CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM Introduce
As New Yorkers, we appreciate a great dessert, and finding a local spot that offers something truly unique is a real treat. While the city has endless options, sometimes it's worth the drive to discover a hidden gem that feels like a mini-vacation. For those in the New York region looking for a delightful escape, CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM in Canastota, NY, presents a compelling destination. This isn't your average scoop shop; it's a place where tropical flavors meet classic ice cream indulgence, creating a memorable experience for the whole family. Situated conveniently on a main thoroughfare, it's a destination that has garnered a loyal following for its distinct taste and welcoming atmosphere.
CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM stands out by offering a taste of the islands right here in New York. The menu is a vibrant tapestry of flavors, with a focus on Caribbean-inspired creations that you won't find at a typical parlor. Think exotic fruits, rich spices, and creamy textures that transport you to a sun-drenched beach with every spoonful. But it's not just about the unique flavors; it's also about the quality and the experience. This establishment is known for its friendly service, generous portions, and a clean, inviting environment that makes every visit a pleasant one. Whether you’re a local Canastota resident or someone passing through the area, CONEHEADs offers a refreshing break from the everyday with its distinctive and delicious offerings.
For New Yorkers, location and accessibility are key. CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM is strategically located at 3728 NY-31, in Canastota, NY 13032. This address places it directly on a major state route, making it incredibly easy to find and access. The shop's location on NY-31 means it's a convenient stop for those traveling in the area, whether they're on a weekend trip or just running errands nearby. The ample parking space is a significant advantage, removing the stress of finding a spot and making it a hassle-free destination. This is particularly appealing for families or groups, as you won't have to worry about navigating tight parking lots. The presence of a wine store next door also adds to the appeal, offering another local business to explore during your visit. The ease of getting to and from CONEHEADS, combined with its welcoming storefront, makes it a top choice for a quick, satisfying treat.
The shop’s accessibility is a testament to its understanding of what customers value. Its location on a main road means it's a central point for the community and a visible landmark for visitors. The surrounding area is relatively easy to navigate, and the spacious layout of the property itself, including the parking lot, is a major highlight mentioned by customers. This thoughtful approach to the customer experience, starting with the simple act of parking, sets a positive tone for the entire visit. The convenience of its location ensures that CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM is not just a destination for a special occasion, but a place that can be easily incorporated into your daily or weekly routine, whether you're grabbing a quick cone or spending some time with friends and family.
CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM provides a wide range of services and products designed to satisfy every sweet tooth. Beyond the standard scoop, the shop offers a variety of creative and classic treats. Their commitment to quality and variety is evident in the carefully curated menu. Here is a look at what you can expect when you visit:
- Specialty Ice Cream Flavors: The star of the show, these unique flavors are what make CONEHEADS a standout destination. While specific flavors may rotate, the focus on Caribbean and tropical tastes remains constant. A popular example is the "Girl Scout" flavor, which features coconut ice cream, hot fudge, caramel, and graham cracker pieces, and has been praised by customers for its uncanny resemblance to the beloved Samoas cookies. This attention to detail and creative blending of flavors is what keeps customers coming back for more.
- Floats and Sundaes: For those who want more than just a scoop, the shop offers excellent float sundaes. These are not your typical floats; they are expertly crafted combinations that showcase the rich ice cream and complementary toppings. The sundaes are known for being well-prepared and generously portioned, offering a truly indulgent experience.
- Variety of Toppings and Mix-ins: In addition to the signature creations, customers have the option to customize their desserts with a wide variety of toppings, from classic hot fudge and caramel to unique additions that enhance the tropical flavors.
- Welcoming and Friendly Service: As noted in customer reviews, the staff is known for being welcoming and providing service with a smile. This friendly atmosphere contributes significantly to the overall positive experience.
What makes CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM truly special are its unique features and highlights that set it apart from other dessert spots. These are the elements that locals love and that visitors appreciate, creating a memorable visit every time.
- Unique Flavor Profile: The primary highlight is the focus on Caribbean and tropical flavors. This is a niche that is not widely explored in local ice cream shops, and CONEHEADS has perfected it. The flavors are distinct, bold, and incredibly satisfying, offering a refreshing alternative to traditional vanilla and chocolate. The "Girl Scout" is a perfect example of their creativity, demonstrating a deep understanding of flavor combinations that resonate with customers.
- Ample Parking and Seating: A feature that is often overlooked but is crucial for a positive customer experience is the availability of parking. CONEHEADS offers plenty of parking, which is a major convenience for guests, especially during busy times. Additionally, there is seating available, allowing patrons to enjoy their treats on-site in a relaxed setting.
- Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The environment is welcoming and suitable for all ages. The staff's friendly demeanor, combined with the fun and vibrant menu, makes it a great place for families, couples, and individuals alike. It's a place where you can relax, chat, and enjoy a delicious dessert without feeling rushed.
- Consistent Quality and Service: Repeat customers and positive reviews consistently highlight the shop's commitment to quality. Whether it's the taste of the ice cream or the friendliness of the staff, CONEHEADS maintains a high standard that ensures every visit is as good as the last. The fact that customers return and update their positive reviews is a strong indicator of this consistency.
To get in touch or find your way to this delightful ice cream shop, here is the essential contact information:
Address: 3728 NY-31, Canastota, NY 13032, USA
Phone: (315) 240-7441
For those in the New York area, CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM is more than just a place to get dessert; it's a community fixture and a destination for a unique culinary experience. Its suitability for locals stems from several key factors. Firstly, it offers a distinct product that you can't find just anywhere, making it a special place to visit. The unique flavors and creative sundaes provide a welcome change of pace from chain establishments. This originality fosters a sense of local pride and gives residents a "go-to" spot for something different and exciting.
Furthermore, the convenience of its location and the welcoming atmosphere make it an easy and enjoyable part of local life. The ample parking and friendly service eliminate common frustrations, turning a simple ice cream run into a pleasant outing. It's a place where you'll feel at home, greeted with a smile and served a high-quality product. The support for a local business with a strong community presence is also a significant draw for residents who want to see their town thrive. In conclusion, CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM is a suitable and excellent choice for locals because it combines a unique, high-quality product with convenience, great service, and a strong sense of community, making it a beloved local treasure.
The establishment's commitment to creating a memorable experience is evident in every detail, from the unique flavor combinations to the friendly interactions with staff. For New Yorkers seeking an authentic, local, and truly delicious ice cream experience, the journey to Canastota is a small investment for a significant payoff. CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM provides a taste of the exotic while staying firmly rooted in the local community, making it a perfect spot for a sweet escape.
CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM Vibe
Boat Sundaes
- The "Conehead
- The Grass Hopper
- Campfire Sundae
- Movie Madness
- Cookie Monster
Soft Flavors
- Amaretto
- Banana
- Butter Pecan
- Peanut Butter
- Blueberry
- Espresso
- Tutti Frutti
- Rum
- Pistachio
- Pina Colada
- Peach
- Orange
- Coconut
- Cheesecake
- Raspberry
- Strawberry
- Caramel
- Black Cherry
- Blue Raspberry
- Lemon
- Maplenut
- Rootbeer
- Creme De Menthe
- German Chocolate
- Pumpkin Pie
- Grape
- Green Apple
- Mint Chocolate Chip
Hard Flavors
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Strawberry
- Butter Pecan
- Maple Walnut
- Pistachio Nut
- Toasted Coconut
- Cherry Blossom
- Rainbow Sherbet
- Black Raspberry
- Chocolate Chip Yogurt
- Cotton Candy
- Peanut Butter Cup
- Cookie Dough
- Mint Chocolate Chip
- Campfire S'mores
- Peanut Butter Pie
- Cookies & Cream
- Camp Coffee
- Muddy Boots
- Strawberry
- Lemonade Sorbet
Floats
- Coke
- Rootbeer
- Sprite
- Diet Coke
Specialty Sundaes
- Famous Syracuse Sundae
Others
- Gummi Worms
- Butterfingers
- Snickers
- Heath Bar
- Andes Candies
- Graham Crackers
- Twix
- Raider Passion
- Happy Wife
- Piece Of Cake
- Gannoli
- Lemon-Lime Summertime
- Maine Black Bear
- Strawberry Cheesecake
- Sugar Free Vanilla Raspberry
- Sea-Salt Caramel
- Bottled Water
CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM Details
Service options
- Takeout
- Delivery
CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM Photos










CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM Location
CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM
3728 NY-31, Canastota, NY 13032, USA
CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM Reviews
pricesflavorsboatcoconutsundaeparkingshakessummerareato choose
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1The Girl Scout: Coconut Icecream, Hot Fudge, Caramel & Graham Cracker Pieces.This normally comes with 3 scoops of icecream in a boat style dish. I asked for 2 scoops as I wasn't that hungry.This had a flavor profile so similar to the Samoas/Caramel Delites.Oh, my goodness this was so awesome. A bit on the heavy side, but delicious nonetheless.Service with a smile and very welcoming. Plenty of parking and seating too.
July 05 · Tommy PropaneReally great little place. Excellent float sundaes! Lots of options and plenty of parking. There's a nice little wine store next door as well.Update: still awesome!
July 02 · Kevin BoutelleDelicious ice cream with a ton of flavors to choose from. This is a must place to stop during their summer open months if you are in the area!
October 03 · Chad GormanIce cream very good and made great
July 11 · Colleen MarshallGreat little ice cream shop not far from Verona Beach State Park with lots of flavors within view of Oneida Lake. Fun treat if you’re driving through the area on a summer evening.
December 02 · Zachary Peelman
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

604 Main St, Sylvan Beach, NY 13157, USA

2382 NY-49, Blossvale, NY 13308, USA

124 W Hickory St, Canastota, NY 13032, USA

646 Lenox Ave, Oneida, NY 13421, USA

548 NY-49, Cleveland, NY 13042, USA

7562 Lakeport Rd, Chittenango, NY 13037, USA

Twist II, 1121 Glenwood Ave, Oneida, NY 13421, USA

4971 NY-365, Verona, NY 13478, USA

620 Genesee Turnpike, Chittenango, NY 13037, USA

624 Sherrill Rd, Sherrill, NY 13461, USA

110 Hulbert St, Minoa, NY 13116, USA

148 Erie Blvd E, Rome, NY 13440, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





