Ernie's Ice Cream

In the heart of Mahwah, New Jersey, there's an ice cream shop that holds a special place in the hearts of many locals: Ernie's Ice Cream. This establishment has long been a go-to spot for those who appreciate high-quality, homemade hard ice cream. For residents in the area, Ernie's is more than just a place to get a scoop; it's a tradition, a destination for a simple pleasure that feels both classic and comforting. The shop has built a reputation for its wide selection of flavors and its commitment to making ice cream that is both delicious and memorable. It's the kind of place where a single favorite flavor can keep a customer coming back for years, a testament to the quality and consistency that Ernie's strives to maintain.

The story of Ernie's is one of dedicated craftsmanship and a loyal customer base. The reviews highlight a strong divide in customer experiences, but a key takeaway is the consistent praise for its homemade hard ice cream. One long-time customer, for example, declares it their "favorite place to go for homemade hard ice cream" and enthusiastically recommends the "peanut butter pie" flavor, calling it "SO delicious!" This kind of endorsement from a loyal patron who has been "coming here for many years" speaks volumes about the quality of the product and the lasting impression it leaves. The menu, which includes an extensive list of hard and soft ice cream flavors, as well as a variety of sundaes and other treats, shows a commitment to offering something for everyone. This includes a wide array of soft-serve flavors that have also been recognized as some of the best in the state.

While one customer had a poor experience with slow service, a small portion size, and what they felt was a subpar flavor, this serves as a reminder that individual visits can vary. However, the many positive reviews, particularly those focused on the homemade hard ice cream and specific standout flavors, indicate that the shop's core strength lies in its product quality. The shop is a staple in the community, and its reputation for a wide variety of flavors, including unique options like toasted coconut and French Toast Maple, keeps customers coming back to try new things. For those of us living in Mahwah, Ernie's is a place that feels like a true local institution, a reliable spot for a truly special treat.

Ernie's Ice Cream is conveniently located at 78 Franklin Turnpike in Mahwah, New Jersey. This location is easily accessible for residents of Mahwah and surrounding areas in northern New Jersey. Its position on Franklin Turnpike makes it a straightforward destination to find, whether you're coming from a local neighborhood or traveling along the main thoroughfare. The shop is situated in an area that is well-integrated into the community's daily life, making it a familiar landmark for many.

The accessibility of the shop is a significant advantage for locals. It's a convenient stop for a treat after dinner, a day of running errands, or a local activity. The location on a main road ensures that it's easy to reach by car, and there is typically parking available nearby. This ease of access makes a spontaneous trip for ice cream a simple and stress-free affair. The shop is also known to be a seasonal destination, with its opening each spring serving as a sign of warmer weather to come, a tradition that adds to its local charm and appeal.

Ernie's Ice Cream offers a wide and impressive variety of services and products that cater to all kinds of dessert lovers. Their menu is carefully crafted to provide both classic favorites and unique, house-made creations.

• Homemade Hard Ice Cream: The cornerstone of Ernie's reputation is its homemade hard ice cream. With a wide selection of flavors, including the fan-favorite Peanut Butter Pie, customers can always find a new or classic flavor to enjoy.
• Soft Serve Ice Cream: Ernie's is also well-known for its soft serve, with a variety of flavors and options. They have been recognized multiple times for having some of the best soft serve in the state.
• Sundaes, Shakes, and Floats: Beyond scoops, the shop offers a full menu of classic ice cream parlor treats, including custom sundaes, rich milkshakes, and refreshing floats.
• Dairy-Free, Nonfat, and No Sugar Added Options: Ernie's shows a commitment to inclusivity by offering a variety of dietary options, including dairy-free hard and soft ice cream as well as nonfat and no-sugar-added flavors.
• Take-Home Treats: The shop offers hand-packed pints and quarts of both hard and soft ice cream, allowing customers to take their favorite flavors home to enjoy later.

What truly makes Ernie's Ice Cream a cherished part of the Mahwah community are its unique features and highlights that contribute to its local appeal.

• Homemade Quality: The dedication to making hard ice cream in-house is a major draw for customers who appreciate artisanal quality. Flavors like Peanut Butter Pie and Toasted Coconut are frequently mentioned as highlights.
• Extensive Soft Serve Selection: The wide range of soft serve flavors, including options like dulce de leche and Key Lime Pie, provides a unique offering that sets them apart from typical ice cream shops.
• Seasonal Tradition: As a seasonal business, Ernie's opening each year is a welcomed event that marks the start of spring and summer for many locals. This tradition fosters a strong sense of community and anticipation.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Despite a negative review, the shop is a staple for families. It’s the kind of place where locals can gather to enjoy a treat, and the wide variety of options ensures there's something for every member of the family.

To experience the delicious homemade hard ice cream and extensive variety of flavors, you can visit Ernie's Ice Cream at:

Address: 78 Franklin Turnpike, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA

Phone: (201) 252-8373

For residents of Mahwah and the surrounding New Jersey area, Ernie's Ice Cream is a perfect local spot. Its suitability comes from its commitment to homemade quality, its wide variety of options for all tastes and dietary needs, and its status as a beloved seasonal tradition. While not every customer's experience will be perfect, the lasting loyalty and high praise for specific homemade flavors speak to the shop's strengths. By choosing to visit Ernie's, we are not just satisfying a craving; we are supporting a local business that has been a part of our community for many years. It's a place where we can count on finding a classic, delicious treat that feels both special and familiar, making it a treasured gem in our local landscape.

Ernie's Ice Cream

78 Franklin Turnpike, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA