Norma Jean's Ice Cream

Nestled in the heart of Borden, Indiana, you'll find a true local gem that captures the spirit of a classic American small town: Norma Jean's Ice Cream. This isn't just an ice cream shop; it's a community hub, a destination for families, friends, and anyone craving a taste of nostalgia. With a friendly atmosphere and a menu that goes far beyond just sweet treats, Norma Jean's has become a cherished part of Southern Indiana life. Locals know that a visit here is more than just grabbing a cone—it's an experience that brings people together. From the vibrant, colorful chairs that line the creek-side to the welcoming staff who treat every customer like family, this is the kind of place that creates lasting memories.

The owners, Susan and Steve Williams, have deep roots in Borden, and their love for the community is evident in every detail. The shop is a tribute to Susan’s grandmother, Norma Jean, and her sister, who shared the same middle name, creating a deeply personal and heartwarming story behind the business. Since its opening, Norma Jean's has grown in popularity, drawing people from all over the region who are looking for a place to relax and enjoy life’s simple pleasures. This popularity is a testament to the quality of their food and treats, as well as the genuine, small-town charm that defines the establishment. Whether you're a lifelong resident of Borden or just passing through, you'll feel right at home at Norma Jean's Ice Cream. The unique blend of a welcoming environment and an extensive, delicious menu is what sets it apart and makes it a must-visit spot in the area.

More than just a seasonal destination for ice cream, Norma Jean's Ice Cream is a nostalgic institution. The phrase "I had a place like this growing up" is a common refrain heard from customers, highlighting its throwback feel. The vibrant chairs for both children and adults are lined along Muddy Fork, a small creek that winds its way through Borden, creating a picturesque backdrop. The combination of trees, moving water, and picnic tables provides the perfect setting for a relaxing break, whether you're enjoying a full meal or just a simple cone. The shop’s walk-up window adds to its classic charm, making the experience feel even more authentic and inviting. You’ll find that the atmosphere is as much a part of the experience as the food itself, fostering a sense of community that is hard to find elsewhere.

The popularity of Norma Jean's has grown steadily, and for good reason. It’s a place where everyone feels welcome, and the owners have a clear passion for what they do. Susan and Steve have made countless friendships with their customers, especially the children who visit regularly. They truly see their patrons as an extended family, which adds a personal touch that big-city establishments simply can't replicate. The welcoming environment and friendly staff are a huge part of the shop's appeal, making every visit a positive one. From the moment you approach the window, you're greeted with a smile and a sense of warmth that feels quintessentially Hoosier. It’s a spot that embodies the best of small-town living, where neighbors and visitors alike can come together to enjoy good food and great company.

Norma Jean's Ice Cream is conveniently located at 302 E Water St in Borden, IN 47106. Its prime location makes it easily accessible for anyone in the Borden community and surrounding areas. For those traveling by car, the shop is situated just off Indiana Highway 60, between New Albany and Salem, making it a great stopping point for a day trip or a weekend drive. There is ample parking available, and the walk-up window design ensures a quick and easy service experience. The shop’s layout, with its outdoor seating and picnic tables near the creek, is designed for accessibility and a relaxed atmosphere, allowing customers to enjoy their treats in a serene, natural setting. The casual, walk-up style is perfect for families with kids, cyclists on the nearby Monon South Trail, or anyone looking for a quick and delicious treat without the fuss of a formal restaurant.

The Monon South Trail, a popular destination for walkers, runners, and cyclists, runs nearby, making Norma Jean’s a perfect pit stop for a well-deserved break. The accessibility of the location combined with the inviting outdoor seating makes it an ideal spot for people of all ages and activity levels. Whether you're finishing a long bike ride or just taking the family out for an evening drive, getting to Norma Jean's is straightforward and stress-free. Its central location in Borden ensures that it remains a focal point for the community, a place where people can gather and reconnect. The ease of access, combined with the relaxing environment, is a major reason why it has become such a beloved local spot.

Norma Jean's Ice Cream is more than just a place to get dessert; it's a full-fledged eatery with a diverse menu that caters to all appetites. While their extensive selection of ice cream is the star of the show, their food menu offers classic American fare that perfectly complements the sweet treats. The service is always kind and efficient, ensuring you get your order promptly and with a friendly smile.

• Ice Cream: They offer a wide variety of both soft-serve and hand-dipped ice cream. The hand-dipped options are brought in from Madison, Wisconsin, and are a major draw for ice cream lovers. You can enjoy classic cones, sundaes, milkshakes, and more, all made with high-quality ingredients. A customer favorite is the banana split, which is known for its generous size and delicious toppings.

• Hot Fudge Cake: A signature item on the menu, this nostalgic treat features vanilla soft-serve ice cream sandwiched between two slices of freshly made devil's food cake, topped with hot fudge, whipped cream, and a bright red cherry. This classic dessert is a tribute to the owner's grandmother, who served it at a local pizza shop, and it has become a must-try for both new and returning customers.

• Classic American Food: The menu also includes a variety of savory items that are perfect for a full meal. You can enjoy classic burgers, hot dogs, nachos, and fries. The mini sliders and foot-long chili cheese dogs are particularly popular, with the chili coney sauce made fresh daily. They also serve onion rings and other delicious sides.

Norma Jean's Ice Cream offers a unique blend of features that make it a standout destination in the region. Its nostalgic charm and friendly atmosphere are what truly set it apart and keep people coming back time and again.

• Family-Owned and Operated: Run by Borden natives Susan and Steve Williams, the shop has a genuine, personal feel. Their passion for the community and their customers shines through in everything they do, making it a truly welcoming place.

• Nostalgic Vibe: The shop evokes a classic, old-fashioned feel that reminds many people of their childhoods. This nostalgic atmosphere is intentional and contributes to the shop’s unique identity as a throwback to a simpler time.

• Picturesque Outdoor Seating: With colorful chairs and picnic tables set along the bank of the Muddy Fork creek, the outdoor seating area provides a beautiful and relaxing backdrop for enjoying your food and treats. It’s an ideal spot for families to unwind and spend quality time together.

• Signature Hot Fudge Cake: This unique and delicious dessert is a signature item with a heartwarming backstory, making it a special treat that you can't find anywhere else. It’s a tribute to the shop’s namesake and a point of pride for the owners.

Address: 302 E Water St, Borden, IN 47106, USA

Phone: (812) 967-2663

For locals in Indiana, Norma Jean's Ice Cream is more than just a place to get dessert; it's an integral part of the community fabric. Its small-town charm, friendly atmosphere, and dedication to quality food and service make it the perfect spot for a family outing, a casual date, or a simple treat after a long day. The owners’ deep connection to Borden means they've created a place that truly feels like home, where every customer is treated with kindness and warmth. The diverse menu, featuring both classic ice cream treats and hearty American food, ensures there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you’re stopping by for a signature Hot Fudge Cake, a foot-long chili dog, or a simple scoop of hand-dipped ice cream, you're supporting a business that is at the very heart of the community.

Norma Jean's is the kind of place that fosters connection and creates a sense of belonging. The picturesque outdoor seating along the creek provides a peaceful escape, and the nostalgic vibe reminds us of the importance of simple pleasures. For anyone living in or around Borden, it’s a convenient and welcoming spot to make new memories and relive old ones. It's a place where kids can run around while parents relax, and where friends can gather to catch up. In an increasingly fast-paced world, Norma Jean's Ice Cream stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of genuine community and good, old-fashioned fun. This is why it remains a cherished and essential destination for locals in Indiana.

Norma Jean's Ice Cream

302 E Water St, Borden, IN 47106, USA