Famous Cookie Creamery

For many New Jersey residents, a walk along the iconic Ocean City Boardwalk is a time-honored tradition, and the quest for the perfect sweet treat is a huge part of the experience. Among the many options available, Famous Cookie Creamery stands out with a unique concept that combines two beloved Philadelphia institutions: The Famous 4th Street Cookie Company and Bassetts Ice Cream. This partnership brings a distinctive offering to the Jersey Shore, centering on the highly customizable ice cream cookie sandwich. The idea is simple yet brilliant: you choose two of their fresh, delicious cookies and pair them with your favorite flavor of Bassetts Ice Cream to create a one-of-a-kind dessert. This creative approach to a classic treat has made the shop a point of interest for locals and visitors alike who are looking for something a little different from the typical boardwalk fare. The shop, which opened on the Ocean City Boardwalk in 2022, has quickly become a part of the local landscape, offering a memorable and engaging culinary experience. The brand's heritage adds a layer of authenticity, as both the cookies and the ice cream have a long-standing reputation for quality. For those who appreciate a fresh take on a classic dessert, Famous Cookie Creamery is a must-visit spot that provides a fun and delicious way to indulge a sweet tooth while enjoying the seaside atmosphere.

While the concept is undeniably appealing, it’s also important for locals to have a complete picture based on real customer feedback. The reviews for Famous Cookie Creamery offer a mixed but insightful perspective. One customer was enthusiastic about their experience, particularly praising a "Blueberry muffin cookie" and the "Raspberry Truffle as the ice cream." They also highlighted the positive aspects of the staff, noting that the employees were "fast and helpful." This review points to the great potential of the shop's offerings and the quality of their regular products and service. However, another customer had a very different experience, specifically with the gluten-free options and the vanilla ice cream. This individual described the gluten-free cookies as "dry and have a weird taste" and the vanilla ice cream as "not great" and lacking flavor. They felt "very dissapointed" with their order, even while acknowledging that the price for an ice cream sandwich at around $8 was not excessively expensive. This feedback is particularly crucial for local residents who may have dietary restrictions or specific taste preferences, as it provides a valuable heads-up that not all menu items may meet the same high standard. It's a reminder that while some combinations are a hit, others may fall short of expectations. This honest, factual overview is essential for a local audience to make an informed decision and to know what to expect before they visit. It’s also important to note that the shop does offer other gluten-free cookies, but they are made in a facility that also processes dough that contains gluten, which is a key detail for those with severe sensitivities.

The shop’s business model, which centers on the collaboration of two iconic brands, is a major feature. The Famous 4th Street Cookie Company has been a Philadelphia institution since 1978, and Bassetts Ice Cream, established in 1861, is America’s oldest ice cream company. This rich history and reputation for quality give the Famous Cookie Creamery a solid foundation. Customers who love either of these brands, or both, are naturally drawn to the shop. The ability to mix and match different cookie and ice cream flavors, such as a blueberry muffin cookie with raspberry truffle ice cream, is a huge draw for those who enjoy customizing their desserts. The menu also includes other options like cookie sundaes, milkshakes, and individual cookies and scoops of ice cream. This variety ensures that even if you’re not in the mood for the signature sandwich, there are plenty of other delicious treats to choose from. The focus on fresh cookies and a wide range of ice cream flavors provides a sense of fun and discovery. The positive review that mentioned "fast and helpful" employees suggests that the service is often a highlight, contributing to a pleasant and efficient experience, which is particularly important on a busy boardwalk. The shop provides a nostalgic yet fresh option for dessert lovers, and its unique concept helps it carve out a special place in the crowded Ocean City Boardwalk landscape.

Famous Cookie Creamery is located at 1242 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA. Its address places it on a prominent stretch of the iconic Ocean City Boardwalk, making it highly accessible to locals and visitors alike. The boardwalk is a bustling pedestrian thoroughfare, and the shop's central location ensures that it's a convenient and easy stop for anyone walking by. Whether you're coming from a day at the beach, a nearby hotel, or another boardwalk attraction, Famous Cookie Creamery is just a short stroll away. The address, at 12th Street and the Boardwalk, is a familiar landmark for many who know the area. As the boardwalk is a pedestrian-only zone, accessibility is all about convenience for those on foot. There are numerous public parking lots and street parking options in the surrounding area for those who are driving to Ocean City. This allows for a seamless transition from a car to the boardwalk, where you can then easily find the shop. Its location is ideal for attracting a wide range of customers, from families with children to couples on a date night. The shop's presence on this high-traffic path ensures that it's a visible and appealing option for anyone looking for a sweet treat to enjoy with a view of the ocean. This prime location is a key part of the experience, as you can grab your dessert and continue your walk, or find a bench to sit and savor your creation.

Famous Cookie Creamery's menu is built around its unique collaboration, offering a variety of ways to enjoy their products. Here are the services and items they typically provide:

• Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches: Their signature item. Customers can choose from a selection of cookies from The Famous 4th Street Cookie Company and pair them with a scoop of Bassetts Ice Cream.
• Individual Cookies: For those who just want a cookie, they offer their famous cookies on their own, including options like the "Blueberry muffin cookie."
• Ice Cream Scoops: Customers can also get Bassetts Ice Cream in a cup or cone, with a variety of flavors to choose from.
• Milkshakes: They offer specialty milkshakes that combine their cookies and ice cream into a blended drinkable dessert.
• Cookie Sundaes: A classic sundae with a unique twist, featuring their cookies as part of the topping or base.

The highlights of Famous Cookie Creamery are what make it a memorable part of the Ocean City experience. These features are why it has become a go-to spot for many locals:

• Signature Ice Cream Sandwich: The ability to customize an ice cream sandwich with a variety of cookie and ice cream combinations is a major draw and a unique selling point on the boardwalk.
• Collaboration of Iconic Brands: The partnership between The Famous 4th Street Cookie Company and Bassetts Ice Cream brings a sense of quality, history, and brand recognition that customers trust.
• Fast and Helpful Service: As noted in customer reviews, the staff is often praised for being efficient and friendly, which makes for a pleasant and quick experience.
• Variety of Choices: The menu extends beyond the cookie sandwich to include individual cookies, sundaes, and milkshakes, ensuring that there is a delicious option for everyone in a family or group.
• Central Boardwalk Location: The prime location at 1242 Boardwalk makes it a convenient and visible spot to grab a treat, perfect for anyone enjoying a day on the shore.

For more information or to contact the store, here is the provided contact information:

Address:
1242 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

Phone:
(609) 938-0898

In conclusion, Famous Cookie Creamery is a great fit for New Jersey locals because it offers a creative and high-quality dessert experience that is rooted in trusted local brands. It’s a place where the simple pleasure of an ice cream cone is elevated by the unique combination of two iconic Philadelphia companies. The ability to customize an ice cream cookie sandwich with a wide variety of flavors makes it a fun and engaging destination for families and friends. For a local audience, the shop provides a fresh and exciting alternative to the traditional boardwalk fare while still delivering on quality. While it is important for customers to be mindful of individual reviews, particularly regarding gluten-free options, the overall concept and positive feedback on the regular menu and staff suggest a business that is committed to providing a great experience. The prime location on the Ocean City Boardwalk ensures that it is always a convenient and accessible stop. Famous Cookie Creamery is more than just a place to get dessert; it’s a destination that celebrates the delicious bond between cookies and ice cream, and it has quickly become a cherished part of the local scene. For any New Jersey resident looking for a sweet and memorable treat, this shop is a must-try that perfectly captures the spirit of a fun-filled day at the shore.

Famous Cookie Creamery

1242 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA