Cold Stone Creamery in Fitchburg, WI: A Local's Guide to a Unique Ice Cream Experience

Cold Stone Creamery Introduce

For those in Fitchburg and the broader Madison area, the search for a truly unique dessert experience often leads to Cold Stone Creamery. This beloved national chain has established a strong local presence by focusing on a simple but delightful concept: turning the process of getting ice cream into a personalized show. Known for its fresh, handcrafted ice cream and wide variety of mix-ins, this establishment offers a different kind of frozen treat. It’s a place where you don't just order a scoop; you get to create your own unique "Creation," a custom masterpiece blended on a frozen granite stone right before your eyes. This interactive approach has made it a popular spot for families, friends, and anyone looking to celebrate a special occasion or simply satisfy a sweet craving. The Fitchburg location embodies this spirit, aiming to be a go-to destination for Wisconsin locals seeking high-quality ice cream with a personal touch. The commitment to offering a variety of flavors and the fun, customizable experience sets this shop apart from a standard ice cream counter.

As a brand, Cold Stone Creamery has long been a favorite, and this particular shop has garnered attention for its unique qualities and the personal touch it brings to the community. The appeal lies not only in the final product but in the entire process. Customers can choose from a range of classic and seasonal ice cream flavors, and then add in a huge selection of candies, fruits, nuts, and other toppings. These are then expertly folded into the ice cream on the signature frozen granite stone, ensuring that every bite has the perfect mix of flavors and textures. This level of customization ensures that every visit can be a new and exciting experience. While the core experience remains consistent with the brand's standards, a local establishment like the one in Fitchburg often develops its own character, shaped by its staff and its relationship with the community.

This Cold Stone Creamery location provides more than just a quick dessert stop. It's a place designed to be a part of the local routine, whether it's for a reward after a good report card, a sweet treat to cap off a family dinner, or a destination for a casual date. The environment is typically vibrant and welcoming, with the sounds of scoops clinking and mix-ins being folded in, creating a lively backdrop for enjoying your dessert. While the brand is nationally recognized, this specific shop in Fitchburg strives to feel like a neighborhood spot that locals can be proud to have in their community. The focus on quality ingredients, from the ice cream base to the fresh mix-ins, is a point of pride that resonates with customers who appreciate a well-made product.

Location and Accessibility

The Cold Stone Creamery in Fitchburg is conveniently located at 2970 Cahill Main Ste 103, Fitchburg, WI 53711, USA. This address places it within a vibrant commercial area, making it an easy and accessible destination for residents of Fitchburg and the surrounding suburbs. The location is situated within a shopping center, offering plenty of parking and easy access from major roads. This is a significant advantage for families and individuals who prefer a quick and hassle-free stop. Its placement in a frequented local hub means that it's a natural choice for a post-shopping treat, a dessert after a nearby meal, or a convenient pick-up spot for an ice cream cake for a special event. The area is well-lit and welcoming, contributing to a safe and pleasant experience for all visitors, day or night. The accessibility of this location makes it a practical choice for residents who don't want to travel far to get a high-quality frozen treat.

Services Offered

Cold Stone Creamery provides a full menu of delectable options beyond just a scoop in a cup. They offer a wide array of services to satisfy any sweet tooth.

Signature Creations: Handcrafted ice cream combinations mixed on a frozen granite stone with a variety of mix-ins like nuts, candies, fruits, and sauces.
Custom Creations: The opportunity to build your own ice cream flavor and mix-in combination from scratch.
Ice Cream Cakes: Ready-made or custom-ordered ice cream cakes perfect for birthdays, holidays, and other special occasions. These cakes are a popular choice for locals who want a unique and delicious celebratory centerpiece.
Shakes and Smoothies: Rich, creamy shakes and refreshing smoothies made to order with your choice of flavors. One customer review mentioned enjoying any mix flavor as a shake, highlighting the versatility of the menu.
Cupcakes and Cookie Sandwiches: Handcrafted ice cream cupcakes and cookie sandwiches that are easy to grab and go for a quick treat.
To-Go Options: Pints and quarts of your favorite ice cream flavors available to take home and enjoy later.

Features / Highlights

The Fitchburg Cold Stone Creamery is known for a few key features that make it stand out.

High-Quality Ingredients: The ice cream is made fresh in-store, and the mix-ins are of high quality, creating a premium dessert experience.
The Frozen Granite Stone Experience: The iconic process of mixing ingredients on a frozen stone is a key highlight, providing a fun and interactive show for customers.
Passionate and Friendly Staff: One customer review specifically praised the owner for being "Great" and "very happy to always serve anyone that walks thru his shop," suggesting a strong positive culture and commitment to service.
Extensive Customization: The endless options for flavors, mix-ins, and cones mean that every visit can result in a new, personalized dessert creation.
A Community Staple: This location has become a top choice for some locals due to its consistent product quality and welcoming atmosphere, making it a reliable spot for a sweet treat.
Variety Beyond Ice Cream: In addition to the signature ice cream Creations, the availability of ice cream cakes and shakes provides a wide range of choices for customers with different tastes and needs.

Contact Information

For more information or to place an order, you can contact the Fitchburg Cold Stone Creamery using the following details.

Address: 2970 Cahill Main Ste 103, Fitchburg, WI 53711, USA

Phone: (608) 277-0769

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For residents of Fitchburg and the surrounding Wisconsin communities, Cold Stone Creamery offers a dessert destination that is uniquely suited to local tastes and needs. It's more than just an ice cream shop; it's a place that provides a personalized and entertaining experience. Its appeal lies in its commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients and the freedom it gives customers to design their own frozen treats from a vast selection of flavors and mix-ins. For those who appreciate a hands-on approach and a product made just for them, this is the ideal spot. The location’s accessibility and presence in a bustling part of town make it a convenient stop for families, students, and professionals alike.

The personal touch from a committed owner, as noted by a satisfied customer, adds to the charm, making it a business that feels connected to the community. While a customer's experience can always vary, the core promise of Cold Stone—a delightful, custom ice cream Creation—is what makes this location a solid choice. Whether you're celebrating a birthday with one of their famous ice cream cakes or simply want to create your own signature dessert on a warm Wisconsin evening, this Fitchburg location offers a reliable and enjoyable way to satisfy your sweet tooth. It’s a place that turns a simple craving into a memorable event, cementing its role as a valuable local spot for those who seek more than just a scoop of ice cream.

Cold Stone Creamery Food & drink

Create Your Own Creation™
Create Your Own Creation
Select your flavor and one FREE Mix-in. Customize further by adding more Mix-ins and a Waffle Cone or Bowl.
Mix & Go Create Your Own Creation™
Select your flavor and Mix-ins. Customize further by adding more Mix-ins and a Waffle Cone or Bowl.

Signature Creations™
Root Beer Revival
Root Beer Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Caramel & Whipped Topping
Caramel Carnival Churro
Churro Ice Cream, Cinnamon Toast Crunch™, Caramel & Sugar Crystals
Cornbread is My Jam
Honey Cornbread with Blackberry Jam Ice Cream, Cornbread, Honey & Blueberries
Very Berry Non-Dairy™
Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk frozen dessert, mixed with Strawberries, Blueberries, and Raspberries
Don't Cry Over Spilled Silk
Plant-based never tasted so good! Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk Frozen Dessert, Banana, Peanut Butter & Roasted Almonds
Apple Pie a la Cold Stone®
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Cinnamon, Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Apple Pie Filling and Caramel
Banana Caramel Crunch®
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Banana and Caramel
Berry Berry Berry Good®
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Raspberries, Strawberries and Blueberries
The Better NUTTER BUTTER®
NUTTER BUTTER® Ice Cream, NUTTER BUTTER® Cookies, Sugar Crystals & Fudge
Birthday Cake OREO® Celebration
Birthday Cake OREO® Cookie Ice Cream, Birthday Cake OREO® Cookies, Rainbow Sprinkles & OREO® Cookie Frosting
Birthday Cake Remix™
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles, Brownie and Fudge (calories listed per serving)
Cake Batter Batter Batter™
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough and Brownie
Cheesecake Fantasy®
Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Blueberries and Strawberries
Chocolate Devotion®
Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Brownie and Fudge
Coffee Lovers Only®
Coffee Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Heath® Bar and Caramel
Cookie Doughn't You Want Some®
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough, Fudge and Caramel
Cookie Mintster®
Mint Ice Cream with double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge
Cookies Make Everything Batter™
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies, GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Whipped Topping
Dough for It!™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough and Sugar Crystals
Dough-lightful Peanut Butter™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Peanut Butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup and Sugar Crystals
Founder's Favorite®
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Pecans, Brownie, Fudge and Caramel
Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip®
Mint Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Brownie and Fudge
Mud Pie Mojo®
Coffee Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies, Peanut Butter, Roasted Almonds and Fudge
One Smart Brookie™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Brownie and Cookie Dough
OREO® Overload
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge
Our Strawberry Blonde®
Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Strawberries, Caramel and Whipped Topping
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection®
Chocolate Ice Cream with Peanut Butter, Reese's® Peanut Butter Cup and Fudge
REESE'S Peanut Butter Awesome Sauce
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup & Reese’s Peanut Butter Sauce
Somewhere Over the Rain-dough™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Frosting, Rainbow Sprinkles and Sugar Crystals
Surrender to Strawberry™
Strawberry Ice Cream with Strawberries, Yellow Cake and Whipped Topping

Ice Cream Cakes & Novelties – Pre-Order
Choose your pickup time between 1-14 days
Cake Batter Confetti™
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Cookie Dough Delirium™
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Cookie Dough and Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Cookies & Creamery™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Midnight Delight®
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Fudge and Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
OREO® Cookies and Cream Extreme
Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Ice Cream with GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy OREO® Cookie Frosting
Strawberry Passion™
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake, Strawberry Puree and Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Strawberry Frosting
Tall, Dark & Delicious™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Brownies and Chocolate Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting and cascading Fudge Ganache

Ice Cream Cakes & Novelties – Ready Now
These items are ready for you to pickup which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Birthday Cake OREO® Party - Ready Now
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake, Birthday Cake OREO® Cookie Ice Cream, Birthday Cake OREO® Cookies & Rainbow Sprinkles wrapped in fluffy White Frosting and topped with a "Happy Father's Day" Chocolate Plaque **This item is ready for you to pi...
Cake Batter Batter Batter™ Pre-packed Quart US$15.99
Rich, creamy Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough and Brownie pieces
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection™ Pre-packed Quart US$15.99
Rich Chocolate Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Cups and gooey Fudge in a Peanut Butter swirl
Founder's Favorite® Pre-packed Quart US$15.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with chewy Brownies and toasted Pecans, swirled with rich Fudge and Caramel
OREO® Overload Pre-packed Quart US$15.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge

Might Like It
Not sure if you've Gotta Have It? Try something new by adding a sample of one of our favorite flavors to your order!
Root Beer Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Churro Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Honey Cornbread with Blackberry Jam Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Birthday Cake OREO® Cookie Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
NUTTER BUTTER® Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk Frozen Dessert - Sample US$0.99
Cake Batter Ice Cream® - Sample US$0.99
Cheesecake Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Chocolate Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Coffee Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
French Vanilla Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Mint Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Strawberry Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Vanilla Lite Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99

Cold Stone For Your Freezer
Root Beer Revival - Freezer
Root Beer Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Caramel & Whipped Topping
Caramel Carnival Churro - Freezer
Churro Ice Cream, Cinnamon Toast Crunch™, Caramel & Sugar Crystals
Cornbread is My Jam - Freezer
Honey Cornbread with Blackberry Jam Ice Cream, Cornbread, Honey & Blueberries
REESE'S Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup 6-Pack US$19.99
Six Chocolate Cups filled with layers of Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce & Chocolate Ice Cream topped with rich Fudge Ganache, Sea Salt & Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack US$14.99
One of each of our Cake Batter™ Sprinkle, Cookie Crumb Yum, Kiss N' Tell Chocolate, and Perfect Duet Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches Cake Batter™ Sprinkle: Cake Batter Ice Cream® sandwiched by moist Chocolate Chip Cookies and rolled in Rainbow Spri...
Ice Cream Cupcake Variety 6-Pack US$16.99
Two of each of our Sweet Cream, Cake Batter™ Delux and Double Chocolate Devotion™ Ice Cream Cupcakes Sweet Cream Cupcake: A rich Chocolate Cup filled with a layer of Yellow Cake, Fudge and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with fluffy White Frosting...
Apple Pie a la Cold Stone® - Freezer
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Cinnamon, Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Apple Pie Filling and Caramel
Banana Caramel Crunch® - Freezer
"French Vanilla Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Banana and Caramel
Berry Berry Berry Good®
"Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Raspberries, Strawberries and Blueberries
The Better NUTTER BUTTER® - Freezer
NUTTER BUTTER® Ice Cream, NUTTER BUTTER® Cookies, Sugar Crystals & Fudge
Birthday Cake OREO® Celebration - Freezer
Birthday Cake OREO® Cookie Ice Cream, Birthday Cake OREO® Cookies, Rainbow Sprinkles & OREO® Cookie Frosting
Birthday Cake Remix™ - Freezer
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles, Brownie and Fudge
Cake Batter Batter Batter™ - Freezer
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough and Brownie
Cheesecake Fantasy® - Freezer
Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Blueberries and Strawberries
Chocolate Devotion® - Freezer
Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Brownie and Fudge
Coffee Lovers Only® - Freezer
Coffee Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Heath® Bar and Caramel
Cookie Doughn't You Want Some® - Freezer
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough, Fudge and Caramel
Cookie Mintster® - Freezer
Mint Ice Cream with double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge
Cookies Make Everything Batter™ - Freezer
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies, GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Whipped Topping
Dough for It!™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough and Sugar Crystals
Dough-lightful Peanut Butter™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Peanut Butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup and Sugar Crystals
Founder's Favorite® - Freezer
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Pecans, Brownie, Fudge and Caramel
Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip® - Freezer
Mint Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Brownie and Fudge
Mud Pie Mojo® - Freezer
Coffee Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies, Peanut Butter, Roasted Almonds and Fudge
One Smart Brookie™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Brownie and Cookie Dough
OREO® Overload - Freezer
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge
Our Strawberry Blonde® - Freezer
Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Strawberries, Caramel and Whipped Topping
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection® - Freezer
Chocolate Ice Cream with Peanut Butter, Reese's® Peanut Butter Cup and Fudge
REESE’S Peanut Butter Awesome Sauce - Freezer
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup & Reese’s Peanut Butter Sauce
Somewhere Over the Rain-dough™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Frosting, Rainbow Sprinkles and Sugar Crystals
Surrender to Strawberry™ - Freezer
Strawberry Ice Cream with Strawberries, Yellow Cake and Whipped Topping

Shakes
Go With the Float US$5.99
Root Beer Ice Cream, Root Beer, Whipped Topping & a Maraschino Cherry

Give Back
Cold Stone Creamery is Sprinkling Kindness… and you can help! Add a Creation™ Donation to your cart and we will deliver an Ice Cream Creation to local heroes on the front lines. Or add a dollar to your order to support bstrong, founded by Bethenny...
Add a $1 donation to bstrong US$1.00
Add a dollar to your order to support bstrong, founded by Bethenny Frankel and partnered with Global Empowerment Mission. One hundred percent of donations will go directly to bstrong in their efforts in disaster recovery.
Creation™ Donation US$5.00
With each purchase of this item, we will deliver an Ice Cream Creation™ to those affected by, and assisting in relief efforts as the result of, the Los Angeles Wildfires. Some previous donations have included: Rescue teams at Miami Surfside c...

Cold Stone Creamery Details

Service options
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Dining options
Table service

Amenities
Toilet

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Cold Stone Creamery Photos

Cold Stone Creamery Location

Cold Stone Creamery

Wisconsin Dane County Fitchburg Cahill Main

2970 Cahill Main Ste 103, Fitchburg, WI 53711, USA

Cold Stone Creamery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 194 user reviews.

costflavorsmilkshakebatterbirthday caketoppingswafflegift cardoreopeanut butter

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We love Cold Stone, specifically this location! The owner is Great, very happy to always serve anyone that walks thru his shop. Everything we’ve gotten from here was superb, and it continues to be our top choice for ice cream.Try any mix flavor as a shake, lots of topping options available.
May 31 · Los Reviews
Bought ice cream cake which looked different than usual. Whipped cream on top looked green-ish/black-ish which is normally just a light brown. When I tasted a piece of the ice cream cake,it tasted weird and texture was off. The outer layer had a different texture to it which is not normal or the usual taste. (I have bought this cake for years, since it is my favorite.)I wanted to call the store to verify if there was anything wrong, if i could exchange it or what. First time I called, the associates didn't know what to tell me, since there wasn't a supervisor or manager. Called the next day and the associate took my contact info to give the manager. Manager called the next day and just plain out laughed like 4 times saying there wasn't anything wrong with it. I called 2 other stores to confirm what the policy is regarding returns, exchanges, etc. 1 store said that it was final sale (in a nice manner) and the other store said I could come in and get a refund. Both were very polite. Can't believe they let such rude people be managers...I know companies don't care about losing a customer, so i know i don't matter. Customer service positions should be monitored, so they don't behave rudely to people who are just wanting to make sure that whatever they bought is how it should be. Did confirm the policy online and will be throwing the cake away. Very disappointed.
February 11 · Krisia Pagan
Always a tasty treat for us and the kids!Seevice was good but with a smile would of made it 5 stars. She was friendly and efficient for sure, especially for working solo.We'll be back when we come out this way again!
January 02 · Dean Krapf
Cold Stone is legit. It’s very tasty and fun to watch them make your creations! The ice cream cakes are unique- different main flavor options, such as Oreo, and then cake layered inside. Very good. But let thaw a bit before cut and serve.
June 08 · Nicole Wittkopp
Eh. I wouldn't recommend going to this location. Was really disappointed with my creation. Ordered a founders favorite with cookie dough. Visually there are barely any toppings and the taste, or lack there of, backs it up.
March 18 · Amanda Brown