Nikki's Custard® Introduce
For residents of Pennsylvania, especially those in and around Lancaster County, the quest for the perfect sweet treat is a year-round affair. While the region is known for its rich history and beautiful farmlands, it also has a vibrant local food scene that includes some truly exceptional dessert spots. Among them, one name that has been gaining a loyal following is Nikki's Custard®. This local business has carved out a special niche by focusing on what it does best: crafting delicious, high-quality frozen custard. Unlike traditional ice cream, frozen custard is known for its denser, richer, and creamier texture, which makes for a truly decadent experience. Nikki's Custard® has embraced this tradition, offering a straightforward yet satisfying menu that allows customers to create their own perfect dessert. This approach has resonated with many locals, who appreciate the simplicity and the quality of the product. The shop has become a go-to destination for families, friends, and individuals looking for a delightful conclusion to their day or a sweet pick-me-up. With a focus on customer service and a charming atmosphere, Nikki's Custard® has quickly become a standout in the bustling Lancaster food scene. Whether you're a long-time resident or a visitor exploring the area, a stop at this establishment is a great way to experience a local favorite and indulge in a treat that is both familiar and uniquely delicious. This guide will provide an in-depth look at what makes Nikki's Custard® a must-visit spot, from its location and offerings to its unique features and overall appeal, helping you plan your next sweet adventure in Lancaster, PA.
Nikki's Custard® is conveniently located at 1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, USA. Situated on a main road, Oregon Pike (PA-272), the shop is highly accessible for those traveling by car from various parts of Lancaster and beyond. The location is easily found and offers a straightforward stop for a quick treat. While the area can be busy, the shoppe's presence on a major thoroughfare makes it a practical choice for both locals running errands and tourists exploring the county. Parking is available, making it easy to pull in and enjoy your dessert without the hassle of navigating congested urban areas. The shop's location also places it in a great spot for a stop after visiting some of Lancaster County's well-known attractions. Whether you're coming from a day of shopping in downtown Lancaster or exploring the scenic farmlands, Oregon Pike provides a direct and accessible route. A recent customer noted that when they pulled into the location, they weren't sure what to expect, but were immediately delighted with the visual appeal of the place. It's the kind of spot that is easy to get to and provides a welcoming atmosphere from the moment you arrive. This accessibility, combined with the clear signage and attractive exterior, ensures that Nikki's Custard® is a convenient and inviting destination for anyone with a craving for a high-quality frozen treat. The absence of a large, complex parking lot is offset by the ease of access and the general flow of traffic in the area, making it a stress-free stop for a delicious dessert.
Nikki's Custard® offers a focused yet customizable menu, ensuring a satisfying experience for every customer. Their services are centered around their core product, delicious frozen custard.
- Build-Your-Own Custard: The menu is designed to be straightforward and customer-friendly. Guests can create their own custom custard treats, choosing from a variety of options to personalize their dessert exactly how they like it. This flexibility is a major draw for people who enjoy tailoring their food.
- Delicious Frozen Custard: The primary offering is the frozen custard itself, which is praised for being "definitely delicious." Customers appreciate the rich, creamy texture that sets it apart from traditional ice cream.
- Great Variety to Choose From: Despite the straightforward concept, the shoppe provides a "great variety to choose from," which likely includes different flavors of custard, toppings, and mix-ins. This variety ensures that every visit can offer a new and exciting combination.
- Helpful and Friendly Staff: Customer service is a highlight at Nikki's Custard®. Reviews mention that employees are "very nice" and clearly explain the ordering process, which is especially helpful for first-time visitors who are new to the build-your-own concept.
What sets Nikki's Custard® apart as a local favorite in Lancaster, PA?
- Charming Outdoor Patio and Mural: A standout feature is the "cute outdoor patio seating" and a "beautiful mural" that adorns the location. This creates a charming and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a treat on a nice day. It adds to the overall experience, making the visit more than just a quick stop.
- Fair Pricing: Customers consistently mention that the prices at Nikki's Custard® are "fair." This makes the high-quality, delicious custard an accessible treat for a wide range of budgets, encouraging repeat visits.
- Straightforward Menu: The "straightforward" menu with build-your-own options is a major highlight. It simplifies the ordering process, making it easy and enjoyable for everyone, regardless of age or familiarity with the shop.
- Local Community Feel: The shoppe has a strong local business feel, attracting a loyal following. It's a place that feels like a part of the community, where the focus is on a quality product and a positive customer experience.
To learn more or to plan your visit, you can contact Nikki's Custard® using the following details:
Address: 1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, USA
Phone: (717) 517-8439
Mobile Phone: +1 717-517-8439
In a region celebrated for its local flavor, Nikki's Custard® has established itself as a must-visit destination for those in Pennsylvania. For locals in Lancaster and surrounding areas, this shoppe is more than just a place to get dessert; it's a reliable and delightful stop for a high-quality treat. The focus on rich, delicious frozen custard, paired with a straightforward build-your-own menu, makes the experience both simple and satisfying. The customer-friendly approach, where employees clearly explain the process, ensures that every visitor feels welcomed and well-cared for. A major draw is the charming outdoor patio and beautiful mural, which provides a lovely setting to enjoy your custard, especially during warmer months. The fair pricing and great variety of options make it an accessible and appealing choice for families and individuals alike. Although the lack of indoor seating is a consideration on rainy or cold days, the overall positive experience, highlighted by glowing reviews, makes it a top recommendation. For residents who appreciate supporting local businesses and value a combination of quality product, fair prices, and a pleasant atmosphere, Nikki's Custard® is an ideal choice. It’s a place that adds to the unique charm of Lancaster County, offering a sweet, memorable escape right on Oregon Pike. It truly is a local gem that any Pennsylvanian with a sweet tooth should make a point to visit.
Nikki's Custard® Food & drink
SIZE
- Rocksolid - 12oz. MINI $6.94
12oz. Our version of a concrete, blended with toppings (milkshake without the milk). Have fun with it!
- Milkshake - 16oz. REG $8.14
16oz. We use whole milk. We do offer oat milk for a 'plant milk' alternative. Create to your heart's content!
- Pint $8.38
Creativity is a must! If you need more than (4) pints of any one flavor, please call the shop to order. 717-517-8439
- Rocksolid - 16oz. REG $7.90
16oz. Our version of a concrete, blended with toppings (milkshake without the milk). Have fun with it!
- Add On - Sides $0.00
Side of sauces, nuts or toppings - provided in a separate container
- Milkshake - 12oz. MINI $7.18
12oz. We use whole milk. We do offer oat milk for a 'plant milk' alternative. Create to your heart's content!
- Single Cup $4.66
1 scoop
- Double Cup $6.94
Two scoops
- Kids Cup $2.83
1/2 scoop in a cup.
Nikki's Custard® Details
Service options
- Takeout
- Delivery
Popular for
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Dining options
- Table service
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Trendy
Crowd
- Groups
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Nikki's Custard® Photos










Nikki's Custard® Location
Nikki's Custard®
1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, USA
Nikki's Custard® Reviews
toppingsauceveganfrozen custardflavorvanilla custardoat milkdairy freespoonscolors
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Loved my visit to Nikki’s Custard! As soon as I walked in, an employee clearly explained everything and how to order, which made it really easy. The workers were all very nice, and they have a great variety to choose from. The custard was definitely delicious, and the prices are fair. A must-visit spot!
April 27 · Simi OdetteWe stopped at Nikki’s Custard right before close on a Sunday night because we were craving a sweet treat to conclude our weekend. When we pulled into the location on Oregon Pike, we were unsure what to expect - but we were immediately delighted with the beautiful mural and cute outdoor patio seating. The menu was straightforward with build-your-own custard treats. It was delicious (but maybe next time we won’t come on a rainy day - we didn’t realize there wouldn’t be indoor seating)!
May 18 · MC ReviewsAmazing! Hands down the best custard I’ve ever tried. The prices were pretty reasonable. A kids size was less than 2$. I tried the vanilla custard with strawberry and graham crackers. I highly recommend the combination! They have a parking lot.
May 25 · C PortilloJust tried out Nikki’s with my family today and it’s safe to say I will be coming back! Blonde girl at the front was very friendly and funny—offering samples of not only custard but sauces too! Made the selection process easier for someone who is indecisive. Custard tasted fresh and absolutely delicious. Overall has great food for great prices served by great staff members.
July 19 · Happy BopThe best ice cream hands down!!!!! I always get some type of non dairy. It is the best vegan ice cream around here. Perfect soft serve consistency. I just tried the non dairy cookie dough and let me tell you, this is my new favorite. The spoons are THE CUTEST. Hot pink and then when they touch the ice cream it turns purple. They switch their flavors every week, so make sure to follow them on Facebook!! You get the scoop on their page, pun intended!! Thank you for being such an amazing business and catering to people with allergens and different dietary views
April 23 · Alisha
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me
Good Life Ice Cream & Treats4.0 (151 reviews)2088 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, USA
Penny's Ice Cream3.0 (4 reviews)595 N Charlotte St, Lancaster, PA 17603, USA
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard4.0 (119 reviews)1585 Manheim Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, USA
Splits and Giggles Cafe4.0 (453 reviews)500 W Lemon St, Lancaster, PA 17603, USA
Rolled Cold Creamery4.0 (922 reviews)24 E Orange St, Lancaster, PA 17602, USA
Mezcla Ice Cream4.0 (76 reviews)318 S Duke St, Lancaster, PA 17602, USA
The Milkhouse at Oregon Dairy4.0 (865 reviews)2900 Oregon Pike, Lititz, PA 17543, USA
Freeze & Frizz Drive-In, LLC4.0 (721 reviews)2250 New Holland Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, USA
Son's4.0 (691 reviews)1991 Miller Rd, East Petersburg, PA 17520, USA
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard4.0 (216 reviews)46 Peters Rd, Lititz, PA 17543, USA
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard4.0 (285 reviews)1951 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster, PA 17602, USA
Dairy Queen4.0 (765 reviews)1935 Columbia Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Tsitsiki Ice Cream & Snacks5.0 (42 reviews)
Pamala's Ice Cream4.0 (96 reviews)
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream Twinsburg4.0 (602 reviews)
Wolfie's Ice Cream4.0 (383 reviews)
Utterly Ice Cream, Coffee and Cereal Bar4.0 (43 reviews)
Dairy Isle4.0 (440 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts
Is Ice Cream Better Than Frozen Yogurt? Let's Settle the Debate
Why You Should Try Making Your Own Ice Cream at Home – Flavor, Fun, and Freedom
Why Ice Cream is the Perfect Dessert for Your Next Party
Exploring the World of Gelato vs. Ice Cream
Why Ice Cream is the Ultimate Comfort Food During Winter
Why Ice Cream Parlors Are Replacing Fast Food Chains in the US 
