Jahnke's Creamery Introduce
For residents of Milford, New York, and the wider Otsego County region, Jahnke's Creamery stands out as a beloved local destination that offers much more than just ice cream. This popular spot has earned a reputation for its fantastic, high-quality ice cream, a wide selection of flavors, and a friendly, welcoming atmosphere. It's the kind of place that becomes a go-to for a family outing or a simple treat on a warm day. Jahnke's has built on its legacy (with one customer even recalling a previous name, "Pops") by continuing to provide a top-notch experience. The shop is not only praised for its creamy, delicious ice cream but also for its equally fantastic hot food offerings, making it a well-rounded stop for a full meal or just a dessert. The commitment to quality is evident in the positive reviews, with one customer specifically highlighting the delicious waffle cones and the overall quality of the ice cream. The friendly service, exemplified by an employee named Cheyenne who went out of her way to make a special request, further solidifies Jahnke's Creamery as a community favorite. This establishment embodies the spirit of a small, local business that genuinely cares about its customers and provides a memorable experience for everyone who walks through its doors.
Jahnke's Creamery is conveniently situated at 4370 NY-28, Milford, NY 13807. This address places it on a main state highway, making it an easy and accessible stop for both locals and those traveling through the area. As one customer noted, it's an "easy spot to pull in off the road," which is a significant advantage for families and groups on the go. The location provides ample parking, so visitors don't have to worry about finding a spot even during busy times. Being on NY-28, the creamery is easily reachable from nearby communities like Cooperstown, Oneonta, and Schenevus. This central location in Otsego County makes it a natural destination for a treat after a day of work, school, or weekend activities. The shop's visibility and easy access contribute to its popularity and make it a hassle-free addition to any local's routine. The convenience of the location, combined with the relaxing environment, creates a perfect setting for a casual stop.
Jahnke's Creamery offers a diverse and appealing range of products and services, ensuring there's something to please everyone's palate. Their menu is thoughtfully crafted to include both classic ice cream treats and other delicious items.
- A wide variety of ice cream flavors, including a mix of classic and seasonal options.
- Hand-scooped hard ice cream and creamy soft serve.
- Hand-crafted sundaes, with one customer even requesting a special "Turtle Sundae."
- Deliciously fresh and high-quality waffle cones.
- A selection of fantastic hot food, which makes the shop a great lunch or dinner stop as well as a dessert destination.
- Frozen yogurt and other lighter dessert options.
- Classic milkshakes and floats.
- Take-home options, such as pints and quarts, so you can enjoy their ice cream at home.
This varied menu, praised for its "nice flavor selection" and quality, allows Jahnke's to cater to a broad range of tastes and dietary preferences.
Jahnke's Creamery distinguishes itself from other local shops through several key features and highlights that enhance the customer experience.
- A reputation for serving fantastic, high-quality ice cream that is consistently delicious.
- The availability of a delicious hot food menu, a unique feature that makes it a convenient and versatile dining option.
- A wide selection of flavors that ensures there is "a bit of something for everyone," as noted in a review.
- The presence of a friendly and accommodating staff, with a review specifically highlighting the helpfulness of an employee named Cheyenne.
- A family-friendly environment with ample seating and fun outdoor games, creating a space where people can relax and stay for a while.
- Easy accessibility and plenty of parking, which adds to the convenience of the visit.
- A commitment to quality ingredients, particularly in products like their delicious waffle cones.
- A strong connection to the local community, as evidenced by loyal customers who have been visiting the location for years.
- The shop's ability to create a "5 star experience," as rated by a satisfied customer who received exceptional service.
These highlights collectively paint a picture of a business that is dedicated to providing not just a great product, but a memorable and enjoyable experience for all who visit.
To get in touch with Jahnke's Creamery, you can use the following contact information.
- Address: 4370 NY-28, Milford, NY 13807, USA
- Phone: (607) 286-4054
- Mobile Phone: +1 607-286-4054
This information is useful for checking their hours, asking about specific menu items, or inquiring about any special requests you might have.
For locals in Milford and the surrounding New York area, Jahnke's Creamery is an excellent choice and a true community asset. Its suitability stems from its perfect balance of high-quality products, great value, and a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere. The fact that you can get not only fantastic ice cream but also delicious hot food makes it a versatile destination for a quick meal or a satisfying treat. The positive reviews from customers who highlight the friendly service, the quality of the ice cream, and the comfortable seating with outdoor games all point to a business that is deeply connected to its community's needs. The convenient location on a main road with plenty of parking ensures that it is always a hassle-free and accessible option. Jahnke's Creamery is more than just a place to get dessert; it's a gathering spot that provides a consistently high-quality experience, making it a must-visit for anyone in the region seeking a sweet treat or a friendly meal. It stands as a testament to the success of a local business that prioritizes its customers and the quality of its offerings.
Jahnke's Creamery Photos






Jahnke's Creamery Location
Jahnke's Creamery Reviews
turtlesundae
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Fantastic ice cream!!Nice flavor selection, a bit of something for everyone and the actual ice cream is delicious! I particularly love the quality and flavor of the waffle cones!They even have fantastic hot food!Easy spot to pull in off the road with plenty of parking and a lot of nice seating, outdoor games, etc.
June 16 · Jesse Crowley5 star experience. When Jahnke’s was called Pops they had the best ice cream concoction of all time called the Turtle Sundae. This item was not on the Jahnke’s menu however the friendly employee Cheyenne (spelling?) made me a Turtle Sundae. I would highly recommend adding the Turtle Sundae as a mainstay menu item. Other than that this place is a must visit.
July 06 · Jack SchwoererJust take my money (salted caramel ice cream )was absolutely awesome. The homemade waffle cone the best.Great little ice cream place on NY-28. If you're up near Cooperstown, stop in and enjoy!!!
August 14 · J BWe came here for food and ice cream. Our kids loved the playground! And my husband and I love that the meat and ice cream are local. Great flavors. We met the owner and his kids on the playground and they were all very kind. Looking forward to coming back all summer!
May 06 · Kelly PattersonI used to love coming here when it was previously Pop’s and am happy to report that Jahnke’s lives up to Pop’s. Very good ice cream, great flavor selection. Coconut crunch was so good. I wish they would add Turtle sundae to the menu- then it would be perfect! 😊
July 06 · Lily Schwoerer
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

46 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY 13326, USA

69 Main St, Cooperstown, NY 13326, USA

6635 NY-28, Hartwick, NY 13348, USA

478 Main St, Oneonta, NY 13820, USA

261 Main St, Oneonta, NY 13820, USA

15 Main St, Oneonta, NY 13820, USA

413 Chestnut St, Oneonta, NY 13820, USA

30-32 S Broad St, Morris, NY 13808, USA

5212 NY-28, Oneonta, NY 13820, USA

106 Park Ave, Jefferson, NY 12093, USA

664 US-20, Sharon Springs, NY 13459, USA

1524 NY-7, Richmondville, NY 12149, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





