Cayuga Lake Creamery: A Local Favorite in Interlaken, NY

Cayuga Lake Creamery Introduce

In the scenic heart of New York's Finger Lakes region, right along the shores of Cayuga Lake, stands a local favorite that has become an essential stop for both residents and visitors: Cayuga Lake Creamery. This beloved establishment is more than just a place to get ice cream; it’s a destination for a delicious meal, a refreshing treat, and a beautiful view. The creamery has built a reputation on its homemade ice cream, which, despite one review's lukewarm take, is championed by others as the "best ice cream I ever did have." The passion and artistry that go into crafting their flavors are evident in the enthusiasm of their most loyal patrons. The menu extends well beyond desserts, with a food selection that has also earned high praise. One dedicated customer declared that the "food is also bomb," and specifically highlighted the "buffalo chicken sandwich" as a must-have for every road trip. This combination of both excellent savory and sweet options makes Cayuga Lake Creamery a versatile spot suitable for a full meal or a simple dessert. The environment is also a key part of the experience, with a loyal fan claiming it is the "#1 best ice cream and ice cream eating-environment in all of Tburg area and also the world." This kind of passionate feedback speaks volumes about the quality of the overall experience. Whether you’re a local craving a classic cone or a traveler in need of a satisfying meal with a view, the Cayuga Lake Creamery offers a complete package that has solidified its place as a cherished local gem.

---

Cayuga Lake Creamery is ideally located at 8421 NY-89, Interlaken, NY 14847, directly on the western shore of Cayuga Lake. This location makes it a prime stop for anyone exploring the scenic Finger Lakes region. For locals, the creamery is a convenient and beautiful destination that is easy to access by car, with plenty of parking available for patrons. The address on State Route 89 is a main road that follows the lake, making the creamery a natural stop for those driving between towns or enjoying a leisurely tour of the area. The location is not just accessible; it's also a key part of the experience. The proximity to Cayuga Lake provides a picturesque backdrop, enhancing the enjoyment of a cone or a meal. A customer's glowing review of the "ice cream eating-environment" underscores the importance of the beautiful setting. For residents of Interlaken, Trumansburg, and other nearby communities, Cayuga Lake Creamery is a quick and simple drive, offering a delightful escape without having to travel far. This easy accessibility, combined with the stunning natural surroundings, makes it an attractive destination for families, couples, and individuals looking to enjoy a high-quality meal or dessert in a relaxing setting. It’s a perfect pit stop for those on a road trip, providing a much-needed break with great food and a view to remember.

---

Cayuga Lake Creamery offers a more comprehensive menu than just ice cream, making it a versatile destination for different cravings. The shop is celebrated for its homemade products, and its services are built around providing both satisfying meals and delicious desserts.

Homemade Ice Cream: The cornerstone of the creamery, offering a variety of flavors that, according to a devoted customer, are the "best ice cream I ever did have."
Savory Food Menu: The creamery is also well-known for its food, with one customer raving that the "food is also bomb." The "buffalo chicken sandwich" was specifically mentioned as a favorite for road trips.
Variety of Flavors: While one review found the flavors to be "okay; nothing special," this is a matter of personal taste. The strong praise from other customers for the ice cream suggests a wide range of flavors that can delight a variety of palates.
Takeout for Road Trips: The fact that the buffalo chicken sandwich is a go-to for a "road trip" indicates that the creamery is well-suited for takeout orders, perfect for those on the move.
Family-Friendly Environment: The inviting atmosphere and scenic location make it a great spot for families to enjoy a meal or a treat together.

---

What truly makes Cayuga Lake Creamery a special place is its combination of exceptional food, beautiful location, and strong community reputation. These highlights are what make it a beloved local establishment and a memorable stop for visitors.

High-Quality Food and Ice Cream: The creamery's dedication to quality is a major highlight, with one customer stating the food is "bomb" and the ice cream is the "best." This commitment to both savory and sweet items is a huge draw.
Iconic Road Trip Stop: For many, the creamery is an essential stop on a journey, with the "buffalo chicken sandwich" serving as a staple for road trips. This reputation makes it a reliable and trusted destination.
Scenic Location: Situated on the shores of Cayuga Lake, the "ice cream eating-environment" is a key feature. The beautiful view and relaxing atmosphere elevate a simple visit into a special experience.
Community Favorite: The passionate, almost hyperbolic, praise from a customer calling it the "#1 best" in the area speaks volumes about its standing within the local community.
Versatile Offerings: The ability to serve both a full meal and a delicious dessert makes the creamery a versatile destination, suitable for lunch, dinner, or just a treat.

---

For more information or to plan your visit to this local favorite, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 8421 NY-89, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA

Phone: (607) 532-9492

---

Cayuga Lake Creamery is the perfect place for locals in the New York region to frequent for several key reasons. It’s a genuine community institution that offers a unique and high-quality experience. For those living in the Finger Lakes area, it's not just another restaurant; it’s a destination that is as much about the stunning scenery as it is about the food. The passionate customer reviews, from the "best ice cream I ever did have" to the "bomb" food, demonstrate the deep connection and loyalty the creamery has cultivated with its patrons. Its location along Cayuga Lake provides a beautiful setting that enhances the enjoyment of every meal and every scoop, making it a place to relax and unwind. The versatility of the menu, with both a savory food selection and an extensive ice cream list, means it’s a suitable choice for any occasion, whether it’s a quick lunch or a celebratory dessert. The review mentioning its status as a "good stop" on the way for ice cream further solidifies its role as a convenient and reliable local fixture. Supporting Cayuga Lake Creamery means supporting a business that is an integral part of the local landscape and culture. It’s a place that brings people together, where families gather, and where travelers get a true taste of the region. A visit here is more than a simple transaction; it's an experience that is deeply rooted in the beauty and community spirit of the New York Finger Lakes.

Cayuga Lake Creamery Food & drink

HOMEMADE FLAVORS - EVERY DAY
Our Homemade Ice Cream Is Made On The Premises In Small Batches For Excellent Quality Control. We Start With A 14% Butterfat Mix From Our Dairy, Upstate Farms. We Then Add The Finest Ingredients Available-From Down The Road And Around The World-To...
Vanilla
Chocolate
Mocha
Peanut Butter
Coffee
Fruit

HOMEMADE FLAVORS - COMPLETE LIST OF FLAVORS
All flavors are not always available. If you are taking a trip up to the Creamery for a specific flavor, please call to make sure it is in stock
Banana
Banana ice cream made with fresh bananas
Banana Nut Fudge
Our fresh banana ice cream with walnuts and fudge swirl
Banoreo
Our fresh banana ice cream with Oreo
Beary Cotton Candy
Cotton Candy flavored ice cream with Gummy Bears
Black Raspberry
Made with black raspberry puree
Blue Hawaiian
Coconut based ice cream with Blue Curacao Liquor
Blueberry
Blueberry ice cream chockful of blueberries
Blueberry Almond
Blueberry ice cream with almonds
Blueberry Cheesecake
Cheesecake flavored ice cream with blueberry swirl and graham cracker pieces
Butter Pecan
Delicious buttered pecans in butter pecan ice cream
Butterscotch
Butterscotch ice cream with butterscotch swirled throughout
Cake Batter Supreme
Made with yellow cake mix and a fudge swirl
Cantaloupe
Made with locally grown cantaloupes
Cherry Jubilee
Vanilla ice cream with dark cherry halves and chocolate chunks
Cherry Vanilla
Vanilla ice cream with lots of maraschino cherry halves
Chilifest Chocolate (Seasonal)
Chocolate ice cream with chili powder
Chipitty Chocolate
Our chocolate ice cream with chocolate chunks
Chocolate
A dark chocolate ice cream using the finest Dutch cocoa and dark chocolate
Chocolate Almond
Our chocolate ice cream with roasted almonds
Chocolate Cheesecake
Chocolate cheesecake flavored ice cream with graham cracker pieces
Chocolate Chunk
Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chunks
Chocolate Marshmallow
Our chocolate ice cream with a marshmallow swirl
Chocolate Mint Cookie
Chocolate ice cream with chocolate mint cookies
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
Chocolate ice cream with swirls of chocolate and peanut butter with delicious peanut butter pretzel balls added throughout
Chocolate Raspberry Cheescake
Cheescake flavored ice cream with raspberry and fudge swirl and graham craker pieces
Cinn-ful
Cinnamon ice cream with pralines and a caramel swirl
Cinnamon
ice cream flavored with ground cinnamon
Coconut
Creamy coconut based ice cream with shredded coconut
Coconut Almond Fudge
Coconut ice cream with almond pieces, chocolate chunks and chocolate fudge swirl
Coffee
If you're a coffee lover you will love this strong coffee flavored ice cream with freshly ground coffee "specs" added
Coffee Cup
A light coffee ice cream with chopped peanut butter cups added throughout
Coffee & Toffee
A light coffee ice cream with Heath® Candy Bar pieces added throughout
Cookie Dough
Vanilla ice cream with cookie dough pieces and chocolate chunks
Cookies & Cream
Vanilla ice cream with cream filled chocolate cookie
Cotton Candy
Cotton Candy flavored ice cream with either pink or blue food coloring
Creme Caramel
Caramel based ice cream with a caramel swirl
Crunchy Grasshopper
Ice cream with Creme de Menthe for flavor and chocolate mint cookie pieces throughout
Dark Cherry Sorbet
Made with pureed bing cherries
Egg Nog (seasonal)
Egg nog ice cream with nutmeg
Fluffer Nutter
Our scrumptious peanut butter ice cream with a marshmallow swirl
German Chocolate
German chocolate based ice cream with German chocolate chunks, coconut and pecan pieces
Gianduia
Chocolate ice cream with hazelnut pieces and chocolate chunks
Ginger Snap
Our premium ice cream made by juicing fresh ginger root and adding pieces of ginger snap cookies
Good Life Ginger
Our premium ice cream made by juicing fresh ginger root from Good Life Farm in Interlaken, NY
Green Tea
Green Tea Flavored ice cream
Grape
Grape ice cream made with locally grown concord grapes
Hazelnut
Hazelnut base with chopped hazelnuts
Holiday Cherry Vanilla (seasonal)
Vanilla ice cream with lots of red and green maraschino cherry halves
Irish Cream
Vanilla ice cream with Irish Cream liqueur
Itty Bitty Pb Pieces
Vanilla based ice cream with Reese's Pieces® candies and a peanut butter swirl
Jalapeno Popper (seasonal)
A cream cheese flavored ice cream with pureed jalapeno peppers and a raspberry habanero pepper sauce swirl
Jittery Snickers
Our coffee ice cream with Snickers candy pieces
Junior Mint
Mint ice cream (we use white mint) with lots of chocolate chunks and Junior Mint candies
Kahlua Almond Fudge
Our Mocha ice cream with real Kahlua, almond pieces a fudge swirl
Key Lime Pie
Made with real key lime juice and graham cracker pieces
Lavender
Made with organic lavender
Lemon Sorbet
Made with juice of fresh lemons and lemon zest
Licorice
A black licorice flavored ice cream
Mango
Made with the finest Mango puree
Maple Bacon
Maple ice cream using New York State maple syrup and caramelized bacon
Maple Chestnut
Maple ice cream with roasted chestnuts from Goosewatch Winery
Maple Walnut
Maple ice cream using New York State maple syrup and walnuts
Mint Chocolate Chunk
Mint ice cream (we use white mint) with lots of chocolate chunks
Mocha Almond Fudge
Our mocha ice cream with almond pieces and a fudge swirl
Mocha Chocolate Chunk
Mocha Ice Cream loaded with chocolate chunks
Mud Pie
Mocha Ice Cream with graham cracker pieces and fudge swirl
Mudslide
Made with Kahlua, vodka and Irish Creme Liqueur
No Doze
Mocha ice cream with pieces of chocolate covered coffee beans
Nut Brown Ale
Beer flavored ice cream made with Ithaca Brewery Nut Brown Ale
Nutty Nut Brown Ale
Nut Brown Ale ice cream with honey roasted peanuts
Orange Pineapple
An orange pineapple flavored ice cream with a pineapple swirl
Orange Sorbet
Made with Orange juice and orange zest
Passionate Peanut Butter Cup
Peanut butter ice cream with Reese's peanut butter cup pieces, crushed peanuts and a fudge/peanut butter swirl
Peach Cobbler
Made with real peaches and graham cracker pieces
Peachy Keen
Made with real peaches
Peppermint Candy (seasonal)
Peppermint ice cream with red and green peppermint candies
Pina Colada Sorbet
Coconut flavored sorbet with pieces of pineapple
Pistachio
Pistachio flavored ice cream with no artificial coloring, and loads of pistachio pieces
Pralines & Cream
Delicious candy coated pecans in a butter pecan ice cream base with a caramel swirl
Pumpkin
Taste's just like mom's pumpkin pie
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Taste's just like mom's pumpkin pie
Purple Cow
Black raspberry ice cream with chocolate chunks
Red Hot Mama
Cinnamon ice cream with crushed Red Hot candies
Red Raspberry
Made with real red raspberries
Red, White & Blueberry (seasonal)
Vanilla ice cream with a strawberry and blueberry swirl
Rocky Road
Our rich chocolate ice cream with almonds, mini marshmallows and a marshmallow swirl
Rum Raisin
Ice cream with rum soaked golden raisins
S' mores
Vanilla ice cream with mini marshmallows, chocolate chunks, graham cracker pieces plus fudge and marshmallow swirls
Sea Salt Caramel
Caramel base ice cream with a caramel swirl and sea salt
Snickers
Vanilla ice cream with Snickers, chocolate chunks, crushed peanuts and caramel swirled throughout
Spiced Apple
Tastes like apple pie
Strawberrry
Strawberry ice cream with pieces of strawberries
Strawberry Cheesecake
Cheesecake flavored ice cream with strawberry swirl and graham cracker pieces

HOMEMADE FLAVORS - COMPLETE LIST OF FLAVORS CONTINUED
All flavors are not always available. If you are taking a trip up to the Creamery for a specific flavor, please call to make sure it is in stock
Strawberry Shortbread
Vanilla based ice cream with pieces of shortbread cookies and a strawberry swirl
The O.C.
Our chocolate ice cream with orange juice, Triple-Sec, and orange zest
Tiger Strips
Orange Flavored ice cream with a fudge swirl
Tiramisu
Just like the dessert!! Espresso based ice cream with Marsala wine soaked Lady Fingers and chocolate chunks
Ultimate Fudge Brownie
Chocolate ice cream with homemade brownie pieces, chocolate chunks and fudge swirled throughout
Vanilla Bean
We use the finest Madagascar vanilla and vanilla "specs" to make this awesome flavor
Vanilla Fudge
Our vanilla ice cream with a fudge swirl
Vanilla Malt W/ Whoppers
Vanilla ice cream with malt powder and whoppers
Watermelon Sorbet
A very refreshing flavor made with fresh watermelon
WCRT
White chocolate ice cream with white chocolate chunks and red raspberry swirled throughout
White Gold
Vanilla ice cream with cookie dough pieces, white chocolate chunks and caramel swirled throughout
White Out
Vanilla ice cream with white chocolate chunks
White Russian (seasonal)
If you like the drink you're sure to like this flavor made with real Vodka and Kahlua, and white chocolate chunks

WINE SORBETS
Americana Vineyard Barn Raising Red Dark Cherry Sorbet
gluten-free
Americana Vineyard Sweet Rosie Strawberry Sorbet
gluten-free
Buttonwood Grove Winery Reisling Orange Sorbet
gluten-free
Buttonwood Grove Winery Blackberry Briar Blackberry Sorbet
gluten-free
Cayuga Ridge Estate Winery Cranberry Essence Orange Sorbet
gluten-free
Cobblestone Farm Winery Merlot Dark Cherry Sorbet
gluten-free
Goose Watch Winery Strawberry Splendor Strawberry Sorbet
gluten-free
Goose Watch Winery Melody Lemon Sorbet
gluten-free
Lucas Vineyard Riesling Orange Sorbet
gluten-free
Montezuma Winery Cranberry Bog Orange Sorbet
gluten-free
Montezuma Winery Northern Harrier Dark Cherry Sorbet
gluten-free
Sheldrake Point Vineyard Summer Blush Chocolate Ice Cream
gluten-free
Sheldrake Point Vineyard Reisling Raspberry Sorbet
gluten-free
Six Mile Creek Vineyard Dolce Vita Raspberry Sorbet
gluten-free
Swedish Hill Vineyard Doobie Blues Orange Sorbet
gluten-free
King Ferry Winery Merlot Raspberry Sorbet
gluten-free
King Ferry Winery Mystere Raspberry Sorbet
gluten-free

ICE CREAM
Hard Ice Cream Or Sorbet
Wine Sorbet/ice Cream
Soft Serve Custard

ADD-ONS
Waffle Cone Or Dish
Gluten Free Cone
Sprinkles
Dip Top
Candy, Nuts Or Sauce

SUNDAES AND MORE
Sundaes
Brownie Sundae
Seasonal Sundae
Banana Split
Cayuga-uga Sundae
Slice Of Ice Cream Pizza
Take Out
6 pack Ice Cream Sandwich

DRINKS
Ice Cream Soda
Float
Shake

FOOD
Fried Haddock Sandwich
1/4 Lb Hamburger or Vegi-burger
Add Bacon and/or Cheese
Chicken Sandwich
Crispy, Grilled or Buffalo
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich
Pulled Pork Sandwich
BLT
Hofmann Hot Dog
Red or White
Chili Dog
Cheese Dog
Chili Cheese Dog
Grilled Cheese
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Hot-zzarella Cheese Sticks
Sweet Potato Fries
French Fries
Chili Cheese Fries
Nachos & Cheese
Add Salsa

DRINKS
Soda
Regular or Large
Coffee
Regular or Large
Iced Coffee
Regular or Large
Hot Tea
Bottled Water
16 Oz. Milk
Hot Chocolate
Hot Chocolate Float
Iced Tea
Regular or Large
Lemonade
Ice Cream Soda
Float
Shake

Cayuga Lake Creamery Details

Service options
In-store pickup
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Cayuga Lake Creamery Photos

Cayuga Lake Creamery Location

Cayuga Lake Creamery

New York Seneca County Interlaken New York 89

8421 NY-89, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA

Cayuga Lake Creamery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 810 user reviews.

flavorsscoopsareacustardwaffle conesandwichgluten freeseasonalmochapicnic tables

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

If you are craving for ice creams on the way, it can be good stop. The flavors are okay; nothing special.
June 04 · Farhan Fuad Abir
Best ice cream I ever did have. Food is also bomb. I get the buffalo chicken sandwich every time I’m about to make a road trip! This is where it’s at. #1 best ice cream and ice cream eating-environment in all of Tburg area and also the world.
July 11 · rory
Cayuga Lake Creamery was a great ice cream stop. They have a large selection of homemade ice cream and they have hard, soft, custard and sundaes to choose from. They also have some savory food options if you're interested in that. The ice cream was great, my wife enjoyed the cake batter and her waffle cone and I got the Reese's pieces sundae which was incredible! I got the small and it was way more than enough. Only go large if you haven't had food in 24 hours.The place was busy but we really had no wait at all. The team was working fast back there. Prices are average for ice cream nowadays and I thought portions were appropriate.They have an inside and outside eating area attached to the creamery and there is more outside down the hill where there is extra parking as well. It's nothing special inside but for an overly hot day nice to have. The outside down the hill provides shade so that is nice as well.Either way a great stop for ice cream if you are in the area. Enjoy!
August 05 · Michael LaBarbera
Excellent handmade local ice cream. The taste "No Doze" By far one of my favorites. And of course gluten free options including a waffle cup
August 09 · Michal Shiryon
The service itself was fine, the staff were welcoming and friendly but the prices and quality left much to be desired- $8.25 for a single scoop of blueberry cheesecake ice cream that had zero blueberry flavor in a rubbery, stale waffle cone. Very disappointing.
June 11 · Carrie Jeanne