Libby’s Ice Cream

In the heart of downtown Fortville, Indiana, Libby’s Ice Cream has become a cherished local institution, providing the community with a welcoming spot to enjoy delicious frozen treats. This isn't just a place to grab a quick cone; it's a pleasant and enjoyable destination where families and friends can gather to cool off and socialize. Since opening, Libby's has cultivated a reputation for its tasty ice cream and sweet treats, as well as its clean and spacious environment. The shop's commitment to creating a positive experience is evident in its pleasant atmosphere, which makes it a popular spot that is often busy, a clear sign of its strong local following.

The success of Libby’s Ice Cream is a story of community and quality. The shop was born out of a desire to fill a void in the downtown area after a previous ice cream parlor closed its doors. Libby and her family, who were already local business owners, stepped in to provide a space where the community could continue to enjoy ice cream and spend quality time together. This dedication to the community is a major part of the shop's appeal. They've made a point to support other local businesses, and their hand-dipped ice cream comes from Sundaes Homemade Hand-Dipped Ice Cream, a beloved local brand based in Indianapolis that has been serving the area for over 35 years. This partnership ensures that customers are not only getting a delicious treat but are also supporting a network of local Indiana businesses.

Beyond the hand-dipped offerings, Libby’s also makes its own soft serve ice cream at the Fortville location, providing another option for customers. The variety of treats, from sundaes and milkshakes to a unique item called the Tornado, ensures that there is something for everyone. Customers have consistently given the shop high marks, with one review noting that the ice cream was "worth the wait." The indoor facility is described as a pleasant place to eat, with a nicely cool temperature that keeps the ice cream from melting too quickly. This attention to detail, from the quality of the product to the comfort of the environment, is what makes Libby's Ice Cream a recommended and highly rated destination for a sweet treat in Fortville.

Libby’s Ice Cream is conveniently located at 222 W Broadway St in Fortville, IN 46040. Its address places it right in the heart of downtown Fortville, making it a central and easily accessible destination for local residents and visitors. The shop's location in a vibrant community ensures that a visit to Libby's can be seamlessly integrated into a larger outing, whether it's a stroll through the downtown area, a visit to other local shops, or a family trip to a nearby park. The presence of the shop in a renovated filling station adds a unique and charming touch to its location, giving it a distinctive character that sets it apart from other businesses.

The accessibility of Libby's is a key factor in its popularity. Situated on a main street, it is easy to find for those traveling by car. Parking in the downtown area is generally manageable, allowing for a quick and stress-free stop. For those on foot, the shop is perfectly positioned within a walkable area, making it a natural part of a downtown exploration. The interior of the shop is spacious and well-maintained, providing a comfortable place to sit and enjoy a treat, even when the shop is busy. The pleasant atmosphere and cool indoor temperature, as noted in a customer review, make it a great escape from the summer heat. This combination of a central location and a welcoming, comfortable environment ensures that a visit to Libby’s Ice Cream is always a pleasant and convenient experience for all.

Libby’s Ice Cream offers a delicious and extensive menu of services designed to satisfy every kind of sweet craving. The shop prides itself on providing a variety of options, from classic scoops to creative concoctions, all made with quality ingredients. The menu is a mix of traditional ice cream favorites and unique specialty items, ensuring a new and exciting experience with every visit.

• Hand-Dipped Ice Cream: The shop's hand-dipped ice cream comes from Sundaes, a beloved local brand in Indianapolis. Flavors include staples like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, as well as unique options like Graham Central Station, which is a customer favorite.
• Soft Serve Ice Cream: For those who prefer a classic, Libby’s makes its own soft serve on-site at the Fortville location.
• Specialty Sundaes: The menu features a variety of sundaes, including classic options as well as specialty items like the Brownie Sundae and the Banana Split, all generously portioned.
• Tornadoes and Twisters: These blended treats combine soft serve or ice cream with a variety of mix-ins like candy or cookies, creating a dense and delicious dessert. A Twister is a similar offering, blending ice cream with your choice of candy.
• Milkshakes and Malts: Hand-spun milkshakes and malts are available, offering a smooth and creamy beverage version of your favorite ice cream flavors.
• Specialty Desserts: The shop also features unique treats like "Waffle Nachos," which are waffle cone chips with soft serve and toppings, as well as a variety of ice cream sandwiches ("Sammies") with gluten-free options available.
• Pup Cups: Libby's caters to its four-legged customers with "Pup Cups," a small treat for dogs.

This wide range of services ensures that Libby’s Ice Cream is a comprehensive dessert destination that has something for everyone in the family.

Libby’s Ice Cream is a local gem with several key features and highlights that make it a standout business in the Fortville community. These attributes are what create its unique appeal and contribute to its strong reputation, turning first-time visitors into loyal customers. The shop’s dedication to quality, variety, and a positive atmosphere are at the core of its success.

• Local and High-Quality Ice Cream: The decision to serve hand-dipped ice cream from Sundaes, a respected Indianapolis-based brand, is a major highlight. This partnership not only ensures a high-quality product but also demonstrates a commitment to supporting local Indiana businesses.
• Pleasant and Comfortable Atmosphere: A customer review notes that the indoor facility is a "pleasant, enjoyable place to eat" and is "clean & spacious." The temperature is also "nicely cool inside," which creates a comfortable environment for customers, especially on hot days.
• Unique Menu Items: The menu goes beyond the standard scoop shop fare with creative offerings like "Waffle Nachos" and "Sammies," which include gluten-free options. This variety caters to different tastes and dietary needs, making the shop more inclusive.
• Family-Friendly and Popular: The fact that the shop is "busy" is a testament to its popularity. It's clearly a beloved spot in the community, and its welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect destination for families, as evidenced by its wide appeal.
• Gluten-Free Options: The availability of gluten-free ice cream sandwiches and cones is a significant feature that makes Libby's an accessible and thoughtful choice for customers with dietary restrictions.

These highlights, from the locally sourced ice cream to the welcoming and inclusive atmosphere, are what make Libby's Ice Cream a special and cherished part of the Fortville community.

For those in the Fortville area and beyond looking to visit or get in touch with Libby’s Ice Cream, the contact information is clear and straightforward. The physical address provides a reliable way to find the shop's location in downtown Fortville. The provided phone number offers a direct line to the business, which can be used for any questions about hours of operation, menu items, or general inquiries. Having this information readily available is crucial for a local business, as it helps customers plan their visit and get the information they need.

Address: 222 W Broadway St, Fortville, IN 46040, USA

Phone: (317) 496-4576

The mobile phone number, +1 317-496-4576, is the same as the landline, providing a consistent point of contact. This information confirms the shop’s presence in the town and provides a reliable way for customers to engage with it, adding to its professional and local appeal. It shows that Libby's is an established business that is easy to reach and connect with.

Libby’s Ice Cream is an excellent fit for locals in the Indiana region, especially those in Fortville, for several compelling reasons. The shop’s origin story, born from a desire to serve the community, gives it a special local connection that resonates with residents. By serving hand-dipped ice cream from a well-known Indianapolis brand, Libby’s not only provides a high-quality product but also proudly supports another local Indiana business. This commitment to local partnerships and community ties is a major draw for people who want to keep their money in the local economy.

Furthermore, the shop's pleasant and comfortable atmosphere, as noted by customer reviews, makes it a reliable and enjoyable destination. Whether it's a hot summer day or a cool evening, the clean and spacious interior provides a great place to sit down and enjoy a treat without feeling rushed. The wide variety of offerings, including gluten-free options and fun items like "Waffle Nachos," ensures that every member of the family can find something to love. This combination of great products, a welcoming environment, and a strong sense of community makes Libby's Ice Cream more than just a shop—it's a cherished part of the Fortville lifestyle. For all these reasons, it is a perfect place for locals seeking a high-quality and enjoyable dessert experience in Indiana.

Libby’s Ice Cream

222 W Broadway St, Fortville, IN 46040, USA