Heavenly Creamery

Heavenly Creamery, located in the charming town of Conneaut, Ohio, is a beloved local institution that has quickly become a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. This unique ice cream shop is more than just a place to get a scoop; it's a from-scratch creamery that prides itself on using quality ingredients to create a truly exceptional product. The journey of its owners, Joe and Christine, began with a simple plan for an ice cream truck and evolved into saving a historic church, transforming it into the inviting space it is today. The result is a shop that not only serves delicious treats but also provides a warm, community-focused atmosphere that feels both unique and welcoming. Locals know that a line out the door isn't a sign of a long wait, but rather a testament to the quality and popularity of this Conneaut gem.

The creamery's commitment to quality is evident in its "Angelic" line of French ice creams and sorbets, which are made with real vanilla and no shortcuts. They are constantly innovating, with a rotation of over 500 different flavor creations to keep the menu fresh and exciting. This dedication to craft and quality has earned Heavenly Creamery a loyal following and a reputation for being one of the best ice cream spots in the region. It's a place that perfectly blends small-town charm with a high-end, artisan approach to dessert, making it an ideal spot for a family outing, a quick treat, or a special indulgence.

The physical location of Heavenly Creamery is one of its most distinctive features. Situated at 264 Sandusky St, the shop is housed within a beautifully repurposed century-old church. This unique setting provides an incredible backdrop for enjoying your dessert, with ample indoor seating that is both spacious and cozy. The owners took great pride in saving the old church and maintaining its historical integrity, allowing customers to appreciate the building's charm while enjoying their treats. The location is easily accessible for Conneaut residents and those traveling through the area.

In addition to the inviting indoor space, Heavenly Creamery also offers a small outdoor seating area. This provides a quaint spot for those who prefer to enjoy their ice cream al fresco, especially on a beautiful Ohio day. The central location in Conneaut makes it a convenient stop for locals and a delightful discovery for visitors. While it can get busy during peak hours, the friendly and efficient staff ensure that the flow of customers is well-managed, so you can get your order without an excessive wait.

Services Offered

• Extensive Ice Cream Selection: Heavenly Creamery offers a huge variety of ice cream flavors, with a constant rotation of over 500 unique creations. They specialize in from-scratch "Angelic" French ice creams and sorbets, with options for everyone, including gluten-free, dairy-free, and keto-friendly desserts.

• Soft Serve and Sundaes: In addition to their hard-serve offerings, they also serve excellent soft serve, as well as a wide range of sundaes, including classic banana splits. The menu is full of options to satisfy any craving.

• Specialty Items: Beyond traditional ice cream, customers can find unique items like Texas Sheet Cake and other desserts.

• Ample Indoor and Outdoor Seating: The shop provides both spacious indoor seating within the historic church building and a smaller outdoor seating area. This gives customers the option to dine in or enjoy their treat outside.

• Dietary Accommodations: Heavenly Creamery is committed to being inclusive, offering a variety of options for those with dietary restrictions. They have gluten-free, dairy-free, and keto-friendly ice creams, ensuring that almost everyone can find something they love.

Features / Highlights

• Unique Location in a Historic Church: The shop's setting in a beautifully restored century-old church is a major draw. This creates a memorable and distinctive atmosphere that is both cozy and visually stunning.

• From-Scratch, Premium Ingredients: Heavenly Creamery prides itself on using real, high-quality ingredients with no artificial colors, flavors, or additives. This commitment to quality is evident in the delicious taste of their products.

• Friendly and Welcoming Staff: The staff is consistently praised for being nice, friendly, and efficient. They treat every customer like a friend, creating a warm and inviting environment.

• Rotating Flavors and Extensive Options: With a rotation of over 500 flavors, there's always something new to try. This keeps the experience fresh for regular customers and makes every visit exciting.

• Support for Local Community: Heavenly Creamery is not just a business; it's an active member of the community. They donate ice cream to local charity events and even open their doors to trick-or-treaters with warm hot chocolate during the off-season.

• Inclusive Menu: The presence of gluten-free, dairy-free, and keto options ensures that a wide range of customers can enjoy a treat without worry.

Contact Information

Address: 264 Sandusky St, Conneaut, OH 44030, USA

Phone: (440) 593-6080

For the people of Ohio, and especially Conneaut, Heavenly Creamery is a true treasure. It’s a local business that goes above and beyond, not just in its products but in its commitment to the community. The shop provides a divine experience that is both delicious and comforting, whether you're looking for a classic soft serve or an adventurous new flavor. The dedication to using high-quality, from-scratch ingredients ensures that every scoop is a testament to their passion. Furthermore, the unique setting in a historic church adds a layer of charm that makes a visit to Heavenly Creamery more than just a trip for ice cream—it's a memorable outing. This is the kind of local business that makes a town feel like home, and its popularity is well-deserved. For anyone in the Conneaut area looking for excellent ice cream, a welcoming atmosphere, and a place that truly cares about its community, Heavenly Creamery is a must-visit spot.

Heavenly Creamery

264 Sandusky St, Conneaut, OH 44030, USA