Katie's Ice Cream Introduce
Welcome, Maryland residents, to a delightful journey into the world of frozen treats, right here in our own backyard. When the sun shines bright and the craving for something sweet and refreshing hits, there's a local gem that stands out: Katie's Ice Cream. Situated in the charming community of McHenry, this beloved ice cream shop has earned a reputation for its delectable offerings and welcoming atmosphere, making it a must-visit for anyone in the Garrett County area and beyond.
Katie's Ice Cream is more than just a place to grab a cone; it's an experience. It’s where families create lasting memories, friends share laughter over scoops, and locals find their favorite sweet escape. This overview will delve into what makes Katie's Ice Cream a cherished establishment, exploring its convenient location, the array of services it provides, its unique highlights, and why it continues to be a top choice for ice cream enthusiasts across Maryland. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, prepare to discover your next favorite dessert destination.
Katie's Ice Cream is conveniently located at 25800- 25864 Garrett Hwy, McHenry, MD 21541, USA. This prime spot places it right in the heart of the Deep Creek Lake area, making it an easily accessible stop for both local residents and tourists enjoying the many attractions of Garrett County. The shop's location on Garrett Highway, a main thoroughfare, ensures visibility and straightforward navigation for those looking to satisfy their sweet tooth.
Accessibility to Katie's Ice Cream is generally excellent. For those traveling by car, there is typically parking available, though it's always wise to anticipate busier times, especially during peak tourist seasons or warm summer evenings. The shop's position along a well-trafficked road means it's often a convenient stop before or after other activities in the Deep Creek Lake region, such as boating, hiking, or exploring local shops. While specific details on public transport links are often limited for businesses in more rural settings, the primary mode of access for most visitors will be personal vehicles, for which the location is well-suited. Its proximity to various vacation rentals and recreational spots solidifies its status as an easy and appealing destination for anyone in the vicinity.
Services Offered:
- A wide variety of ice cream flavors, catering to diverse preferences.
- Fresh strawberry shakes, a popular choice for fruit-lovers.
- Flavor burst options, allowing for customized ice cream experiences.
- Generous portion sizes, offering great value for customers.
- Payment accepted via cash or check only.
- Take-out service for convenient enjoyment on the go.
Features / Highlights:
- Highly praised by customers for rich and flavorful ice cream.
- Offers unique and indulgent flavors like coconut cream-pie, described as exceptionally rich and satisfying.
- Known for providing large portions, making each treat a substantial delight.
- A popular return destination for visitors to Deep Creek Lake, indicating strong customer loyalty and satisfaction.
- Friendly and welcoming atmosphere, contributing to a pleasant experience for all visitors.
- Focus on traditional payment methods (cash or check) adds a unique, old-school charm to the establishment.
Contact Information:
Address: 25800- 25864 Garrett Hwy, McHenry, MD 21541, USA
Phone: While a specific phone number isn't publicly available in the provided information, local search engines or a quick drive-by would confirm if one is listed on-site or through other directories. For immediate inquiries, a visit during operating hours is recommended.
For locals and frequent visitors to the Deep Creek Lake area, Katie's Ice Cream is more than just an ice cream shop; it's a cherished part of the community fabric. Its suitability for locals stems from several key aspects that resonate deeply with the Maryland ethos. Firstly, its commitment to generous portions and rich, satisfying flavors means you're getting excellent value for your money – a practical consideration that always appeals to residents. The unique and beloved flavors, like the lauded coconut cream-pie, offer a delightful escape from the everyday, providing a consistent source of high-quality treats that keep people coming back.
Secondly, the "cash or check only" policy, while requiring a small adjustment for some, imbues the shop with a sense of local charm and simplicity. It's a reminder of a time when transactions were more direct, fostering a connection that goes beyond just a purchase. This unpretentious approach contributes to a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, making everyone feel at home. For families, especially those with children, Katie's Ice Cream becomes a traditional stop, building happy memories that endure for years, a testament to its family-friendly environment.
Finally, its strategic location on Garrett Highway makes it an easily accessible destination, whether you're running errands, enjoying a day on the lake, or simply craving a sweet treat after work or school. It serves as a convenient and enjoyable stop that seamlessly fits into the rhythm of local life. In essence, Katie's Ice Cream provides a consistent, high-quality, and community-oriented experience that perfectly aligns with what Maryland locals look for in their favorite neighborhood spots. It's not just about the ice cream; it's about the feeling of home, comfort, and delicious satisfaction that keeps the community returning time and time again.
Katie's Ice Cream Food & drink
Specialities
- Mr. Salty
- Smores Delite
- Brownie Delite
- Strawberry Xtreme
- Strawberry Shortcake
- Coconut-Crème Pie
- Boston Crème Pie
- Nutty Banana
- Cookie Xtreme
- Pineapple Upside Down Cake
- Apple Pie Delite
- Dirt Delite
- Sunshine Burst
- The Froggy
- The Roundabout
- Mint Madness
- Wicked Mint Shake
- Boston Shake
- Chocolate Covered
- Birthday Cake Shake
- Waffle Sundae Dish
- Parfait
Ems
- Trawberry Shake
- S Sundae
- Tshake
- Pie Sundae
- E Sundae
- Down Cake
Others
- Vanilla Ice Cream
- Pretzels
- Vanilla
- Peanut Butter
- Oreo
- Pup Cups
- Pumpkin Pie
- Wet Nut Sundae
Katie's Ice Cream Details
Service options
- Delivery
Katie's Ice Cream Photos










Katie's Ice Cream Location
Katie's Ice Cream
25800-, 25864 Garrett Hwy, McHenry, MD 21541, USA
Katie's Ice Cream Reviews
pricesconeshakesflavorsundaecashbanana splitservingscredit cardscotton candy
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1My wife and daughter rave about their ice cream. This was the first time I got something and it was the coconut cream-pie, I typically decline desserts but this was so rich in flavor and hit a sweet tooth that rarely comes around. We will always return to this icecream shop when we are visiting deep creek.
July 04 · daniel estradaCash or check only! Large portions. Fresh strawberry shake was good. I was disappointed by the flavor burst, could barely taste it. Also my cone got soft and soggy within a few minutes, i ended up throwing half of my ice cream away. Waste of money. Wouldn't go back.
June 11 · Melissa HoffmanI have been coming here every summer for as long as I can remember. Katie’s is my all-time favorite soft serve spot to the point where I can’t enjoy soft serve from anywhere else! Always delicious ice cream served up by friendly folks.Make sure to have cash with you as they only accept cash and local checks.
September 01 · Emma FlahertyYum! A lot of ice cream for the price - we all ate about half and took half home for the freezer. My son was a big fan of the mint madness sundae. Good selection of classic soft serve options - cones, flurries, shakes, sundae, etc. Nice picnic tables in the shade. We liked this much more than the Lakeside Creamery.
August 09 · Jenny SullivanAwesome ice-cream, large portions, great price!
June 25 · Eileen Ward
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

20282 Garrett Hwy, Oakland, MD 21550, USA

104 E Oak St, Oakland, MD 21550, USA

1001 Lafayette Dr, Farmington, PA 15437, USA

225 W Main St, Frostburg, MD 21532, USA

13125 Warrior Dr, Cumberland, MD 21502, USA

148 State Hwy 32, Thomas, WV 26292, USA

659 Point Marion Rd, Morgantown, WV 26505, USA

101 E Brockway Ave, Morgantown, WV 26501, USA

RR 1 Box 189C, Fort Ashby, WV 26719, USA

152 Baltimore St, Cumberland, MD 21502, USA

3671 Glades Pike #8071, Somerset, PA 15501, USA

125 N 7th St, Connellsville, PA 15425, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





