Cooney's Island Introduce
For anyone in New York, especially those in the charming town of Ripley, the pursuit of the perfect ice cream cone is a quintessential summer activity. While the Empire State boasts many delightful spots, Cooney's Island has emerged as a truly special destination, earning a loyal following and a reputation for truly exceptional frozen treats. This isn't just another ice cream shop; it's a place where quality ingredients, passionate craftsmanship, and a warm, inviting atmosphere converge to create a memorable experience for every customer.
Cooney's Island stands out in the New York ice cream landscape for its commitment to delivering "Fantastic ice cream!!!" and its dedication to homemade deliciousness. Patrons consistently rave about the superior quality, often highlighting specific flavors that leave a lasting impression. The "Strawberry cheesecake was one of the best ice creams I've had," according to one enthusiastic reviewer, showcasing the unique and expertly crafted options available. Beyond the delectable flavors, the experience at Cooney's Island is further enhanced by its welcoming environment. Customers appreciate that the "owner was personable," adding a personal touch that makes each visit feel special. Combined with "Great prices," Cooney's Island offers an unbeatable combination of high-quality, delicious homemade ice cream, excellent value, and friendly service, making it a must-visit spot for any ice cream lover in New York.
Cooney's Island is conveniently located at 25 W Main St, Ripley, NY 14775, USA. This prime address places it directly on West Main Street, a central thoroughfare in Ripley, making it exceptionally easy to find for both local residents and visitors traveling through the area. West Main Street is a well-known route, ensuring that navigation to the ice cream shop is straightforward and hassle-free.
For New Yorkers in Ripley and the surrounding communities, the creamery's central location is a significant advantage, allowing for quick and convenient visits whether it's for a spontaneous treat or a planned outing. Ample parking options are typically available in such main street locations, facilitating easy access for customers arriving by car. While public transportation options might be limited in a smaller town like Ripley, the shop's prominent position ensures that it's a popular and easily reachable destination for those driving. Being situated on a main street also provides visibility, drawing in both dedicated ice cream enthusiasts and casual passersby looking for a delicious refreshment. This accessible location plays a vital role in Cooney's Island's status as a beloved community spot in Western New York.
Services Offered:
- A wide array of fantastic and delicious homemade ice cream flavors.
- Specialty ice cream options, including highly praised creations like strawberry cheesecake.
- Great prices for all ice cream selections, offering excellent value.
- Friendly and personable service from the owner and staff.
- Take-out service for enjoying treats on the go.
- A welcoming and enjoyable atmosphere suitable for families and individuals.
Features / Highlights:
- "Fantastic Ice Cream!!!": Consistently receives top praise for the overall quality and taste of its ice cream, indicating a truly superior product.
- Delicious Homemade Ice Cream: The emphasis on "homemade" highlights the freshness, quality ingredients, and artisanal approach, setting it apart from mass-produced options.
- Exceptional Strawberry Cheesecake Flavor: A specific flavor that has garnered significant acclaim, suggesting unique and expertly crafted options beyond the basics.
- Personable Owner: The owner's friendly and engaging demeanor enhances the customer experience, making visits more pleasant and memorable.
- Great Prices: Patrons appreciate the affordability, noting that the excellent quality comes at a reasonable cost.
- Local Gem: Clearly a beloved and highly recommended spot within the Ripley, NY community and potentially for visitors to the region.
- Positive Customer Experience: The combination of great products, good value, and friendly service leads to overwhelmingly positive reviews.
Contact Information:
Address: 25 W Main St, Ripley, NY 14775, USA
Phone: (814) 824-9542
For residents of Ripley, NY, and those across the wider New York state looking for a truly outstanding ice cream experience, Cooney's Island stands out as an ideal choice. Its suitability for locals is multifaceted, deeply rooted in its commitment to quality, value, and community spirit. The consistent praise for "Delicious homemade ice cream" is a major draw. Locals appreciate establishments that prioritize fresh, quality ingredients and artisanal craftsmanship, leading to a superior taste that simply can't be replicated by mass-produced alternatives. This commitment to homemade goodness ensures a consistently delightful product that brings patrons back time and again.
Furthermore, the "Great prices" mean that enjoying this high-quality treat doesn't have to be an infrequent luxury; it can be a regular, affordable pleasure for families and individuals. In a state where living costs can be high, finding such value is a significant advantage. The "personable owner" and implied friendly service create a welcoming and engaging atmosphere that transforms a simple transaction into a pleasant social interaction. New Yorkers appreciate genuine hospitality, and Cooney's Island delivers on this front. Whether it's to indulge in a celebrated flavor like the strawberry cheesecake, grab a quick, delicious cone, or simply enjoy a moment of sweet relaxation, Cooney's Island offers a perfect blend of fantastic ice cream, excellent value, and local charm, firmly establishing itself as a cherished community staple in Ripley, NY.
Cooney's Island Details
Service options
- Onsite services
- Takeout
Offerings
- Coffee
Atmosphere
- Casual
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Cooney's Island Photos










Cooney's Island Location
Cooney's Island Reviews
flavorsdartspoolatmospherebottlescheesecakebeerwafflesummer
β 5β 4β 3β 2β 1Fantastic ice cream!!! Strawberry cheesecake was one of he best ice creams I've had πππ
July 13 Β· Gary AshtonDelicious homemade ice cream. The owner was personable. Great prices.
July 04 Β· Michele FordDelicious ice cream, great customer service, definitely going back, been multiple times always delicious
July 26 Β· Gretchen KleinfelderWhile visiting Western NY, I was blessed to have been taken to Cooney's. Truly some of the best ice cream I have ever had. So creamy and an amazing number of choices. I ordered a scoop of Snickers and a scoop of Cherry NY Cheesecake....Incredible!
June 01 Β· Scott Richardson - Occasionally YoursDonβt miss this place! True, delicious homemade ice cream! The flavors are fantastic! I donβt stop for ice cream often but sooo glad I stopped here!!!
July 14 Β· Kara Smith
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

10362 W Main St, North East, PA 16428, USA

3799 Shannon Rd #106, Erie, PA 16510, USA

861 Panama-Bear Lake Rd, Panama, NY 14767, USA

804 E 38th St, Erie, PA 16504, USA

929 Parade St, Erie, PA 16503, USA

427 State St, Erie, PA 16501, USA

1406 W Gore Rd, Erie, PA 16509, USA

1504 W 38th St, Erie, PA 16508, USA

950 Central Ave, Dunkirk, NY 14048, USA

7 9 lakeshore drive, Dunkirk, NY 14048, USA

60 N Main St, Union City, PA 16438, USA

12643 US-19, Waterford, PA 16441, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





