Nutter's Ice Cream

For over two decades, Nutter's Ice Cream has been a sweet fixture in the historic town of Sharpsburg, Maryland. More than just a place to grab a cone, this family-owned shop has become a cherished part of the local community, known for its generous portions, wide variety of flavors, and an atmosphere that feels like a delightful step back in time. Situated near the historic Antietam National Battlefield, Nutter's offers a perfect treat for everyone, whether you're a local resident or a visitor exploring the rich history of Washington County. It's the kind of place that creates lasting memories, a destination where the ice cream is as memorable as the experience itself.

The shop first opened its doors in May of 1996, the realization of a dream for owner Deb Nutter. The location itself holds a special place in Sharpsburg's history, having once been home to the well-loved Kretzer's Market. By preserving the nostalgic feel of the old grocery store, Deb Nutter created an ice cream parlor that feels both new and deeply familiar. The shop's commitment to quality and community has earned it a consistent spot on Hagerstown Magazine's "Hot List" for Best Ice Cream Shop. With an unwavering dedication to its craft and its customers, Nutter’s Ice Cream has become an iconic gathering place, a tradition for generations of families, little league teams, and history buffs alike.

The charm of Nutter's Ice Cream lies in its ability to blend old-fashioned values with a modern passion for delicious treats. Many customers have noted that the shop feels like it's "straight out of the past," and this is no accident. The building itself is a historical gem, with much of the original structure from when it was built still intact. The vintage shelving, the floors, and even some of the items on display are all part of the building's storied past, lending an authentic and unique character to the shop. This attention to detail and preservation makes every visit feel like a special occasion.

The reputation for massive portions and incredible value is a frequent highlight in customer reviews, with many people commenting on the unbeatable prices for the amount of ice cream they receive. One reviewer noted that a "small" banana split was equivalent to "six scoops of ice cream anywhere else," a testament to the shop's commitment to giving its customers their money's worth. This focus on value, combined with the quality of the ice cream, ensures that everyone leaves with a smile. The shop serves popular brands like Hood and Turkey Hill, ensuring a classic and satisfying taste with every scoop.

Beyond the scoops, Nutter's is also known for its dedicated staff. Customers often mention the friendly, smiling faces of the team, even when they're working hard to serve a line stretching out the door. This kind of warm, welcoming service adds to the overall experience and reinforces the shop's role as a beloved community hub. The passion and camaraderie of the staff make every visit feel personal and special.

With a commitment to serving the community, Nutter's Ice Cream is a must-visit destination in Sharpsburg. It’s more than just a quick stop; it’s a local institution that embodies the heart and soul of the town. Whether you're craving a classic cone or an indulgent sundae, Nutter's provides a genuine, memorable, and delicious experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back year after year.

---

Location and Accessibility

Nutter's Ice Cream is conveniently located in the heart of Sharpsburg, Maryland, a town rich in Civil War history and a popular spot for visitors to the Antietam National Battlefield. The shop's address is 100 E Main St, Sharpsburg, MD 21782, USA. It sits just off the town square, making it a short and pleasant walk from many of the town's historical landmarks and local establishments. For those driving, the shop is easily accessible from Route 34, and its central location makes it a simple stop on any tour of the area.

When it comes to parking, the area offers street parking on a quiet street. However, one detail to note is the limited seating. One customer review mentioned the lack of indoor or outdoor seating, noting that there are only "metal park benches outside." This is a key piece of information for anyone planning a visit, especially on days with inclement weather. The best way to enjoy your treat might be to take a leisurely stroll around the historic town square, allowing you to soak in the atmosphere while savoring your ice cream. The shop’s proximity to local attractions like the C&O Canal Towpath also makes it an ideal place to refuel after a hike or bike ride.

---

Services Offered

• Extensive Ice Cream Selection: Nutter's proudly serves a wide variety of ice cream, including a rotating selection of special seasonal flavors that keep the menu fresh and exciting.
• Classic Sundaes: Customers can build their own sundaes with a choice of two ice creams, a variety of toppings, whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry. The hot fudge brownie sundae is a popular choice.
• Banana Splits: For those with a big appetite or a group to share with, the banana split is a must-try. It comes with a choice of three flavors, each a scoop and a half, topped with three different toppings, whipped cream, peanuts, and cherries.
• Milkshakes and Flurries: The shop also offers rich, creamy milkshakes and delectable flurries, perfect for a treat on the go.
• Other Treats: Beyond the traditional offerings, Nutter's also serves up snowballs and lollipops, which are a combination of snowballs and ice cream—a perfect summertime treat.

---

Features / Highlights

• Generous Portions: The shop is famous for its massive servings, offering excellent value for the price.
• Old-Fashioned Charm: The vintage atmosphere and historical building create a nostalgic experience that transports visitors back in time.
• Seasonal Flavors: The menu includes special flavors that change with the seasons, such as Apple Pie for fall and Orange Pineapple in the summer, ensuring there’s always something new to try.
• Friendly Service: The staff is well-known for their warm smiles and efficient service, even during the busiest hours.
• Cash-Only Policy: A key detail to remember is that Nutter's is a cash-only business. This policy adds to the old-school feel and is important to note for a smooth transaction.

---

Contact Information

Phone: (301) 432-5809

---

Conclusion: Why This Place is Suitable for Locals

Nutter's Ice Cream isn't just a business; it's a vital part of the Sharpsburg community. For locals in Maryland, it represents a tradition, a place to celebrate small victories, and a reliable spot for a delicious treat after a long day. Its historical charm and commitment to generous portions make it a unique destination that stands out from typical chain ice cream shops. The friendly faces behind the counter, many of whom are long-standing members of the Nutter family and community, create a welcoming environment where everyone feels at home.

The shop’s proximity to local landmarks like Antietam National Battlefield and the C&O Canal Towpath means it's perfectly integrated into the daily life and recreational activities of the area. It’s the perfect end to a day of exploring the area's history or enjoying its natural beauty. While the lack of seating is a notable feature, it simply encourages a different kind of experience—a chance to stroll through the charming town with a cone in hand, enjoying the historic surroundings. Nutter's Ice Cream embodies the spirit of a true local gem, and its continued success is a testament to the community's enduring love for a classic, honest, and delightfully delicious institution. For anyone in Maryland looking for an authentic and memorable ice cream experience, Nutter's is well worth the visit.

Nutter's Ice Cream

100 E Main St, Sharpsburg, MD 21782, USA