Extreme Creamery Introduce
In the heart of Lancaster, Ohio, lies Extreme Creamery, an establishment that has gained attention for its visually stunning and highly creative "extreme shakes." This local shop has carved out a niche for itself by moving beyond traditional ice cream offerings to provide over-the-top, photogenic desserts that are designed to impress. These aren't your average milkshakes; they are extravagant creations piled high with an array of toppings, from full slices of cheesecake to cookies and more. This focus on uniqueness and visual appeal makes Extreme Creamery a popular destination for those looking for a dessert that doubles as a shareable experience on social media. The business's commitment to creating these elaborate treats is a major part of its identity and appeal in the local community.
The concept of the "extreme shake" is a significant draw for many customers. These shakes are not just about the flavor but also about the presentation. They are crafted to be a feast for the eyes, often featuring a base milkshake topped with a seemingly impossible amount of additional dessert items. This style of dessert has become a trend, and Extreme Creamery has capitalized on it to become a local hotspot for those seeking something out of the ordinary. However, this focus on extreme aesthetics and quantity can lead to a mixed experience for customers. Some may appreciate the visual spectacle and the fun of the over-the-top design, while others might find that the quality of the individual components, like the cheesecake or the cookie, may not meet their expectations. The experience of enjoying these shakes can be highly subjective, depending on what a customer values most: the spectacle or the taste.
Customer service and the overall environment of a business are just as important as the products it sells. Online reviews about Extreme Creamery highlight a number of different experiences that a potential customer might encounter. While the concept of the shakes is intriguing, some patrons have expressed concerns regarding the cleanliness and service. The reviews mention a "filthy" and "sticky" environment, as well as a lack of professionalism from the young staff. These are crucial points for any business, as a clean and welcoming space is a fundamental part of a positive customer experience. The reviews suggest that while the workers may be present, there may be a lack of attention to detail and customer care. This feedback is valuable for a local audience, as it helps them set expectations and make informed decisions about where to spend their money. It's a reminder that a unique product needs to be backed by a strong foundation of sanitation and professional service to truly succeed in the long term.
Ultimately, Extreme Creamery is a business with a very specific identity. It is a place for those who are seeking a novel, visually impressive dessert experience. The business's success and reputation in Lancaster, Ohio, are built on the spectacle of its shakes. For a local audience, it is an establishment that offers a different kind of treat, one that is highly focused on presentation. The variety of experiences shared by past patrons shows a business that has both clear strengths in its unique product line and areas for potential improvement in its operations and customer care. It's a place that stands out, but its full value is determined by each individual customer's priorities.
Location and Accessibility
Extreme Creamery is located at 726 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130, USA. This address places it on a significant thoroughfare in Lancaster, making it a highly visible and accessible destination for residents and visitors. Memorial Drive is a key road that runs through the city, which means the shop is convenient for a quick stop while running errands or as a planned destination. The location's ease of access is a benefit for a business that relies on customer traffic. For a local audience, its address is likely familiar, and its presence on a main road makes it a known and recognizable spot. The physical location is a strong point for the business, as it is simple to find and get to from various parts of the city and surrounding areas.
Services Offered
Extreme Creamery's services are built around providing an extravagant dessert experience. While specific menu details might vary, the business is known for its creative and over-the-top offerings. The services offered include:
- "Extreme Shakes": The signature item, featuring a milkshake base with various toppings, full desserts, and a creative presentation. These shakes are designed for visual appeal and indulgence.
- Other Ice Cream Products: While the focus is on the extreme shakes, the business likely offers other traditional ice cream items such as sundaes, cones, and possibly rolled ice cream, as suggested by a different business with a similar name, which is a popular trend for its visual creation process.
- Desserts and Toppings: The shakes are often topped with other baked goods like slices of cheesecake and cookies, which may also be available as standalone items.
Features / Highlights
Extreme Creamery's unique approach to dessert has made it a memorable spot in Lancaster. While some features may be a point of contention for some customers, they are central to the business's identity. The key features and highlights include:
- Visually Unique Shakes: The "extreme shakes" are a major highlight, known for their elaborate presentation and unique combinations. They are designed to be "great for pictures" and provide a distinct dessert experience.
- Indulgent Toppings: The generous use of toppings and inclusion of full dessert items like cheesecake slices is a notable feature, appealing to those who desire a truly decadent treat.
- Focus on a Niche Product: The business has successfully created a specialized product that separates it from more traditional ice cream shops, attracting a specific customer base interested in trendy desserts.
- Convenient Location: Its presence on N Memorial Dr makes it an accessible and well-known spot in Lancaster, which is a significant advantage for business.
Contact Information
Address: 726 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130, USA
Phone: (740) 785-5080
Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals
Extreme Creamery is suitable for a segment of the Lancaster, Ohio, community that values novelty and visual appeal in their food. For locals looking for a unique and indulgent dessert experience, the business offers a product that is unlike anything else in the area. The extreme shakes are perfect for a special occasion, a celebration, or simply as a fun treat to share with friends and family. Its convenient location on a main road makes it an easy stop. However, it is also a business that a local consumer will approach with certain expectations, particularly regarding sanitation and service, as highlighted by some of the online feedback. For the right customer, someone who is interested in the spectacle and the unique product, Extreme Creamery provides a memorable, if not always perfect, experience. It has established itself as a go-to spot for a specific type of dessert, and for that reason, it holds a distinct place in the local food scene of Lancaster, Ohio.
Extreme Creamery Details
Service options
- Dine-in
Extreme Creamery Photos










Extreme Creamery Location
Extreme Creamery
726 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130, USA
Extreme Creamery Reviews
shakesrolled ice creampricecheesecakepresentationstrawberrycleanflavorbuildingbowl
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1The extreme shakes are very unique and look great for pictures, but I was disturbed by how filthy the place was.I took a picture of the sticky looking, crumb covered counter that people's desserts are prepared on... that cheesecake slice they plopped there was part of my order.You'd think with their prices that they would be a bit more sanitary and professional. They do not care about their image, so it makes me wonder if they care about food safety.If they present themselves like that to the public, how horrifying is it behind the counter?I would've taken more pictures but I didnt want people to think I was taking pictures of them. Literally every table was sticky and covered in crumbs.There were many teenage workers behind the counter. Many of them were standing around when I walked in. At least 1 of them could have cared enough to clean.I personally will not come back to this place. I can pay less for higher quality elsewhere.
May 24 · AJ GonzalezSuper overpriced and they don’t even taste good. The cheesecake was horrible and my shake barely had any flavor. The cookies were dry, cookie dough tasted good but the shake tasted like fake chocolate syrup. Definitely won’t be returning. $26 for these little shakes is ridiculous. They aren’t that “special”.
September 12 · Liberty SchultzThe extreme shakes have extravagant, artistic, and tasty toppings, but the milkshakes themselves were bland and very underwhelming - not at all worth $13. The rolled ice cream tasted great, but it was either cold and hard, making it difficult to eat, or runny/melted. There was no in between. This is a cool place to visit once, but we would not go back.
May 24 · John BanghoffDelicious ice cream and helpful employees. This is not a quick ice cream place unless you're wanting a scoop of normal icecream. They pour the cream on the chillers right in front of you and you get to watch as it all comes together right in front of your eyes. Such a cool experience and delicious as well! Will definitely go back.
January 19 · FrankyGreat local place that serves not only the current fancy rolled ice cream craze but also the traditional hand dipped favorites in cones or cups or as a yummy sundae. If you are willing to spend a little more they have some pretty great looking extreme shakes that could easily be shared with a loved one! ❤️
February 17 · Jeanette Price
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

213 S Broad St, Lancaster, OH 43130, USA

1804 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130, USA

601 W Market St, Baltimore, OH 43105, USA

51 Angle St, Bremen, OH 43107, USA

26776 US-33, Rockbridge, OH 43149, USA

7520 Hill Rd, Canal Winchester, OH 43110, USA

2887 Canal Dr, Millersport, OH 43046, USA

20 S High St, Canal Winchester, OH 43110, USA

192 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147, USA

30713 Lake Logan Rd, Logan, OH 43138, USA

4595 Walnut Rd unit p, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008, USA

5171 N Bank Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





