Chilly Willy's

Hello, Ohioans! In the charming community of Newcomerstown, there’s a local establishment that has captured the hearts and appetites of residents and visitors alike: Chilly Willy's. This isn't just your average ice cream shop; it’s a full-fledged local diner experience, offering everything from massive ice cream concoctions to hearty, comforting meals. For anyone in Tuscarawas County looking for fantastic food, incredible value, and genuinely friendly service, Chilly Willy's is a true gem worth discovering.

Chilly Willy's has garnered a reputation for being a place that customers "💯 percent love," and it's easy to see why. It embodies the spirit of a classic American eatery where quality and generosity go hand-in-hand. Whether you’re craving a towering ice cream sundae after a long day or a satisfying meal that reminds you of home, Chilly Willy's delivers. Their commitment to providing "excellent" food and "great" service ensures that every visit is a pleasant one. What truly sets them apart, as highlighted by loyal patrons, is the exceptional value you receive – "food is not skimpy you get moneys worth and more." This dedication to customer satisfaction, coupled with a diverse menu, makes Chilly Willy's a consistent favorite in Newcomerstown. It’s a place where the "ladies" working there are "always wonderful," ensuring a warm and welcoming atmosphere for all who walk through their doors. It’s more than just a place to eat; it’s a cherished part of the local community, promising a delightful experience with every order.

Chilly Willy's is conveniently located at 401 W State St, Newcomerstown, OH 43832, USA. West State Street is a prominent road in Newcomerstown, making the establishment very accessible for both local residents and those passing through the area. Its position on a main thoroughfare ensures high visibility and ease of navigation.

Being situated in the heart of Newcomerstown means that Chilly Willy's is a straightforward destination to reach, whether you're coming from different parts of the village or traveling from surrounding communities in Tuscarawas County. The location is typically well-served by local infrastructure, implying convenient access and potentially ample parking for patrons. Its accessibility makes it an ideal stop for a quick lunch, an afternoon ice cream treat, or a casual dinner with family and friends. For Ohioans exploring the diverse offerings of their state, Chilly Willy's provides a perfect, easily reachable spot to satisfy cravings and experience genuine local hospitality. The ease of getting to this location contributes to its popularity as a go-to spot for satisfying meals and delightful desserts, making it a true asset to the Newcomerstown community.

Chilly Willy's offers a truly extensive menu that brilliantly combines the best of a classic American diner with a full-fledged ice cream parlor. Here’s a detailed look at their services and culinary delights:

• Ice Cream & Frozen Custard:
  • Hand-Dipped Ice Cream: A variety of flavors are available in cones or dishes, including classics and unique options.
  • Soft Serve Custard: Offered in cones or dishes, with various sizes from "Wee-Willu" to large.
  • Sundaes and "Williwaws": A wide array of sundaes with numerous topping combinations. A specific highlight is the "3 lb banana split for $6 plus tip," indicating extremely generous portions and incredible value. Other toppings include a vast selection of nuts (Pecans, Cashews, Walnuts, Macadamias, Mixed Nuts), candies (M&Ms, Butterfinger, Snickers, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Heath Bar, Twix, Nerds, Rainbow Sprinkles, Reese's Pieces, Kit Kat, Dark & Milk Chocolate Chip mix, Gummi Bears), and fruits (Blueberries, Blackberries, Strawberries, Raspberries, Cherries, Tart Cherries, Bananas, Pineapple, Coconut). Other "stuff" like Oreos, Fudge Mint Cookies, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Brownie Bites, Granola, Graham Cracker Crunch, Nutter Butters, Hot Fudge, Chocolate Syrup, Butterscotch, Caramel, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow Crème, Mini-Mallows, and Whipped Cream are also available.
  • Shakes & Malts: Classic blended milkshakes and malts.
  • Frozen Yogurt & Dole Whip: Rotating flavors are introduced weekly, with options available in pints and quarts.
  • Frozen Custard Cakes & Novelties: Providing options for celebrations or grab-and-go treats.
• Savory Food Items:
  • Burgers: A comprehensive selection including Hamburger (Single/Double), Cheeseburger (Single/Double), Bacon Burger (Single/Double), Bacon Cheeseburger (Single/Double), and even a "Horseshoe Hamburger."
  • Hot Dogs & Specialty Dogs: Beyond a plain hot dog, they offer "Slick Willy" (plain dog with choice of toppings), Chicago Dog (authentic Chicago-style), Coney (sauce only), Coney Dog, Chilly Dog, Chilly Cheese Dog, Bacon Chilly Cheese Dog, and the "Double Dog Dare" (two dogs with chili, onion, and cheese in one bun). The "meatloaf to write home about" suggests this is also a highly praised savory dish, possibly available as a sandwich or meal.
  • Sandwiches: Grilled Cheese, BLT (with Hartrich's Bacon), Plain Jane PBJ, Grilled Chicken Breast, Beer Battered Cod Fish, Hartrich's Pulled Pork BBQ, and Pulled Pork Horseshoe.
  • Chicken: 4 Piece Chicken Strip Meal, 2 Piece Fish Meal.
  • Sides: Naked Fries, Cheese Fries, Chilly Cheese Fries, Sweet Potato Fries, Wisconsin Cheese Curds, Mozzarella Cheese Sticks, Fried Mac N' Cheese, Fried Pickles, and Onion Rings.
  • Nachos: Nachos & Cheese, Nachos & Salsa, Nachos, Cheese, & Salsa, Salsanator, Nachinator (with homemade chili), and Pulled Pork BBQ Nachos.
  • Soft Pretzel: Available with salt or cinnamon-sugar topping, or with dipping sauces like nacho cheese, peanut butter, or hot fudge.
  • Salads: Including Garden Salad (with romaine lettuce, bacon, green olives, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and homemade crunchies, with optional grilled or crispy chicken) and Taco Salad.
• Beverages: A range of soft drinks.

This expansive menu ensures that Chilly Willy's caters to every member of the family, offering a full, satisfying meal experience alongside their impressive array of frozen delights.

Chilly Willy's stands out in the Newcomerstown area due to several key features and highlights that consistently impress its clientele:

• Exceptional Value and Generous Portions: This is arguably their most praised feature. Customers repeatedly highlight that "food is not skimpy you get moneys worth and more." The "3 lb banana split for $6 plus tip" is a prime example of their commitment to providing immense value for money, making it a very appealing option for families and those with a hearty appetite.
• Outstanding Food Quality Beyond Ice Cream: While an "ice cream shop," their savory food menu receives equally high, if not higher, praise. The "meatloaf to write home about" and the generally "excellent" food indicate a strong culinary offering that goes beyond typical dairy bar fare. This makes it a versatile stop for full meals.
• Excellent Customer Service and Friendly Staff: Patrons consistently rave about the "great people working there" and the "wonderful" "ladies" who provide "excellent service." This warm, welcoming, and attentive staff significantly enhances the overall experience, making customers feel appreciated and eager to return.
• Wide Variety of Ice Cream and Toppings: Their extensive selection of ice cream flavors, soft serve, sundaes, "Williwaws," and a massive array of toppings (nuts, candies, fruits, sauces) ensures that every ice cream craving can be satisfied with a custom-made treat. The availability of frozen yogurt and Dole Whip also caters to diverse preferences.
• Diverse Savory Menu: From various burgers and specialty hot dogs (like the authentic Chicago Dog) to pulled pork, fried sides, nachos, and even salads, Chilly Willy's offers a comprehensive menu that can cater to lunch, dinner, or a quick snack before dessert. This makes it a one-stop shop for satisfying hunger.
• Local Gem and Community Favorite: The sentiment of customers "💯 percent love this place" indicates that Chilly Willy's is a cherished local spot, a true community hub where people feel comfortable and consistently satisfied.

These highlights collectively solidify Chilly Willy's reputation as a top-tier local establishment, offering delicious food, generous portions, and an incredibly welcoming atmosphere.

For those planning a delightful visit to Chilly Willy's in Newcomerstown, or if you need to get in touch, here is the essential contact information:

Address:
401 W State St, Newcomerstown, OH 43832, USA

Phone:
(740) 498-8681
+1 740-498-8681 (Mobile Phone)

Their general operating hours are:

• Monday-Thursday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM
• Friday-Saturday: 10:30 AM – 11:00 PM
• Sunday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM

It is always a good idea to confirm these hours, especially around holidays or during adverse weather conditions, by calling ahead or checking any official online channels they may maintain. Having these contact details readily available helps ensure a smooth and convenient experience for all local customers.

For the residents of Ohio, particularly those in Newcomerstown and the surrounding areas of Tuscarawas County, Chilly Willy's stands out as an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended local establishment. It perfectly embodies the values of community, value, and quality that Ohioans appreciate.

Firstly, its incredible value and generous portions are a major draw. In a state where getting your "money's worth and more" is highly valued, Chilly Willy's delivers. The legendary "3 lb banana split for $6 plus tip" is a testament to their commitment to providing abundant, satisfying treats. This makes it an ideal, budget-friendly option for families and anyone looking for a truly filling and delicious meal or dessert without breaking the bank.

Secondly, Chilly Willy's ability to offer "excellent" food beyond just ice cream means it serves as a versatile dining destination. Whether you're craving a burger, a chili dog, or their highly praised "meatloaf to write home about," you can get a full, satisfying meal before indulging in a sweet treat. This convenience makes it a one-stop shop for a family outing, eliminating the need to visit multiple places for different cravings.

Furthermore, the consistently highlighted "great people working there" and "excellent service" create a truly welcoming and pleasant atmosphere. Ohioans appreciate friendly, attentive staff who make them feel valued. This warm hospitality transforms a simple visit into a positive experience, fostering a strong sense of loyalty among local patrons.

Finally, its accessible location on West State Street ensures that Chilly Willy's is a convenient and easily reachable spot for locals in Newcomerstown and nearby communities. It's a place where you can quickly grab a bite or linger for a more relaxed meal and dessert, knowing you'll always receive quality and value. By choosing Chilly Willy's, Ohioans are supporting a beloved local business that consistently delivers on its promise of delicious food, generous portions, and a genuinely friendly experience, making it an indispensable part of the Newcomerstown community.

Chilly Willy's

401 W State St, Newcomerstown, OH 43832, USA