Carvel Jefferson Valley, NY: A Classic New York Ice Cream Tradition

Carvel Introduce

For generations of New Yorkers, the name Carvel instantly conjures images of creamy soft serve, crunchy sprinkles, and those iconic ice cream cakes that have graced countless birthday celebrations. In Jefferson Valley, New York, Carvel continues this cherished tradition, offering a taste of nostalgia alongside a variety of frozen treats. It's a place where locals can find the classic soft serve that Carvel is famous for, as well as a selection of hard-scooped ice cream, making it a go-to spot for satisfying a sweet craving. While the landscape of dessert shops has evolved, Carvel holds a special place in the hearts of many for its enduring commitment to classic ice cream flavors and beloved character cakes.

Carvel has been a cornerstone of the American ice cream experience since its founding in 1934, pioneering the soft serve concept and building a legacy on its unique flavors and festive ice cream cakes. The Jefferson Valley location aims to uphold this legacy, providing the familiar taste and experience that customers have come to expect. It's more than just a place to grab a cone; for many, it's a part of their local community, a destination for celebratory cakes, or a simple treat after a long day. The brand's distinctive taste, particularly its rich soft serve, has created a loyal following. While the general expectation for Carvel is consistent quality and a wide array of options, recent customer feedback for this specific location has pointed to some areas of inconsistency, particularly concerning portion sizes and customer service. Despite these specific concerns, the core appeal of Carvel – its classic offerings and a touch of sweet nostalgia – continues to draw in patrons looking for that familiar, comforting ice cream experience in New York.

---

Location and Accessibility

The Carvel ice cream shop in Jefferson Valley, New York, is conveniently located at 3643 Hill Blvd, Jefferson Valley, NY 10535, USA. This address places it within a commercial stretch that is generally easy to access for residents of Jefferson Valley and the wider Westchester County area. Hill Boulevard is a local road that connects to larger thoroughfares, making the shop reasonably simple to reach by car. As it's situated in a suburban commercial setting, there is typically ample parking available for customers, which is a significant advantage, especially during peak hours when families or groups might be visiting.

The location on Hill Boulevard makes Carvel a recognizable spot for locals, often integrated into their routines for errands or leisure. Its placement means it's a straightforward stop for those driving through the area or specifically heading out for a sweet treat. While public transportation options might be less extensive than in more urban parts of New York, for those relying on personal vehicles, the shop's accessibility is generally good. This ease of access contributes to its suitability as a quick and convenient destination for a classic ice cream experience in the community, allowing patrons to easily pick up their favorite soft serve or a celebratory ice cream cake.

---

Services Offered

Carvel in Jefferson Valley offers a range of classic ice cream products that have been satisfying sweet cravings for decades. While the specific availability and execution of these services at this location have been noted by customers as inconsistent, the general offerings include:

Soft Serve Ice Cream: The cornerstone of the Carvel brand, known for its iconic creamy texture. Available in classic vanilla, chocolate, and often a twist option. This is a primary draw for customers seeking that traditional Carvel experience.
Hard Scoop Ice Cream: In addition to soft serve, this location also offers a selection of hard-scooped ice cream flavors for those who prefer a denser, richer ice cream experience.
Ice Cream Cakes: Carvel is famous for its wide variety of ice cream cakes, perfect for birthdays, holidays, and other celebrations. These include popular designs featuring "Fudgie the Whale" and "Cookie Puss," as well as custom-ordered cakes. This is a significant part of their business, offering a convenient dessert solution for parties.
Sundaes: Build-your-own sundaes with various toppings, whipped cream, and cherries, allowing for personalized frozen treats.
Shakes and Malts: Blended beverages made with soft serve or hard scoop ice cream, often with mix-ins. One customer review specifically mentioned purchasing a "medium shake." However, there was feedback about reduced cup sizes and feeling "awfully light" on product.
Flying Saucers: A nostalgic Carvel treat consisting of soft serve ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate wafer cookies. A customer mentioned purchasing "flying saucers over $20 in total," indicating they are a popular item for bulk purchase.
Cones and Cups: Customers can choose their preferred way to enjoy their ice cream, whether in a traditional cone or a cup.
Take-Home Treats: Various pre-packaged options like pint and quart containers of ice cream, novelty items, and ice cream sandwiches are typically available for convenient at-home enjoyment.

---

Features / Highlights

Carvel in Jefferson Valley carries the legacy of a beloved ice cream brand with several key features, though recent customer feedback suggests some inconsistencies at this specific location.

Iconic Soft Serve: Carvel is synonymous with its uniquely creamy, classic soft serve ice cream. This signature product is a major draw, offering a distinct texture and flavor profile that sets it apart from other ice cream shops. It provides a comforting, nostalgic taste that many New Yorkers have grown up with.
Famous Ice Cream Cakes: The shop is a go-to destination for Carvel's celebrated ice cream cakes, including the recognizable "Fudgie the Whale" and "Cookie Puss." These cakes are a staple for birthdays and celebrations, making the location a convenient stop for party planning. The availability of "Plenty of ice cream cakes," as mentioned by a reviewer, is a key highlight.
Variety of Offerings: Beyond soft serve, the availability of hard scoop ice cream, sundaes, shakes, and Flying Saucers ensures that there are options to satisfy different preferences and cravings, from a simple cone to a more elaborate treat.

Important Considerations Based on Customer Reviews: It is crucial for potential customers to be aware of the recurring issues highlighted by recent reviews for this specific Carvel location in Jefferson Valley:

Inconsistent Portions: Multiple reviews mention "very inconsistent portions," particularly concerning shakes. One customer detailed receiving a "small shake" in a reduced-size cup that felt "awfully light" and was "barely half full," despite traditionally expecting a fuller cup with whipped cream. This inconsistency can lead to dissatisfaction regarding value for money.
Customer Service Issues: Reviewers describe "very inconsistent portions and customer service." One specific instance involved an employee forgetting whipped cream for a shake and then providing an unsatisfactorily filled cup. The general sentiment points to a need for improved staff training and management supervision. The review explicitly states, "To management/ownership, you have to do better."
High Prices: A significant concern raised is that "The prices are very high." One customer cited spending "$15 on a medium shake and hard scoop of ice cream with no toppings," which they perceived as expensive. This perception of high cost combined with inconsistent portions can negatively impact the overall value proposition for customers.

These consistent reports about pricing, portion control, and customer service are significant factors that local New Yorkers should consider when choosing to visit this particular Carvel location, despite the brand's long-standing appeal and popular product offerings.

---

Contact Information

For those in the New York region looking to contact the Carvel ice cream shop in Jefferson Valley, here is the direct information:

Address: 3643 Hill Blvd, Jefferson Valley, NY 10535, USA

Phone: (914) 245-6500

Mobile Phone: +1 914-245-6500

Given the customer feedback regarding inconsistent portions and service, especially for shakes and pre-purchased items like Flying Saucers, it might be advisable for customers to communicate their expectations clearly at the time of order or to verify specific details if they have concerns. While the phone numbers provided are direct, potential patrons may find it useful to inquire about current pricing or specific product availability if they have particular items in mind, especially large orders like ice cream cakes.

---

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For locals in the New York region, specifically within Jefferson Valley and surrounding areas of Westchester County, Carvel represents a cherished, long-standing tradition in the ice cream landscape. Its primary suitability stems from its iconic status and the nostalgic appeal of its classic soft serve and famous ice cream cakes. Many New Yorkers have grown up with Carvel, making it a place that evokes warm memories and a sense of familiarity. For those seeking the unique taste and texture of Carvel's soft serve, this location provides that specific and beloved experience that differentiates it from other ice cream shops.

The accessibility of the Jefferson Valley location on Hill Boulevard, with convenient parking, makes it an easy stop for a quick treat or to pick up a celebratory ice cream cake. For families planning birthdays or gatherings, the wide array of Carvel cakes, from the classic "Fudgie the Whale" to custom designs, offers a convenient and popular dessert solution. The variety of other offerings, including hard scoop ice cream, sundaes, shakes, and Flying Saucers, ensures there’s a product to suit different preferences within a family or group, catering to both the traditionalist and those seeking a slightly different treat.

However, it is imperative for local New Yorkers to be mindful of the recent customer feedback for this particular Carvel. While the brand itself is beloved, reviews highlight significant inconsistencies in portion sizes, particularly for shakes, which can lead to a perception of poor value given the "very high prices." Furthermore, concerns about customer service and staff attentiveness have been raised. Therefore, while Carvel in Jefferson Valley offers the comforting familiarity and classic taste that many locals appreciate, it would be wise for patrons to manage their expectations regarding consistency and potentially inquire about portion sizes or prices beforehand to ensure a satisfactory experience. Despite these operational challenges, for those craving that distinctive Carvel soft serve or a classic ice cream cake, this location remains a local option to fulfill that specific desire.

Carvel Vibe

Sundae Dashers
Bananas Foster Sundae Dasher® $8.99
Layers of bananas, vanilla ice cream and caramel topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.
Fudge Brownie Sundae Dasher® $8.99
Layers of fudge brownie bites, vanilla ice cream and hot fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Heath® Sundae Dasher® $8.99
Layers of Heath® pieces, vanilla ice cream and caramel topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher® $8.99
Layers of vanilla ice cream, strawberries and pound cake topped with whipped cream and strawberry drizzle.
OREO® Cookie Sundae Dasher® $8.99
Layers of Oreo® cookies, vanilla ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Mint Chocolate Chip Sundae Dasher® $8.99
Layers of chocolate crunchies, mint ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Reese’s Peanut Butter Sundae Dasher® $8.99
Layers of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce, vanilla ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.

Non Dairy made with Oatly
Oatly Soft Serve $5.79
The Original Soft Serve™ you know and love, made with Oatly.
Oatly Round Cake (Small) $24.99
Layers of non-dairy soft serve made with Oatly, separated by a layer of our chocolate crunchies. Serves 10-12.
Oatly Shake $6.49
Non-dairy soft serve spun into creamy deliciousness.
Oatly Scooped $5.79
Thick, creamy and non-dairy. Enjoy scooped ice cream made with Oatly.
Oatly Flying Saucer® $2.99
Non-dairy soft serve made with Oatly, sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers.
Oatly Lil' Love® $21.99
Layers of non-dairy soft serve made with Oatly, separated by a layer of our chocolate crunchies. Serves 2-4.

Holiday Cake
Patriotics Seasonal Round (8in) $34.79
Celebrate the Stars and Stripes with a patriotic-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Red, White, & Blue Cake (Small Sheet) $46.79
Celebrate the Stars and Stripes with a patriotic-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Cookie O'Puss (One-Size) $33.99
Celebrate St. Patrick's Day with the cake that has everything on it. Straight from the party planet it's Cookie O'Puss.

Cakes
Father's Day Seasonal Round Cake (8") $34.79
Celebrate Dad this Father’s Day with a classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.

Ice Cream, Sorbet and Sherbet
Ice Cream Quart $13.99
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a quart.
Soft Serve Ice Cream $5.99
Our classic soft ice cream available in a variety of flavors.
Scooped Ice Cream $5.99
Classic scooped ice cream in a variety of flavors.
Ice Cream Pint $8.99
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a pint.
Sherbet Scooped $2.99
A light and creamy treat featuring delicious fruit flavors.
Sorbet Scooped (Vegan & Dairy-Free Dessert) $5.99
A sweet and fruity frozen treat that’s dairy-free but full of flavor. Toppings may not be vegan or dairy free.
Cup Of Toppings $2.75
Your choice of extra toppings.

Limited Time Offer
Reese’s Toasted Marshmallow Sundae Dasher® $7.79
Layers of creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve swirled with REESE’S® peanut butter sauce and chunks of peanut butter cups. Topped with fluffy whipped cream and a final drizzle of rich, peanut buttery goodness. It’s the ultimate campfire treat in a cup. Product contains milk, soy, wheat, and peanut.
Mother's Day Round Cake $34.79
Celebrate mom with a delicately decorated floral classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Toasted Marshmallow Pop $16.49
This pop’s got it all-creamy toasted marshmallow ice cream with a snap of our iconic brown bonnet hard shell. It’s a crackly, melty, toasty treat on a stick. Product contains soy, wheat.
Mother's Day Heart Cake $33.99
Celebrate mom with a decadently decorated, classic Carvel Ice Cream in the shape of a heart. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies, lovingly sandwiched between layers of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Mother's Day Seasonal Round Cake $34.79
Celebrate mom with a spring-inspired classic Carvel Ice Cream cake. Each of Carvel's handmade cakes features Carvel Crunchies lovingly sandwiched between a layer of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Toasted Marshmallow Flying Saucers $3.99
Creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve tucked between two rich chocolatey wafers for a twist on your favorite campfire treat. Product contains soy, wheat.
S'mores Sundae Dasher® $7.79
Creamy toasted marshmallow soft serve layered with crunchy graham cracker crumbles and rich ribbons of fudge. Finished with whipped cream and a fudge drizzled - need we say s’more? Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
S’mores Sundae $7.19
Enjoy the sweetness of caramelized toasted marshmallow ice cream topped with graham cracker and rich fudge. Product contains soy, wheat.
S’mores Scoped Ice Cream $4.89
Toasted marshmallow ice cream brings the campfire flavor with graham cracker and ribbons of fudge in every creamy bite - your favorite s’mores combo, scooped to perfection. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
S’mores Shake $5.49
Toasted marshmallow ice cream, hand-spun with rich fudge and graham cracker topping. Product contains soy, wheat.
Toasted Marshmallow Soft Serve $4.89
Dive into the sweetness of caramelized toasted marshmallow with our original soft serve. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.

Handheld Treats
Cup Of Toppings $2.75
Your choice of extra toppings.
Crunchie Pop $22.58
Crunchie Ice Cream Pops are made with The Original Soft Serve™, dipped in a brown Bonnet® hard shell and rolled in the iconic Carvel Chocolate Crunchies (TM). They're a classic Carvel treat that brings the crunch to every bite. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Heart Pops $23.18
Heart-shaped pops made with The Orginal Soft Serve(TM) covered in Brown hard shell Bonnet and drizzled with White Bonnet. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Ice Cream Quart $13.99
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a quart.
Brown Bonnet® (Individual) $4.99
Soft ice cream dipped in Brown Bonnet®, and served on a sugar cone.
Flying Saucers® (6-Pack) $16.99
Soft ice cream sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers. Served as a 6 pack for multiple people to enjoy.
Brown Bonnet® (4 Or 6-Pack) $17.99
Soft ice cream dipped in Brown Bonnet®, and served on a sugar cone.
Heart Pops (4-Pack) $18.99
Heart-shaped pops made with The Original Soft Serve (TM) covered in Brown Bonnet and drizzled with White Bonnet.
Lil Gobblers $15.58
Celebrate Thanksgiving with Lil’ Gobblers—adorable turkey-shaped ice cream treats! Made with creamy vanilla ice cream, coated in rich chocolate, and topped with candy eyes, they’re the perfect bite-sized dessert for kids and adults alike. Grab a pack today and get ready to gobble them up!
Chipsters (6-Pack) $18.99
Soft serve vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies.
Flying Saucers® (Individual) $4.99
Soft ice cream sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers.
Sprinkle Pop $22.58
Sprinkle Ice Cream Pops are made with The Original Soft Serve™, dipped in a white Bonnet® hard shell and rolled in colorful rainbow sprinkles. A classic Carvel treat that brings the fun to every bite. Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Ice Cream Pint $8.99
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a pint.
Fudgie Pops $18.99
Mini Fudgie-shaped ice cream pop on a stick, made with vanilla soft serve ice cream covered in chocolate bonnet shell and decorated with frosting. Product Contains: Milk, Soy, Egg
Sprinkle Cups (6- Pack) $17.99
Vanilla or chocolate ice cream with rainbow sprinkles served with a cherry on top.
OREO® Rounders (6-Pack) $18.99
Soft serve ice cream sandwiched between two mini OREO® cookies.
Jolly Pops $18.99
Celebrate the season with Jolly Pops—a festive six-pack of our signature soft serve dipped in classic bonnet, featuring cheerful designs like Christmas lights, a snowman, snowflakes, and sprinkle-topped holiday magic!

Shakes and Carvelanche®
Carvelanche® $8.99
Our signature soft ice cream with your choice of mix-ins. Thicker than a shake, a Carvelanche® is best enjoyed with a spoon.
Shakes $5.99
Hand-spun shakes made with our signature soft serve ice cream.

Sundaes
Cup Of Toppings $2.75
Your choice of extra toppings.
Ice Cream Sundae $6.99
Your choice of soft ice cream with one topping, whipped cream and a cherry included.

Ice Cream Celebration Cakes
Tom The Turkey $23.98
Get ready to gobble up this irresistible treat! Tom the Turkey Ice Cream Cake features rich layers of creamy chocolate and vanilla ice cream, perfectly paired with a crunchy layer of chocolatey Crunchies. Decorated like a turkey, it’s the ultimate Thanksgiving dessert!
Cup Of Toppings $2.75
Your choice of extra toppings.
Pumpkin Cake $30.99
Layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 10-16 people. No substitutions, alterations, or additions. For a more customized cake, please call or visit this location . Product Contains: Milk, Soy and Wheat
Cookie Puss® Cake $37.99
A favorite party guest with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then topped with a scoop of chocolate ice cream in a sugar cone, two chocolate chip cookies, and fudge. Serves 10-12 people.
24 Pack Of Candles $1.98
24 candles to blow out. Wish not included.
Festival Of Lights Cake $40.99
Celebrate the season with layers of chocolate, vanilla ice cream, and Carvel Crunchies™, all beautifully adorned with a festive menorah design.
Santa Cake $38.99
Celebrate the season with layers of chocolate, vanilla ice cream, and Carvel Crunchies™, all dressed up as jolly old Saint Nick. Perfect for sharing holiday cheer!
Red White & Blue Cake $44.99
Layers of premium chocolate ice cream, chocolate crunchies, and vanilla ice cream. Topped with a patriotic trim. Product Contains: Milk, Soy and Wheat
Round Ice Cream Celebration Cake $34.99
Round ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 10-16 people.
Crunchie Munchie Monster $34.99
Lovable, fun, and full of flavor, this monster of a cake is ready to bring monstrous fun to any celebration. Topped with a mountain of smooth milk chocolate fudge, cone horns, and signature Chocolate Carvel Crunchies™, Crunchie Munchie Monster is layered with delicious vanilla and chocolate soft serve sandwiching a layer of chocolate Carvel Crunchies™. It’s the perfect mix of creamy goodness and a delightful crunch with every bite. Whether you’re hosting a monster bash or a spooky season gathering, invite the lovable Crunchie Munchie Monster to your next party!
Square Ice Cream Celebration Cake $19.99
Square Ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 4-8 people.
Sheet Ice Cream Celebration Cake $45.99
Rectangular sheet ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft-serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 14 -40.
Baseball Cake $33.99
Layers of chocolate ice cream, chocolate crunchies, and vanilla ice cream. Festively decorated for your special occasions. No substitutions, alterations, or additions. For more customization, please call or visit this location. Baseball Cake is an 8” small round cake. Serving size is 10-12 people.
Fudgie The Whale® Cake $39.99
Our famous whale of a cake with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then covered with fudge, crunchies and whipped topping. Variety of sizes that serve 6-12 people.
Chocolate Decadence Heart Cake $33.99
Feed your chocolate addiction this Valentine's Day with The Original Soft Serve (TM), Carvel Crunchies (TM), and lots of fudge.
Game Ball® Cake $33.99
Everyone's a winner with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then topped with chocolate crunchies and whipped topping.
Numbered Candles $1.98
Number of your choice. We won't tell.
Round Ice Cream Celebration Cake Deluxe $39.99
Round ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 10-16 people.

Carvel Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Carvel Photos

Carvel Location

Carvel

New York Westchester County Jefferson Valley Hill Boulevard

3643 Hill Blvd, Jefferson Valley, NY 10535, USA

Carvel Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 91 user reviews.

shakecuppricesbirthdaypatientflying saucerlinewednesday

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Traditional Carvel ice cream soft serve and regular. Plenty of ice cream cakes. The prices are very high, I spent $15 on a medium shake and hard scoop of icecream with no toppings.
January 31 · Dreas View
I go here on the regular, very inconsistent portions and customer service. I just got a small shake, which in recent times they reduced the size of the cups. I wasn't expecting a medium or large portion in a small cup. Typically, I get whipped cream, which will be topped with an expanded clear cap. The young person forgot the whipped cream as it had a flat lid, so I asked for the whipped cream, then I was handed the same cup and regular lid, which whipped cream was added to. The shake felt awfully light. So, I gave the benefit of the doubt to the ice cream server. Not suprised by what I received a cup, barely half full, which the top of the cup is what allows for the product. Additionally, I purchased flying saucers over $20 in total. To management/ ownership, you have to do better .
October 21 · Thomas Wilkinson
Picked up a nice ice cream cake for my friend. Staff was friendly and did a great job on writing the name. The store is packed with many ice cream cakes and desserts available.
June 25 · Simon Chung
Christina was wonderful!! Great costumer service skills 10/10 would recommend this location, she makes very good dashers
March 15 · Alesia
Our favorite Carvel by far! The staff is wonderful, always helpful, patient and very accommodating to special requests! The service is great! The store is very clean and they serve quality ice cream and beautifully decorated cakes (they can make pretty much make any design/style you want). Another plus- convenient hours and location. The best ice cream shop around!
August 13 · Madelene Conetta