Fetter's Dairy Isle Introduce
Welcome to our local guide, written especially for the residents of Ohio, to help you uncover the sweet charm of Fetter's Dairy Isle. Nestled in the heart of Newark, this ice cream shop has been a fixture in the community, serving up classic treats and creating fond memories for generations. When you're looking for a local spot that offers a wide range of frozen delights and classic American snack foods, Fetter's Dairy Isle is a name that often comes to mind for many Ohioans. This article is your comprehensive guide to what you can expect, from their menu offerings to their location and overall community feel.
In the world of local businesses, especially in a tight-knit community like Newark, places like Fetter's Dairy Isle are more than just a place to grab a cone. They are meeting spots, destinations for a family outing, and a simple pleasure on a warm day. The atmosphere is typically casual and welcoming, a place where you can relax and enjoy a simple, sweet treat. The goal of this article is to give you an insider's look at this well-known establishment, providing factual and helpful information to enhance your next visit. We’ll delve into the specifics of what they offer, where to find them, and what makes them a part of the local fabric.
The history of Fetter's Dairy Isle is a story intertwined with the history of Newark itself. Over the years, countless locals have made it a tradition to stop by, whether it's for a celebratory cone after a little league game, a casual date night dessert, or just a spontaneous craving. This kind of local legacy is what gives a business its true character. We understand that residents of Ohio value authenticity and community, and Fetter's Dairy Isle embodies these qualities. By providing a clear and honest overview, we aim to help you make an informed decision and perhaps even discover a new favorite spot right in your own backyard.
Our journey into Fetter's Dairy Isle begins with the essentials: its location and how to get there. For anyone living in or visiting Newark, knowing the lay of the land is key. This article is crafted with you in mind, a local user who needs practical and straightforward information. We’ll ensure you have all the details you need to easily find your way to this local gem.
The appeal of a local ice cream shop is often found in its simplicity and familiarity. It’s not about flashy marketing or complicated menus; it's about good food and a friendly face. This is the essence of what Fetter's Dairy Isle aims to provide. As you read on, you'll learn about the variety of services and products available, from classic ice cream flavors to a range of other menu items. We'll also highlight some key features that set this place apart, giving you a complete picture of what to expect.
By the end of this article, you should feel well-equipped with the knowledge you need to plan your next visit to Fetter's Dairy Isle. Whether you're a long-time customer or a newcomer to the area, we hope this guide serves as a helpful resource, celebrating a local business that contributes to the unique character of Newark, Ohio.
Location and Accessibility
Fetter's Dairy Isle is conveniently situated at 471 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055, USA. This location places it within easy reach for many residents of Newark and the surrounding Licking County area. The shop is located on a main thoroughfare, making it simple to find for anyone familiar with the city's street layout. For those traveling by car, the location typically offers accessible parking options, which is a significant plus for families and groups. The ease of access from various parts of Newark makes it a practical choice for a quick stop after work or a planned outing on the weekend.
Navigating to the shop from different parts of the city is straightforward. If you're coming from the downtown area, a short drive will get you there. For residents in the western or northern parts of Newark, W Church Street is a key route, making the drive to Fetter's Dairy Isle a breeze. This central yet easily accessible location is one of the reasons it has remained a popular choice for so long. The presence on a well-trafficked road also means it’s a visible and well-known landmark, making it easy to spot for newcomers.
The accessibility of Fetter's Dairy Isle extends beyond just its physical location. The business is often set up to handle customers efficiently, which is important during peak hours in the summer. Whether you're walking up to a window to place your order or pulling into a designated parking spot, the process is designed to be as smooth as possible. This focus on customer convenience is a hallmark of many successful local businesses. The easy-to-find address and practical access points make it a go-to destination for locals who appreciate efficiency and simplicity.
Services Offered
Fetter's Dairy Isle offers a variety of services and products that extend beyond just traditional ice cream. Their menu is designed to cater to a range of tastes and preferences, ensuring there's something for everyone in the family. While the primary focus is on frozen treats, they also have a selection of food items, which makes it a great spot for a quick snack or a light meal.
- A wide variety of ice cream flavors, including both classic and seasonal options.
- Soft-serve ice cream, a popular choice for its creamy texture.
- Milkshakes and malts, blended to order with a choice of flavors.
- Sundaes, featuring a variety of toppings like hot fudge, caramel, and nuts.
- Classic American snack foods, such as fries and cheese sticks, for those looking for a savory option.
- Take-home options, including pints and quarts, to enjoy your favorite treats at home.
Features and Highlights
What makes Fetter's Dairy Isle a staple in the Newark community are its unique features and highlights. These are the elements that create a loyal customer base and keep people coming back year after year. It's these small details that define the local experience.
- A long-standing local presence, with a history that is deeply rooted in the Newark community.
- A nostalgic, classic ice cream shop feel that harkens back to a simpler time.
- A menu that includes both sweet and savory items, providing more options for a quick stop.
- Family-friendly environment, making it an ideal destination for a treat with children.
- Service is often quick, which is perfect for those on the go or with a limited time for their treat.
Contact Information
For those who need to get in touch or simply want to know the address, here is the essential contact information for Fetter's Dairy Isle.
Address: 471 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055, USA
Phone: (740) 328-8713
Conclusion: Why This Place is Suitable for Locals
In conclusion, Fetter's Dairy Isle is more than just an ice cream shop for the residents of Ohio, and specifically, for the people of Newark. It is a local institution that has earned its place in the community through years of serving up sweet treats and providing a familiar, comfortable place for families and friends to gather. For locals, the suitability of Fetter's Dairy Isle lies in several key factors. First, its convenient location on a main road makes it an easy and practical stop for anyone in the area. Whether you're heading home from work, running errands, or just looking for a simple outing, its accessibility is a major benefit.
The menu, which offers a mix of classic ice cream, soft serve, milkshakes, and savory snacks, ensures that there is always something to satisfy every craving. This variety is crucial for a family-friendly establishment, where different members of the group might have different preferences. The ability to grab a quick snack along with your dessert makes it a more versatile destination than a single-item shop. Furthermore, the option to take home pints and quarts means you can enjoy the same great taste from the comfort of your own home, a service that locals appreciate.
What truly makes Fetter's Dairy Isle suitable for locals is its nostalgic and authentic feel. In a world of large, impersonal chains, a local spot with a history and character stands out. It’s a place where many residents have shared childhood memories and continue to create new ones. The sense of community and the familiarity of a local business are invaluable. It’s a place where you're not just a customer but a neighbor. By supporting businesses like Fetter's Dairy Isle, locals are also investing in the character and charm of their own community. It's a sweet tradition that we hope will continue for many years to come.
Fetter's Dairy Isle Vibe
Add Ons
- Extras US$0.00
- Fixins US$0.00
- Sauce US$0.00
Ice Cream Cones
- Soft Serve Ice Cream US$0.00
- Dole Whip Ice Cream US$0.00
- Hard Dip Ice Cream US$0.00
- Pint US$4.50
- Quart US$6.50
Sundaes.Parfaits & More
- Twister US$5.25
- Kids Twister US$4.00
- Shakes US$0.00
- Banana Split US$6.00
- Turtle US$4.50
- Parfait US$4.50
- Reese Sundae US$5.00
- Brownie Sundae US$5.50
- Almond Delight US$5.00
- Hot Fudge Cake US$5.50
- Spanish Parfait US$5.00
- Oreo Disaster US$5.50
- Pecan Royal US$5.00
- Soda US$4.50
- Smoothie US$4.50
- Ice Burg US$4.50
- Float US$5.00
- Sundae US$0.00
- Slushy US$0.00
Novelties
- Chipwich US$4.00
- Circus Slice US$3.00
- Choc.Covered Banana US$2.00
- Doggy Sundae US$1.50
Soft Drinks
- Kids Soft Drinks US$2.00
- Regular Soft Drinks US$3.00
- Large Soft Drinks US$3.50
Kids Meal
- Hot Dog Kids Meal US$6.00
- Corn Dog Kids Meal US$6.00
- Grilled Cheese Kids Meal US$6.00
Wings & More
- Wing Dings US$6.00
- Boneless Wings 6 Pc US$6.00
- Boneless Wings 12 Pc US$10.00
Sides
- Fries US$0.00
- Mushrooms US$4.30
- Cauliflower US$4.30
- Onion Rings US$4.30
- Cheese Sticks US$4.30
- Poppers US$4.30
- Mac Bites US$4.30
- Munchers US$4.30
- Fried Pickles US$4.40
- Funnel Fries US$4.30
- Loaded Funnel Fries US$6.00
- Pasta Salad US$3.00
- Mac Salad US$3.00
- 6pc Bonless Wings US$6.00
- 12pc Boneless Wings US$10.00
- Coleslaw US$2.50
- Chips US$1.00
- Soup US$4.00
Burgers
- Hamburger US$5.50
- Double Burger US$7.50
- Mushroom Swiss Burger US$6.60
- BBQ Onion Burger US$6.60
- Cheese Stick Burger US$6.60
- Pizza Burger US$6.00
Sandwiches
- Hot Dog US$2.75
- Ft.Long Hotdog US$3.75
- Coney US$4.00
- Ft.Long Coney US$5.00
- Shrd Chicken US$4.40
- Chicken Dog US$5.00
- Ft.Long Chicken Dog US$6.00
- Sloppy Joe US$4.40
- BBQ Beef US$4.40
- Corn Dog US$3.00
- Fish Sandwich US$5.50
- Grilled Cheese US$3.50
- BLT US$4.50
- Steak Sandwich US$5.00
UNCATEGORIZED
- Edible Straw US$1.00
- Sucker US$0.50
- Airhead US$0.80
- Ring Pop US$1.00
Fetter's Dairy Isle Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeaway
Popular for
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Seating
- Table service
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Trending
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Fetter's Dairy Isle Photos










Fetter's Dairy Isle Location
Fetter's Dairy Isle Reviews
pricesfriesfudgeconey dogsmushroomsvanillasundaelunchpeanut buttertraining
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Bought multiple orders of fries and cheese sticks. A couple containers of fries weren't filled all the way up, and some weren't even close to being cooked all the way. We specifically asked how many cheese sticks come in an single order, bc we needed a specific amount, but they shorted us on a couple sticks.My wife's strawberry ice cream was barely pink, and tasted like vanilla. She had to add her own crushed strawberries to it at home to make edible. Rising prices, lower quality.
March 02 · Kelley FlanaganYou better teach the girls the difference between a quart and a pint container. They charged me what they said was a quart in a pint container..i then asked for the larger container which I know was a quart. So they charged me pint price for a container that was a quart container. Im 72 years old and know the difference. Between a pint and a quart.They argued with me that the smaller pint container was a quart. Your losing money on the real quart size if they concider that a pint. Needs some training on them unless the price on the pint one is being charged as a quart then they are cheating the customer. Either way. I wasnt gonna argue with them but dont they know the difference between the size of a pint and a quart? Icecream was good tho. Been here before and didnt have a problem. Just descrepancy over this container thing. It really bugged me.
July 20 · Lorie D KellyWorst food and service I’ve ever had at a Dairy Isle!!!!! My husband ordered a blt sandwich and the bacon was almost raw. He ordered a vanilla malt and got a chocolate shake! I ordered the fish sandwich and it was almost burnt and had nothing on it and our fries were terrible.I ordered a hot fudge cake and then when we asked where it was they said that they don’t have those. The place was filthy inside
May 17 · Kara ChristyNot a good experience. Place is looking run down and the service was questionable. Worst banana split I’ve had. No whip cream or nuts placed on top. Barely any strawberry’s as well. We got two that were supposed to be made the same. Asked for extra strawberries because we don’t like pineapple. The girls working were running out of items. The one girl told the other “stop selling those we don’t have stuff to make them”. Then tried to wash the items in the hand sink. Nothing was said prior to paying that they had run out of certain items to make a banana split if so we could have easily ordered something else.
April 19 · Kelsie MichelleI thought this place was absolutely amazing. Their funnel fries are unbelievably awesome! I ended up getting a banana split along with them and could not eat the entire banana split. I would highly recommend this place not only for their food but their staff is extremely friendly. If you're looking for a place to sit down this is not the place for you. If you're looking for a place to grab some food and sit in your car or take it back to wherever you came from you found it.
May 07 · Adam W Nelson
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

17 W Main St, Newark, OH 43055, USA

29 N 3rd St, Newark, OH 43055, USA

919 N 21st St, Newark, OH 43055, USA

303 S 30th St, Heath, OH 43056, USA

527 E Main St, Newark, OH 43055, USA

1872 Cherry Valley Rd, Newark, OH 43055, USA

226 E Broadway, Granville, OH 43023, USA

103 W Main St, Hebron, OH 43025, USA

5171 N Bank Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008, USA

4595 Walnut Rd unit p, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008, USA

14900 OH-13, Thornville, OH 43076, USA

14547 Township Rd 1061 Unit C, Thornville, OH 43076, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





