Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop: Gourmet Ice Cream in Jersey City

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Introduce

Welcome, New Jersey locals, especially those residing in and around the vibrant community of Jersey City! As professional content writers specializing in local business SEO, we are excited to introduce you to a truly special establishment that's making waves in the local dessert scene: Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop. This independent shop, while compact, offers a genuinely gourmet ice cream experience that stands out for its high quality, unique flavors, and handcrafted approach. It's a place where passion for ice cream and baking clearly shines through, offering a delightful escape for those seeking something beyond the ordinary.

Our goal with this article is to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop. We aim to help local users in the New Jersey region discover what makes this place a must-try for discerning ice cream lovers. We’ll explore its cozy location, the innovative services and products it offers, and the special features that contribute to its charm. While our tone will be friendly and slightly promotional, our core commitment is to deliver accurate and factual information, based on publicly available data and genuine customer feedback. We understand that supporting small businesses, especially in a competitive market like ice cream, holds significant value for many in our community, and Milk Sugar Love exemplifies real effort and creativity that deserves recognition.

From unique ice cream flavors like Honey Lavender and Lemon Olive Oil to delicious bakeshop items like ice cream sandwiches and cookies, Milk Sugar Love strives to deliver a memorable experience. Despite its "pricy" nature as noted by some, the consensus leans towards the quality making it "worth it." Whether you're a long-time resident or new to Jersey City, this guide will help you understand why Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop is a cherished addition to our local culinary landscape. Let's delve into what makes this spot a true gem for gourmet frozen treats.

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop, located at 19 McWilliams Pl, Jersey City, NJ 07302, USA, enjoys a charming and convenient position within the Hamilton Park neighborhood of Jersey City. This area is known for its beautiful namesake park, historic brownstones, and a friendly, residential atmosphere, making it a desirable spot for both families and individuals. The shop's location on McWilliams Place means it's nestled slightly off the main thoroughfares, yet remains easily accessible to residents of Hamilton Park and surrounding areas.

For those relying on public transportation, the accessibility of Milk Sugar Love is quite good. While not directly adjacent to a PATH station, it is within a reasonable walking distance from the Grove Street PATH station, which provides direct links to Manhattan and other parts of New Jersey. Several NJ Transit bus lines also operate in the vicinity of Hamilton Park, offering convenient connections from various parts of Jersey City. This allows customers to reach the creamery without necessarily needing a car, making it a viable option for a wider audience.

For customers who prefer to drive, street parking in the Hamilton Park neighborhood can sometimes be found, though it may require a bit of searching, especially during peak hours. The residential nature of the area means that parking is primarily street-side. However, the intimate and walkable character of the neighborhood encourages local foot traffic, ensuring that the shop is easily discoverable for those strolling through the area or enjoying Hamilton Park. The small size of the shop, offering primarily a "to-go option," aligns well with the neighborhood's charm and encourages customers to enjoy their treats in the nearby park or while exploring the local streets. This blend of community-centric location and moderate accessibility makes Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop a pleasant destination for a dedicated visit, appealing to those who appreciate a local, independent business.

Services Offered:

Handmade, small-batch gourmet ice cream with a focus on unique and natural flavors.
A rotating selection of distinctive ice cream flavors such as Honey Lavender, Classic Chocolate, Lemon Olive Oil, Earl Grey Fudge, Matcha Cookie, Malted Cookie, Alfajores 'n' Cream, Guava Cream Cheese, Midnight Cocoa, and more.
Ice cream available by the scoop (cups or cones) and in pints for take-home enjoyment.
Handmade ice cream sandwiches featuring their unique ice cream flavors paired with freshly baked cookies (e.g., Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich, Birthday Sprinkle, Red Velvet Dream, Coffee Chip, Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy).
Custom ice cream cakes, including classic options like "The Classic 6" Ice Cream Cake."
A selection of bakeshop items such as Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies, Fudge Brownies, Magic Bars, Raspberry Crumb Bars, and cupcakes.
"To-go" focus, perfect for enjoying treats in Hamilton Park across the street.
Online ordering for pickup is available.
Cashier service with staff who are straightforward and focused on efficiency and explaining unique flavors.

Features / Highlights:

Genuinely Gourmet Quality:
Unique and Inventive Flavors:
Handmade Excellence:
Independent Small Business Charm:
Delicious Ice Cream Sandwiches:
Friendly Staff (Cashier Lilia noted):
Cozy and Tidy Space:
Proximity to Hamilton Park:

Contact Information:

Address: 19 McWilliams Pl, Jersey City, NJ 07302, USA

Phone: (551) 277-8252

In conclusion, Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop at 19 McWilliams Pl in Jersey City, NJ, is an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended destination for locals in the New Jersey region seeking a genuinely gourmet and unique ice cream experience. While some customers note that it is "pricy" for a single scoop, the overwhelming sentiment is that the "quality holds up" and the handcrafted flavors are "worth the try." The shop's commitment to creating inventive, natural, and often organic flavors, such as the praised Honey Lavender and Lemon Olive Oil, truly sets it apart from more conventional ice cream parlors. This dedication to unique tastes and high-quality ingredients is a significant draw for discerning palates.

The charm of Milk Sugar Love also stems from its identity as a small, independent business. In a competitive market, patrons express a strong desire to "support a small business" that demonstrates "real effort and creativity." This resonates deeply with the local community, fostering a sense of connection and appreciation for unique, non-franchise establishments. Despite its "very tiny" space primarily offering "to-go" options, its tidy and cute interior, coupled with the proximity to Hamilton Park, provides an ideal setting for enjoying your gourmet treat outdoors. The positive mention of "Cashier Lilia" for her "lovely" demeanor and "great customer service" also highlights the personal touch that a small business can offer, creating a welcoming environment. For New Jersey locals who prioritize handcrafted quality, unique flavor profiles, and supporting independent ventures, Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop is a delightful and deserving addition to their must-visit list, promising a delicious and memorable experience that justifies the premium price point.

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Food & drink

Ice Cream Pints
Alfajores 'n' Cream Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Sweet Cream ice cream with Alfajores cookies---light buttery cookies filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut. Contains Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Coconut)
Classic Chocolate Ice Cream Pint $14.00
Chocolate ice cream made with melted 72% chocolate. Contains Milk, Soy.
Earl Grey Fudge Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Earl grey tea infused ice cream with a generous ripple of house made fudge. Contains Milk, Soy.
Guava Cream Cheese Ice Cream Pint $14.00
Cream Cheese ice cream with our own Guava ripple. Contains Milk.
Hazelnut Chip Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Hazelnut ice cream with dark chocolate flakes. Contains Milk, Soy.
Honey Lavender Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Honey ice cream made with local honey and gently infused with lavender. Contains Milk.
Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Creamy lemon olive oil ice cream made with lemon-infused Sicilian olive oil. Contains Milk.
Malted Cookie Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Our #1 seller from day 1! Malted milk ice cream swirled with our housemade sea salt chocolate chip cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy
Matcha Cookie Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Matcha ice cream chock full of our very own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.
Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Jet black ice cream made with activated charcoal and cocoa powder. Contains Milk, Soy.
Nate's Mango Tamarind Jam $12.00
PRE-ORDER FOR PICKUP SEPTEMBER 6Fresh and creamy mango ice cream rippled with sweet-and-sour tamarind jam.This special flavor is made in collaboration with ice cream fanatic Nate Esquite, guitarist from the band A R I Z O N A. Nate will be scooping behind the counter on the release day, Saturday September 6 so come say hi!
Goldrush Coffee's Egyptian Baklava $14.00
PRE-ORDER FOR PICKUP SEPTEMBER 19Pistachio ice cream studded with pieces of Goldrush Coffee's own baklava---made with deeply toastedpistachios and an orange blossom water syrup.Contains Milk, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Pistachios)
Goldrush Egyptian Baklava $14.00
PRE-ORDER FOR PICKUP SEPTEMBER 19Pistachio ice cream studded with pieces of Goldrush Coffee's own baklava---made with deeply toastedpistachios and an orange blossom water syrup.Contains Milk, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Pistachios)
Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Caramel ice cream made with just enough sea salt to enhance its rich flavor. Contains Milk.
Strawberry Ice Cream Pint $12.00
A childhood favorite made only with pureed strawberries---never any artificial colors or flavors. Contains Milk;
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint $12.00
America's favorite flavor, made with real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract. Contains Milk.

Ice Cream Sandwiches
Coffee Chip Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two handmade Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with our Parlor Coffee Ice Cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
Birthday Sprinkle Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two Confetti Sugar Cookies filled with Vanilla ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
Red Velvet Dream Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two handmade Red Velvet White Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
The Peanut Butter Brownie $8.00
Two of our own fudge brownies filled with Peanut Butter ice cream and candied peanuts, dipped in dark chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Peanuts, Soy
Specialty Pint: Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy ice cream sandwich $8.00
Two French Macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs

Ice Cream Cakes
The Midnight Cookie 6 Ice Cream Cake $40.00
Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy. *NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
Super Sammie Ice Cream Cake $45.00
Vanilla Bean ice cream rolled in rainbow sprinkles and sandwiched between 2 Giant chocolate chip cookies!Contains Milk, Eggs, Soy, Wheat*NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
The Fruity Cereal 6 Mac Daddy Ice Cream Cake2 $45.00
A 6 cake made with two giant French macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs, Soy. *NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
The 6 Classic Ice Cream Cake $45.00
Layers of Vanilla Bean ice cream, Classic Chocolate ice cream and Chocolate Cookie Crunch decorated with Specialty Rainbow Sprinkles.Contains Milk, Soy, Wheat*NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
Sugar Paste Message Plaque $5.00
A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your custom message in edible ink. Let us know your special message so we can inscribe it for you! *MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21* *PLAQUES ARE BLANK AND WE WRITE YOUR CUSTOM MESSAGE ON THEM---THE PRODUCT PHOTO IS AN EXAMPLE ONLY*

Bakeshop Treats
1 Fudge Brownie $5.25
Made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
1 Matcha Brownie $4.50
A cross between a brownie and a blondie, chewy and bright green, made with matcha powder and white chocolate. Contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs
1 Magic Bar $4.50
A salted graham crust covered with layers of chocolate, coconut, dulce de leche, toffee, raisins and toasted almonds. Contains wheat, milk, tree nuts (coconut and almonds).
1 Raspberry Crumb Bar $4.50
Brown sugar shortbread crust with layers of raspberry jam and brown sugar crumb topping. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
1 Toffee Walnut Blondie $4.50
Made with brown butter, toasted walnuts, handmade toffee pieces and a sprinkling of chocolate chunks on top. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy, Tree Nuts (Walnuts)
1 Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.95
Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
1 Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies $19.50
Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Soy
Confetti Cookie $1.95
All butter sugar cookie with Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
Red Velvet Dark Chocolate $1.95
Red Velvet cookie with dark chocolate chips. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
Snickerdoodle $1.95
A cakey, fluffy sugar cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.

Single Serve Non-Dairy
Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy Mint Chip $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Mint Chip---a non-dairy ice cream made with Oatly Oat Milk, Mint and Vanilla extracts and dark chocolate flakes. Contains Soy.***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough---a non-dairy Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough pieces. Contains Soy, Peanuts. ***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Cookie Butter $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Cookie Butter---a non-dairy ice cream made with Cookie Butter (think crushed graham crackers and fall spices) and Soy Milk. Contains Soy, Wheat***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***

Merchandise
Milk Sugar Love Mug $9.50
A 10oz ceramic pink mug with chocolate brown logo on the front ---- perfect for a cup of hot chocolate at home! Handwash recommended.
Milk Sugar Love Cooler Bag $10.00
A chocolate brown insulated tote that carries 4 pints PLUS a reusable cold brick!
Milk Sugar Love Classic T-Shirt $20.00
Available in Small only with a hand-drawn illustration by Nanu Studios in Hoboken!

Ice Cream Pints
Alfajores 'n' Cream Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Sweet Cream ice cream with Alfajores cookies---light buttery cookies filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut. Contains Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Coconut)
Classic Chocolate Ice Cream Pint $14.00
Chocolate ice cream made with melted 72% chocolate. Contains Milk, Soy.
Earl Grey Fudge Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Earl grey tea infused ice cream with a generous ripple of house made fudge. Contains Milk, Soy.
Guava Cream Cheese Ice Cream Pint $14.00
Cream Cheese ice cream with our own Guava ripple. Contains Milk.
Hazelnut Chip Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Hazelnut ice cream with dark chocolate flakes. Contains Milk, Soy.
Honey Lavender Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Honey ice cream made with local honey and gently infused with lavender. Contains Milk.
Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Creamy lemon olive oil ice cream made with lemon-infused Sicilian olive oil. Contains Milk.
Malted Cookie Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Our #1 seller from day 1! Malted milk ice cream swirled with our housemade sea salt chocolate chip cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy
Matcha Cookie Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Matcha ice cream chock full of our very own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.
Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Jet black ice cream made with activated charcoal and cocoa powder. Contains Milk, Soy.
Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Caramel ice cream made with just enough sea salt to enhance its rich flavor. Contains Milk.
Strawberry Ice Cream Pint $12.00
A childhood favorite made only with pureed strawberries---never any artificial colors or flavors. Contains Milk;
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint $12.00
America's favorite flavor, made with real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract. Contains Milk.
Specialty Pint: Carmen Rosa's Dominican Cake $14.00
Almond ice cream with our own Guava Jam, blue meringue swirls and pieces of fluffy, buttery Dominican Cake from Carmen Rosa's Bakery in Jersey City. Contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts (Almonds)
Specialty Pint: Sour Cream Blueberry $12.00
Smooth and creamy Sour Cream ice cream rippled with our own New Jersey Blueberry Jam. Contains Milk

Ice Cream Cakes
The Midnight Cookie 6 Ice Cream Cake $40.00
Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy. *NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
Super Sammie Ice Cream Cake $45.00
Vanilla Bean ice cream rolled in rainbow sprinkles and sandwiched between 2 Giant chocolate chip cookies!Contains Milk, Eggs, Soy, Wheat*NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
The Fruity Cereal 6 Mac Daddy Ice Cream Cake2 $45.00
A 6 cake made with two giant French macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs, Soy. *NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
The 6 Classic Ice Cream Cake $45.00
Layers of Vanilla Bean ice cream, Classic Chocolate ice cream and Chocolate Cookie Crunch decorated with Specialty Rainbow Sprinkles.Contains Milk, Soy, Wheat*NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
Sugar Paste Message Plaque $5.00
A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your custom message in edible ink. Let us know your special message so we can inscribe it for you! *MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21* *PLAQUES ARE BLANK AND WE WRITE YOUR CUSTOM MESSAGE ON THEM---THE PRODUCT PHOTO IS AN EXAMPLE ONLY*

Ice Cream Sandwiches
Coffee Chip Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two handmade Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with our Parlor Coffee Ice Cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
Birthday Sprinkle Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two Confetti Sugar Cookies filled with Vanilla ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
Red Velvet Dream Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two handmade Red Velvet White Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
The Peanut Butter Brownie $8.00
Two of our own fudge brownies filled with Peanut Butter ice cream and candied peanuts, dipped in dark chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Peanuts, Soy
Specialty Pint: Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy ice cream sandwich $8.00
Two French Macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs

Single Serve Non-Dairy
Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy Mint Chip $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Mint Chip---a non-dairy ice cream made with Oatly Oat Milk, Mint and Vanilla extracts and dark chocolate flakes. Contains Soy.***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough---a non-dairy Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough pieces. Contains Soy, Peanuts. ***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Cookie Butter $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Cookie Butter---a non-dairy ice cream made with Cookie Butter (think crushed graham crackers and fall spices) and Soy Milk. Contains Soy, Wheat***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***

Bakeshop Treats
1 Matcha Brownie $4.50
A cross between a brownie and a blondie, chewy and bright green, made with matcha powder and white chocolate. Contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs
1 Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies $19.50
Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Soy
1 Fudge Brownie $5.25
Made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
Confetti Cookie $1.95
All butter sugar cookie with Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
Red Velvet Dark Chocolate $1.95
Red Velvet cookie with dark chocolate chips. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
Snickerdoodle $1.95
A cakey, fluffy sugar cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
1 Magic Bar $4.50
A salted graham crust covered with layers of chocolate, coconut, dulce de leche, toffee, raisins and toasted almonds. Contains wheat, milk, tree nuts (coconut and almonds).
1 Raspberry Crumb Bar $4.50
Brown sugar shortbread crust with layers of raspberry jam and brown sugar crumb topping. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
1 Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.95
Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
1 Toffee Walnut Blondie $4.50
Made with brown butter, toasted walnuts, handmade toffee pieces and a sprinkling of chocolate chunks on top. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy, Tree Nuts (Walnuts)

Merchandise
Milk Sugar Love Mug $9.50
A 10oz ceramic pink mug with chocolate brown logo on the front ---- perfect for a cup of hot chocolate at home! Handwash recommended.
Milk Sugar Love Cooler Bag $10.00
A chocolate brown insulated tote that carries 4 pints PLUS a reusable cold brick!
Milk Sugar Love Classic T-Shirt $20.00
Available in Small only with a hand-drawn illustration by Nanu Studios in Hoboken!

Ice Cream Cakes
The Midnight Cookie 6 Ice Cream Cake $40.00
Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy. *NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
Super Sammie Ice Cream Cake $45.00
Vanilla Bean ice cream rolled in rainbow sprinkles and sandwiched between 2 Giant chocolate chip cookies!Contains Milk, Eggs, Soy, Wheat*NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*
Sugar Paste Message Plaque $5.00
A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your custom message in edible ink. Let us know your special message so we can inscribe it for you! *MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21* *PLAQUES ARE BLANK AND WE WRITE YOUR CUSTOM MESSAGE ON THEM---THE PRODUCT PHOTO IS AN EXAMPLE ONLY*
The 6 Classic Ice Cream Cake $45.00
Layers of Vanilla Bean ice cream, Classic Chocolate ice cream and Chocolate Cookie Crunch decorated with Specialty Rainbow Sprinkles.Contains Milk, Soy, Wheat*NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Add a sugar paste message plaque to your order and specify your custom inscription in the order notes*

Ice Cream Sandwiches
Coffee Chip Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two handmade Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with our Parlor Coffee Ice Cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
Birthday Sprinkle Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two Confetti Sugar Cookies filled with Vanilla ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
Red Velvet Dream Ice Cream Sandwich $6.75
Two handmade Red Velvet White Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
The Peanut Butter Brownie $8.00
Two of our own fudge brownies filled with Peanut Butter ice cream and candied peanuts, dipped in dark chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Peanuts, Soy

Ice Cream Pints
Alfajores 'n' Cream Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Sweet Cream ice cream with Alfajores cookies---light buttery cookies filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut. Contains Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Coconut)
Classic Chocolate Ice Cream Pint $14.00
Chocolate ice cream made with melted 72% chocolate. Contains Milk, Soy.
Earl Grey Fudge Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Earl grey tea infused ice cream with a generous ripple of house made fudge. Contains Milk, Soy.
Guava Cream Cheese Ice Cream Pint $14.00
Cream Cheese ice cream with our own Guava ripple. Contains Milk.
Honey Lavender Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Honey ice cream made with local honey and gently infused with lavender. Contains Milk.
Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Creamy lemon olive oil ice cream made with lemon-infused Sicilian olive oil. Contains Milk.
Malted Cookie Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Our #1 seller from day 1! Malted milk ice cream swirled with our housemade sea salt chocolate chip cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy
Matcha Cookie Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Matcha ice cream chock full of our very own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.
Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Jet black ice cream made with activated charcoal and cocoa powder. Contains Milk, Soy.
Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pint $12.00
Caramel ice cream made with just enough sea salt to enhance its rich flavor. Contains Milk.
Strawberry Ice Cream Pint $12.00
A childhood favorite made only with pureed strawberries---never any artificial colors or flavors. Contains Milk;
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint $12.00
America's favorite flavor, made with real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract. Contains Milk.

Single Serve Non-Dairy
Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy Mint Chip $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Mint Chip---a non-dairy ice cream made with Oatly Oat Milk, Mint and Vanilla extracts and dark chocolate flakes. Contains Soy.***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough---a non-dairy Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough pieces. Contains Soy, Peanuts. ***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Cookie Butter $8.25
A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Cookie Butter---a non-dairy ice cream made with Cookie Butter (think crushed graham crackers and fall spices) and Soy Milk. Contains Soy, Wheat***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***

Bakeshop Treats
1 Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies $19.50
Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Soy
1 Fudge Brownie $5.25
Made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
1 Magic Bar $4.50
A salted graham crust covered with layers of chocolate, coconut, dulce de leche, toffee, raisins and toasted almonds. Contains wheat, milk, tree nuts (coconut and almonds).
1 Raspberry Crumb Bar $4.50
Brown sugar shortbread crust with layers of raspberry jam and brown sugar crumb topping. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
1 Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.95
Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy

Catering
Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our cookies are baked fresh for your order and made with all butter and dark and milk chocolates. Cookies come packaged in a white bakery box.
Fudge Brownies
Our delicious fudge brownies made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together. Packaged in a white bakery box.
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Sandwiches are individually packaged with ingredient and allergen information.If you are traveling further than 15 minutes away, please add the foam cooler and dry ice option to your order. Our ice cream is all natural, without any chemical stabilizers and will begin to melt immediately without the protection of dry ice and an insulated cooler.BIRTHDAY SPRINKLE: Two Confetti Sugar Cookies filled with Vanilla ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.COFFEE CHIP: Two handmade Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with Coffee Ice Cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.RED VELVET DREAM: Two handmade Red Velvet White Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.FRUITY CEREAL MAC DADDY: Two Fruity Cereal French Macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs.
Single Serve Ice Cream Cups
Individual 5 oz cups with lids, labels and allergen information.If you are traveling further than 15 minutes away, please add the foam cooler and dry ice option to your order. Our ice cream is all natural, without any chemical stabilizers and will begin to melt immediately without the protection of dry ice and an insulated cooler.Available Flavors:Vanilla Bean, Classic Chocolate, Strawberry, Salted Caramel, Honey Lavender, Earl Grey Fudge, Guava Cream Cheese, Alfajores 'n' Cream, Matcha Cookie, Malted Cookie, Midnight Cocoa
Coolers with Dry Ice $100.00
An insulated foam cooler (19 1/2 x 12 1/2 x 12 1/2 - 1 1/2 Thick) perfect for transporting ice cream sandwich orders or single serve ice cream cups. Includes enough dry ice to store product inside for up to 24 hours. Can fit up to 48 single serve cups and up to 48 ice cream sandwiches.
Hot Chocolate Service for 48 $125.00
Our handmade hot chocolate in a disposable kraft beverage dispenser (keeps beverages hot for up to 3 hours). Comes with 10oz cups and lids, a can of whipped cream and a bag of 25 of our Vanilla Bean Marshmallows.

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Children
Good for kids

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Photos

No photos available at the moment.

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Location

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop

New Jersey Hudson County Jersey City Hamilton Park McWilliams Place

19 McWilliams Pl, Jersey City, NJ 07302, USA

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 480 user reviews.

flavorsscoopstorico ice creamearl greyhoneyolive oillavenderice cream sandwichescocoared velvet

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Finally gave this place a try! IT’S PRICEY $6.50 (1 scoop), BUT the quality holds up— GENUINELY GOURMET. The staff is straightforward without much personality. They are not trying to charm you, just there to keep the line moving & explain the unique flavors..The space is small.. It’s clearly an independent shop still finding its rhythm, which adds to its charm.A newcomer in the ice cream game without a franchise backing, hence, the premium. A good spot to try when you have extra money to spare.The rating should probably be lower, but I still want to support a small business—especially in the tough, competitive world of ice cream. It’s not like cafes, which are a more common and arguably easier type of business to start and sustain. There’s real effort and creativity behind this, and that deserves recognition.
June 25 · s e
Great place with handmade ice-cream. Honey lavender and classic chocolate are my favorite, tastes very natural. The place is very tiny, offers only to-go option, but inside is very tidy and cute. Cashier Lilia is very lovely, great customer service! 5 stars!
November 30 · Dariia Miroshnychenko
It’s really delicious ice cream with unique & seasonal flavors. If you are deciding between ice cream shops to go to in JC, this is the best scoop in terms of quality. The only downside is that it’s pretty expensive, these days $6 for a small.
July 05 · audrey
Waited in line at 9.45 for ice cream. They close at 10pm. We were the next customers ready to walk in the door and at 9.58 a girl came out and told us they were closed after seeing us wait for the past 15 minutes, understand they close at 10pm but did not come out and give us or the other customer behind us any warning or come out 5 minutes beforehand to let us know they would not be serving us. We said we had been waiting and she rudely shut the door on us. Will 100% not be going back as this is not the first bad customer experience I’ve had.
June 06 · hayley kiriposki
Probably the best ice cream cookie sandwich I've ever had in my life. I try not to toss that around lightly.The cookies were so good and tasted homemade. The sea salt that you taste on each bite of the gooey chocolate chip cookie just adds a whole flavor to each bite. Then there's a hefty size scoop of ice cream that gets sandwiched between the cookies.I think it's the best bang for your buck over here at MSL. Will definitely come back whenever I'm in the area. The flavors are also so different from other creameries that you see around here.
August 11 · Chris Sandoli