Nicky Doodles

Located within the bustling New Hartford Shopping Center at 54 New Hartford Shopping Center, New Hartford, NY 13413, Nicky Doodles stands as a long-standing local eatery that offers more than just ice cream. For residents of New Hartford and the wider New York region, particularly those in Central New York, this establishment has built a reputation for its remarkable consistency in savory food items, alongside its frozen treats. While the ice cream experience can sometimes present challenges, the enduring appeal of its classic dishes keeps patrons returning year after year. This overview aims to provide a comprehensive look at what makes Nicky Doodles a unique spot in the local culinary landscape, from its convenient location to its diverse menu.

In the competitive food scene of New York, a business that can maintain a consistent taste profile over many years is a true gem. Nicky Doodles exemplifies this, with loyal customers repeatedly highlighting the unchanging flavor of their favorite dishes, such as the chicken pita. This reliability is a powerful draw, offering a comforting sense of familiarity in an ever-changing world. It’s this dedication to consistency that fosters deep customer loyalty, turning first-time visitors into regulars who trust that their beloved order will taste exactly as they remember it.

While the "ice cream shop" designation is part of its identity, Nicky Doodles’ offering extends far beyond just frozen desserts. The positive feedback for its "macaroni salad, potato salad and onion rings" indicates a strong foundation in classic American comfort food. This diverse menu positions Nicky Doodles not just as a place for a sweet treat, but as a viable option for a full meal, catering to a broader range of dining needs. The heartfelt plea from a customer not to close this location, referencing a past closure in North Utica, further underscores the deep connection the community has with this particular establishment. This article will delve into the various aspects that make Nicky Doodles a suitable and much-loved destination for locals in New York, ensuring they have all the information needed to explore its offerings.

Whether you’re in search of a nostalgic savory meal or a classic ice cream, Nicky Doodles offers a blend of consistent quality and diverse options that keeps its doors open and its customers coming back, solidifying its place as a New Hartford institution.

---

Nicky Doodles is conveniently located at 54 New Hartford Shopping Center, New Hartford, NY 13413, USA. This placement within a shopping center is a significant advantage, offering prime visibility and excellent accessibility for residents of New Hartford and the wider New York region, particularly those in Central New York.

The New Hartford Shopping Center is a well-established commercial hub, which means the area is accustomed to high foot and vehicle traffic. For customers arriving by car, the shopping center typically provides ample parking space, alleviating concerns about finding a spot. Its location within a shopping center also means it's often near other retail outlets and services, making it a convenient stop during a shopping trip or an errand run. Public transportation options, if available in the New Hartford area, would likely serve a major shopping center, further enhancing its accessibility for non-drivers. The ease with which customers can reach Nicky Doodles, combined with the convenience of its surrounding amenities, makes it a practical and appealing destination for a quick meal or treat.

---

• Ice Cream Offerings: Nicky Doodles provides a variety of ice cream options, including cones. While one review noted issues with fast melting, the "ice cream flavor was good," indicating a focus on taste.
• Savory Food Menu: Beyond ice cream, Nicky Doodles offers a full savory menu. A highly praised item is the "chicken pita," noted for its consistent taste year after year.
• Side Dishes: The menu also includes popular side dishes such as "macaroni salad," "potato salad," and "onion rings," which are well-received by customers.
• Consistent Food Quality: A core service highlight is the "consistency" of their savory food items, which keeps customers returning. This reliability in taste is a strong selling point.
• Take-Out Options: Given its nature as a quick-service eatery within a shopping center, take-out is certainly a primary service, allowing customers to enjoy their food and ice cream on the go.

---

• Unwavering Food Consistency: The most prominent highlight is the "consistency" of their savory food items, particularly the "chicken pita." This consistent taste "year after year" is a significant reason customers keep coming back, building strong loyalty.
• Diverse Menu Beyond Ice Cream: Nicky Doodles stands out by offering a substantial food menu in addition to ice cream. Items like "macaroni salad, potato salad and onion rings" are praised, making it a versatile eatery for full meals or snacks.
• Loyal Customer Base: The heartfelt plea from a customer not to close the New Hartford location, citing the closure of a previous North Utica branch, clearly demonstrates a deeply loyal and passionate customer base that values the specific offerings and consistency of this establishment.
• Friendly Staff: Despite an issue with the ice cream, a reviewer noted that the "Girls were nice," indicating a generally positive and friendly customer service experience.
• Established Local Presence: Having operated for a significant period (implied by "year after year" consistency and a past location), Nicky Doodles holds a well-recognized and cherished spot in the local community.
• Convenient Shopping Center Location: Being situated in the New Hartford Shopping Center provides high visibility, easy access, and ample parking, enhancing its convenience for everyday visits.

---

Address: 54 New Hartford Shopping Center, New Hartford, NY 13413, USA

Phone: (315) 732-2088

---

For the residents of New Hartford and the wider Central New York region, Nicky Doodles offers a compelling blend of consistency, variety, and community familiarity, making it a highly suitable and cherished local eatery. The most significant draw for locals is undoubtedly the remarkable consistency of its savory food menu, particularly the "chicken pita." In a world where tastes and establishments can change, the ability of Nicky Doodles to deliver the exact same beloved flavor "year after year" creates a powerful sense of comfort and reliability. This makes it a go-to spot for those seeking dependable and familiar comfort food, fostering strong customer loyalty.

Beyond the consistent quality of its main dishes, the diverse menu, including well-regarded sides like "macaroni salad, potato salad and onion rings," means that Nicky Doodles is more than just an ice cream stop. It serves as a versatile option for lunch, dinner, or a quick snack, catering to a wider range of daily needs for local families and individuals. This comprehensive offering enhances its utility as a regular dining choice within the community.

While a recent review noted challenges with the ice cream's melting speed and sprinkle aftertaste, the underlying flavor was still praised, and the staff were described as "nice." This suggests that even with occasional product-specific issues, the core quality of the ice cream itself and the positive human element of the service are present. The heartfelt sentiment from a customer about the closure of a previous location underscores the deep emotional connection many locals have with Nicky Doodles, highlighting its status as a valued community institution that people genuinely care about preserving.

Situated conveniently within the New Hartford Shopping Center, Nicky Doodles is easily accessible, providing ample parking and making it a practical stop during daily errands or shopping trips. For all these reasons – its consistent savory food, diverse menu, loyal customer base, and accessible location – Nicky Doodles remains a highly suitable and enduring favorite for locals in New Hartford, New York.

Nicky Doodles

54 New Hartford Shopping Center, New Hartford, NY 13413, USA