Holey Cream

holy cream nyc

In the dynamic and always-on landscape of New York City, the search for a truly unique and satisfying dessert can lead to some exciting discoveries. Holey Cream, located in the bustling Midtown West neighborhood, has carved out a niche for itself by offering a dessert concept that is as whimsical as it is indulgent: the donut ice cream sandwich. This isn't your average scoop shop; it's a creative destination where warm, freshly made donuts become the perfect canvas for a custom-built ice cream masterpiece. For New Yorkers looking for a fun, over-the-top sweet treat, especially after a Broadway show or for those late-night cravings, Holey Cream has long been a memorable stop.

Holey Cream gained its reputation by allowing customers to build their own donut ice cream sandwiches. The concept is simple yet brilliant: choose your donut, select your ice cream flavors, add frosting, and pile on the toppings. This level of customization has made it a popular spot for those who enjoy creating their ultimate dessert fantasy. Beyond the famous donut sandwiches, Holey Cream also offers a wide array of other sweets, including various ice cream flavors, sundaes, milkshakes, and a selection of baked goods like cookies, brownies, and cupcakes. While individual experiences may vary, as with any bustling New York establishment, the core appeal lies in its inventive menu and the sheer joy of customizing a truly decadent treat. It's designed to be a vibrant spot for indulgence, catering to a sweet tooth with an adventurous spirit.

This article aims to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Holey Cream, highlighting what makes it a local fixture and an intriguing option for anyone seeking a unique dessert experience in New York City. We will explore its convenient location and accessibility, the imaginative range of services and customizable options, and the distinct features that contribute to its well-known status. We'll also provide essential contact information, ensuring you can easily find your way to this iconic dessert spot. Prepare to discover why Holey Cream is a must-try for anyone seeking a "fever dream" of a sweet treat in the heart of NYC.

---

Holey Cream is strategically located at 791 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA. This address places it firmly in the vibrant Midtown West neighborhood, specifically in the Hell's Kitchen area. This is a dynamic part of Manhattan, known for its diverse dining scene, proximity to the Theater District, and a lively atmosphere that extends late into the night.

The accessibility of Holey Cream is one of its key advantages for New Yorkers. Its location on 9th Avenue makes it easily reachable by various forms of public transportation. It is within walking distance of several subway lines, including the A, C, E trains at Port Authority Bus Terminal (42nd Street), the N, Q, R, W trains at 49th Street, and the 1 train at 50th Street. This extensive subway network ensures that whether you're coming from a Broadway show, exploring Times Square, or simply craving a late-night treat, Holey Cream is conveniently accessible. The Hell's Kitchen neighborhood itself is highly walkable, making it easy for locals to integrate a visit into their evening plans. For those working or residing in Midtown, it offers a quick and indulgent escape. The presence of other eateries and entertainment venues in the vicinity means that a stop at Holey Cream can seamlessly complement a night out in the city. Its central position and late operating hours make it a popular destination for spontaneous dessert runs.

---

• Customizable Donut Ice Cream Sandwiches: Holey Cream's signature offering allows customers to build their own decadent donut ice cream sandwiches. This involves choosing a fresh donut (often plain or glazed), selecting multiple scoops of ice cream, adding a frosting flavor (like vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry), and then piling on various toppings.

• Wide Variety of Ice Cream Flavors: The shop typically offers a broad selection of ice cream flavors to choose from. While inventory may vary, especially at late hours, common flavors include Oreo, vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, cookie dough, peanut butter, and more adventurous options like S'mores or Birthday Cake.

• Frozen Yogurt and Sorbet Options: In addition to traditional ice cream, Holey Cream often provides fat-free frozen yogurt and various fruit sorbets (such as lemon, mango, and raspberry), catering to different preferences and dietary needs.

• Sundaes and Milkshakes: Customers can also enjoy classic sundaes, including Famous Hot Fudge Sundaes, Banana Splits, and customizable "Make Your Own Sundae" options with various toppings and sauces. A range of milkshakes, frappes, and ice cream sodas are also available.

• Baked Goods: Beyond frozen treats, Holey Cream offers a selection of fresh donuts (for standalone purchase), cookies (including jumbo sizes), brownies, and cupcakes, providing alternatives for those not seeking an ice cream-based dessert.

• Late-Night Operating Hours: Holey Cream is known for its extended operating hours, making it a popular destination for late-night dessert cravings, particularly for those leaving Broadway shows or working late in the area.

• Take-out and Delivery Services: The shop facilitates orders for pick-up and offers delivery services through popular platforms like Uber Eats and Grubhub, enhancing convenience for New Yorkers who prefer to enjoy their treats at home.

---

• Iconic Donut Ice Cream Sandwiches: The most significant highlight is their famous donut ice cream sandwich, offering a unique and highly customizable dessert experience that has become a staple for many looking for an over-the-top sweet treat in NYC.

• Late-Night Dessert Destination: Its extended operating hours, often until 1:30 AM or 2:00 AM on weekends, make it a premier spot for satisfying late-night cravings, especially after a Broadway show or evening activities in Midtown.

• Customization Options: The ability to select your donut, multiple ice cream flavors, frosting, and a wide array of toppings allows for endless customization, ensuring a personalized and unique dessert creation with every visit.

• Variety of Sweet Treats: Beyond the signature donut sandwiches, Holey Cream offers a comprehensive menu of ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, sundaes, milkshakes, and various baked goods (donuts, cookies, brownies, cupcakes), catering to a broad range of preferences.

• Central Midtown West Location: Situated in the lively Hell's Kitchen neighborhood, its proximity to Broadway theaters and other entertainment venues makes it a convenient and exciting dessert stop for both locals and tourists.

• Indulgent and Playful Concept: Holey Cream embraces a fun, indulgent, and somewhat "fever dream" aesthetic in its dessert creations, appealing to those seeking a whimsical and memorable sweet experience.

---

For those ready to dive into the unique dessert world of Holey Cream, here's how you can connect with them:

Address: 791 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA

Phone: (212) 247-8400

For the most current operating hours, specific flavor availability, or to inquire about delivery options, it is recommended to call the store directly or check their official website or popular food delivery platforms like Grubhub or Uber Eats, which often provide real-time menu and service updates.

---

Holey Cream, with its inventive concept and prime Midtown West location, holds a unique appeal that makes it particularly suitable for New Yorkers seeking a distinctive dessert experience. While individual experiences may vary, its core offerings align with several key aspects of the local lifestyle and preferences.

Firstly, its strategic location on 9th Avenue, in the heart of Hell's Kitchen, is a significant draw. For locals working in Midtown, catching a Broadway show, or simply exploring the vibrant dining scene, Holey Cream offers a convenient and accessible spot for a sweet indulgence. The ability to grab a decadent treat on the go, especially for late-night cravings after an evening out, perfectly fits the city's fast-paced, always-on culture. Its proximity to major transit hubs further solidifies its accessibility for New Yorkers from all boroughs.

Secondly, the highly customizable nature of its signature donut ice cream sandwiches resonates deeply with New Yorkers' desire for personalization and unique experiences. In a city where options abound, the ability to craft your own dessert from a choice of fresh donuts, ice cream flavors, frostings, and toppings provides a creative outlet and ensures that each visit can be a new adventure. This "build-your-own" model offers a sense of novelty and fun that appeals to those looking beyond standard ice cream cones.

While some reviews highlight inconsistencies in service or product availability, the fundamental concept of Holey Cream — combining two beloved comfort foods into one extravagant treat — holds a strong appeal. For many New Yorkers, a unique, over-the-top dessert is an experience in itself, often sought out for special occasions, late-night munchies, or just a delightful indulgence. The sheer scale and creativity of the offerings make it a memorable destination.

In conclusion, Holey Cream provides New Yorkers with a distinctive, customizable, and often over-the-top dessert experience. Its convenient Midtown West location, coupled with its focus on imaginative creations like the famous donut ice cream sandwich, makes it a noteworthy spot for locals seeking a fun and indulgent sweet escape in the heart of the city.

Holey Cream

791 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA