Main Street Ice Cream: Your Local Scoop in Hamburg, NY

Main Street Ice Cream Introduce

Welcome to Main Street Ice Cream, a true jewel of Hamburg, NY. Tucked away on a bustling thoroughfare that lives up to its name, this local ice cream shop has carved out a special place in the hearts of the community. Far more than just a place to grab a cone, it’s a destination where families and friends gather to create sweet memories. For New Yorkers in the know, this spot represents the very best of small-town charm, with a quality of product that rivals anything you’d find in the city. The atmosphere is warm, the staff are friendly, and the ice cream is, without a doubt, exceptional. It’s the kind of place where everyone knows your name—or at least remembers your favorite flavor. Whether you’re a long-time resident of the Southtowns or just passing through the picturesque Village of Hamburg, a visit to Main Street Ice Cream is an essential part of the experience.

Located at 35 Main St Suite A, Hamburg, NY 14075, Main Street Ice Cream is perfectly situated for easy access. The shop is a central hub within the Village of Hamburg, making it an ideal stop after a day of exploring local shops, enjoying a meal at a nearby restaurant, or catching a game. For those traveling by car, there is often street parking available, making it a convenient destination. The location’s accessibility and its position on a major local road mean that getting your ice cream fix is never a hassle. It’s a convenient and welcoming spot for locals who can walk or bike there, as well as for visitors driving in from Buffalo and other parts of Western New York. The ease of access is a significant reason why so many people make it a regular part of their routine, turning a simple ice cream run into a delightful and seamless outing. The shop’s spot on Main Street truly makes it a cornerstone of the community.

Main Street Ice Cream offers a wide range of services designed to satisfy every sweet tooth. This isn’t just a place for a simple scoop; it’s a full-service dessert destination.

Scooped Ice Cream: The cornerstone of the menu, featuring a constantly rotating selection of classic and unique flavors. Customers rave about the small-batch special flavors that are introduced regularly.
Sundaes: From classic hot fudge and caramel sundaes to more elaborate creations, these are a popular choice for those looking for a more decadent treat.
Milkshakes and Malts: Hand-spun to perfection, these offer a rich and creamy way to enjoy your favorite flavors in a drinkable form.
Floats: A classic pairing of soda and ice cream that brings a nostalgic touch to the menu.
Ice Cream Cakes: Custom-made ice cream cakes are available, perfect for birthdays, celebrations, or any special occasion. These can be customized with your choice of ice cream and toppings.
Take-Home Containers: Don't want to run out of your favorite flavor? You can purchase pints or quarts to enjoy at home.

What truly sets Main Street Ice Cream apart are its unique features and the dedication to quality that shines through in every scoop.

Homemade and Small-Batch Flavors: The shop is known for its incredible homemade ice cream, which often includes special, small-batch flavors that you won't find anywhere else. These unique creations, like the mentioned cannoli and chocolate orange ice creams, keep customers coming back for new discoveries.
Friendly and Fast Service: As noted by customers, the staff is exceptionally friendly and the service is quick, even on busy days. This contributes to the welcoming and pleasant atmosphere of the shop.
Quaint, Hometown Vibe: The shop exudes a small-town charm that is both comforting and authentic. It feels like a place where everyone is treated like a neighbor, creating a strong sense of community.
High-Quality Ingredients: The focus on quality is evident in the taste. The ice cream is rich, creamy, and made with care, ensuring a superior product that stands out from mass-produced alternatives.
Family-Friendly Environment: Main Street Ice Cream is an ideal spot for families. The relaxed and welcoming atmosphere makes it a great place to bring children for an after-dinner treat or a weekend outing.

For direct inquiries or to place an order for a custom ice cream cake, you can reach out to Main Street Ice Cream using the information below.

Address: 35 Main St Suite A, Hamburg, NY 14075, USA
Phone: (716) 649-2970

In conclusion, Main Street Ice Cream is more than just a place to get dessert; it’s a local institution. For those living in and around Hamburg, it's the perfect spot for a delicious treat. Its homemade, small-batch flavors offer a refreshing and high-quality alternative to larger chains, and the friendly, hometown feel makes every visit feel special. The convenient location makes it an easy stop, whether you're taking a leisurely stroll through the village or stopping by after running errands. It's the kind of place that embodies the spirit of the community—a spot where quality, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere come together to create a truly wonderful experience. If you’re a New York resident looking for a go-to ice cream shop that feels like home, Main Street Ice Cream is the place for you. Its combination of delicious products and a warm, inviting environment makes it the quintessential local gem.

Main Street Ice Cream Food & drink

Homemade Hard Ice Cream
Oreo Cloud $6.50
Oreo ice cream mixed with Oreo chunks
Salty Caramel Espresso $6.50
Espresso ice cream, salted caramel swirls
Gold Rush $6.50
Vanilla ice cream with caramel swirls
Chocolate $6.50
Cookie Monster $6.50
Blue moon ice cream with chunks of oreo, chocolate chip cookies, and cookie dough pieces
Firecracker $6.50
Cinnamon firecracker ice cream mixed with cinnamon candies
Coffee $6.50
You're so bold coffee ice cream
Funfetti Party Cake $6.50
Handcrafted cake batter ice cream, swirls of frosting, cake pieces and rainbow sprinkles
Coconut $6.50
Coconut flavored ice cream, shredded coconut and dark chocolate flakes
Cookie Dough $6.50
Cookie dough flavored ice cream with cookie dough chunks and chocolate flakes
Chocolate Custard Soft Serve $6.50
Enjoy our chocolate flavored custard at home
Vanilla Custard Soft Serve $6.50
Our soft serve vanilla flavored ice cream to enjoy at home
Peanut Butter Paradise $6.50
Vanilla ice cream, peanut butter and caramel swirls, peanut butter cups and reese's pieces
Chocolate Peanut Butter $6.50
Chocolate peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter swirls
Maple Walnut $6.50
Maple ice cream with walnut pieces
Strawberry $6.50
Strawberry ice cream with strawberries mixed throughout
Cotton Candy $6.50
Cotton candy ice cream, swirls of cotton candy flavor and cotton candy sprinkles
Two Berry Twist Soft Serve $6.50
Enjoy Main Street Ice Cream's Two Berry Twist. A combination of our Black Raspberry yogurt and our Red Raspberry Sherbet twisted together
Red Raspberry Soft Serve Sherbet $6.50
Enjoy our soft serve red raspberry sherbet at home
Key Lime $6.50
Key lime ice cream, made with fresh squeezed limes, with swirls of graham cracker
Black Raspberry Soft Serve Yogurt $6.50
Enjoy our creamy soft serve yogurt at home
Chocolate And Vanilla Twist Custard $6.50
Enjoy our chocolate and vanilla twist custard at home
Brownie Mudslide $6.50
Brownie batter ice cream, brownie chunks and fudge swirls
Mint Chip $6.50
Mint ice cream and chocolate flakes
Hot Chocolate Covered Pretzel $6.50
Hot chocolate flavored ice cream, marshmallow swirls and chocolate covered pretzels
Vanilla $6.50
Thunder & Lightening $6.50
Handcrafted vanilla ice cream with blue raspberry and sour green apple swirls

Ice Cream Cakes
8" Ice Cream Cake $43.00
Feeds 8-10 people. Layer of vanilla custard, chocolate cake crunch and fudge, layer of chocolate custard, whipped cream frosting and rainbow sprinkles
10" Ice Cream Cake $52.00
Feeds 12-16 people. Layer of vanilla custard, chocolate cake crunch and fudge, layer of chocolate custard, whipped cream frosting and rainbow sprinkles

Ice Cream Pies
Ice Cream Cake Pie $29.00
Chocolate and vanilla custard layered with fudge and chocolate crunch topped with whipped cream frosting and rainbow sprinkles
Apple Ice Cream Pie $29.00
Homemade cinnamon apple ice cream with chunks of real apples topped with whipped cream frosting and a dusting of cinnamon
Peanut Butter Pie $29.00
Peanut butter custard layered with fudge and peanut butter sauce topped with more fudge, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, Reese's Pieces, and whipped cream frosting
Turtle Pie $29.00
Vanilla custard layered with caramel and fudge topped with more caramel, fudge, pecans and whipped cream frosting
Snickers Pie $29.00
Vanilla custard layered with fudge and caramel topped with more fudge, caramel, peanuts, pieces of snickers candy and whipped cream frosting
Banana Cream Pie $29.00
Banana flavored custard mixed with fresh banana chunks topped with whipped cream frosting
Black Raspberry Yogurt Pie $29.00
Vanilla custard layered with low fat black raspberry yogurt topped with whipped cream frosting
Peppermint Pie $29.00
Layer of chocolate custard topped with homemade peppermint ice cream, whipped cream frosting, chocolate shavings and crushed peppermint pieces
Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie $29.00
Thin layer of vanilla custard topped with homemade pumpkin ice cream and whipped cream frosting
Chocolate Lover's Pie $29.00
Chocolate custard layered with fudge and chocolate crunch topped with more fudge, oreo cookie pieces, whipped cream frosting and chocolate sprinkles
Oreo Pie $29.00
Vanilla custard with chunks of oreo cookies topped with whipped cream frosting, fudge and oreo cookies

To Go-Go'S
Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich $6.95
Vanilla custard sandwiched between two homemade chocolate chip cookies
Chocolate Lovers Bar $5.75
Chocolate custard mixed with M&M's and Oreos, dipped in chocolate, rolled in chocolate crunch on a stick
Fudgy Peanut Bars $5.50
Layers of vanilla custard, peanuts and fudge covered in chocolate on a stick.
Peanut Butter Explosion Bar $5.75
Vanilla custard mixed with peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, reeses pieces, dipped in chocolate and rolled in peanut crunch on a stick
Cotton Candy Ice Cream Bar $5.75
Vanilla custard mixed with cotton candy sprinkles dipped in blue raspberry, rolled in cotton candy sprinkles on a stick
Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches $4.50
Vanilla custard sandwiched between two chocolate wafers
Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwich $4.50
Chocolate custard sandwiched between two chocolate wafers
Buddy's Dog Treat $4.25
Vanilla custard with a Milk bone. For the friend that's always there for you!
Oreo Explosion Bar $5.75
Vanilla custard mixed with Oreos, dipped in chocolate and rolled in chocolate crunch on a stick

Items of the Week
Gluten Free Oreo Ice Cream (Pint Only) $11.75
Gluten Free Oreo ice cream mixed with gluten free Oreo chunks
Flavor Of The Week: Maple Blondie $6.50
Handcrafted maple ice cream, maple brown sugar swirls, and chunks of blondie bars
Flavor Of The Week: Chocolate Therapy $6.50
Gluten Free Mint Oreo Ice Cream (Pint Only) $11.75
Gluten free mint Oreo ice cream with gluten free Oreo chunks
Flavor Of The Week: Pistachio $6.50
Handcrafted pistachio ice cream with pieces of pistachio nuts
Item Of The Week: Vanilla Molasses Ice Cream Sandwich $8.00
Homemade molasses cookie with vanilla custard
Flavor Of The Week: Blueberry $6.50
Homemade blueberry ice cream made with fresh, locally grown blueberries.
Flavor Of The Week: M&M Madness $6.50
Handcrafted vanilla ice cream mixed with M&Ms
Flavor Of The Week: Lemonade Sunshine Girl Scout Cookie $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Eskimo Kisses $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Chocolate Chip $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Main Street All Nighter $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Frosty's Magic $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Egg Nog $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Ho, Ho, Ho $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Strawberry Rhubarb $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Carrot Cake Ice Cream $6.50
Cinnamon ice cream, pieces carrot cake, and swirls of cream cheese frosting
Flavor Of The Week: 4th Of July Explosion $6.50
Homemade vanilla ice cream, patriotic cake chunks, red white & blue sprinkles, and cherry & blue raspberry hardening dip swirls
Flavor Of The Week: Cinnamon Crazy $6.50
Homemade cinnamon ice cream, crushed cinnamon toast cereal, and pieces of "Toast-Yay!" girl scout cookies
Flavor Of The Week: Loganberry $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Nutella $6.50
Handcrafted Nutella ice cream
Flavor Of The Week: Ultimate Peanut Butter $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Cinnamon Apple $6.50
Cinnamon ice cream with apple chunks
Flavor Of The Week: Frankenstein Party Cake $6.50
Vanilla ice cream with pieces of Frankenstein cake, Halloween whipped cream frosting swirls, and scary sprinkles
Flavor Of The Week: Solar Eclipse $6.50
Handcrafted orange chocolate ice cream with swirls of orange ice cream
Flavor Of The Week: Nutter Butter Blast $6.50
Homemade peanut butter ice cream with crushed Nutter Butter Cookies
Flavor Of The Week: Peppermint $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Candy Crush $6.50
Vanilla ice cream with Heath Bar, Butterfinger, M&M's, Nestle Crunch and Reese's Pieces mixed throughout
Flavor Of The Week: German Chocolate Cake $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Blackberry $6.50
Handcrafted berry ice cream with swirls of fresh blackberry
Flavor Of The Week: Thin Mint Girl Scout Cookie $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Pumpkin $6.50
Pumpkin ice cream with whipped cream frosting swirls
Flavor Of The Week: Peanut Butter Oatmeal $6.50
Handcrafted sweet cream ice cream, swirls of peanut butter, fudge, and chunks of peanut butter oatmeal cookies. Made with Girl Scout "Scout's Honor" peanut butter sandwich cookies
Flavor Of The Week: Banana Pudding $6.50
Homemade banana pudding ice cream, fresh banana chunks, vanilla wafer cookies and marshmallow swirls
Flavor Of The Week: Mummy Tracks $6.50
Handcrafted vanilla ice cream, fudge swirls and peanut butter cups
Flavor Of The Week: Black Forest $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Grape $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Spumoni $6.50
Homemade chocolate, cherry and pistachio ice cream swirled together with black cherries and pistachios - A holiday tradition
Flavor Of The Week: Holy Cannoli $6.50
Sweet cream ice cream, sweet ricotta cheese swirls, chocolate covered wafer pieces and mini chocolate chips
Flavor Of The Week: Chocolate S'mores $6.50
Homemade chocolate ice cream, swirls of fudge and marshmallow, with chunks of chocolate covered graham crackers
Flavor Of The Week: Pineapple Upside Down Cake $6.50
Flavor Of The Week: Tigers Blood $6.50
Handcrafted tropical strawberry and coconut ice cream with swirls of hardening chocolate
Flavor Of The Week: Orange Creamsicle $6.50
Item Of The Week: Pumpkin Molasses Ice Cream Sandwich $8.00
Homemade molasses cookie with homemade pumpkin ice cream
Flavor Of The Week: Peach Melba $6.50
Handcrafted peach ice cream and raspberry swirls
Flavor Of The Week: Lavender Honey $6.50
Homemade lavender ice cream with swirls of honey
Flavor Of The Week: Gingerbread Man $6.50
Handcrafted gingerbread ice cream with pieces of homemade gingerbread cookies
Flavor Of The Week: The Burg $6.50
Chocolate ice cream, marshmallow swirls, peanuts and caramel swirls

Milkshakes
Mint Milkshake $9.50
Strawberry Milkshake $9.50
Banana Milkshake $9.50
Strawberry Banana Milkshake $9.50
Chocolate Milkshake $9.50
Vanilla Milkshake $9.50
Raspberry Milkshake $9.50
Cherry Milkshake $9.50

Whirlwinds
Chocolate Whirlwind $10.75
Chocolate custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
Twist Whirlwind $10.75
Chocolate/Vanilla twist custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
Vanilla Whirlwind $10.75
Vanilla custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)

Vegan Pints
Lime Dolewhip $11.75
Espresso Oat Milk $11.75
Pomegranate Dolewhip $11.75
Strawberry Oat Milk $11.75
Vanilla oat milk with strawberry swirls
Lemon Ice $11.75
Home made lemon ice made with fresh squeezed lemons and lemon zest
Cherry Dolewhip $11.75
Chocolate Oat Milk $11.75
Pineapple Dolewhip $11.75
Watermelon Dolewhip $11.75
Oreo Oat Milk $11.75
Vanilla oat milk with gluten free oreos
Vanilla Oat Milk $11.75
Mango Dolewhip $11.75

Premium Sundaes
Ice Cream Cake Sundae $10.25
Chocolate and vanilla custard, hot fudge, chocolate crunch, whipped cream and rainbow sprinkles
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Peanut Butter And Jelly Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted grape ice cream, peanut butter sauce, topped with vanilla custard raspberry topping and whipped cream
Almond Joyful Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, chocolate sauce, coconut, almonds, whip cream, and a cherry. NO substitutions
Gluten Free Brownie Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, gluten free brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Solar Eclipse Sundae $10.25
Hand crafted orange chocolate ice cream with neon sprinkles, topped with chocolate custard, marshmallow sauce, bright yellow sprinkles and whipped cream
Peanut Butter Supreme Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, reeses pieces and whipped cream. NO Substitutions
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Fluffer Nutter Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted peanut butter paradise ice cream with marshmallow sauce topped with vanilla custard, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups and whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Peppermint Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted peppermint ice cream with hot fudge, topped with vanilla soft serve, peppermint Oreos, peppermint sprinkles, and whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Mom's Favorite Sundae $10.25
Hand crafted peanut butter oatmeal ice cream with hot fudge, topped with vanilla custard, peanut butter sauce, granola topping and whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Apple Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted cinnamon ice cream with caramel sauce topped with vanilla custard, cinnamon apple topping, cinnamon struesal and whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Double Berry Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted blueberry ice cream, cheesecake pieces, topped with vanilla custard, strawberry topping, cheesecake pieces and whipped cream
Dirt & Worm Sundae $10.25
Vanilla soft serve, chocolate crunch "dirt", hot fudge "mud", gummy worms and whipped cream
Mexican Sundae $10.25
Vanilla soft serve, chocolate sauce, Spanish peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Cranberry $10.25
Vanilla custard, fresh made cranberry topping, brown sugar oatmeal streusel, whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Witches Brew Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted Frankenstein party cake ice cream, chocolate crunch "graveyard dirt", topped with vanilla custard, creepy sprinkles, and whipped cream
Turtle Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, hot fudge, caramel, pecans, whipped cream, and a cherry. No Substitutions
Chocolate Lovers Sundae $10.25
Chocolate custard, chocolate syrup, oreo pieces, chocolate sprinkles and whipped cream. No substitutions
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Brookie Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted brownie mudslide ice cream and peanut butter sauce topped with vanilla custard, hot fudge, a brookie (half brownie, half peanut butter cookie), and whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Easter Basket Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted Funfetti ice cream and marshmallow sauce topped with vanilla custard, caramel sauce, whipped cream, Easter sprinkles and a marshmallow bunny
Premium Sundae Of The Week: 4th Of July Sundae $10.25
Handcrafter July 4th party cake ice cream, marshmallow sauce, topped with vanilla custard, cherry and blue raspberry hardening dip, whipped cream and red, white and blue sprinkles
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Go Bananas $10.25
Handcrafted banana pudding ice cream with marshmallow sauce topped with vanilla custard, chocolate syrup, chopped banana chunks and whipped cream
Smores Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, graham cracker, whipped cream and a cherry. No Substitutions
Tropical Hurricane Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, pineapple, coconut, banana, pecans, whip cream, and a cherry. No substitutions
Chunky Monkey Sundae $10.25
Vanilla soft serve, fresh banana chunks, chocolate syrup, walnuts, whip cream and a cherry. No substitutions
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Dad's Cookie Monster Sundae $10.25
Hand crafted cookie monster ice cream with hot fudge topped with vanilla custard, chocolate sauce, Oreos & chocolate chip cookie crumbles and whipped cream
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Lucky Leprechaun Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted mint chip ice cream and fudge sauce topped with vanilla custard, mint sauce, whipped cream and mint/chocolate sprinkles
Fudge Brownie Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, moist brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. No substitutions
Buttery Blast Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, butterscotch sauce, crushed butterfinger, whip cream, and a cherry. No Substitutions
Premium Sundae Of The Week: Strawberry Rhubarb Sundae $10.25
Handcrafted strawberry rhubarb ice cream with strawberry topping, topped with vanilla custard, rhubarb sauce and whipped cream
Nutty Buddy Sundae $10.25
Vanilla custard, hot fudge, pieces of sugar cone, peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry. No substitutions

Main Street Ice Cream Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Seating
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Main Street Ice Cream Photos

Main Street Ice Cream Location

Main Street Ice Cream

New York Erie County Hamburg Main Street

35 Main St Suite A, Hamburg, NY 14075, USA

Main Street Ice Cream Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 367 user reviews.

flavorspricessundaesmilkshakesscoopsgluten freeconecustardpumpkindole whip

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

A quaint ice cream stop in the Southtowns. Service was fast and the staff was friendly. If you are passing through the Village of Hamburg, be sure to visit Main Street Ice Cream.
July 09 · Michael Kuzma
This place is such a gem! We enjoyed some ice cream here a few weeks ago while in town visiting with family. I am still dreaming about the cannoli flavored ice cream and the chocolate orange ice cream (both small batch special flavors) 🤤Love the vibe of this small hometown shop!
July 20 · Heather Pedigo
Good ice cream, fun flavorsSeemed like the staff wasn't really quick to help, they were friendly but they all looked confused. Very small space inside. If you go there plan to eat outside.
July 13 · Amanda Dulaney
Super friendly service and a great variety of unique homemade ice creams, along with the usuals. This trip we enjoyed the special 4th of July flavor along with their coconut ice cream. Both very good! We'll keep coming back
July 05 · Erin Redmond
Excellent homemade ice cream, amazing and unique flavors. Not great at getting the portions right tho - my 2 scoops of ice cream were about the same size as some else's 1 scoop
July 05 · Greg Mavissakalian