Hibbard's Custard

For those of us living in Western New York, especially in and around the charming village of Lewiston, there are certain local institutions that are simply legendary. Hibbard's Custard is undeniably one of them. For decades, this iconic establishment has been serving up its signature frozen custard, a treat so rich and creamy that it has earned a dedicated following and a reputation as a must-visit spot for anyone with a sweet tooth in the region. This isn't just an ice cream shop; it's a taste of local history and a beloved summer tradition.

Hibbard's Custard prides itself on its distinct product: real frozen custard. What sets custard apart from traditional ice cream is its higher butterfat content and the inclusion of egg yolks, resulting in a denser, smoother, and incredibly creamy texture with less air. This difference is precisely what customers rave about, describing it as "rich and creamy." While one customer noted a perceived small size for the price, the consensus among loyal patrons is that the quality and unique experience of Hibbard's custard justify its value. They offer a "large selection of flavors," ranging from their daily "core four" to exciting "special" combinations, ensuring there's always something new and delicious to try. This commitment to quality and variety is why Hibbard's has maintained its iconic status for over 85 years, truly defining the "creamy goodness" they serve.

Hibbard's Custard is conveniently located at 105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY 14092, USA. Portage Road is a well-known artery in Lewiston, making it a straightforward destination for those traveling from various points in Western New York. Its presence in the heart of Lewiston contributes to its local charm, allowing visitors to easily combine a trip to Hibbard's with other activities in the historic village.

Accessibility to Hibbard's is generally good for those arriving by car. While specific details about the size of their parking lot are not provided in the reviews, its location on a main road in a small town usually implies readily available parking, either directly on-site or nearby street parking. It's a drive-up style establishment that caters well to those looking for a quick, delicious treat on the go. The ease of access makes it a popular spot for both planned excursions and spontaneous stops during warmer months. As a seasonal business, its opening for the spring and summer is always eagerly anticipated by New Yorkers in the region.

Hibbard's Custard focuses primarily on its signature frozen custard, offering it in a variety of forms and flavors to suit every preference. Their services include:

• Frozen Custard Scoops: Available in cones (original, homemade waffle, or dipped waffle) or dishes, in single, double, or kiddie sizes.
• Core Four Flavors: Daily staples include Vanilla, Chocolate, Black Raspberry, and Pistachio custard.
• Rotating Specialty Flavors: Beyond the core four, they offer a "large selection of flavors" that change regularly, such as Cookie Monster, Strawberry, Amaretto, Banana, Butter Pecan, Butterscotch, Caramel Pretzel, Blueberry Cheesecake, Cherry Cheesecake, Strawberry Cheesecake, Chocolate Almond, and Chocolate Brownie. They are known for exciting "special" combinations that bring "pure pleasure to your taste buds."
• Perry's Ice Cream: For those who may prefer traditional hard ice cream over custard, Hibbard's also serves popular Perry's Ice Cream flavors.
• Milkshakes: Hand-spun milkshakes are available in various flavors, including Vanilla, Chocolate, Banana, and Strawberry, with the option to make it a malt.
• Flurries: Frozen custard blended with various toppings like Cookies and Crème, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Fudge Brownie, Oreo, M&M Mini's, Nutter Butter, Reese's Cup, and Snickers.
• Sundaes: Classic sundaes with a wide range of toppings and sauces including Hot Fudge, Chocolate, Strawberry, Marshmallow, Peanut Butter, Raspberry, Pineapple, Caramel, Butterscotch, and a variety of candies and nuts.
• Take-Home Novelties: They offer unique pre-made frozen treats such as Chip Wheels, Oreo Wheels, Nutty Dips, Frozen Bananas, and their Famous Turtle.
• Customizable Pies: Customers can order Peanut Butter Cup, Oreo, or Turtle pies, or create their own.

Hibbard's Custard boasts several distinctive features and highlights that solidify its legendary status in Western New York. These elements are what make it a perennial favorite for locals:

• Exceptional Frozen Custard Quality: The defining feature is their rich, creamy, and consistently high-quality frozen custard, made essentially the same way since 1939. It's known for being dense and smooth, with less air than traditional ice cream.
• Extensive and Rotating Flavor Selection: With core daily flavors and a wide array of rotating specialties, there's always something new to entice customers. This keeps the experience fresh and encourages repeat visits to try new combinations.
• Long-Standing Local Institution: Having been in business for over 85 years, Hibbard's is a deeply rooted part of Western New York's history and culture, representing consistency and tradition.
• Commitment to Consistency: As one review notes, "It's always the same product. You have butter pecan today, you have butter pecan in September – it's gonna be the same, because we're very consistent in how we make it." This ensures a reliable and satisfying experience every time.
• Variety of Offerings: Beyond just scoops, the availability of milkshakes, flurries, sundaes, pies, and take-home novelties caters to a wide range of preferences and occasions.
• Option for Hard Ice Cream: The inclusion of Perry's Ice Cream flavors provides an alternative for those who may prefer traditional hard ice cream.

For those in New York eager to experience the legendary frozen custard at Hibbard's, here is their contact information:

Address: 105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY 14092, USA

Phone: (716) 754-4218

Mobile Phone: +1 716-754-4218

Hibbard's Custard is a seasonal business, typically opening around the Friday before Presidents Day and closing the Sunday before Thanksgiving. During their operating season, their hours are generally Monday-Sunday: 11 AM - 8 PM, extending to 9 PM on Friday and Saturday. Given the current date (August 2025), they should be fully open. However, it's always advisable to confirm their exact operating hours, especially closer to the beginning or end of their season, by calling ahead or checking their official website for any updates or special holiday hours.

In conclusion, Hibbard's Custard is an absolute must-visit for locals in the New York region, particularly those in Western New York and the Niagara Frontier. Its reputation as a legendary establishment is well-earned, built on over 85 years of serving consistently rich, creamy, and incredibly delicious frozen custard. For New Yorkers, a trip to Hibbard's is more than just getting a dessert; it's a cherished summer tradition, a taste of nostalgia, and an experience that truly "doesn't get better."

Despite one comment about scoop size for the price, the overwhelming sentiment emphasizes the exceptional quality and the "large selection of flavors," ensuring there's always a perfect scoop (or shake, or sundae) waiting. The presence of both classic flavors like black cherry and exciting "special" combinations keeps patrons coming back to explore. Its convenient location in Lewiston makes it an easy stop, and the promise of a consistently high-quality product means every visit is a reliable source of "pure pleasure to your taste buds." For anyone in New York seeking the ultimate frozen custard experience, Hibbard's Custard is truly the place to be, a foundational piece of our local culinary landscape.

Hibbard's Custard

105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY 14092, USA