Carvel evokes a sense of nostalgia, bringing back memories of childhood birthdays, warm summer evenings, and the simple joy of a classic soft-serve cone. The Carvel location at 130 Dolson Ave in Middletown, NY, is part of this long-standing tradition, serving as a local spot for people to satisfy their sweet cravings. As a well-known brand, Carvel has a reputation built on its signature soft-serve ice cream, unique ice cream cakes, and a range of other frozen treats. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of what this particular location offers, focusing on its place in the community and the services it provides to local residents.

The brand's history is deeply intertwined with the New York area, making this a particularly relevant business for locals. Carvel has been a fixture in the ice cream world for decades, known for its distinct flavor and creamy texture. The Middletown location, therefore, carries the torch of this legacy, offering a menu that features both classic Carvel favorites and a few seasonal specials. While Carvel is a chain, each location often develops its own personality and relationship with its customers. It is a place where locals can depend on finding a familiar treat, whether it's a simple cone or a custom-ordered ice cream cake for a special occasion.

The experience at an ice cream shop is as much about the product as it is about the service. While many customers appreciate the classic offerings, some recent feedback has highlighted issues with customer service and order accuracy. These are important factors for any local consumer to consider, and it's a reminder that even well-established brands can have varying experiences from one visit to the next. For those who value the classic Carvel taste and are patient with potential service hiccups, the Middletown store remains an option.

The Carvel shop is conveniently situated at 130 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA. This address places it in a high-traffic area of Middletown, making it easily accessible for people traveling from different parts of the city. Dolson Avenue is a major thoroughfare, which means the store is not hard to find for anyone familiar with the local roads. Its location provides a quick and convenient stop for families on their way home from school, for individuals looking for a dessert after dinner, or for anyone simply passing by with a craving for ice cream.

For those driving to the location, the store is easily visible from the road and likely has dedicated parking for customers, a significant convenience in a busy area. Its position within the local business landscape means it's often close to other shops and restaurants, making it a natural part of a day out or a stop as part of a larger errand-running trip.

The menu at this Carvel location is centered around its classic ice cream and dessert offerings. The core of their business is providing a range of frozen treats that have been a part of the brand's identity for generations.

Soft-Serve Ice Cream: The cornerstone of the Carvel experience. They offer their signature soft-serve in classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and a twist of both. It is known for its smooth texture and consistent quality. This is the foundation for many of their other products, including sundaes and shakes.
Ice Cream Cakes: Carvel is famous for its ice cream cakes, particularly those with the iconic chocolate crunchies in the middle. These cakes are a popular choice for birthdays and other celebrations. The Middletown location offers both pre-made cakes and options for custom orders, though recent customer experiences suggest that pre-ordering may not always guarantee a smooth pickup process.
Sundaes and Scooped Ice Cream: Beyond soft serve, the menu includes traditional scooped ice cream and a variety of sundaes. These often feature classic toppings like hot fudge, whipped cream, and cherries. They also offer their "Dasher" sundaes, which are layered with different mix-ins like Oreo cookies, brownies, or Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
Flying Saucers and Other Novelties: For a quick and easy treat, customers can enjoy "Flying Saucers," which are soft-serve ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. They also have other handheld treats and take-home options like pints and quarts of ice cream.
Shakes and Carvelanches: For those who prefer their ice cream in a drinkable form, the store provides hand-spun shakes. The "Carvelanche" is a thicker, spoonable dessert blended with various mix-ins, similar to a classic blizzard or concrete.

The menu focuses on delivering a consistent and familiar product that has been a favorite for many years.

The Carvel brand has several key features that have made it a recognizable name in the ice cream industry.

Nostalgic Appeal: For many locals, Carvel represents a part of their childhood. The classic Fudgie the Whale and Cookie Puss ice cream cakes are iconic figures that bring a sense of nostalgia to any celebration. The taste of their soft-serve and chocolate crunchies is often a trip down memory lane.
Signature Chocolate Crunchies: A unique feature of Carvel is its famous chocolate crunchies, a layer of chocolate cookie pieces and fudge that separates the ice cream layers in their cakes. This element is so popular that it can be added to many other menu items, from sundaes to cones.
Variety of Treats: The menu extends beyond simple cones and scoops. The availability of custom cakes, sundaes, shakes, and novelty items like Flying Saucers means there is something for every type of ice cream lover, whether they are looking for a quick treat or a centerpiece for a party.
Promotional Offers: Carvel locations often participate in brand-wide promotions, such as "BOGO Wednesday," which can be a draw for budget-conscious customers looking for a deal. These promotions make the treats more accessible and encourage repeat visits.

For more information about the Middletown Carvel, you can use the following contact details.

Address: 130 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

Phone: (845) 343-8041

For locals in the Middletown, NY area, the Carvel on Dolson Avenue serves as a convenient and familiar option for frozen treats. While recent customer feedback points to potential inconsistencies in service and order fulfillment, the store provides the classic products that the brand is known for. The nostalgic charm of Carvel’s signature soft serve, the famous ice cream cakes, and the variety of menu items make it a viable choice for families and individuals. The accessibility of its location on a major road is a clear benefit, allowing for easy stops. Ultimately, for those who prioritize the nostalgic flavor of Carvel and are willing to navigate potential service challenges, this shop remains a part of the local landscape and a destination for a classic ice cream experience.

Carvel Services

Limited Time Offer
Toasted Marshmallow Pop $16.49
This pop’s got it all-creamy toasted marshmallow ice cream with a snap of our iconic brown bonnet hard shell. It’s a crackly, melty, toasty treat on a stick. Product contains soy, wheat.
Reese’s Toasted Marshmallow Sundae Dasher® $7.79
Layers of creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve swirled with REESE’S® peanut butter sauce and chunks of peanut butter cups. Topped with fluffy whipped cream and a final drizzle of rich, peanut buttery goodness. It’s the ultimate campfire treat in a cup. Product contains milk, soy, wheat, and peanut.
S’mores Shake $5.49
Toasted marshmallow ice cream, hand-spun with rich fudge and graham cracker topping. Product contains soy, wheat.
S’mores Scoped Ice Cream $4.89
Toasted marshmallow ice cream brings the campfire flavor with graham cracker and ribbons of fudge in every creamy bite - your favorite s’mores combo, scooped to perfection. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Mother's Day Round Cake $38.99
Celebrate mom with a delicately decorated floral classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
S'mores Sundae Dasher® $7.79
Creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve layered with crunchy graham cracker crumbles and rich ribbons of fudge. Finished with whipped cream and a fudge drizzled - need we say s’more? Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Mother's Day Heart Cake $40.99
Celebrate mom with a decadently decorated, classic Carvel Ice Cream in the shape of a heart. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies, lovingly sandwiched between layers of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Mother's Day Seasonal Round Cake $38.99
Celebrate mom with a spring-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Toasted Marshmallow Flying Saucers $3.99
Creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve tucked between two rich chocolatey wafers for a twist on your favorite campfire treat. Product contains soy, wheat.
Toasted Marshmallow Soft Serve $4.89
Dive into the sweetness of caramelized toasted marshmallow with our original soft serve. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
S’mores Sundae $7.19
Enjoy the sweetness of caramelized toasted marshmallow ice cream topped with graham cracker and rich fudge. Product contains soy, wheat.

Sundae Dashers
Heath® Sundae Dasher® $7.99
Layers of Heath® pieces, vanilla ice cream and caramel topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.
Reese’s ® Peanut Butter Sundae Dasher® $7.99
Layers of Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups, Reese's® Peanut Butter Sauce, vanilla ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Mint Chocolate Chip Sundae Dasher® $7.99
Layers of chocolate crunchies, mint ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
OREO® Cookie Sundae Dasher® $7.99
Layers of Oreo® cookies, vanilla ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher® $7.99
Layers of vanilla ice cream, strawberries and pound cake topped with whipped cream and strawberry drizzle.
Fudge Brownie Sundae Dasher® $7.99
Layers of fudge brownie bites, vanilla ice cream, and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Bananas Foster Sundae Dasher® $7.99
Layers of bananas, vanilla ice cream and caramel topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.

Cakes
Father's Day Seasonal Round Cake (8") $34.79
Celebrate Dad this Father’s Day with a classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.

Sundaes
Ice Cream Sundae $6.59
Your choice of soft ice cream with one topping, whipped cream, and a cherry included. *Extra charge for additional toppings.

Ice Cream, Sorbet and Sherbet
Ice Cream (Pint) $8.49
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a pint.
Soft Serve Ice Cream $5.29
Our classic soft ice cream available in a variety of flavors.
Scooped Ice Cream $5.29
Classic scooped ice cream in a variety of flavors.
Cup Of Toppings $4.25
Your choice of extra toppings.
Ice Cream (Quart) $12.99
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a quart.
Sorbet Scooped $5.29
Vegan & Dairy-Free Dessert. A sweet and fruity frozen treat that’s dairy-free but full of flavor. Toppings may not be vegan or dairy free.

Holiday Cake
Red, White, & Blue Cake (Small Sheet) $46.79
Celebrate the Stars and Stripes with a patriotic-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Cookie O'Puss (One-Size) $39.99
Celebrate St. Patrick's Day with the cake that has everything on it. Straight from the party planet it's Cookie O'Puss.
Patriotics Seasonal Round (8in) $34.79
Celebrate the Stars and Stripes with a patriotic-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.

Ice Cream Celebration Cakes
Tom The Turkey $38.99
Get ready to gobble up this irresistible treat! Tom the Turkey Ice Cream Cake features rich layers of creamy chocolate and vanilla ice cream, perfectly paired with a crunchy layer of chocolatey Crunchies. Decorated like a turkey, it’s the ultimate Thanksgiving dessert!
Fudgie The Whale® Cake $42.99
Our famous whale of a cake with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then covered with fudge, crunchies, and whipped topping. Variety of sizes that serve 6-12 people.
Sheet Ice Cream Celebration Cake $45.99
Rectangular sheet ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla, and chocolate soft-serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Border Color: White.
Cup Of Toppings $5.14
Your choice of extra toppings.
Crunchie Munchie Monster $39.99
Lovable, fun, and full of flavor, this monster of a cake is ready to bring monstrous fun to any celebration. Topped with a mountain of smooth milk chocolate fudge, cone horns, and signature Chocolate Carvel Crunchies™, Crunchie Munchie Monster is layered with delicious vanilla and chocolate soft serve sandwiching a layer of chocolate Carvel Crunchies™. It’s the perfect mix of creamy goodness and a delightful crunch with every bite. Whether you’re hosting a monster bash or a spooky season gathering, invite the lovable Crunchie Munchie Monster to your next party!
Game Ball® Cake $36.99
Everyone's a winner with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then topped with chocolate crunchies and whipped topping. Variety of sizes that serve 6-12 people.
Festival Of Lights Cake $38.99
Celebrate the season with layers of chocolate, vanilla ice cream, and Carvel Crunchies™, all beautifully adorned with a festive menorah design.
Chocolate Decadence Heart Cake $36.99
Feed your chocolate addiction this Valentine's Day with The Original Soft Serve (TM), Carvel Crunchies (TM), and lots of fudge.
Red White & Blue Cake $35.99
Layers of premium chocolate ice cream, chocolate crunchies, and vanilla ice cream. Topped with a patriotic trim. Product Contains: Milk, Soy and Wheat
Pumpkin Cake $36.99
Layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 10-16 people. No substitutions, alterations, or additions. For a more customized cake, please call or visit this location . Product Contains: Milk, Soy and Wheat
24 Pack Of Candles $3.25
24 candles to blow out. Wish not included.
Round Ice Cream Celebration Cake $37.99
Round ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Border Color: White. Variety of sizes that serve 10-16 people.
Cookie Puss® Cake $39.99
A favorite party guest with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then topped with a scoop of chocolate ice cream in a sugar cone, two chocolate chip cookies, and fudge. Serves 10-12 people.
Baseball Cake $36.99
Layers of chocolate ice cream, chocolate crunchies, and vanilla ice cream. Festively decorated for your special occasions. No substitutions, alterations, or additions. For more customization, please call or visit this location. Baseball Cake is an 8” small round cake. Serving size is 10-12 people.
Square Ice Cream Celebration Cake $33.99
Square Ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Border Color: White. Variety of sizes that serve 6-8 people.
Santa Cake $39.99
Celebrate the season with layers of chocolate, vanilla ice cream, and Carvel Crunchies™, all dressed up as jolly old Saint Nick. Perfect for sharing holiday cheer!
Numbered Candles $3.25
Number of your choice. We won't tell.

Non Dairy made with Oatly
Oatly Lil' Love® $21.99
Layers of non-dairy soft serve made with Oatly, separated by a layer of our chocolate crunchies. Serves 2-4.
Oatly Scooped $5.79
Thick, creamy and non-dairy. Enjoy scooped ice cream made with Oatly.
Oatly Soft Serve $5.79
The Original Soft Serve™ you know and love, made with Oatly.
Oatly Flying Saucer® $11.99
Non-dairy soft serve made with Oatly, sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers.
Oatly Round Cake (Small) $24.99
Layers of non-dairy soft serve made with Oatly, separated by a layer of our chocolate crunchies. Serves 10-12.
Oatly Shake $6.49
Non-dairy soft serve spun into creamy deliciousness.

Handheld Treats
Ice Cream (Quart) $12.99
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a quart.
Flying Saucers® (Individual) $3.99
Soft ice cream sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers.
Sprinkle Cups (6-Pack) $17.99
Vanilla or chocolate ice cream with rainbow sprinkles served with a cherry on top.
Jolly Pops $18.99
Celebrate the season with Jolly Pops—a festive six-pack of our signature soft serve dipped in classic bonnet, featuring cheerful designs like Christmas lights, a snowman, snowflakes, and sprinkle-topped holiday magic!
Ice Cream (Pint) $8.49
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a pint.
Flying Saucers® (6-Pack) $13.99
Soft ice cream sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers. Served as a 6 pack for multiple people to enjoy.
Sprinkle Pop $3.59
Sprinkle Ice Cream Pops are made with The Original Soft Serve™, dipped in a white Bonnet® hard shell and rolled in colorful rainbow sprinkles. A classic Carvel treat that brings the fun to every bite. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Lil Gobblers $18.99
Celebrate Thanksgiving with Lil’ Gobblers—adorable turkey-shaped ice cream treats! Made with creamy vanilla ice cream, coated in rich chocolate, and topped with candy eyes, they’re the perfect bite-sized dessert for kids and adults alike. Grab a pack today and get ready to gobble them up!
Deluxe Flying Saucers® (6-Pack) $15.99
Soft ice cream rolled in sprinkles, nuts and sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers. Served as a 6 pack for multiple people to enjoy.
Fudgie Pops $3.99
Mini Fudgie-shaped ice cream pop on a stick, made with vanilla soft serve ice cream covered in chocolate bonnet shell and decorated with frosting. Product Contains: Milk, Soy, Egg
Heart Pops $4.19
Heart-shaped pops made with The Orginal Soft Serve(TM) covered in Brown hard shell Bonnet and drizzled with White Bonnet. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
OREO® Rounders® (6-Pack) $15.99
Soft serve ice cream sandwiched between two OREO® cookies.
Crunchie Pop $3.59
Crunchie Ice Cream Pops are made with The Original Soft Serve™, dipped in a brown Bonnet® hard shell and rolled in the iconic Carvel Chocolate Crunchies (TM). They're a classic Carvel treat that brings the crunch to every bite. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Heart Pops (4-Pack) $11.99
Heart-shaped pops made with The Original Soft Serve (TM) covered in Brown Bonnet and drizzled with White Bonnet.
Chipsters (6-Pack) $15.99
Soft serve vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies.
Cup Of Toppings $4.25
Your choice of extra toppings.
Bonnet® Cone (Individual) $4.99
Soft ice cream dipped in brown or cherry bonnet® and served on a sugar cone.
Bonnet® Cone (4 -Pack) $14.99
Soft ice cream dipped in brown or cherry bonnet® and served on a sugar cone.

Shake & Carvelanche®
Shakes $5.99
Hand-spun shakes made with our signature soft-serve ice cream.
Carvelanche® $6.99
Our signature soft ice cream with mix-ins. Thicker than a shake, a Carvelanche® is best enjoyed with a spoon.

Carvel Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Carvel Photos

Carvel Location

Carvel

New York Orange County Middletown Dolson Avenue

130 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

Carvel Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 120 user reviews.

cleanmoneysundaenamemilkshakeice cream cakesgrocery storecookievanillaparking

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Preordered and paid for an ice-cream cake a week in advance. When my daughter arrived to pick it up, it wasn’t ready and the employee couldn’t time the ticket. He then picked one out of the case, which was the wrong color. It was slightly freezer burned. Took an additional 20 minutes for a message to be written… poorly. Then he tried to make my daughter pay for it. She left. By the way, it was the same employee who took the order and then failed today.
June 08 · Jennifer Piliere-Gutzeit
Used to love going here but the last 2 times ice creams was very small and staff is rude . I asked for a soft serve sample girl gave me a hard serve sample. I ordered a twist with cookie crunch and the girl asked me 4 times in 3 mins what I wanted. A man claiming to be owner told me to not be hostile because I asked what was so hard about a twist with cookie crunch. 2 med ice cream with sprinkles was over $20 . I aksed why service is so horrible as I never had issues and the Indian man said he was owner and I needed to leave. Dont spend your money here as they don't like Americans. I guess for $9 ice creams I'll be going back to sweet frog mon $6 ice cream and 100s of toppings for $6. And they have over 20 flavors and now carry van , cho, twist
May 29 · snow dog family
So i got a cake from carvel in middletown cut it after dinner and the cake was frostbetten call the store the works are rude the first one hung up on me the second on said they is nothing they can do there cakes are made fresh so you pay 30 for a cake and its no good watch what you buy from there it almost as bad as buying it in the grocery store there must be another place to buy icecream cakes in middletown i will never spend my money there again very customer service
February 25 · Pat Fernandez
There is an employee named Fadi, He is wonderful very polite and deserves recognition. He was more than wonderful, we need more people like FADI!! My family and I will be returning!
March 08 · Jungle City
Carvel is everyones favorite soft serve ice cream.The young lady that served us was curt and rushed (I understand people want to be served but customer service should still mean something)The container for sundaes (medium in this case) wasnt even filled to me it feels like they try to get over on you. You decide.Not the worse experience but I was expecting better frim a chain
April 28 · Michael Bottone