Island Creamery New Jersey: Your Atlantic City Ice Cream Destination

Island Creamery New Jersey Introduce

Welcome to Island Creamery New Jersey, a cherished local establishment that has become a go-to spot for ice cream lovers in Atlantic City and beyond. For residents of New Jersey, particularly those in and around Atlantic City, finding that perfect scoop of ice cream often leads them to this delightful creamery. Island Creamery New Jersey isn't just another ice cream shop; it's a community staple, renowned for its diverse flavor offerings, friendly service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes every visit a pleasant experience.

The charm of Island Creamery lies in its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the tantalizing aroma of sweet treats and the cheerful chatter of happy customers. It's a place where families gather, friends catch up, and individuals can simply enjoy a moment of sweet indulgence. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of Island Creamery New Jersey, highlighting why it's a must-visit destination for anyone craving exceptional ice cream in the Garden State.

Island Creamery New Jersey is conveniently located at 3901 Ventnor Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA. This prime location makes it easily accessible for both Atlantic City residents and those visiting the shore. Situated on Ventnor Avenue, the shop is a straightforward drive from various points in Atlantic City and neighboring communities. For those relying on public transportation, local bus routes often run along or near Ventnor Avenue, providing a convenient option for access. Ample parking is typically available in the vicinity, making it hassle-free for customers arriving by car. The shop's presence on a main thoroughfare ensures that it’s easy to find, whether you’re coming from the boardwalk, a local hotel, or a residential area. Its central location in Atlantic City means it’s a perfect stop after a day at the beach, a visit to the casinos, or simply an evening stroll. The accessibility of Island Creamery New Jersey contributes significantly to its popularity, making it a convenient treat for any occasion.

Services Offered:

Extensive selection of ice cream flavors: Island Creamery New Jersey prides itself on offering a vast array of flavors, ensuring there's something to satisfy every palate.
Cones and cups: Customers can choose to enjoy their ice cream in traditional cones or convenient cups.
Take-home options: While not explicitly stated, many ice cream shops offer pints or quarts for enjoyment at home.
Friendly and welcoming service: Customer reviews consistently highlight the pleasant and accommodating nature of the staff.
Nut allergy awareness: The staff is noted for clearly identifying nut-allergy friendly flavors, demonstrating a commitment to customer safety and comfort.

Features / Highlights:

Wide variety of flavors: One of the most frequently praised aspects of Island Creamery is the sheer number of flavors available. This extensive selection encourages repeat visits as customers explore new and exciting options.
Exceptional customer service: The staff at Island Creamery New Jersey are consistently described as "super nice" and welcoming. This friendly atmosphere contributes significantly to the overall positive experience.
Welcoming owners: Customers have specifically mentioned that the owners make them "feel at home the moment you walk in," fostering a sense of community and personal connection.
Unique and beloved flavors: Specific flavors like Rum Raisin and Coconut have garnered enthusiastic praise from regulars, indicating a commitment to unique and high-quality recipes.
Allergy awareness: For those with nut allergies, the clear identification of nut-allergy friendly flavors is a significant highlight, offering peace of mind and demonstrating responsible practices.
Memorable touches: The mention of an "ice cream bird" suggests charming and quirky elements that make the shop stand out and create a memorable experience.

Contact Information:

Address: 3901 Ventnor Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA

Phone: (609) 246-6279

Mobile Phone: +1 609-246-6279

For locals in New Jersey, Island Creamery New Jersey is more than just an ice cream shop; it's an integral part of the community experience in Atlantic City. Its suitability for locals stems from several key factors. Firstly, its convenient location on Ventnor Ave makes it an easily accessible destination for a quick treat or a planned family outing. Residents can pop in after work, on a weekend, or as a delightful stop during their daily errands without venturing far.

Secondly, the welcoming and personal atmosphere cultivated by the owners and staff resonates deeply with the local community. The reviews highlight how customers "feel at home," fostering a sense of belonging and familiarity that encourages repeat visits. This isn't just a transactional stop; it's a place where relationships are built, and regulars are recognized and appreciated. For New Jersey locals, this personal touch transforms a simple outing for ice cream into a more meaningful and enjoyable experience.

Furthermore, the diverse range of flavors ensures that every local, regardless of their specific taste preferences, will find something to love. From classic favorites to unique creations like Rum Raisin and Coconut, the extensive menu caters to a wide audience. This variety means families can easily satisfy everyone's cravings in one place, making it a convenient and appealing option for local households. The commitment to identifying nut-allergy friendly options also speaks to a thoughtful approach to customer care, which is highly valued by a local customer base concerned with health and safety.

Finally, the consistent positive feedback from real customers underscores Island Creamery New Jersey's reputation as a reliable and high-quality establishment. Locals can trust that they will consistently receive delicious ice cream and excellent service. In a vibrant community like Atlantic City, having a trusted local spot for treats is invaluable. Island Creamery New Jersey embodies the essence of a beloved local business, making it an ideal choice for anyone in the New Jersey area seeking a delightful and community-oriented ice cream experience. Its blend of quality products, friendly service, and convenient location firmly establishes it as a local favorite.

Island Creamery New Jersey Menu

Italian Water Ice
Philadelphia Italian Water Ice $4.25
Philadelphia Italian water ice is dairy free, gluten free, soy free and nut free.
Gelati Scooped Ice Cream $6.99
Choose a delicious Italian water ice flavor layered with your choice of a yummy ice cream.
Gelati Soft Serve $5.99
Layers of delicious Italian water ice and soft serve ice cream.

Hot Dogs
Hot Dog $2.75
All beef hot dog.
Pretzel- Jumbo $1.75
Hot Dog Box $9.95
The Hot Dog Lunch Box- 2 Nathans all beef hot dogs, small bag of Lays chips & a can of soda.

Banana Splits
Upside Down Scooped Banana Split Cup 20 Oz $12.99
32 oz. quart size upside down banana split packed with ice cream, strawberries, pineapple, chocolate syrup and sliced bananas topped with whipped cream & Cherry.
Scooped Banana Split Boat $9.95
Chocolate, vanilla bean and strawberry ice cream topped with strawberries, pineapple, chocolate syrup, bananas and whipped cream.
Soft Banana Split Boat $8.99
Soft serve ice cream topped with strawberries, pineapple, chocolate syrup, bananas and whipped cream.
32 Oz Quart Soft Serve Banana Split Cup $15.99
Soft Serve Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream layered with sliced bananas, chocolate syrup, pineapple and strawberries. Topped with whip cream and cherry.
32 Oz Scooped Banana Split Cup $16.99
Chocolate, Vanilla Bean and Strawberry Ice Cream. Sliced Bananas, Chocolate Syrup and Strawberries topped with whip cream and cherry.
Upside Down Soft Banana Split Cup 20oz $11.99
32 oz. Quart size upside down banana split packed with soft serve ice cream, strawberries, pineapple, chocolate syrup, sliced bananas and whipped cream & cherry. Add your own toppings to customize your banana split.

Popsicle
Snow Cone $3.75
Sponge Bob $3.99
Ninja Turtle $3.99
Spiderman $3.99
Sonic $3.99

Cups, Cones & Toppings
Sugar Cones $0.55
A sugar cone may be wrapped on the side to go.
Waffle Bowl $2.00
A waffle bowl may be wrapped on the side to go or choose to have your ice cream made right in the bowl.
Cake Cone $0.35
Cookie Cone $2.50
Cookie cones are one size cone and may be wrapped on the side to go. Will be a yummy addition to your ice cream.
Scooped Ice Cream Summer '25 $4.75
Choose a creamy delicious scooped flavor.
Chocolate Dipped Waffle Cone $2.25
Waffle Cone Dipped in Chocolate with Sprinkles - wrapped on side
Pretzel Cone $2.50
Pretzel cones are one size cone and may be wrapped on the side to go. Will go perfect with your ice cream.
Waffle Cone $1.50
Waffle cones may be wrapped on the side to go.
Soft Serve Ice Cream $3.95
Soft vanilla, chocolate or vanilla chocolate twist.

Hurricane Blitz
Shamrock Blitz $6.95
Choose your favorite topping to be blended into a mint flavored blitz.
Soft Serve Ice Cream Blitz $6.95
Soft serve vanilla ice cream with your favorite topping blended in. From traditional toppings to popular candy toppings. Add additional toppings to create your own blitz. 12oz, 16oz, or 21oz

Specialty Sundaes
Nutty Lori (Turtle Sundae) $7.55
Peanuts, hot fudge and hot caramel layered in a cup of ice cream of your choice. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
S'mores Sundae $7.55
Crushed graham crackers, chocolate syrup and marshmallow sauce layered in a cup of ice cream of your choice. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry is available by request at no additional charge.
Stellar Coffee $7.55
Creamy Coffee Ice Cream (or your pick) topped with Hot Fudge Sauce and Mini Chocolate Chips. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Oreo Cheesecake $7.55
Our Oreo Packed Cookies & Cream Ice Cream topped with Cheesecake bites , Crushed Oreos and Caramel Drizzle. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Blondie $7.55
Your choice of one of our creamy ice cream flavors, Chocolate chip cookie dough bites topped with yummy caramel layered in a cup of ice cream of your choice. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Cinnamon Churro Crunch $7.55
Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream or your favorite flavor, ribboned with chocolate sauce & caramel, stuffed with a warm cinnamon churro, topped with cinnamon crunch. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Banana Cream Pie $7.55
Rich flavor Banana Ice Cream drizzled with MarshMallow Sauce, topped with crushed Graham Cracker. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Twixie Goodness $7.55
Hot Caramel Sauce, topped with Twix candy bar over Creamy Vanilla ice cream or your favorite pick. Note: Whip Cream and Cherry Available by request at no additional charge
Dusty Road $7.55
Classic malt and hot fudge sauce layered in a cup of ice cream of your choice. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional request.
Caramel Bomb $7.55
Made with our Caramel packed Caramel Caribou Ice Cream(or choose your favorite), topped with Caramel Sauce, Sprinkled with Heath Bar Crunch and Butterfinger for a caramel adventure. Note; Whip Cream and Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Parfait $7.55
Choose your favorite ice cream flavor and have it topped with granola and your choice of a topping. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae $7.55
Your choice of ice cream layered with creamy peanut butter sauce and hot fudge. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Twisted Tori $7.55
Your choice of ice cream layered with hot fudge, creamy peanut butter sauce and sliced bananas. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae $7.55
Your choice of ice cream layered with our delicious homemade cake and strawberries. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Garbage Can $7.55
Your favorite Ice Cream Choice, with a dumping of Rainbow Sprinkles, M&Ms, Gummy Bears, KitKat Bar & Chocolate Syrup Drizzle Note : Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
BlueBerry Cheesecake $7.55
Made with our Vanilla Bean Ice Cream, Blueberry Topping and our signature Cheesecake Bites. Note: Whip Cream and Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Baja Chocolate $7.55
Our creamy Chocolate Ice Cream (or choose), Dunes of Cookie Dough Bites, drizzled with MarshMallow Sauce, topped with Mini Chocolate chips Note: Whip Cream and Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Cheesecake Sundae $7.55
Your choice of ice cream layered with scrumptious cheese cake bites and your favorite sundae topping. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Peanut Butter Blast $7.55
Calling all peanut butter lovers- peanut butter sauce, Reese peanut butter cups and Reese pieces layered in a cup of ice cream of your choice. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional price.
Banana Sundae $7.55
Sliced bananas, your choice of a sundae topping layered in a cup of ice cream of your choice. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry is available by request at no additional charge.
Toasted Coconut Almond Sundae $7.55
Sliced almonds, chocolate sauce and shredded coconut layered in a delicious cup of Coconut ice cream or your choice. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Birthday Cake Sundae $7.55
A yummy sundae made with your choice of ice cream, our homemade cake, topped with chocolate syrup and rainbow sprinkles. Did someone say more sprinkles!! Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Pineapple Upside Down Sundae $7.55
Our homemade cake, your choice of ice cream layered with crushed pineapple topped with caramel drizzle. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Island Creamery Special $7.55
Your choice of ice cream, hot fudge, hot caramel, crushed pretzels and our signature homemade fudge brownies. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available at no additional charge by request.
Mud Sundae $7.55
Your choice of ice cream layered with crushed Oreo cookies, chocolate syrup and marshmallow sauce. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available at no additional charge by request.
Calypso Crunch $7.55
Aim to please with our Sweet & Salty Caramel pretzel Ice Cream (or Choose your Flavor) topped with Pretzel Pieces and a drizzle of Peanut Butter Sauce. Note: Whip Cream and Cherry available at no additional charge by request.
"C" Is 4 Cookie $7.55
Delicious Cookie Monster Ice Cream- or your pick-topped with crushed Oreo, Cookie Dough Bites & drizzled with Chocolate Syrup. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae $7.55
Your choice of a delicious ice cream, layered with hot fudge and our signature brownies. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Dirty Worm $7.55
Gummy worms buried in a layered cup of ice cream of your choice, chocolate syrup and crushed Oreo cookies. Note: Whip Cream & Cherry available by request at no additional charge.
Snickelicious $7.55
Vanilla Ice Cream with a ribbon of Hot Caramel Sauce with loads of crushed snicker bar. Note: Whip Cream and Cherry Available by request at no additional charge.

Milkshakes & Slush
Slush $3.00
Choose a refreshing ice flavored drink.
Soft Serve Milkshake $6.55
Creamy soft serve ice cream mixed with your favorite syrup, traditional toppings, cookies or candy toppings.
Slush Float Soft Ice Cream $5.25
Choose a refreshing slush flavor and have your favorite soft serve floating on top.
Smoothie Soft Only '25 $5.25
Choose a refreshing slush flavor and blend it with soft serve ice cream.
Scooped Milkshake '25 $6.95
Choose a hand dipped ice cream flavor and have it blended into a creamy milkshake.

Cookie Muncher Sandwich
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich $6.75
Large loaded chocolate chip cookie or Oatmeal Cookie. Choose your favorite ice cream to make a yummy ice cream sandwich.
Chocolate Cookie Wafer $2.99
Original Chocolate Cookie Wafer Sandwich. Have it plain or roll it in your favorite topping.
Chocolate Cookie Wafer 5 For $12.75 $12.75

Grab & Go Drinks
Can Soda Summer '25 $1.75
12 oz cans. Can Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer, Orange, Grape
20 Oz Gatorade Summer '25 $2.75
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Bottled Water Summer '25 $1.50
Nestle Pure Life 16.9 oz.
12oz Gatorade Summer '25 $1.75
12 oz Gatorade in a variety of flavors.
Bottle Soda Summer '25 $2.75
20 oz bottle Coke.

Island Creamery New Jersey Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Identifies as veteran-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout

Highlights
Great dessert

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Dining options
Table service

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Island Creamery New Jersey Photos

Island Creamery New Jersey Location

Island Creamery New Jersey

New Jersey Atlantic County Atlantic City Ventnor Avenue

3901 Ventnor Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA

Island Creamery New Jersey Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 128 user reviews.

pricesmilkshakeflavorssundaepeanut buttersummereveningconesACTV

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

They have a ton of flavors and the staff was super nice! Note: Nut allergy flavors were clearly identified but they do not carry gluten free or vegan flavors. Bonus points for the ice cream bird🍦🐦
May 25 · Karle Yanocha
It's one of my favorite Ice Cream places in Jersey area!!! The owners will make you feel at home the moment you walk in. I'm sure all of their flavors are delightful. However, my 2 favorite Rum Raisins and Coconut are to die for.
April 28 · Annie
Since June I have ordered 3 ice cream cakes from Island creamery, every single one of them were outstanding looking and tasting! Their prices are so affordable and the best part is the overall quality and taste. The shop is kept very clean and staff is always helpful. Definitely worth taking the family to get some ice cream here!
August 03 · Amanda Reese
1st time... Great Experience 😋 Thanks John
April 22 · SoColorful -
We came in mid-evening for some ice cream cones and a milkshake. The staff was super helpful in picking out flavors and toppings and putting together some great cones (with cups for backup). We also got a hand-scooped chocolate and peanut butter milkshake. It was awesome. I'd kinda like another now, as I write this. Prices were reasonable. All good. Bonus points: they were playing the Avatar animated series on the TV while we were in. Cool shop.
August 23 · Ryan Eubank