Fortunes Ice Cream

For those living in or visiting the Hudson Valley, Fortune's Ice Cream in Tivoli, New York, is a destination that truly stands out. It's not just a place to grab a cone; it's an experience built on a passion for creating exceptional, small-batch ice cream. The story of Fortune's is rooted in the local community, started by two Bard College alumni, Brian Ackley and Lisa Farjam, who met in Tivoli as students. After moving away and finding success in other fields, they returned to the town they loved with a desire to create a place for people to gather and enjoy something special. They saw a need for a local scoop shop offering fresh, seasonal, and locally made ice cream, and when a space on Broadway became available, they took it as a sign. That leap of faith, based on Brian's talent for making "really good ice cream," became their "fortune."

What sets Fortune's Ice Cream apart is its deep commitment to quality and local sourcing. The ice cream is made from scratch right in the shop, using dairy from farms right here in the Hudson Valley. This dedication to fresh, local ingredients is evident in every scoop. The flavors are a testament to their creativity and a celebration of the seasons. Instead of a static menu, Fortune's offers a rotating selection of flavors, often using fruits and berries sourced from nearby farms like Montgomery Fruit Farm and Rose Hill Farm. This ensures that customers can always find something new and intriguing to try, with unique combinations that you won't find anywhere else.

The quality of their product has earned them rave reviews, with one customer declaring it "Some of the best ice cream I've ever had." Another review praised the specific flavors, noting that the peach ice cream "tasted like fresh peaches" and the "basil blackberry crumble was intriguing and addicting," with a perfect balance of strong basil, salty crumble, and just a little sweetness. This attention to detail in flavor profiles is a major highlight. For those looking for options, the shop also provides a range of vegan and dairy-free flavors, such as a dark chocolate and a tahini- and oat-milk based honeycomb, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a delicious treat.

Beyond the ice cream, the atmosphere of the shop itself is a major draw. A reviewer noted that the building is "super cute with indoor and outdoor seating," which creates a welcoming environment for customers to relax and savor their dessert. This is the kind of place where locals linger and enjoy the simple pleasure of a good scoop. While a pint may be "pricier than what most are used to," as one customer noted, the same reviewer also said that "once you taste, you will come to understand" the value. This reinforces the idea that for Fortune's, the focus is on a premium, high-quality product, not a mass-produced one. The shop's seasonal closing, mentioned by a customer stocking up for winter, is a well-known feature that adds to its special charm, making a visit feel like a cherished part of the warm-weather season.

Fortune's Ice Cream is perfectly situated at 55 Broadway, Tivoli, NY 12583, USA. This location places it right on the main street of the charming and artistic village of Tivoli in Dutchess County. The shop is easily accessible by car, and its central location makes it a natural destination for both residents of Tivoli and those visiting from surrounding Hudson Valley towns like Red Hook and Rhinebeck.

While Broadway is a bustling street, the welcoming storefront and available seating, both indoors and out, make it a comfortable and easy stop. Its presence in a walkable village means it's a great place to stop for a treat while exploring the local shops and galleries. The accessibility and charming setting are key to its success as a community hub.

Fortune's Ice Cream provides a range of services designed to deliver their exceptional products to a broad audience.

• In-Store Scooping: The primary service is serving their freshly made, scratch-made ice cream in cups and cones at their Tivoli shop. They offer a rotating selection of flavors and toppings.
• Take-Home Pints: Customers can purchase pints of their favorite flavors to stock up and enjoy at home. This is especially popular during the season, as a way to enjoy Fortune's ice cream in the colder months when the shop is closed.
• Custom Orders and Catering: Fortune's has a process for booking catering or events through their website, indicating they can provide their delicious ice cream for special occasions, such as parties and gatherings.
• Espresso Drinks and Affogatos: The shop also offers coffee-based treats. Customers can enjoy an affogato, which is a scoop of vanilla ice cream with hot espresso poured over it, or other espresso drinks, with vegan options available.

Several key features make Fortune's Ice Cream a beloved and highly-regarded destination.

• Scratch-Made with Local Dairy: The ice cream is made in-house using high-quality Hudson Valley dairy, ensuring a rich, creamy texture and a delicious taste.
• Seasonal and Inventive Flavors: The menu changes regularly, with flavors often inspired by local produce. This commitment to seasonality results in unique and exciting flavors like peach, basil blackberry crumble, and more, which keeps customers coming back to see what's new.
• Highly Acclaimed: Fortune's has been recognized for its quality, with accolades such as being named "Best Ice Cream in New York" by Food & Wine magazine, a significant achievement that speaks to their excellence.
• Inclusive Options: The shop offers a variety of vegan and dairy-free options, including sorbets and unique flavors made with oat-milk and tahini, ensuring that people with different dietary needs can also enjoy their treats.
• Charming Atmosphere: The "super cute" building and available indoor and outdoor seating create a cozy and welcoming environment, perfect for enjoying a scoop with friends or family.

For those in Tivoli and the surrounding New York region, here is the essential contact information for Fortune's Ice Cream:

Address: 55 Broadway, Tivoli, NY 12583, USA

Phone: (845) 757-2899

This information is useful for checking hours, inquiring about specific flavors, or learning more about their catering options.

Fortune's Ice Cream is a perfect fit for the local New York community, especially for those in the Hudson Valley. It's a business founded by locals who love the area, and that passion is reflected in every aspect of the shop. From the commitment to using fresh, local dairy and seasonal ingredients to the creative, small-batch flavors, Fortune's offers a product that is both high-quality and deeply connected to the region. While it may be a premium experience, the taste and craftsmanship are worth the price, as attested by loyal customers.

The shop itself serves as a gathering place, a social hub where people can enjoy a delicious dessert and the company of others. The friendly atmosphere and the availability of seating, both inside and out, make it a great spot for a simple treat or a relaxed afternoon. For New Yorkers looking for an authentic, local experience that celebrates the best of the Hudson Valley, Fortune's Ice Cream is a must-visit destination that promises not just a scoop of ice cream, but a scoop of local pride and happiness. Its seasonal nature only adds to its charm, making each visit a special and cherished part of the year.

Fortunes Ice Cream

55 Broadway, Tivoli, NY 12583, USA