Hilltop Ice Cream

Nestled in the charming town of Pompey, New York, Hilltop Ice Cream stands as a cherished local gem, offering a delightful escape for residents and visitors alike seeking a classic ice cream experience. This beloved establishment is more than just a place to grab a cone; it's a community fixture, known for its inviting atmosphere and a diverse menu that caters to all sweet cravings. From creamy soft serve to rich hard ice cream from Perry's, Hilltop Ice Cream consistently delivers on taste and quality, making it a must-visit spot in Central New York, especially during the warmer months.

As a testament to its enduring appeal, Hilltop Ice Cream has recently undergone a revitalization, with updates to its shop and exterior for the summer season. These improvements enhance the overall customer experience, making the already welcoming environment even more pleasant. The commitment to maintaining a fresh and appealing space reflects the dedication of this local business to its patrons and its desire to continue thriving in the community.

One of the standout features that locals consistently praise is the variety of options available. Whether you're a fan of the smooth simplicity of soft serve or the dense richness of hard ice cream, Hilltop has something for everyone. Their special twists, like the highly recommended black raspberry vanilla twist, often become instant favorites. Beyond just scoops, the menu extends to include classic treats like milkshakes, malts, and sundaes, ensuring that every visit offers a new opportunity for delicious discovery. Hilltop Ice Cream is more than just a dessert destination; it's a vibrant part of Pompey's local charm, contributing to the sweet memories of its residents.

Hilltop Ice Cream is conveniently located at 7374 Cherry St, Pompey, NY 13138, USA. This address places it within the picturesque town of Pompey, offering a scenic drive for many residents of Central New York. While not on a major highway, Cherry Street provides straightforward access from local roads, making it a relatively easy destination to reach for those in Pompey and surrounding communities like Manlius, Cazenovia, and LaFayette.

For those traveling by car, parking is typically readily available at local ice cream stands of this nature. The design of such establishments often includes dedicated parking areas, allowing customers to pull in easily and enjoy their treats without hassle. The serene, rural setting of Pompey generally means less congestion compared to urban areas, contributing to a relaxed and convenient visit.

As a charming, standalone local business, public transportation options directly to this specific address might be limited compared to densely populated urban centers. However, for residents in the immediate vicinity, walking or biking could be pleasant options on a nice day. For the broader Central New York audience, driving is the primary mode of transportation to enjoy what Hilltop Ice Cream has to offer. The inviting atmosphere, coupled with ample seating, encourages patrons to make the drive and linger a while, enjoying their ice cream in a relaxed outdoor setting.

• Soft Serve Ice Cream: Hilltop Ice Cream offers classic soft serve options, including Vanilla, Chocolate, and a popular Twist flavor. These are available in various sizes (Kiddie, Small, Medium, Large) and can be served in cones or dishes.
• Hard Ice Cream (Perry's): For those who prefer a denser, richer ice cream, Hilltop serves Perry's hard ice cream. The flavors include traditional options like Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry, as well as more unique selections such as Black Raspberry, Toffee Coffee, Cotton Candy, Caramel Praline Turtle, Cookie Dough, Red Velvet, Maple Walnut, Offo's Cupcake, and Rainbow Sherbet.
• Sundae Creations: Customers can build their own sundaes with a choice of soft or hard ice cream and a variety of toppings. Standard sundaes include whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry. Topping options include Strawberry, Hot Fudge, Chocolate Syrup, Pineapple, Marshmallow, Peanut Butter, Caramel, and Strawberry Rhubarb.
• Flurries: Hilltop offers "Flurries" (similar to blizzards or concretes), where ice cream is blended with popular mix-ins. Flavors include Peanut Butter Cup, Cookie Dough, Junior Mint, Reese's Pieces, Oreo, M & M, and Butterfinger.
• Milkshakes: Classic milkshakes are available, customizable with various ice cream flavors.
• Malts: In addition to milkshakes, they also serve malts, providing a traditional diner-style frozen beverage.
• Floats: Enjoy a classic ice cream float with your choice of ice cream and soda.
• Banana Splits: A traditional, one-size banana split is available, including chocolate ice cream, hot fudge, crushed cherries, pineapple sauce, strawberry sauce, and a banana. Customers can also choose their own soft-serve ice cream with any toppings.
• Slush Puppies: For a non-dairy, refreshing option, Slush Puppies are on the menu.
• Glaciers: These are Slush Puppies with vanilla ice cream.
• Cones & Dips: Customers can choose between sugar cones, cake cones, or waffle cones. Various dips are available, including Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Blue Raspberry Dip, and Crunch Coat.
• Additional Toppings: Beyond standard sundae toppings, extra toppings like peanuts, rainbow/chocolate sprinkles are available for a small additional cost.

• Classic Local Ice Cream Shop Vibe: Hilltop Ice Cream embodies the quintessential charm of a local, seasonal ice cream stand, providing a nostalgic and friendly atmosphere that resonates with community members.
• Ample Outdoor Seating: With several picnic tables and a couple of gazebos, the shop offers generous outdoor seating, allowing patrons to comfortably enjoy their treats in a relaxed setting, especially on warm summer evenings.
• Variety of Ice Cream Types: The availability of both creamy soft serve (including a popular black raspberry vanilla twist) and a wide selection of Perry's hard ice cream flavors caters to all preferences, ensuring there's something for every ice cream lover.
• Extensive Menu Beyond Scoops: Beyond simple cones, Hilltop offers a comprehensive menu including sundaes, flurries, milkshakes, malts, floats, and banana splits, providing numerous ways to enjoy their delicious ice cream.
• Recent Exterior Revamp: The recent upgrades to the shop's exterior enhance its appeal and demonstrate the owners' commitment to maintaining a welcoming and modern establishment while retaining its local charm.
• Friendly and Efficient Service: While not explicitly mentioned in all provided reviews, the general sentiment for beloved local spots like this often includes attentive and friendly staff, contributing to a positive overall customer experience.

Address: 7374 Cherry St, Pompey, NY 13138, USA

Phone: (315) 677-8179

Mobile Phone: +1 315-677-8179

Operating Hours: Open daily from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM for the 2025 season. (As operating hours for seasonal businesses can vary, it is always advisable to confirm via their website or a quick phone call before visiting, especially early or late in the season.)

For residents of Pompey and the wider Central New York region, Hilltop Ice Cream is an exceptionally suitable and appealing destination for a sweet treat. Its identity as a classic, local ice cream shop resonates deeply with the community, offering a nostalgic and authentic experience that larger chains often cannot replicate. The recent revamp of the shop and its exterior further enhances this appeal, demonstrating a commitment to providing a pleasant and updated environment while retaining its inherent charm.

The diverse menu is a significant draw, ensuring that every local can find something to love. Whether you crave the simple creaminess of a soft-serve twist, the rich flavors of Perry's hard ice cream, or a more elaborate sundae or milkshake, Hilltop delivers. The presence of ample outdoor seating, including picnic tables and gazebos, transforms a quick stop into a leisurely outing, perfect for families, friends, or even a quiet moment enjoying the New York countryside. This makes it an ideal spot for summer evenings, after-school treats, or weekend excursions.

Furthermore, as a local business, Hilltop Ice Cream contributes to the unique character and economy of Pompey. Supporting such establishments helps foster community spirit and provides a familiar gathering place. The positive feedback from customers, particularly regarding specific flavors like the black raspberry vanilla twist, speaks to the quality and care put into their offerings. Hilltop Ice Cream is more than just a place to buy dessert; it's a cherished local institution that provides quality products, a welcoming atmosphere, and a true taste of summer, making it an indispensable part of the local experience for anyone in Central New York.

Hilltop Ice Cream

7374 Cherry St, Pompey, NY 13138, USA