Cowboy Creamery: A Taste of the Wild West in Middlefield, OH

Cowboy Creamery Introduce

Howdy, Ohio dessert lovers! If you're on the lookout for a fun, friendly, and delicious ice cream experience, you'll be thrilled to discover Cowboy Creamery in Middlefield. This isn't your average scoop shop; it's a destination with a "fun atmosphere" and a menu full of unique and exciting treats. Located right here in Ohio, Cowboy Creamery has quickly become a local favorite for its "delicious ice cream" and "great service." It’s the kind of place that captures your attention, whether you're a local who's heard the buzz or a traveler who simply did a quick search to find a sweet stop on your way home. The shop is celebrated for its commitment to quality, crafting "super-premium" ice cream with a rich, creamy texture that's simply irresistible. With a wide variety of flavors, from classic to creative, and a host of other delectable desserts, there's always something new to try. This guide is designed to give you a comprehensive overview of what makes Cowboy Creamery a cherished part of the Middlefield community, highlighting its welcoming vibe, diverse offerings, and commitment to excellence.

The core of Cowboy Creamery’s appeal lies in its incredible variety and quality. Their hand-dipped ice cream is crafted with a 14% butterfat mix and fresh Wisconsin milk, which gives it a rich and creamy texture that customers rave about. The flavor selection is truly impressive, featuring a mix of core scoops and unique creations that you won't find anywhere else. You can find everything from classics like Old Fashioned Vanilla and Zanzibar Chocolate to more adventurous flavors like "Exhausted Parent," a bourbon-spiked espresso ice cream, or "This $@&! Just Got Serious," a salted caramel ice cream with sea salt fudge and cashews. The shop also offers a variety of dairy-free and vegan options, ensuring that everyone in the family can find a delicious treat. Beyond the scoops, the menu is packed with other fantastic items. Their "Barrel Sundaes" are a crowd-pleaser, with creative combinations like the "Fluffernutter" or the "Strawberry Oreo Cheesecake." They also offer "Stampedes," which are their signature blended creations, as well as milkshakes and malts. This commitment to a diverse and high-quality menu is a major reason why the shop has earned a reputation for being a true "gem."

The experience at Cowboy Creamery is consistently described as a positive one. Customers note the atmosphere is "fun" and the staff is "pleasant and very polite." This focus on excellent customer service is a key part of the shop's charm. The clean and well-maintained environment also contributes to a welcoming feeling, making it a comfortable place to sit and enjoy your dessert. The shop goes beyond just serving ice cream; it offers a variety of "novelty items" and other products, creating a more engaging and comprehensive experience. For instance, they have a selection of beautifully crafted ice cream cakes, which are perfect for special occasions and celebrations. Their catering services, which include an ice cream truck, pre-scooped servings, and a build-your-own sundae bar, further solidify their role as a community-centric business. This willingness to go above and beyond, both in their product offerings and their customer service, is what makes Cowboy Creamery stand out. The shop has successfully created a destination that is not only about getting a sweet treat but also about having a great time in a friendly and enjoyable environment.

Cowboy Creamery has clearly made a strong impression on its customers, earning repeat visits from locals and a great reputation among newcomers. The sentiment that the shop is "Extremely clean with pleasant and very polite staff" and offers "great service" and "delicious ice cream" is a common theme in the reviews. The wide selection of flavors, from their core scoops to their specialty creations, means that there's always a reason to return. The "Exhausted Parent" and "This $@&! Just Got Serious" flavors, with their unique and playful names, are perfect examples of the creativity that goes into their products. The shop's commitment to providing a variety of options, including dairy-free and no-sugar-added flavors, ensures that it can cater to a broad audience. This inclusive approach, combined with the fun atmosphere and high-quality products, makes Cowboy Creamery more than just an ice cream shop; it's a valuable community asset. For locals in Middlefield and the surrounding areas, it’s a reliable and delightful spot to satisfy a craving and create lasting memories with family and friends.

### Location and Accessibility

Cowboy Creamery is conveniently located at 14895 N State Ave d, Middlefield, OH 44062, USA. This address places it in a prime spot for residents of Middlefield and the surrounding communities in Geauga County. N State Avenue is a well-known local road, which makes finding the shop a straightforward process for both new and returning customers. The location is easily accessible by car, and its presence on a main road means it's a visible and easy-to-spot destination. The clear address and recognizable storefront make navigating to the shop a breeze, ensuring that you can get to your delicious dessert without any hassle. This ease of access contributes significantly to its popularity, making it a go-to spot for a quick treat or a planned family outing. Whether you're a local running errands or a visitor passing through, Cowboy Creamery's location makes it a convenient and appealing choice for a frozen treat.

### Services Offered

Hand-Dipped Ice Cream: A wide variety of super-premium flavors, including classic, seasonal, and unique options.
Soft Serve: Delicious soft serve ice cream for a classic, creamy treat.
"Stampedes": Their signature blended creations with your choice of mix-ins.
Sundaes and Specialties: A menu of delicious and creative sundaes, including "Barrel Sundaes" and a "Giant Banana Split."
Milkshakes and Malts: Hand-spun shakes made with your choice of ice cream.
Ice Cream Cakes: A selection of beautifully crafted ice cream cakes, perfect for celebrations.
Catering Services: Options including an ice cream truck, pre-scooped cups, and build-your-own sundae bars for events.

### Features / Highlights

Fun Atmosphere: The shop is praised for its "fun atmosphere" and a clean, welcoming environment.
Exceptional Service: Customers consistently mention the "pleasant and very polite staff" and "great service."
Unique Flavor Selection: The menu features a creative mix of ice cream flavors, from traditional to inventive, with options like "Exhausted Parent" and "This $@&! Just Got Serious."
Super-Premium Quality: The ice cream is made with a 14% butterfat mix and fresh local milk, ensuring a rich and creamy texture.
Inclusive Menu: The shop offers dairy-free options and no-sugar-added flavors, catering to a diverse range of dietary needs.

### Contact Information

Address: 14895 N State Ave d, Middlefield, OH 44062, USA

Phone: (440) 632-0414

### Conclusion: Why This Place Is Suitable for Locals

Cowboy Creamery is the perfect fit for the residents of Middlefield, OH, because it offers a truly unique and high-quality ice cream experience. The fun atmosphere, combined with the consistently excellent service, makes every visit a pleasure. The super-premium ice cream, with its wide variety of delicious and creative flavors, ensures that there's always something to satisfy every craving. For locals, it's a reliable and enjoyable destination that provides great value, whether you're stopping by for a quick scoop or picking up a specialty cake for a celebration. The shop's commitment to quality, a diverse menu, and a welcoming environment has earned it a well-deserved reputation as a beloved local gem. For anyone in the Middlefield area seeking a delicious frozen treat and a fun, family-friendly experience, Cowboy Creamery is a must-visit spot that embodies the best of local business and community spirit.

Cowboy Creamery Menu

Freezer Favorites
Nuts For Ice Cream Wagon Wheel Sandwiches (5-Pack) US$14.99
Fat Elvis, Peanut Butter Cup, Yippee Skippee This $@!& Just Got Serious
Giant Chocolate Chip Wagon Wheel Sandwich US$6.99
A hefty pile of vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies. Rolled in semi-sweet chocolate chips. Enough to satisfy your craving now and save some for later.
Ice Cream Stuffed Oreos US$9.99
Giant Oreo wafers stuffed with chocolate and vanilla soft serve.
Kid's Box Wagon Wheel Sandwiches (5-Pack) US$14.99
Giant Oreo cookie wafers stuffed with Blue Moon, Super Human, Munchie Madness, and Birthday Cake ice cream.
Soft Serve Variety Box (5-Pack) US$12.99
Strawberry Shortcake, Cotton Candy Crunch, Peanut Brittle Crunch Coat, Rainbow Sprinkles, and Peanuts
Cookie Monster Wagon Wheel Sandwiches (5-Pack) US$14.99
Giant Oreo cookie wafers stuffed with Ultimate Oreo, Cookie Dough, Mint Avalanche, and Kitty Kitty Bang Bang (Raspberry Cheesecake & Oreo) ice cream.

Drinks & Sides
Freddie's Ginger Ale (Single Bottle) US$2.79
This delicious ginger ale is named after our famed tour guide Freddie Johnson. Freddie, whose father and grandfather both worked at the Distillery before him, has worked as a tour guide at Buffalo Trace for many years and well known for delighting guests with his fun personality and fabulous story telling. Freddie was inducted into the Kentucky Bourbon Hall of Fame and his “bubbly” personality is a natural fit for this ginger ale. The bottle has Freddie’s image and claims his well-known catchphrases, like “How cool is that?” and “Hey daddy-o!” The six bottle carrier depicts scenes of the Distillery and Freddie fishing along the banks of the Kentucky River.
Basket O' Waffle Nachos US$4.99
Add a crispy, crunchy, slightly-sweet element to ice cream
Chocolate Chip Brownie US$2.50
Freddie's Root Beer (6-Pack) US$13.99
This delicious root beer soda is named after our famed tour guide Freddie Johnson. Freddie, whose father and grandfather both worked at the Distillery before him, has worked as a tour guide at Buffalo Trace for many years and is well known for delighting guests with his fun personality and fabulous story telling. Freddie was inducted into the Kentucky Bourbon Hall of Fame and his personality is a natural fit for this old fashioned root beer. The bottle has Freddie’s image and claims his well-known catchphrases. The six bottle carrier depicts scenes of the Distillery and Freddie fishing along the banks of the Kentucky River. This root beer is made with natural herbs real oil of birch and imported vanilla. For adults, mix it with Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cream to make a fabulous root beer float.
4 Pack Of Waffle Cones US$4.99
Freddie's Ginger Ale (6-Pack) US$13.99
This delicious ginger ale is named after our famed tour guide Freddie Johnson. Freddie, whose father and grandfather both worked at the Distillery before him, has worked as a tour guide at Buffalo Trace for many years and well known for delighting guests with his fun personality and fabulous story telling. Freddie was inducted into the Kentucky Bourbon Hall of Fame and his “bubbly” personality is a natural fit for this ginger ale. The bottle has Freddie’s image and claims his well-known catchphrases, like “How cool is that?” and “Hey daddy-o!” The six bottle carrier depicts scenes of the Distillery and Freddie fishing along the banks of the Kentucky River.
Freddie's Root Beer (Single Bottle) US$2.79
This delicious root beer soda is named after our famed tour guide Freddie Johnson. Freddie, whose father and grandfather both worked at the Distillery before him, has worked as a tour guide at Buffalo Trace for many years and is well known for delighting guests with his fun personality and fabulous story telling. Freddie was inducted into the Kentucky Bourbon Hall of Fame and his personality is a natural fit for this old fashioned root beer. The bottle has Freddie’s image and claims his well-known catchphrases. The six bottle carrier depicts scenes of the Distillery and Freddie fishing along the banks of the Kentucky River. This root beer is made with natural herbs real oil of birch and imported vanilla. For adults, mix it with Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cream to make a fabulous root beer float.

Hand Dipped Ice Cream
Double Hand Dipped Ice Cream US$7.20
Build-Your-Own 4 Scoop Flight US$9.00
Single Hand Dipped Ice Cream US$6.00

Pints
Black Cherry Pint US$9.00
Simply sweet black cherry ice cream with boat-loads of whole black cherries.
Raspberry Rhapsody Pint US$9.00
Black raspberry ice cream swirled with a sweet raspberry ripple and heavenly chocolate covered raspberry cups.
Peanut Butter Cup Pint US$9.00
Smooth chocolate ice cream brimming with mouthwatering peanut butter ripples and rich peanut butter cups.
Cookie Dough Pint US$9.00
Sweet cookie-flavored ice cream with heaps of soft chocolate chip cookie dough chunks and tons of rich chocolate chips.
Strawberry Pint US$9.00
Award-winning and deliciously fresh strawberry ice cream loaded to the brim with real, whole strawberries.
Birthday Cake Pint US$9.00
Forgo your fork and grab your spoon! Pop the lid to reveal rainbow bursts of fun confetti sprinkles packed into rich yellow cake ice cream. This party in a pint is topped off with festive swirls of blue buttercream frosting and bursts of colorful confetti sprinkles.
Mint Avalanche Pint US$9.00
A mint lover’s paradise! Fresh mint ice cream loaded with Andes® Candies and Grasshopper® cookies spun off with a chocolate fudge swirl.
Blueberry Cheesecake Pint US$9.00
Delectably smooth cheesecake ice cream topped off with a tangy blueberry ripple and soft cheesecake chunks.
Cashews And Caramel Pint - NO SUGAR ADDED US$9.00
Creamy, no-sugar-added vanilla ice cream rippled with gooey, sugar-free caramel and loaded with real cashews.
Zanzibar Chocolate Pint US$9.00
All-natural and award-winning chocolate ice cream made with three kinds of cocoa for a rich, fudge brownie taste.
Old Fashioned Vanilla Pint US$9.00
An award-winning and all-natural classic vanilla ice cream made with Wisconsin cream, cane sugar and pure vanilla.
Exhausted Parent Pint US$9.00
Bourbon-spiked espresso ice cream swirled with bittersweet chocolate chunks.
Ultimate Oreo Pint US$9.00
Scrumptious Oreo crumb ice cream packed with boat-loads of whole Oreo cookies.
This $@&! Just Got Serious Pint US$9.00
Award-winning, smooth salted caramel ice cream brimming with rich sea salt fudge and salted cashews.
Super Human Pint US$9.00
Meet your new kryptonite… Cherry, Blue Moon and Vanilla ice creams combine forces to bring you one super scoop!
Butter Pecan Pint US$9.00
Buttery pecan ice cream with boat-loads of crispy, lightly roasted and salted pecans.
Munchie Madness Pint US$9.00
Sweet cake batter ice cream swirled with a salted caramel ripple and brimming with Oreos, M&M pieces and peanut butter cups.
Cappuccino Break Pint US$9.00
Crisp coffee-infused ice cream churned with chocolate-covered toffee and candy-coated almonds.
Yippee Skippee Pint US$9.00
Creamy peanut butter ice cream loaded with salted caramel ripples, soft brownie chunks and crispy chocolate-covered pretzels.

Cakes
Peanut Butter Cup 8'’ Cake US$44.99
Name a better duo than chocolate and peanut butter. We’ll wait... Peanut Butter Cup ice cream is layered with chocolate cake and chocolate soft serve to make the perfect combination. With a Reese’s Pieces border and topped with chunks of Reese’s, this cake is drizzled with peanut butter sauce for an extra dose of delicious.
Soft Serve 8" Cake US$39.99
Our classic vanilla and chocolate soft serve stuffed with chocolate crunchies and fudge, topped with caramel sauce, chocolate candies, and rainbow sprinkles.
Death By Chocolate 8'' Cake US$44.99
One word: Zanzibar. Our darkest chocolate Zanzibar ice cream is paired with chocolate cake, chocolate soft serve, chocolate sauce, brownie bites, chocolate crunchies, Oreos, and Kit Kat to make the most chocolatey confection in the ice cream cake industry.
Birthday Cake 8'’ Cake US$44.99
Nothing screams Happy Birthday like Birthday Cake ice cream! This vibrant blue ice cream base compliments the yellow cake and vanilla soft serve perfectly. Covered in our colorful rainbow sprinkles, this classic choice is perfect whether you’re turning 6 or 60!
Ultimate Oreo 8'’ Cake US$41.99
Cookies n’ Cream just got a new meaning with our Ultimate Oreo cake. Ultimate Oreo ice cream, chocolate cake, and vanilla soft serve make up this masterpiece with the border covered in fudge, Oreo cookies, and brownie bites.
Peanut Brittle Crunch Coat 8" Cake US$39.99
Just like the classic crunch coat ice cream cone, this cake is made with layers of vanilla and chocolate soft-serve, stuffed with chocolate crunchies and hot fudge, and covered in a delicious peanut brittle crunch coat.
Munchie Madness 8'' Cake US$44.99
Indulge in Munchie Madness hand-dipped ice cream layered with a yellow cake and vanilla soft-serve ice cream. Smothered in our vanilla buttercream and topped with M&M’s, Oreos, Reese’s, and caramel sauce, this cake is a crowd-pleasing favorite for everyone.

Specialties
Fluffernutter Barrel (Full) US$9.99
Vanilla soft serve covered in peanut butter sauce, marshmallow creme, Reese's Pieces, peanut butter cups, pretzels, and whipped cream.
Bourbon Blueberry Waffle Barrel (Full) US$9.99
Vanilla soft serve layered with blueberry preserves, waffle cone pieces, bourbon-infused caramel sauce and maple syrup, topped with whipped cream.
Banana Pudding Barrel (Full) US$9.99
Vanilla ice cream layered with banana cream pudding, and crunchy Nilla Wafers, topped with freshly sliced bananas and whipped cream.
Giant Banana Split US$9.99
3 mountains of vanilla ice cream on a bed of waffle cone pieces, pineapple, strawberry, hot fudge, loads of whipped cream, cherries, chocolate sauce, and peanuts.
Turtle Sundae Barrel (Full) US$9.99
Vanilla soft serve, sweet cream caramel, rich hot fudge, and salted pecans.
Strawberry Oreo Cheesecake Barrel (Full) US$9.99
Vanilla soft serve layered with strawberry sauce, cheesecake pieces, crushed Oreos, marshmallow sauce, and whipped cream.
Nutty Buddy Sundae US$8.49
Yippee Skippee ice cream. peanut butter & marshmallow sauce, whipped cream, & a Nutty Buddy Bar. Served in a a waffle bowl.
Chunky Monkey Barrel (Full) US$9.99
Vanilla ice cream layered with rich peanut butter sauce, freshly sliced bananas, and Monkey Munch. Topped with whipped cream.

Stampedes
Large Stampede US$7.99
Vanilla, chocolate, or twist ice cream blended with your choice of inclusion.
Small Stampede US$5.99
Vanilla, chocolate, or twist ice cream blended with your choice of inclusion.
Medium Stampede US$6.99
Vanilla, chocolate, or twist ice cream blended with your choice of inclusion.

Milkshakes
Large Milkshake US$9.99
Small Milkshake US$6.49
Medium Milkshake US$8.49

Cowboy Creamery Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Toilet

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
Family friendly
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Cowboy Creamery Photos

Cowboy Creamery Location

Cowboy Creamery

Ohio Geauga County Middlefield North State Avenue

14895 N State Ave d, Middlefield, OH 44062, USA

Cowboy Creamery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 228 user reviews.

to choosepricesice cream cakebirthdaysundaeflavorgumball machinetablebarrelthe oatmeal

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Did a Google search to find ice cream on our way home. Fun atmosphere. Delicious ice cream with a lot of flavors. Great service.
July 18 · Crystal Siembida Boggs
First visitExtremely clean with pleasant and very polite staff. Great selection of novelty items as well as different flavors of ice cream and drinks. Definitely plan on a return visit
April 18 · John Caracci
Ice cream parlor that has some of the best imaginative flavor combos I've seen. Large indoor seating area with long counter showcasing a wide variety of flavors. Our 4 pack sampler was more than expected. The Zanzibar Chocolate, Burbon Pecan Pie, Mint Avalanche and This S*** Just Got Serious were all flavors I'd order again. Coming back.
July 31 · Jim Calvert
We have been here a few times. The ice cream is very good, and they have a good variation of different flavors. The advent calendar they did in December was a perfect way to figure out what flavors we liked best. They are always changing things up here and have something new all the time. The ice cream cakes are much better than DQ.
June 03 · Todd Esola-Gyongyosi
We rented the ice cream truck for. Work event , I got the dates confused . I called in a panic the day of when I realized what I had done! Nicole (the owner) made several calls and got staff to bring the truck and make it happen ! I couldn’t be more appreciative of her . The ice cream was amazing ! We have two more events booked with them and will continue to use them every year ! So impressed!!!!!! Great to have such GREAT customer service !
June 05 · Kelly Bennett