Coney Waffle: A Sweet Escape in Toms River, New Jersey

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Introduce

When you’re looking for a dessert destination that goes beyond the ordinary, look no further than Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop in Toms River. This local gem has built a reputation for its over-the-top, indulgent creations that are as much a feast for the eyes as they are for your taste buds. Originally founded in Belmar, Coney Waffle has brought its unique brand of sweet treats to Ocean County, quickly becoming a go-to spot for families, friends, and anyone with a serious craving for something special. More than just a simple ice cream parlor, this shop is a full-fledged sweet emporium, offering a creative menu that features everything from classic scoops to their signature Coney Waffles and elaborate, candy-filled milkshakes. The atmosphere is always friendly and welcoming, and the sheer number of options guarantees there's something for everyone, no matter their preference.

The name itself, "Coney Waffle," pays homage to a tradition that started back in the 1940s on Coney Island, where Angelina D'Esposito began selling a unique, handheld waffle-and-ice-cream confection. Her grandson has continued that legacy, bringing the concept to New Jersey and expanding it into the vibrant, modern dessert shop we know today. The Toms River location provides a convenient and delightful spot to experience this rich history. Patrons frequently mention the friendly staff and clean dining area, which create a pleasant environment for enjoying a sweet treat. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick soft-serve cone or planning to sit down with a group and tackle one of their larger, more creative concoctions, the experience is always a memorable one. This commitment to both quality products and a great customer experience is a major part of what makes Coney Waffle a standout establishment in the local community.

With its generous portions, wide variety of flavors, and a menu that continuously pushes the boundaries of dessert, Coney Waffle has firmly established itself as a must-visit spot for anyone in the Toms River area. The shop is also known for its seasonal offerings, such as the pumpkin twist soft serve that a recent customer raved about, ensuring there is always something new and exciting to try throughout the year. Beyond the cones and sundaes, the shop’s specialty items and custom cakes have made it a popular choice for celebrations and special occasions, adding to its reputation as a one-stop shop for all things sweet. The passion for creating unique and delicious desserts is evident in every item, from the homemade ice cream to the freshly made waffle cones, making it a true destination for dessert lovers.

Location and Accessibility

You can find Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop conveniently located at 141 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA. Situated on a major thoroughfare, the shop is easily accessible for both locals and those passing through the area. Its location makes it a simple stop after a day at the beach, a meal out, or just a quick trip for a treat. The shop is well-positioned for residents of Toms River and surrounding communities like Seaside Heights, Bayville, and Island Heights, as it's just a short drive from many residential areas and popular attractions.

A great feature of this particular location is its accessibility. It's an ideal spot for a quick and easy visit, whether you're bringing a small group of friends or a large family. The ease of access from Route 37 means you don't have to navigate complicated side streets, and the address is simple to find using any GPS service. While some locations might require a trip to a bustling boardwalk, the Toms River shop provides a more convenient and relaxed setting for enjoying their delicious products. This makes it a perfect destination for a spontaneous dessert run, a scheduled celebration, or a post-dinner treat with the whole family.

Services Offered

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop offers a vast selection of desserts and services to satisfy every kind of sweet tooth. Their menu is thoughtfully designed to include classic favorites as well as inventive, modern treats that you won’t find anywhere else.

Handmade Ice Cream and Soft Serve: Choose from an extensive range of hard ice cream flavors, as well as a selection of creamy soft serve. They offer unique flavors like pumpkin twist and a variety of hard ice cream options including chocolate chip cookie dough, salted caramel pretzel, and many more. They are also known to offer non-dairy and vegan ice cream options, ensuring that guests with dietary restrictions can also enjoy a treat.
Custom Ice Cream Cakes: Planning a special event? Coney Waffle specializes in custom ice cream cakes for any occasion. These aren't your average cakes—they're often layered with different ice cream flavors, topped with cookies, candies, and various delicious crumbles, and can be personalized to your liking. They offer options like the Reese's Peanut Butter cake or the Oreo Ice Cream cake, which are popular for birthdays and other celebrations.
Signature Coney Waffles: The item that gives the shop its name, the Coney Waffle, is a must-try. These waffles are a creative base for a variety of scoops and toppings, offering a delightful combination of warm waffle and cold, creamy ice cream.
Ice Cream Sandwiches: Their ice cream sandwiches are a fan favorite. They come in different varieties, including ones made with chocolate chip cookies, Oreos, and even "Brookies" (a brownie and cookie combination), all with creamy ice cream in the middle.
Specialty Shakes and Sundaes: For those who want an unforgettable dessert, the shop's specialty shakes are legendary. They are often overloaded with a variety of toppings, from cookies and candy to entire slices of cake, creating a show-stopping dessert experience.
Other Sweets and Treats: Beyond ice cream, you can find a selection of other delicious items, including fresh-filled cannoli, gourmet fudge, cotton candy, large cookies, and a variety of bulk candies, making it a true one-stop-shop for all your sweet cravings.

Features and Highlights

Coney Waffle stands out in the crowded dessert market not just for its products, but for the overall experience it provides. The shop is a hub of creativity and flavor, offering several features that make it a local highlight.

Unbeatable Variety: The sheer number of options available is a major draw. From dozens of hard and soft ice cream flavors to different types of waffles, shakes, and other sweets, you can visit countless times and still find something new to try. Customers regularly praise the vast selection, noting that there are "so many options to choose from."
Generous Portions: A common theme in customer reviews is the generous portion sizes. You definitely get your money's worth, with scoops and toppings that are more than satisfying. As one reviewer mentioned, they are "not greedy with the amount of ice cream they gave me."
Friendly and Efficient Staff: The staff at Coney Waffle are often commended for being "very friendly" and providing "great service." Even during busy periods, the team is known for being welcoming and efficient, which contributes to a positive experience.
Creative and Unique Offerings: Coney Waffle is famous for its inventive dessert combinations. The "Rainbow Cone," which is topped with a vibrant array of colors and toppings, and their "Coney Freeze" shakes filled with various confections are great examples of their originality.
Clean and Inviting Atmosphere: The shop maintains a clean and pleasant environment, which is important for a food establishment. The dining area is well-kept, and there is often a nice outdoor sitting area available, which is perfect for enjoying a treat on a warm day.

Contact Information

For more information, to place a custom cake order, or to ask about their current flavors, you can reach out to Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop using the following details:

Address: 141 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA

Phone: (732) 556-6951

Conclusion: Why Coney Waffle is Perfect for New Jersey Locals

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop is much more than just a place to get dessert; it's a true community hub and a local institution in Toms River. For New Jersey residents, it provides an unparalleled sweet experience that is both convenient and memorable. Its prime location on Route 37 makes it an easy trip for a post-dinner treat or a weekend outing with the kids. The shop’s ability to cater to a wide range of tastes and dietary needs, from classic hard ice cream to vegan options, ensures that every member of the family or friend group will find something to love.

The business’s dedication to quality is evident in every aspect, from the homemade feel of their ice cream to the innovative designs of their custom cakes. The friendly and efficient staff creates an inviting atmosphere, whether you are a first-time visitor or a regular. The existence of a comfortable sitting area, both inside and outside, also makes it a great spot to relax and socialize while enjoying your dessert.

Whether you’re in the mood for a simple scoop of soft serve, an indulgent milkshake, or a custom cake for a special celebration, Coney Waffle has you covered. It's a place that brings people together, creates lasting memories, and satisfies even the most intense sweet cravings. For New Jersey locals, it’s a sweet escape that promises quality, creativity, and a welcoming smile with every visit.

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Food & drink

Ice Cream
KIDS CUP $4.35
1 Scoop Kids Cup
Coney Chillato $8.90
A refreshing combination of Italian ice and creamy soft serve ice cream, blended to a smooth and delightful consistency. Get Ready for the Flavor Explosion of the season!!
12 Flavor Ice Cream Sampler $34.25
A delightful assortment of 12 hand crafted creamy ice cream flavors, approximately 4 oz each, offering a diverse range of tastes from rich chocolate to tangy fruit.
Cherries Underground $10.80
A hearty serving of Sweet maraschino cherries buried beneath a creamy swirl of the soft serve of your choice, creating a hidden delight in every scoop. Sold in 12 oz serving Choose up to two flavors! (Single Selection will result in both servings in single choice)
Ice Cream Sandwich Singles $3.80
Creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two cookies and adorned with colorful sprinkles, chocolate chips or plain, creating a delightful treat.
Italian Ice $4.35
Italian Ice
Ice Cream Filled Cannoli (Two) $9.95
Two Cannoli Filled with Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream
Float (Soda) $8.90
Float
The American Firecracker $8.90
Celebrate the chill of freedom with The American Firecracker—our explosive blend of Italian ice, layered with creamy soft serve and sprinkled with rainbow sprinkles. It’s the taste of summer, served up Coney-style. Available in 20oz or 32oz(Red White & Boom Pictured)
MILKSHAKE $4.85
Hand-spun milkshakes crafted with creamy ice cream, topped with a generous swirl of whipped cream, available in over 60 delightful flavors. Kids 12oz ,Small 20oz, Large 32oz
Coney Waffle 3 Pack $16.20
Sugar Cone $4.35
Sugar Cone
Brookie Ice Cream Sandwiches $23.75
4-Pack of our BROOKIE Ice Cream Sandwiches - vanilla or chocolate ice cream sandwiched between a fudgey brownie and a chocolate chip cookie!
Beach Ball Sandwich $7.05
1 Large Scoop Ice Cream
Rainbow Bowl/Cone $9.70
Our house made flavored Rainbow Waffle Cones and Bowls served with 2 Large Scoops of Ice Cream. Cone orders are served in medium cup with cone on the side.
Cereal Treat Ice Cream Sandwich Pack $23.75
Delicious cereal treat made into an ice cream sandwich. Two cereal treats with ice cream in the middle.
QUART $14.05
4 Large Scoops Quart Cup
Coney Waffle $8.65
3 Scoops Ice Cream or Cannoli Cream
BROWNIE WAFFLE $9.45
3 Scoops of Ice Cream
Cake Cone $4.35
Cake Cone
SMALL CUP $6.75
2 Scoops of Ice Cream
Plain Waffle Waffle Cone/Bowl $9.20
Plain Waffle Cone or bowl. Cone orders are served in medium cup with cone on the side.
Italian Ice Shake $8.90
Refreshing Italian ice blended seamlessly with your choice of creamy milk, tangy lemonade, or chilled ice tea to create a smooth and invigorating shake.
LARGE / PINT $10.25
3 Large Scoops Pint Cup
MEDIUM CUP $8.10
Up to 3 Flavors Medium Cup
CONEY FREEZE $9.70
Made with Soft Serve Ice Cream (Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist) pick 1 blend in.
1/2 Gallon $25.35
A generous 1/2 Gallon serving of rich and creamy Ice Cream, available in a choice of over 60 luscious flavors, perfect for sharing with the family.
Cereal Sundae $9.70
Cereal Sunday. Choose up to 2 flavors of ice cream.
Sprinkle Dipped Bowl/Cone $9.70
Sprinkle Dipped Bowl/Cone Cone orders are served in medium cup with cone on the side.
Ice Cream Sandwiches $16.20
6-Pack of Ice Cream Sandwiches with a choice of Chocolate Chip or Oreo ice cream sandwiches! Assorted flavors or vanilla, chocolate.

Extras
Baby Nutella $2.45
A mini jar of nutella, a sweetened hazelnut cocoa spread.
Cake Topper $4.85
HBD Candles $5.40
Colorful letter-shaped candles spelling out a celebratory message for special occasions.

Specialty Items
Reese's Peanut Butter Waffle Sundae $12.40
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate & Peanut Butter Drizzle, Crushed Reese's and Reese's Pieces.
Cookie Dough Milkshake $10.55
A Cookie Dough Milkshake with Cookie Dough ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, Chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Cookie Dough pieces.
M&M's Milkshake $10.55
M&M Milkshake with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, mini M&M's & a Chocolate Drizzle.
Double Chocolate Milkshake $10.55
A Chocolate Milkshake with Chocolate Ice Cream, topped with Chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle, Whipped Cream & Cherry
Double Chocolate Brownie Sundae $13.05
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Drizzle, and Chocolate Cake Crunch
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Dough Sundae $14.40
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Cookie Dough pieces.
Oreo Brownie Sundae $13.05
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, crushed Oreos & Chocolate Drizzle.
Cookie Dough Brownie Sundae $14.40
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Cookie Dough pieces.
Cookie Dough Waffle Sundae $12.40
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle, Cookie Dough pieces & chocolate chips.
Nutella Ferrero Rocher Milkshake $10.55
A Vanilla or Chocolate Nutella Milkshake topped with Whipped Cream, Nutella Drizzle, Chocolate Chips, Cake Crunch, and a Ferrero Rocher
Reese's Brownie Sundae $14.40
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Reese's Pieces, Crushed Reese's, Peanut Butter Sauce & Chocolate Drizzle
M&M Brownie Sundae $12.75
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with M&M's & Chocolate Drizzle
S'mores Brownie Sundae $14.40
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with crushed graham crackers, chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, and s Chocolate and Marshmallow Drizzle.
Ferrero Rocher Nutella Brownie Sundae $14.40
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate cake crunch, mini chocolate chips, Nutella drizzle, and a Ferrero Rocher
M&M Waffle Sundae $10.80
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle and mini M&M's
Cookie Butter Biscoff Waffle Sundae $12.40
A Coney Waffle with Cookie Butter Ice Cream, Biscoff & Butterscotch Drizzle, Ground Biscoff & topped with a Biscoff cookie!
Double Chocolate Waffle Sundae $12.40
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle & Chocolate Chips, and Chocolate Cake Crunch
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Ferrero Rocher Nutella Sundae $14.40
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, chocolate cake crunch, Nutella drizzle & a Ferrero Rocher
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Chocolate Sundae $13.05
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, chocolate cake crunch, and a chocolate drizzle
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Oreo Sundae $13.05
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Oreo pieces.
Giant 1/2lb Cookie M&M Sundae $12.75
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with mini M&M's & Chocolate Drizzle
Oreo Waffle Sundae $12.40
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle, Chocolate Chips, and Crushed Oreos
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Reese's Peanut Butter Sundae $14.40
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Reese's Pieces, Crushed Reese's, Chocolate Drizzle & Peanut Butter Drizzle
Oreo Milkshake $10.55
An Oreo Milkshake with Oreo ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, Chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Oreo pieces.
Reese's Peanut Butter Milkshake $10.55
Reese's Peanut Butter Milkshake with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Crushed Reese's, Reese's Pieces, Chocolate Drizzle & Peanut Butter Drizzle
Ferrero Rocher Nutella Waffle Sundae $12.40
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Nutella Drizzle, Cake Crunch, Ferrero Rocher & Chocolate Chips
S'mores Waffle Sundae $12.40
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate & Marshmallow Drizzle, Chocolate Chips, crushed Graham crackers, and mini Marshmallows
Giant 1/2lb Cookie S'mores Sundae $14.40
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with crushed Graham crackers, chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, and a Marshmallow & Chocolate Drizzle
S'mores Milkshake $10.55
A S'mores Milkshake with Brownie S'mores ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, Marshmallow, Chocolate Drizzle, mini marshmallows, chocolate chips & graham cracker pieces
Shirley Temple Ice Cream Float $10.55
A delightful combination of creamy vanilla ice cream and a splash of grenadine syrup, topped with fizzy lemon-lime soda and garnished with sweet maraschino cherries & Whipped Cream. *Items ordered for delivery will arrive Un poured and DO NOT include Whipped Cream

Toppings
Make It A Sundae $1.35
whipped cream cherry 1 Topping

Beverages
Mangonada $14.05
Popular Mexican frozen beverage made from ripe mangoes, lime juice, chamoy sauce, and chili-lime salt. It combines sweet, tangy, spicy, and savory flavors for an exotic, refreshing taste, perfect for serving any day of the year! Large 20oz

Toppings
Toppings $0.00
Toppings

Grab & Go
No Sugar Added Vanilla Peanut Butter $6.90
No Sugar Added
Chocolate Covered Ice Cream Bars / Paletas $4.35
Assorted Ice Cream Bars (pops)/ Paletas made with fresh ingredients and dipped in Chocolate coating.
Bars / Paletas $4.35
Crafted with a creamy texture and bursting with fresh fruit flavors, these ice cream bars are a refreshing treat anytime. Enjoy the perfect blend of sweetness and chill in every bite.

Ice Cream Cake
Cookie Dough Oreo Mix Cake $46.40
2 layers of COOKIE DOUGH or COOKIES & CREAM ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, cookie dough, and crushed Oreo cookies!
Cannoli Ice Cream Cake $59.35
An 8 inch cake with 2 layers of CANNOLI ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, topped with ice cream sandwiches, decorated with cannoli shells and mini chocolate chips!
Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake Ice Cream Cake $59.35
8-inch Cake - 2 layers of PUMPKIN CARAMEL CHEESECAKE ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, graham cracker crumbs, cheesecake bites, and a caramel drizzle! **Seasonal item available for limited time only
Ice Cream Sampler Plate $46.40
A variety of 8 sample slices of our most popular ice cream flavors! Toppings and ice cream flavors will vary per order based on availability.
Chocolate Fudge Brownie Cake $46.40
2 layers of CHOCOLATE FUDGE BROWNIE ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, chocolate cake crunch, brownie bites, and mini chocolate chips!
Mini Ice Cream Cake $20.70
A 4-inch Mini Ice Cream Cake with your choice of decorations and ice cream flavor. Serves 1-2
Sprinkle Ice Cream Cake $46.40
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches and rainbow sprinkles! **NOTE: Custom sprinkle colors can be added to the order notes. **NOTE: Additional toppings available for an additional charge.
Patriotic Ice Cream Cake $46.40
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, a chocolate drip, red, white, & blue sprinkles and M&M's!
Ice Cream Sandwich Pull-Apart Cake $51.80
A tower of ice cream sandwiches for your guests to pull-apart and enjoy The Perfect mix of Vanilla Oreo and Vanilla Chocolate Chip ice cream sandwiches
Giant Ice Cream Sandwich Cake $45.95
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, sandwiched between two GIANT chocolate chip cookies, rolled in your choice of toppings!
Monster Blue Cookie Cake $57.45
2 layers of MONSTER BLUE ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, topped with Oreos, mini chocolate chip cookies, and blue sprinkles! **NOTE: Additional toppings available for an additional charge.
Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Cake $59.35
An 8 inch cake with 2 layers of STRAWBERRY ice cream filled with a layer of white cake crunch, topped with ice cream sandwiches, decorated with cheesecake bites and strawberry shortcake crumbs! **NOTE: Additional toppings available for an additional charge.
Raffaello White Chocolate Cake $75.85
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, wrapped with white chocolate Kit Kats and Pirouline Wafers, topped with ice cream sandwiches, Raffaello truffles, white sprinkles, and an assortment of white chocolate candies. **NOTE: Additional toppings available for an additional charge.
Nutella Drip Cake $59.65
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, topped with a chocolate fudge drip, decorated with chocolate sprinkles, mini Nutella jars, Ferrero Rochers, and an assortment of chocolate bars!
Reese's PB Cake $51.80
2 layers of VANILLA PEANUT BUTTER or CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, sprinkles, crushed Reese's, and Reese's pieces!
S'mores Ice Cream Cake $53.95
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, a chocolate drip, marshmallows, crushed graham crackers, and more chocolate!
Oreo Ice Cream Cake $46.40
2 layers of COOKIES & CREAM ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, topped with Oreo ice cream sandwiches rolled with rainbow sprinkles, and loaded with crushed Oreos!
Ice Cream Pie $36.70
Indulge in a Coney Waffle ice cream pie, featuring your choice of ice cream nestled in a delicious cookie crust! Topped with ice cream sandwiches and overflowing with your favorite toppings, these pies are the ultimate dessert treat!
Easter Ice Cream Cake $46.40
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, Easter sprinkles, Oreo Crumbs, an icing bunny butt, and chocolate carrots and eggs! **NOTE: This cake is only offered until Easter.
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Cake $46.40
2 layers of COOKIE DOUGH ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, and loads of cookie dough!
Monster Pink Cookie Cake $57.45
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, topped with Oreos, mini chocolate chip cookies, and pink sprinkles! **NOTE: Additional toppings available for an additional charge.
Cheesecake Topped Cake $46.40
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, graham cracker crumbs, and cheesecake bites!
7-Layer Rainbow Cookie Cake $57.45
2 layers of Chocolate ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with sprinkles, ice cream sandwiches, and 7-layer rainbow cookies!
Kit Kat Cake $75.85
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, wrapped in Kit Kats, topped with ice cream sandwiches, mini M&M',s and chocolate covered pretzels! **NOTE: Additional toppings available for an additional charge.
Candy Ice Cream Cake $55.20
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with a chocolate fudge drip, ice cream sandwiches, rainbow sprinkles, and an assortment of chocolate and gummy candies!
Pull Apart Cake $60.90
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches around the cake, and your choice of toppings! **NOTE: Rainbow sprinkles will be used if no toppings are selected. Additional toppings available for an additional charge.

Common
Gatorade $3.25
Ice Cream Party $258.75
Mineragua $3.25
Fresh Filled Cannoli Station $776.25
Sprite $3.25
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Fresh Filled Cannoli Station $690.00

Candy/Fudge
Hot Cocoa Bomb Variety 4-Pack $30.20
Enjoy a cozy variety with our Hot Cocoa Bomb 4-Pack! Featuring classic, cookies and cream, s'mores, and peppermint flavors, each bomb melts into a rich, creamy cup of hot chocolate. Perfect for gifting or treating yourself to a delicious seasonal indulgence!
Cotton Candy Large $8.10
Coney Cotton Candy
Gourmet Fudge $5.40
Indulge in our handcrafted gourmet fudge made at the Jersey Shore. Whether you're a local longing for a taste of home, or a visitor craving a delicious souvenir, dive into the nostalgia of the boardwalk with our artisan fudge.
Hershey Bar $3.00
Hot Cocoa Bomb $8.65
Indulge in the ultimate cozy treat with our hot cocoa bombs! These chocolate spheres melt into rich, creamy hot chocolate when you add hot milk. Perfect for gifting or enjoying a cozy moment this holiday season.
Fudge $5.40
Ring Pop $1.35
A jewel-shaped hard candy on a plastic ring, offered in a strawberry flavor.
Kit Kat $3.00
Cereal Treat $5.40
Cereal Treats, assorted Cereals made into Delicious Treats!
2 Tootsie Pops $1.35
Hard candy lollipop with a chocolatey center in assorted fruit flavors.
12oz Taffy Tub 3/4lb $10.25
Coney Waffle 3/4 Pound of Taffy
KIT KAT WHITE CHOCOLATE $3.00
Coney Waffle Chocolate Treat Box $62.05
Variety Chocolate Covered Pretzels, Chocolate Covered Oreos, Non-Pareils, & Homemade Fudge Variety*Contents may vary based on availability *Each Pound will serve approximately 10 people
Whirly PoP 1.5oz $3.80
Cotton Candy Small $5.95
Coney Cotton Candy

Drinks
Seltzer $3.80
Stewarts Classic Soda $3.25
STEWART'S FOUNTAIN CLASSICS
Gatorade $3.25
Classic Shirley Temple $5.15
A refreshing blend of sweet grenadine and bubbly lemon-lime soda on the rocks, garnished with maraschino cherries for a touch of classic charm that kids of any age love!
Prime $3.25
Assorted Selection of Prime Hydration Drinks providing hydration in a 16.9 fl oz (500ml) bottle.
Coffee $1.90
Snapple $3.25
A blend of tea with a hint of natural lemon flavor.
Hot Chocolate $5.40
ITALIAN Ice Tea / Lemonade $8.10
Welcome to this summers most refreshing drink! Instead of ice cubes, cool down our fresh brewed Sweet Tea or Fresh Squeezed Lemonade with 2 scoops of our house made Italian Ice!
Drinks $3.25
Assorted Drinks including Stewarts Fountain Classic flavors
Red Bull $3.80
Coke $3.25
Classic cola with a rich, caramel flavor and a refreshing effervescence.
Lemonade / Ice Tea $6.50
Giant 32oz Fresh Squeezed Lemonade!

Baked Goods
Chocolate Pudding $6.75
Layers of chocolate pudding and whipped cream, topped with mini chocolate chips
Chocolate Banana Pudding $6.75
Layers of bananas, vanilla wafers, creamy homemade pudding topped with whipped cream.
Banana Pudding $6.75
Layers of bananas, vanilla wafers, creamy homemade pudding, and whipped cream.
Baked Pies $23.00
Homemade Real Baked Pies. Your Choice of Apple Crumb Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Key Lime Pie, Pecan Pie, or Coconut Custard Pie
Vanilla Pudding $6.75
Layers creamy vanilla pudding and whipped cream
Giant 1/2lb Cookie $7.05
Assorted GIANT 1/2lb cookie
Birthday Cake Pudding $6.75
Layers of funfetti cake, rainbow sprinkles, and creamy homemade pudding, topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream.
Chocolate Oreo Pudding $6.75
Layers of Oreo Cookies and creamy chocolate pudding, topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream.
Italian Cannoli (One) $4.35
Fresh Filled Cannoli
Brownies $5.65
Assorted brownie flavors
Oreo Pudding $6.75
Layers of Oreo Cookies and creamy homemade pudding, topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream.
Coconut Macaroon $5.65
Coney Waffle Coconut macaroons have a rich, buttery coconut flavor and a chewy texture. Made with sweetened condensed milk and no flour, coconut macaroons are closer to being a candy than coconut cookies. To up their candy-like flavor, choose chocolate dipped – this is my favorite way to eat them!
Vanilla / Chocolate Pudding $6.75
Layers of chocolate pudding, vanilla pudding, and whipped cream
Rice Pudding $8.10
Creamy rice pudding, topped with whipped cream and a sprinkle of cinnamon

Milkshake
Large Shake $13.50
Small Shake $8.90
Small Milk Shake

Vegan
Vegan $5.40
A robust selection of plant-based frozen deserts, crafted with non-dairy ingredients, offering a flavorful experience that celebrates the richness of NON-DAIRY treats.
Vegan Shake $10.25
A robust selection of plant-based frozen deserts, crafted with non-dairy almond milk, offering a flavorful experience that celebrates the richness of NON-DAIRY treats. Almond Milk
Vegan 6 Pack $21.05
A selection of six Vegan sandwiches made with fresh plant-based ingredients, complemented by a sweet treat of vegan-friendly Oreo cookies. NO DAIRY
Vegan $5.40
A robust selection of plant-based frozen deserts, crafted with non-dairy ingredients, offering a flavorful experience that celebrates the richness of NON-DAIRY treats.

Coney Waffle
Caramel/Fudge Packets $2.20

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Details

Service options
Delivery
Drive-through
In-store pickup
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options
Seating

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Children
Good for kids

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Photos

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 1

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 2

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 3

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 4

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 5

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 6

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 7

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 8

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Picture 9

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Location

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop

New Jersey Ocean County Toms River Toms River New Jersey 37

141 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA

Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 125 user reviews.

priceto chooseflavortoppingsdrive thrustrawberryvanillafudgecupmilkshake

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Some friends and I went here after work Friday, and were delighted by how our ice cream came out. I got the pumpkin twist soft serve, which was amazing. My other friends got chocolate chip cookie dough, chocolate, and a milkshake. The only complaint was the milkshake, as we thought it really lacked flavour. Other than that, the staff were very friendly, and there is a nice little sitting area outside! There were so many options to choose from, and way more than just ice cream. I would definitely come here again.
October 20 · Clifton Nivison
Tried this place for the first time on Tuesday summer evening after 8:30 and had great service - we had a large group of 10 kids and 5 adults and I thought their prices were reasonable. They have so many different flavors to choose from, I would recommend the soft serve and hard ice cream over Italian ice. I did not like the Italian ice as much. The dining area was nice and clean. They also have a large selection of ice cream cakes.
August 27 · Aneliya Georgieva
I can't say enough about the wonderful young ladies that work there. They were absolute ANGELS! I came for my Daughter to have a birthday treat with her cousins. My mother-in-law and her Aunt overrode my direction that the kids not be wild, run around or be loud inside the dining area. I felt so mortified and yet the sweet girls that worked there were SO PATIENT and didn't make me want to crawl under a table. Thank you all for the best service and complete patience. The only thing that outshines the staff is the creative and absolutely delicious treats and ice cream. Unlike any place I've ever been!!!
June 05 · Jenny Burroughs
Always an amazing experience! Fantastic customer service, delicious options .. and all wonderful flavors for nondairy options!
July 12 · MindySue Fry
This place is so dairy free friendly! There are so many more df flavors than usual ice cream places and the strawberry is amazing. They can even make df milkshakes. This is my new favorite ice cream parlor!
July 12 · Tara Rice