Diamonds Ice Cream

For those in the Columbus, Ohio, area seeking a truly distinctive and adventurous ice cream experience, Diamonds Ice Cream at Bethel Sawmill Center offers a vibrant taste of Mexico. This establishment stands out not only for its unique ice cream flavors that push the boundaries of traditional American palates but also for its extensive array of authentic Mexican snacks and beverages. It's a place where every visit promises a culinary exploration, inviting locals to delve into a world of new and exciting sweet and savory sensations. This article will guide you through the flavorful journey that awaits at Diamonds Ice Cream, highlighting its special offerings, convenient location, and what makes it a must-try for Ohio residents.

Diamonds Ice Cream is celebrated for its authentic Mexican ice cream, which often boasts a richer, denser texture and bolder flavors compared to typical American ice cream. Customers rave about unique creations like the "blackberry cream cheese" and "queso ice cream," which are "must-try" items for adventurous foodies. These flavors showcase a creative approach to frozen desserts, incorporating savory and tangy notes that truly set them apart. Beyond the creamy delights, Diamonds Ice Cream also offers an impressive selection of Mexican snacks, fruit drinks, and specialty items, ensuring a comprehensive culinary experience.

The atmosphere at Diamonds Ice Cream is designed to transport patrons to a vibrant cultural setting, notably featuring a "real size mannequin" of the iconic Frida Kahlo, making for fun photo opportunities. While some aspects of the experience, such as consistency in certain snack preparations, may vary, the core appeal lies in its unique menu and the opportunity to explore flavors rarely found in conventional ice cream shops. For Columbus locals eager to try something new and exciting, Diamonds Ice Cream promises an unforgettable adventure for the taste buds.

Diamonds Ice Cream is conveniently located at 5461 Bethel Sawmill Center, Columbus, OH 43235, USA. This address places it within a well-known commercial center in the northwest part of Columbus. The Bethel Sawmill Center is a bustling area with various shops and businesses, making Diamonds Ice Cream easily accessible for residents across Columbus, Dublin, and Worthington. Its presence in a strip mall environment suggests ample parking availability, generally alleviating concerns about finding a spot during a visit.

While its exterior might be unassuming, the location on Bethel Sawmill Center ensures high visibility and straightforward navigation for patrons. The area is served by well-established road networks, making it a quick trip from many surrounding neighborhoods. Being situated within a larger shopping complex means visitors can combine a treat at Diamonds Ice Cream with other errands or activities in the area. Despite some anecdotal feedback regarding specific menu items or service experiences, the overall accessibility of this location contributes to its popularity as a go-to spot for unique Mexican treats.

• Mexican Ice Cream: A wide variety of unique and traditional Mexican ice cream flavors, including popular choices like blackberry cream cheese and queso ice cream. Other common Mexican ice cream flavors often include mango, tamarind, chile, corn, avocado, rose petal, and various fruit-based sorbets (nieves).
• Sorbet (Helados de Agua): Offers refreshing fruit-based sorbets.
• Milk Popsicles (Paletas de Leche): Popsicles with a milk base and various ingredients.
• Mangonadas: A popular Mexican frozen treat made with mango slices, mango sherbet, lime, chamoy, and spicy tajín seasoning.
• Esquite: Corn in a cup, typically prepared with mayonnaise, cheese, chili powder, and lime.
• Elote Loco: Corn on the cob with various toppings like ruffles, cheese, sour cream, Valentina sauce, chamoy, chili powder, and mayo.
• Fresh Strawberries & Cream (Fresas con Crema): Natural strawberries served with homemade sweet cream, available fresh or frozen.
• Bionico: A Mexican fruit salad featuring papaya, melon, apples, pears, strawberries, and bananas, topped with sweet cream specialty and other toppings.
• Horchata: Traditional cinnamon-flavored rice milk, also available in strawberry flavor.
• Fruit Drinks: Natural fruit drinks in flavors such as guava, lemon & chia seeds, mixed fruit, egg nog, coconut cream, and passion fruit.
• "Bolsitas Locas": A variety of Mexican snack bags with ingredients like chicharrón, cueritos (pork rinds), cabbage, cucumber, jicama, peanuts, tamarind candy, lime, chamoy, and Valentina sauce.
• Other Mexican Snacks: Including Pepino Loco (stuffed cucumber) and Papas Locas (various toppings on potato chips/pork rinds).
• Milk Shakes: Customizable milkshakes blended with your choice of ice cream flavors.
• Banana Splits: Traditional banana splits with three scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, and toppings.

• Authentic Mexican Ice Cream: Specializes in unique and traditional Mexican ice cream flavors not commonly found in standard ice cream shops.
• Diverse Menu of Mexican Snacks: Offers a wide array of savory and sweet Mexican treats beyond ice cream, providing a comprehensive cultural experience.
• Unique Flavor Combinations: Features adventurous ice cream flavors like blackberry cream cheese and queso, appealing to customers seeking new tastes.
• Cultural Ambiance: Creates a distinctive atmosphere, notably featuring a "real size mannequin" of Frida Kahlo, adding to its unique charm.
• Variety of Frozen Treats: Provides a range of options including scoops, sorbets, paletas (popsicles), mangonadas, and other fruit-based desserts.
• Refreshing Beverages: Offers a selection of traditional Mexican drinks like horchata and various natural fruit juices.
• Popular Among Locals: Recognized as a unique local owned Mexican ice cream shop within the Columbus community.
• Affordable Pricing: While specific pricing was not universally lauded for all items, ice cream scoops are generally considered to be reasonably priced.

Address: 5461 Bethel Sawmill Center, Columbus, OH 43235, USA

Phone: (614) 718-2980

Mobile Phone: +1 614-718-2980

Diamonds Ice Cream is an exciting and highly suitable destination for locals in the Ohio region, particularly those in Columbus and its surrounding areas, who are eager to explore unique and authentic flavors. What truly sets this establishment apart is its specialization in Mexican ice cream, offering a vibrant departure from the typical dessert scene. For Ohioans accustomed to conventional ice cream, Diamonds provides an opportunity to discover bold, innovative flavors like blackberry cream cheese and queso, along with the refreshing tang of mangonadas and a variety of fruit-based paletas. This commitment to traditional Mexican recipes ensures a genuine and memorable culinary adventure.

Beyond the ice cream, the extensive selection of Mexican snacks and beverages makes Diamonds a comprehensive cultural experience. Whether you're craving a savory esquite, an adventurous Bolsitas Locas, or a refreshing horchata, the menu offers a diverse range of items that cater to both new explorers and those familiar with Mexican cuisine. The engaging atmosphere, complete with the iconic Frida Kahlo mannequin, adds to the fun and unique character of the shop, making it more than just a place to grab a treat, but a destination in itself.

While some isolated feedback points to inconsistencies with certain non-ice cream items or service, the overwhelming positive sentiment regarding the ice cream itself and the uniqueness of the offerings firmly establishes Diamonds Ice Cream as a valuable local gem. Its convenient location in the Bethel Sawmill Center ensures easy access for many residents. For any Ohioan looking to expand their culinary horizons and indulge in truly distinctive and delicious frozen desserts and snacks, Diamonds Ice Cream is a must-visit, offering a slice of Mexican flavor right here in Columbus.

Diamonds Ice Cream

5461 Bethel Sawmill Center, Columbus, OH 43235, USA