Cockeye Creamery Introduce
When you’re in search of the perfect sweet treat in Ohio, a visit to a local ice cream shop isn't just about the dessert—it’s about the experience. In the heart of Warren, a community gem stands out for its delicious creations and commitment to its neighbors: Cockeye Creamery. This is more than just a place to grab a cone; it's a destination where you can taste the passion for crafting high-quality, small-batch ice cream and feel the warmth of a business that truly cares about the people it serves.
Cockeye Creamery has carved out a special place for itself on Warren’s west side, building a reputation for excellence that has been recognized on the prestigious Ohio Ice Cream Trail. This distinction is a testament to the quality and creativity behind every scoop. They’ve also been recognized for their outstanding products, earning multiple awards from the North American Ice Cream Association for flavors like their Deep Chocolate and Fresh Strawberry. What started as a passion project has grown into a beloved local institution, a place where families and friends can come together to enjoy classic flavors or try something new and exciting. The creamery operates in tandem with its sister business, Cockeye BBQ, creating a destination where you can satisfy both your savory and sweet cravings in one trip. From the moment you arrive, you get a sense of the care that goes into everything they do, from their scratch-made ingredients to their friendly, welcoming staff.
One of the most impressive aspects of Cockeye Creamery is its dedication to constant evolution. The flavor menu is a dynamic list that changes with the seasons and the creative inspiration of the team. This means you can visit regularly and always find something new to tempt your taste buds. While you’ll always find staples like rich Deep Chocolate and classic French Vanilla Bean, you might also discover chef-inspired creations with unique ingredients, like their Honey-Lavender ice cream made with real Ohio wildflower honey. This commitment to fresh, new ideas keeps the experience fresh and exciting for every visitor, whether they're a first-timer or a regular patron.
---Cockeye Creamery is conveniently located at 1805 1/2 Parkman Rd NW #7, Warren, OH 44485, USA. It's nestled in a vibrant area that's easy to access for anyone in Warren or the surrounding Trumbull County region. The location is shared with Cockeye BBQ, making it a perfect spot for a full meal and dessert outing.
For those driving, the creamery offers generous parking, which is a significant convenience and a highlight noted by many visitors. The ample parking space ensures that you can stop by without the hassle of searching for a spot, making it an ideal destination for a quick treat or a leisurely visit. The property also features pleasant outdoor seating, providing a comfortable and enjoyable atmosphere to savor your ice cream, especially on a nice day. This combination of easy access and welcoming amenities makes Cockeye Creamery a go-to spot for locals seeking a relaxing and delicious experience.
---Cockeye Creamery provides a variety of services to meet the needs of its customers, both at the shop and for special events.
- Super-premium Ice Cream: They are well-known for their super-premium ice cream, which is made with 15% butterfat for a rich, creamy texture. The menu includes both everyday signature flavors and a rotating selection of unique, seasonal creations.
- Super-premium Milkshakes: Enjoy their delicious ice cream blended into a thick and satisfying milkshake, perfect for a refreshing treat.
- Italian Ice and Sorbet: For those looking for a non-dairy option, the creamery offers Italian ice and sorbet.
- Super-premium Ice Cream Pies: Cockeye Creamery also offers ice cream pies, a fantastic option for parties, holidays, or a special family treat.
- Catering Services: The creamery offers on-site and off-site catering for a variety of events, including wedding receptions, corporate outings, graduation parties, and baby showers. They use a fleet of catering vans to bring their mobile ice cream cart to your event, ensuring a memorable dessert experience for your guests.
- Wholesale Pints: Cockeye Creamery sells its popular ice cream flavors in wholesale pints, allowing customers to take their favorite treats home to enjoy later.
What makes Cockeye Creamery truly special are the details and values that define the business. Here are some of the key features and highlights that set it apart:
- Super-premium and Chef-Inspired Flavors: The creamery prides itself on using only the best ingredients to craft its ice cream. Many of their flavors are chef-inspired, pushing the boundaries of traditional ice cream while also offering expertly made classic varieties. Their small-batch production ensures every scoop is made with care and attention to detail.
- Strong Community Involvement: Cockeye Creamery is deeply committed to giving back to the community. They are highly involved in local charity work, including their "Cockeye Cares Pint Program" which supports local organizations like the Warren Family Mission and Sleep in Heavenly Peace of Trumbull County. This strong community-focused culture is a core part of their identity.
- Friendly and Professional Staff: Customers consistently rave about the friendly, happy, and professional staff. The team goes above and beyond to provide excellent service, creating a welcoming and positive environment for everyone who walks through the door.
- Pleasant Outdoor Seating and Ample Parking: The combination of comfortable outdoor seating and generous parking makes a visit to Cockeye Creamery a stress-free and enjoyable experience.
- Featured on the Ohio Ice Cream Trail: Being included on the Ohio Ice Cream Trail is a significant honor that highlights Cockeye Creamery as one of the state's most beloved and high-quality creameries.
To learn more about Cockeye Creamery, check their current hours, or inquire about catering, you can reach out using the following information.
Address: 1805 1/2 Parkman Rd NW #7, Warren, OH 44485, USA
Phone: (330) 392-7326
---For locals in Warren and Trumbull County, Cockeye Creamery is more than just a place to get dessert; it’s a vital part of the community. It’s a business that not only delivers an exceptional product but also fosters a culture of kindness and generosity. The commitment to local charity work, the use of quality ingredients, and the dedication to crafting unique and delicious flavors all contribute to a sense of local pride.
It’s a place where you can feel good about your purchase, knowing that you are supporting a business that actively contributes to the well-being of the community. Whether you're grabbing a scoop with the kids after a long day, treating yourself to a creative milkshake, or planning a catered event, Cockeye Creamery provides a friendly, high-quality, and community-minded experience that perfectly suits the spirit of local Ohio life. It’s a sweet spot where great taste and good deeds go hand-in-hand.
Cockeye Creamery Food & drink
Current Flavors - updated in real time!
- (Vegan/Dairy-Free) Chocolate
Non-dairy chocolate ice cream made with cocoa and sugar
- (Vegan/Dairy-Free) Vanilla Bean
Oat milk, premium vanilla bean
- Andromeda
Chocolate ice cream, brownies, candy-coated mini chocolate chips.
- Bada-Bing!
Almond ice cream with toasted, slivered almonds and black (bing) cherries.
- Black Cherry
Black cherry ice cream with real halved Bing cherries
- Blackberry Chocolate Chunk
Real blackberries, chocolate chunks. Your wife will love this one.
- Blueberry Cheesecake
Real blueberries in a cheesecake ice cream.
- Butter Pecan
Hillson buttered pecans in smooth nutty base.
- Buttermilk Pie
Cockeye Creamery’s signature chef-inspired flavor; made with fresh-baked buttermilk pies from Cockeye BBQ’s kitchen.
- Cookie Monster
Cookie dough ice cream with Oreos and chocolate chip cookie dough.
- Cornbread And Sorghum
House-made cornbread steeped in sorghum, a rich sweet corn extract, and real-deal Tennessee sorghum syrup
- Deep Chocolate
Cockeye Creamery's take on traditional, American chocolate ice cream.
- Fever Dream
Chocolate ice cream w/ a peanut-butter swirl, brownies, and chocolate-covered peanuts
- French Vanilla Bean
Egg, premium vanilla bean.
- Fresh Strawberry
Strawberry puree and hunks of fresh strawberry.
- Honey Lavender
Real Ohio wildflower honey (Kline Honey, Rootstown, OH), vanilla, and lavender
- Kong
Banana ice cream with graham crackers and mini buckeyes.
- Mint To Be
Creme de menthe, chocolate chunks.
- Peach
Peach super-premium ice cream w/ real peach pureé and hunks of real peaches
- Peanut Butter Pie
Creamy Reese’s peanut butter, marshmallow, graham cracker, chocolate chunks.
- Pistachio
Beautifully green pistachio ice cream with salty Hillson pistachios.
- Pupper Butter Jam
Sweet cream ice cream with strawberry jam, peanut butter, and cinnamon-graham swirls (Cockeye Cares Pint Program: 100% of proceeds to benefit The Healthy Hearts & Paws Project)
- Razzle-Dazzle
Dark raspberry super-premium ice cream w/ blueberry swirl & real blackberries, raspberries
- S'mores
Graham Cracker super-premium ice cream with mini marshmallows and dark chocolate chunks
- Spumoni
Chocolate, pistachio, and black cherry super-premium ice cream
- Superman
Juicy lemon, blueberry blue moon, and red raspberry super-premium ice cream
- White House
Our French vanilla bean ice cream with maraschino cherries throughout.
- Wired!
Coffee ice cream made with fresh ground Youngstown Coffee Co. espresso beans, chocolate chunks, and brownies.
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Sugar - Super-Premium Ice Cream Sandwich US$4.99
Our made-to-order ice cream sandwich with fresh-baked (and then frozen) sugar cookies. Just choose your flavor!
- Chocolate Chip - Super-Premium Ice Cream Sandwich US$4.99
Our made-to-order ice cream sandwich with fresh-baked (and then frozen) chocolate chip cookies. Just choose your flavor!
Ice Cream Pies
- Buttermilk Pie Ice Cream Pie US$22.99
Our Buttermilk Pie ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!
Hot Chocolate
- Signature Hazelnut Hot Chocolate
Cockeye Creamery Signature Hazelnut Hot Chocolate: freshly steamed milk, rich Ghiradelli premium chocolate syrup, and hazelnut syrup for a balanced, velvety finish.
- Chocolate And Caramel Swirl
Caramel Hot Chocolate: freshly steamed milk meets premium Ghiradelli chocolate and caramel for a fusion of rich and sweet delight.
- Vanilla Hot Chocolate
Vanilla Hot Chocolate: freshly steamed milk, rich Ghiradelli premium chocolate syrup, and a splash of vanilla for an aromatic twist on traditional hot chocolate.
Cockeye Creamery Details
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- On-site services
- Takeaway
Popular for
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Assistive hearing loop
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Table service
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
- Toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Family friendly
- Groups
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Cockeye Creamery Photos










Cockeye Creamery Location
Cockeye Creamery
1805 1/2, 1805 Parkman Rd NW #7, Warren, OH 44485, USA
Cockeye Creamery Reviews
waffle coneBBQselectioncookie monsterpeanut butter pieveganparkingflavoringredientsshake
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I enjoyed my experience at Cockeye Creamery very much. The staff was kind and professional. The S'mores milkshake I ordered tasted good. Even in the aftermath of rainy weather, the vibe was pleasant with multiple customers. I would recommend it.
July 16 · D.J.W. Words and SoundsYou don’t need me to tell you how amazing this ice cream is- there are so many other reviews to do that. What I will tell you is that this is a business with an excellent culture. The workers are friendly and happy. One of them cheerfully plugged in my phone for me while my kids and I ate ice cream (I was traveling through, had a situation with my car charger and honestly would have been in trouble without the help). I noticed that the business is highly involved with local charity work.So, in addition to the pleasant outdoor seating, generous parking and fantastic ice cream, they are just good community members. Grateful for the help today!
July 13 · Sarah HirebetCockeye has ice cream dialed in - from the top to the bottom of the menu. Imaginative flavors done very very well. We had the Sweet Corn Sorghum ( yes I was hesitant, but the taste is awesome) and the super good Pecan Praline. If we had the time I would have been so happy to stay and sample the rest of the menu. Good parking and a large, comfortable, partly covered patio make this delicious place easy to stop and stay for a while.
August 22 · Jim CalvertWow! I had no idea this was here and on a stop back from Presque Isle and it was amazing. A decent size parking lot, super cute outdoor area to eat, FOUR vegan flavors at the time we visited, a huge menu otherwise, and fantastic service. Definitely will be back!
July 27 · Molly SmithThe manager, Mia is awesome! She is so kind and thoughtful. We had a little trouble with our pup cup order, I had called so no other dogs would come into possible harm with it. She was adamant to make it right and so apologetic. Because of how this situation was handled, we will now be regulars! The ice cream is wonderful, but the workers are who make or break the experience. She is A+; take good care of her!
June 14 · Hunter Woodley
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

1628 W Market St, Warren, OH 44485, USA

5047 W Market St, Leavittsburg, OH 44430, USA

119 State Rd NW, Warren, OH 44483, USA

4713 Mahoning Ave NW, Warren, OH 44483, USA

2123 Elm Rd NE, Warren, OH 44483, USA

6033 E Market St, Warren, OH 44484, USA

5140 Youngstown Warren Rd, Niles, OH 44446, USA

1144 Wilson Sharpsville Rd, Cortland, OH 44410, USA

1913 Niles Cortland Rd NE, Warren, OH 44484, USA

1924 Niles Cortland Rd SE, Warren, OH 44484, USA

3260 State Rte 5, Cortland, OH 44410, USA

3743 OH-46, Mineral Ridge, OH 44440, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





