Cold Stone Creamery: A Pickerington Favorite for Custom Ice Cream

Cold Stone Creamery Introduce

Cold Stone Creamery is a name synonymous with a unique and customizable ice cream experience, and the Pickerington, Ohio location is a local favorite. This isn't just a place to grab a cone; it's an interactive experience where your dessert is crafted right in front of you on a frozen granite stone. The concept of creating your own "Creation" by mixing in a variety of delicious toppings with a premium ice cream base is what sets Cold Stone apart. For locals, this shop offers a fun and personalized way to enjoy a sweet treat, turning a simple outing into a memorable event.

The quality of the ice cream itself is a major draw. Customers "love love love" the ice cream, with many becoming frequent visitors due to its amazing taste. The ability to customize your order, from substituting flavors to adding a variety of mix-ins, ensures that every visit can be a new and exciting experience. A popular choice, for example, is the "Peanut Butter Cup Perfection," but with a clever substitution of sweet cream ice cream for the chocolate. This level of customization allows regulars to perfect their favorite dessert. While the prices may be "slightly high," customers consistently feel the taste and quality "will justify the price." The shop's commitment to delivering a unique and delicious product is what keeps its customers happy and coming back for more.

The Cold Stone Creamery location at 1718 Hill Rd N Suite 107 in Pickerington, OH, is a convenient and easily accessible spot for the local community. Situated on a main road, it is simple to find for both residents and visitors passing through. The location is clean and well-stocked, creating a pleasant and inviting atmosphere from the moment you walk in. The ample parking available in the shopping center makes a visit hassle-free.

The interior is beautifully displayed, showcasing not only the ice cream but also a variety of other treats, from caramel apples to buckeyes. This visual appeal adds to the overall experience and makes it a fun place to browse. The location’s cleanliness and organization are key factors that contribute to a positive experience. The ease of access and the availability of a comfortable, well-kept space make this Cold Stone a go-to spot for a family outing or a quick treat. It's a place that locals feel comfortable visiting and know they can rely on for a good time.

Cold Stone Creamery offers a variety of services that are built around its unique ice cream creation process and a selection of other delicious treats.

Custom Ice Cream Creations: The signature service, where you choose an ice cream flavor and mix-ins to be blended on a frozen granite stone.
A Wide Variety of Flavors: Customers can sample flavors before making their choice, ensuring they get the perfect scoop.
Ice Cream Cakes: A selection of beautifully crafted ice cream cakes, perfect for birthdays and celebrations.
Other Treats and Sweets: The shop offers a variety of other items, including caramel apples, frosted dog treats, and buckeyes.
Tipping Tradition: When a customer tips, the employees sing a song, adding a fun and memorable element to the service.

The interactive nature of the custom creations is what makes Cold Stone's service so special. The staff’s willingness to provide samples is a great way to ensure customer satisfaction. The shop's dedication to offering more than just ice cream, with a beautiful display of other treats, makes it a one-stop-shop for all your dessert needs. The tipping tradition is a unique and charming touch that creates a lighthearted and fun atmosphere. While there can be occasional issues with order accuracy or consistency, the overall service model is designed to be engaging and enjoyable.

Cold Stone Creamery is a local favorite due to several key features that make it a standout destination.

Unique Customization Process: The signature frozen granite stone method of mixing ice cream and toppings is a major highlight.
High-Quality Ice Cream: The ice cream is consistently praised for its amazing taste and smooth texture.
Wide Array of Treats: The shop is well-stocked with a variety of other delicious items, from caramel apples to frosted dog treats.
Interactive Atmosphere: The employee song when a tip is given adds a fun and memorable touch to the experience.
Clean and Well-Stocked Location: The Pickerington store is noted for its cleanliness and well-organized, beautiful displays.
Generous Sampling: Customers appreciate the ability to sample flavors before making their final choice.

These features collectively create an experience that is both high-quality and deeply rooted in the local community. The shop's commitment to delivering a fun and personalized product is what keeps customers loyal. The variety of treats and the interactive elements make it a destination that goes beyond a simple dessert run.

To visit this local favorite, here is the contact information:

Address: 1718 Hill Rd N Suite 107, Pickerington, OH 43147, USA

Phone: (614) 868-9801

For locals in Ohio, particularly in the Pickerington area, Cold Stone Creamery is a perfect fit for the community because it offers a fun, customizable, and high-quality dessert experience. It's a place where families can go to create their perfect treat and enjoy a moment of shared fun, especially with the tipping song. The variety of treats, from ice cream to other sweets, ensures that it can be a destination for any kind of craving. While some customers have noted occasional inconsistencies, the overall appeal of the unique concept and the delicious product keeps people coming back. It's a modern twist on a classic ice cream shop, providing a reliable and delightful experience that is perfectly suited for the vibrant Pickerington community.

Cold Stone Creamery Menu

Create Your Own Creation™
Create Your Own Creation
Select your flavor and one FREE Mix-in. Customize further by adding more Mix-ins and a Waffle Cone or Bowl.
Mix & Go Create Your Own Creation™
Select your flavor and Mix-ins. Customize further by adding more Mix-ins and a Waffle Cone or Bowl.

Signature Creations™
Root Beer Revival
Root Beer Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Caramel & Whipped Topping
Caramel Carnival Churro
Churro Ice Cream, Cinnamon Toast Crunch™, Caramel & Sugar Crystals
Cornbread is My Jam
Honey Cornbread with Blackberry Jam Ice Cream, Cornbread, Honey & Blueberries
Very Berry Non-Dairy™
Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk frozen dessert, mixed with Strawberries, Blueberries, and Raspberries
Don't Cry Over Spilled Silk
Plant-based never tasted so good! Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk Frozen Dessert, Banana, Peanut Butter & Roasted Almonds
Apple Pie a la Cold Stone®
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Cinnamon, Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Apple Pie Filling and Caramel
Banana Caramel Crunch®
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Banana and Caramel
Berry Berry Berry Good®
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Raspberries, Strawberries and Blueberries
The Better NUTTER BUTTER®
NUTTER BUTTER® Ice Cream, NUTTER BUTTER® Cookies, Sugar Crystals & Fudge
Birthday Cake OREO® Celebration
Birthday Cake OREO® Cookie Ice Cream, Birthday Cake OREO® Cookies, Rainbow Sprinkles & OREO® Cookie Frosting
Birthday Cake Remix™
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles, Brownie and Fudge (calories listed per serving)
Cake Batter Batter Batter™
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough and Brownie
Cheesecake Fantasy®
Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Blueberries and Strawberries
Chocolate Devotion®
Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Brownie and Fudge
Coffee Lovers Only®
Coffee Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Heath® Bar and Caramel
Cookie Doughn't You Want Some®
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough, Fudge and Caramel
Cookies Make Everything Batter™
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies, GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Whipped Topping
Dough for It!™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough and Sugar Crystals
Dough-lightful Peanut Butter™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Peanut Butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup and Sugar Crystals
Founder's Favorite®
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Pecans, Brownie, Fudge and Caramel
Mud Pie Mojo®
Coffee Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies, Peanut Butter, Roasted Almonds and Fudge
One Smart Brookie™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Brownie and Cookie Dough
OREO® Overload
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge
Our Strawberry Blonde®
Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Strawberries, Caramel and Whipped Topping
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection®
Chocolate Ice Cream with Peanut Butter, Reese's® Peanut Butter Cup and Fudge
REESE'S Peanut Butter Awesome Sauce
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup & Reese’s Peanut Butter Sauce
Somewhere Over the Rain-dough™
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Frosting, Rainbow Sprinkles and Sugar Crystals
Surrender to Strawberry™
Strawberry Ice Cream with Strawberries, Yellow Cake and Whipped Topping

Ice Cream Cakes & Novelties – Pre-Order
Choose your pickup time between 1-14 days
Create Your Own Ice Cream Cake
Combine any of our freshly-made ice cream flavors and mix-ins with your choice of Yellow, Red Velvet or Devil's Food cake; many decorating options available.
A Cheesecake Named Desire™
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Raspberry Frosting
Birthday Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream wrapped in fluffy White Frosting and topped with Rainbow Sprinkles
Cake Batter Confetti™
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Caramel Nut Nirvana™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Snickers® wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Chocolate Chipper™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Coffeehouse Crunch™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Coffee Ice Cream with Heath® Bar wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Cookie Dough Delirium™
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Cookie Dough and Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Cookies & Creamery™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Midnight Delight®
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Fudge and Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Mmmmmmint Chip™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Mint Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
OREO® Cookies and Cream Extreme
Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Ice Cream with GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy OREO® Cookie Frosting
Peanut Butter Playground™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Peanut Butter and Chocolate Ice Cream with Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Strawberry Passion™
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake, Strawberry Puree and Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Strawberry Frosting
Tall, Dark & Delicious™
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Brownies and Chocolate Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting and cascading Fudge Ganache
Ice Cream Cupcake Build Your Own 6-Pack US$15.99
Choose from a variety of cupcakes! Sweet Cream Cupcake: A rich Chocolate Cup filled with a layer of Yellow Cake, Fudge and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with fluffy White Frosting and White & Milk Chocolate Curls Cake Batter™ Delux Cupcake: A...
Ice Cream Cookie Build Your Own 4-Pack US$13.99
Choose your selection of our Signature Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches! Cake Batter™ Sprinkle: Cake Batter Ice Cream® sandwiched by moist Chocolate Chip Cookies and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles Cookie Crumb Yum: Sweet Cream Ice Cream sandwiched b...

Ice Cream Cakes & Novelties – Ready Now
These items are ready for you to pickup which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
A Cheesecake Named Desire™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Raspberry Frosting **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Cake Batter Confetti™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles wrapped in fluffy White Frosting **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Chocolate Chipper™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Coffeehouse Crunch™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Coffee Ice Cream with Heath® Bar wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Midnight Delight® - Ready Now
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Fudge and Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Peanut Butter Playground™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Peanut Butter and Chocolate Ice Cream with Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Cookie Dough Delirium™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Cookie Dough and Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy White Frosting **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Cookies & Creamery™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
OREO® Cookies & Cream Extreme - Ready Now
Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Ice Cream with GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy OREO® Cookie Frosting **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or s...
Strawberry Passion™ - Ready Now
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake, Strawberry Puree and Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Strawberry Frosting **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or substitutions.
Tall, Dark & Delicious - Ready Now
Layers of moist Devil’s Food Cake, Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Brownies and Chocolate Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting and cascading Fudge Ganache **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make an...
Cake Batter Batter Batter™ Pre-packed Quart US$11.99
Rich, creamy Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough and Brownie pieces
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection™ Pre-packed Quart US$11.99
Rich Chocolate Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Cups and gooey Fudge in a Peanut Butter swirl
Founder's Favorite® Pre-packed Quart US$11.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with chewy Brownies and toasted Pecans, swirled with rich Fudge and Caramel
OREO® Overload Pre-packed Quart US$11.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge
REESE'S Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup 6-Pack - Ready Now US$15.99
Six Chocolate Cups filled with layers of Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce & Chocolate Ice Cream topped with rich Fudge Ganache, Sea Salt & Reese's Peanut Butter Cup **This item is ready for you to pick up which means we cannot make any changes or su...
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack - Ready Now US$13.99
One of each of our Cake Batter™ Sprinkle, Cookie Crumb Yum, Kiss N' Tell Chocolate, and Perfect Duet Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches Cake Batter™ Sprinkle: Cake Batter Ice Cream® sandwiched by moist Chocolate Chip Cookies and rolled in Rainbow Spri...
Ice Cream Cupcake Variety 6-Pack - Ready Now US$15.99
Two of each of our Sweet Cream, Cake Batter™ Delux and Double Chocolate Devotion™ Ice Cream Cupcakes Sweet Cream Cupcake: A rich Chocolate Cup filled with a layer of Yellow Cake, Fudge and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with fluffy White Frosting...

Might Like It
Not sure if you've Gotta Have It? Try something new by adding a sample of one of our favorite flavors to your order!
Root Beer Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Churro Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Honey Cornbread with Blackberry Jam Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Birthday Cake OREO® Cookie Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
NUTTER BUTTER® Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Try this promotional flavor before it's gone!
Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk Frozen Dessert - Sample US$0.99
Cake Batter Ice Cream® - Sample US$0.99
Cheesecake Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Chocolate Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Coffee Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
French Vanilla Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Mint Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Strawberry Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99
Vanilla Lite Ice Cream - Sample US$0.99

Cold Stone For Your Freezer
Root Beer Revival - Freezer
Root Beer Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Caramel & Whipped Topping
Caramel Carnival Churro - Freezer
Churro Ice Cream, Cinnamon Toast Crunch™, Caramel & Sugar Crystals
Cornbread is My Jam - Freezer
Honey Cornbread with Blackberry Jam Ice Cream, Cornbread, Honey & Blueberries
Very Berry Non-Dairy™ - Freezer
Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk frozen dessert, mixed with Strawberries, Blueberries, and Raspberries
Don't Cry Over Spilled Silk - Freezer
Plant-base never tasted so good! Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk Frozen Dessert, Banana, Peanut Butter & Roasted Almonds
REESE'S Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup 6-Pack US$15.99
Six Chocolate Cups filled with layers of Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce & Chocolate Ice Cream topped with rich Fudge Ganache, Sea Salt & Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack US$13.99
One of each of our Cake Batter™ Sprinkle, Cookie Crumb Yum, Kiss N' Tell Chocolate, and Perfect Duet Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches Cake Batter™ Sprinkle: Cake Batter Ice Cream® sandwiched by moist Chocolate Chip Cookies and rolled in Rainbow Spri...
Ice Cream Cupcake Variety 6-Pack US$15.99
Two of each of our Sweet Cream, Cake Batter™ Delux and Double Chocolate Devotion™ Ice Cream Cupcakes Sweet Cream Cupcake: A rich Chocolate Cup filled with a layer of Yellow Cake, Fudge and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with fluffy White Frosting...
OREO® Ice Cream Sandwiches 4-pack US$13.99
Four OREO® Ice Cream Sandwiches - OREO® Crème Ice Cream sandwiched by OREO® Wafers
Apple Pie a la Cold Stone® - Freezer
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Cinnamon, Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Apple Pie Filling and Caramel
Banana Caramel Crunch® - Freezer
"French Vanilla Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Banana and Caramel
Berry Berry Berry Good®
"Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Raspberries, Strawberries and Blueberries
The Better NUTTER BUTTER® - Freezer
NUTTER BUTTER® Ice Cream, NUTTER BUTTER® Cookies, Sugar Crystals & Fudge
Birthday Cake OREO® Celebration - Freezer
Birthday Cake OREO® Cookie Ice Cream, Birthday Cake OREO® Cookies, Rainbow Sprinkles & OREO® Cookie Frosting
Birthday Cake Remix™ - Freezer
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles, Brownie and Fudge
Cake Batter Batter Batter™ - Freezer
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough and Brownie
Cheesecake Fantasy® - Freezer
Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Blueberries and Strawberries
Chocolate Devotion® - Freezer
Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Brownie and Fudge
Coffee Lovers Only® - Freezer
Coffee Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Heath® Bar and Caramel
Cookie Doughn't You Want Some® - Freezer
French Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough, Fudge and Caramel
Cookies Make Everything Batter™ - Freezer
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies, GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Whipped Topping
Dough for It!™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, Cookie Dough and Sugar Crystals
Dough-lightful Peanut Butter™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Peanut Butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup and Sugar Crystals
Founder's Favorite® - Freezer
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Pecans, Brownie, Fudge and Caramel
Mud Pie Mojo® - Freezer
Coffee Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies, Peanut Butter, Roasted Almonds and Fudge
One Smart Brookie™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Brownie and Cookie Dough
OREO® Overload - Freezer
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips, double the OREO® Cookies and Fudge
Our Strawberry Blonde® - Freezer
Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Strawberries, Caramel and Whipped Topping
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection® - Freezer
Chocolate Ice Cream with Peanut Butter, Reese's® Peanut Butter Cup and Fudge
REESE’S Peanut Butter Awesome Sauce - Freezer
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup & Reese’s Peanut Butter Sauce
Somewhere Over the Rain-dough™ - Freezer
Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Frosting, Rainbow Sprinkles and Sugar Crystals
Surrender to Strawberry™ - Freezer
Strawberry Ice Cream with Strawberries, Yellow Cake and Whipped Topping

Shakes
Go With the Float US$6.49
Root Beer Ice Cream, Root Beer, Whipped Topping & a Maraschino Cherry
Create Your Own Shake
Select your flavor and one FREE Mix-in and we’ll blend with milk for the shake of your dreams. Customize further by adding more Mix-ins!
Cake Batter™ n' Shake
Cake Batter Ice Cream® and Yellow Cake
Chocolate Silk® Shake
Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk Frozen Dessert blended with Silk® Almondmilk
Milk & OREO® Cookies
Sweet Cream Ice Cream and OREO® Cookies
Oh Fudge!
Chocolate Ice Cream and Fudge
REESE'S Chocolate Peanut Butter Dream
Chocolate Ice Cream, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup & Reese’s Peanut Butter Sauce
Savory Strawberry
Strawberry Ice Cream and Strawberries
Very Vanilla
French Vanilla Ice Cream and Caramel

Smoothies
Blueberry Banana
Mango Pineapple
Pineapple Blueberry
Strawberry Banana
Strawberry Mango

Ice Cream Pies
Create Your Own Ice Cream Pie US$15.99
Combine any of our ice cream flavors, mix-ins and frosting all in a crunchy pie crust
Caramel Turtle Treat Pie™ US$16.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Pecans, Caramel and Fudge in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust topped with fluffy White Frosting
Cookie Dough Pie™ US$16.99
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough, Caramel and Fudge on a layer of Fudge Ganache in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust topped with fluffy White Frosting

Mini Catering
The Ultimate Party Pack US$99.99
Serves 20 – 25 (or dessert for a family of five, four times!) 5 quarts & 5 Mix-ins Includes Like It® size cups, spoons, and napkins
The Petite Party Pack US$49.99
Serves 12 – 15 (or dessert for a family of four, three times!) 3 quarts & 3 Mix-ins Includes Like It® size cups, spoons and napkins
The Pint-sized Party Pack US$15.99
Serves 4 – 5 2 pints & 2 Mix-ins Includes Like It® size cups, spoons, and napkins

DIY Cupcakes Kit
DIY 6-Pack Ice Cream Cupcake Kit US$15.99
Six rich Chocolate Cups filled with moist cake (two of each yellow cake, red velvet cake and devil’s food cake) and ice cream (two of each Sweet Cream, Cake Batter™ and Chocolate Ice Cream) ready to decorate with included bag of frosting and mix-i...

Candles
12-Pack Birthday Candles US$1.99
12 Birthday Candles to make your cake shine even brighter! Design may vary – inquire with store for details.

Bottled Beverages
Bottled Water US$1.59
Bottled Soda US$2.59

Caramel Apples by Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory
Ordering more than six? Order from the Pre-Order category or call the store directly.
Caramel Apple US$5.95
Nothing but thick and chewy caramel on a crisp Granny Smith apple on this old-fashioned favorite. • serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.
Caramel Apple featuring M&M’s® US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in M&M’s® candies. Serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.
Peanut Apple US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in roasted peanuts. Serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.
Pecan Apple US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in pecans. Serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.
Apple Pie Apple™ US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in brown sugar and cinnamon. Serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.
Cheesecake Apple US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in crushed graham crackers. Serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.
Cookies & Cream Apple US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in crushed OREO® cookies. Serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.
Pecan Bear™ Apple US$9.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in pecans, drizzled with milk chocolate and white confection. Serving size: 1/2 apple Ordering more than six? Order from the “Pre-Order” category or call the store directly.

Individual Chocolates by Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory
Milk Chocolate Pecan Bear US$4.95
Chewy caramel with pecans covered in rich milk chocolate. Serving size: 1/3 piece
Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Bucket™ US$5.50
Sweet and creamy whipped peanut butter filling surrounded by a thick milk chocolate coating. Serving size: 1/3 piece
Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel US$2.75
Chocolate covered caramels sprinkled with Sel Gris grey sea salt. Serving size: 1/2 piece
Milk Chocolate Caramel US$2.75
Chewy caramel covered with rich milk chocolate. Serving size: 1/2 piece
Milk Chocolate Truffle US$2.95
Creamy milk chocolate center in a rich milk chocolate shell. Serving size: 1 piece
Birthday Cake Truffle US$2.95
White chocolate birthday cake flavored center with colorful sprinkles in a milk chocolate shell and topped with the same bright sprinkles. Serving size: 1 piece
Mint Truffle US$2.95
Cool and creamy milk chocolate peppermint center in a rich milk chocolate shell. Serving size: 1 piece
Raspberry Truffle US$2.95
Creamy raspberry 1/2 milk, 1/2 dark chocolate flavored center in a rich milk chocolate shell. Serving size: 1 piece
Milk Chocolate Dipped OREO® US$1.75
OREO® cookie dipped in rich milk chocolate. Serving size: 1 piece
Milk Chocolate Dipped Pretzel US$1.75
Salty, crunchy Bavarian pretzel dipped in rich milk chocolate. Serving size: 1 piece
Small Dipped Dog Bone US$1.25
Dipped in white confection [not chocolate] make these bones a safe treat for dogs.
Large Dipped Dog Bone US$2.25
Dipped in white confection [not chocolate] make these bones a safe treat for dogs.

Chocolate Gifts by Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory
Ordering more than six? Call the store directly to check availability.
Small Assorted Chocolate Gift Box US$11.50
A sampling of butter creams, chewy caramels and Peanut Butter Pails™, in rich milk and semi-sweet dark chocolate and white confection. Serving size: 2 pieces

Pre-Order by Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
Strawberries hand dipped in rich milk chocolate. Serving size: 1 piece
Caramel Apple US$5.95
Nothing but thick and chewy caramel on a crisp Granny Smith apple on this old-fashioned favorite. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Caramel Apple featuring M&M’s® US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in M&M’s® candies. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Peanut Apple US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in roasted peanuts. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Pecan Apple US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in pecans. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Apple Pie Apple™ US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in brown sugar and cinnamon. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Cheesecake Apple US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in crushed graham crackers. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Cookies & Cream Apple US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in crushed OREO® cookies. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Pecan Bear™ Apple US$9.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in pecans, drizzled with milk chocolate and white confection. Serving size: 1/2 apple

Pre-Order by Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
Strawberries hand dipped in rich milk chocolate. Serving size: 1 piece
Caramel Apple US$5.95
Nothing but thick and chewy caramel on a crisp Granny Smith apple on this old-fashioned favorite. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Caramel Apple featuring M&M’s® US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in M&M’s® candies. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Peanut Apple US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in roasted peanuts. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Pecan Apple US$7.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in pecans. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Apple Pie Apple™ US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in brown sugar and cinnamon. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Cheesecake Apple US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in crushed graham crackers. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Cookies & Cream Apple US$8.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple dipped in white confection, rolled in crushed OREO® cookies. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Pecan Bear™ Apple US$9.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in pecans, drizzled with milk chocolate and white confection. Serving size: 1/2 apple
Rocky Road Apple US$9.95
Caramel-covered Granny Smith apple rolled in walnuts and marshmallows, then drizzled with milk chocolate and white confection. Serving size: 1/2 apple

Give Back
Cold Stone Creamery is Sprinkling Kindness… and you can help! Add a Creation™ Donation to your cart and we will deliver an Ice Cream Creation to local heroes on the front lines. Or add a dollar to your order to support bstrong, founded by Bethenny...
Add a $1 donation to bstrong US$1.00
Add a dollar to your order to support bstrong, founded by Bethenny Frankel and partnered with Global Empowerment Mission. One hundred percent of donations will go directly to bstrong in their efforts in disaster recovery.
Creation™ Donation US$5.00
With each purchase of this item, we will deliver an Ice Cream Creation™ to those affected by, and assisting in relief efforts as the result of, the Los Angeles Wildfires. Some previous donations have included: Rescue teams at Miami Surfside c...

Fundraising Menu
Choose from this menu to participate in the Virtual Fundraiser! Interested in holding a fundraiser for your organization? Contact the store for more information.
Caramel Apple Fundraiser Pie US$13.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Apple Pie Filling, Cinnamon and Caramel on a layer of Caramel in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust topped with fluffy Cinnamon Frosting
Caramel Turtle Treat Fundraiser Pie US$13.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Pecans, Caramel and Fudge in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust topped with fluffy White Frosting
Cookie Dough Fundraiser Pie US$13.99
Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Cookie Dough, Caramel and Fudge on a layer of Fudge Ganache in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust topped with fluffy White Frosting
Pumpkin Fundraiser Pie US$13.99
Pumpkin Ice Cream in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust topped with Cinnamon Frosting and Chocolate Leaves
S'more Some More Fundraiser Pie US$13.99
Dark Chocolate Ice Cream with Marshmallows in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust topped with fluffy White Frosting
A Cheesecake Named Desire™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Raspberry Puree and Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Raspberry Frosting
Butterfinger® Bonanza Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Butterfinger® wrapped in fluffy Peanut Butter Frosting
Cake Batter Confetti™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with Rainbow Sprinkles wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Caramel Nut Nirvana™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Snickers® wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Chocolate Chipper™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Coffeehouse Crunch™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Coffee Ice Cream with Heath® Bar wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Cookie Dough Delirium™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Cookie Dough and Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Cookies & Creamery™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
Midnight Delight® Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Fudge and Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Mmmmmmint Chip™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Mint Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy White Frosting
OREO® Cookies and Cream Extreme Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Ice Cream with GOLDEN OREO® Cookies and Cake Batter Ice Cream® with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy OREO® Cookie Frosting
Peanut Butter Playground™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Peanut Butter and Chocolate Ice Cream with Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Raspberry Truffle Temptation™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake, Raspberry Puree and Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in rich Fudge Ganache
Rich & Dreamy™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake and Yellow Cake, Fudge and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy Chocolate Frosting and Cascading Fudge Ganache
Salted Caramel with a Twist™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Salted Caramel and Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Pretzels, Salted Caramel and Chocolate Chips wrapped in fluffy Caramel Frosting
Strawberry Passion™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Red Velvet Cake, Strawberry Puree and Strawberry Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Strawberry Frosting
Tall, Dark & Delicious™ Fundraiser Cake
Layers of moist Devil's Food Cake, Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Brownies and Chocolate Ice Cream with OREO® Cookies wrapped in fluffy White Frosting and cascading Fudge Ganache
REESE'S Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup Fundraiser 6-Pack US$13.99
Six Chocolate Cups filled with layers of Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce & Chocolate Ice Cream topped with rich Fudge Ganache, Sea Salt & Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety Fundraiser 4-Pack US$11.99
One of each of our Cake Batter™ Sprinkle, Cookie Crumb Yum, Kiss N' Tell Chocolate, and Perfect Duet Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches Cake Batter™ Sprinkle: Cake Batter Ice Cream® sandwiched by moist Chocolate Chip Cookies and rolled in Rainbow Spri...
Ice Cream Cupcake Variety Fundraiser 6-Pack US$13.99
Two of each of our Sweet Cream, Cake Batter™ Delux and Double Chocolate Devotion™ Ice Cream Cupcakes Sweet Cream Cupcake: A rich Chocolate Cup filled with a layer of Yellow Cake, Fudge and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with fluffy White Frosting...

Cold Stone Creamery Details

Service options
Kerbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Toilet

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Cold Stone Creamery Photos

Cold Stone Creamery Location

Cold Stone Creamery

Ohio Fairfield County Pickerington South Columbus Hill Road North

1718 Hill Rd N Suite 107, Pickerington, OH 43147, USA

Cold Stone Creamery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 271 user reviews.

flavorstippricepeanut buttercheesecakewaffle bowlcake battersongtoppingscaramel apple

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Usually the visit here is decent. I get the same ice cream each time and it’s always slightly different. This time the preparer seemed not to know any of the ingredients to the ice cream even though they are in the board. I gave a nice tip and was disappointed when I got home. Just spent $20 on something I did not order.
May 03 · Ali Babba
Love love love their ice cream!! I always get the same thing.. peanut butter cup perfection, but I substitute the chocolate ice cream for sweet cream! Yummmm! I typically get the "gotta have it" size cup. And the only reason I gave four stars instead of five, is because sometimes they don't fill the cup as much as they have advertised. ColdStone has amazing tasting ice cream and I'm a happy, frequent customer!! If you've never been here, you MUST try it! Prices are slightly high but once you taste the ice cream, it will justify the price. Oh, and if you tip the employees, they all sing a song! Cute! You can also sample the ice cream flavors if you can't choose which one you want. This location is always clean and is well stocked with not only ice cream, but other treats such as: caramel apples, ice cream, frosted dog treats, buckeyes, and the list goes on! It's all in a beautiful display at the counter.
August 23 · Antique Shopper
Came in today to get a couple of ice creams and started looking in the toppings case. It was full of fruit flies everywhere. I counted around 6-7, some laying directly on the food - particularly the white chocolate and chocolate chips.For somewhere that charges such premium prices - this is beyond unacceptable. I left without ordering
April 13 · Tyler Crabtree
Too good to say the least — always fresh, tasty and great service. Easily the best ice cream around!
May 29 · mic troopa
I recently visited Cold Stone Creamery and decided to try their Chocolate Silk Shake. The experience was delightful from start to finish. The shake had a rich, creamy texture with a perfect balance of chocolate flavor. It wasn't overly sweet, which made it enjoyable and refreshing. The consistency was just right, not too thick or too runny, making it easy to drink. The service was friendly and efficient, adding to the overall positive experience. If you're a chocolate lover, the Chocolate Silk Shake is definitely worth a try at Cold Stone Creamery.
June 12 · Nomadic Flavors