Old Mill Creamery, LLC

Welcome to the heart of Pennsylvania, where a local treasure awaits you with scoops of happiness and a charming atmosphere. For residents of Mifflinburg and those traveling through the beautiful countryside, finding a sweet escape is as easy as following the scent of fresh waffle cones. Old Mill Creamery, LLC isn’t just another ice cream shop; it’s a destination that brings together the community and offers a taste of true local craftsmanship. This article will be your guide to everything you need to know about this delightful establishment, from its accessible location to its mouthwatering offerings. Whether you’re a long-time local or a curious visitor, get ready to discover your new favorite spot for a delicious treat.

Nestled in the picturesque landscape of Mifflinburg, Pennsylvania, Old Mill Creamery, LLC is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. It stands out not only for its incredible flavors but also for its commitment to quality and a welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit special. The creamery has earned a stellar reputation among locals, with customers raving about the delicious ice cream and the friendly service. From classic chocolate to inventive new flavors like salted caramel pretzel and chocolate espresso, there's a scoop for every palate. The experience is elevated by the shop’s dedication to freshness, particularly with its famous in-house made waffle cones, which fill the air with an irresistible aroma. This commitment to quality and a fantastic customer experience is what makes Old Mill Creamery, LLC a true gem in the heart of Pennsylvania.

Finding Old Mill Creamery, LLC is a breeze, whether you're coming from a nearby town or passing through on a road trip. The shop is conveniently located at 6542 Buffalo Creek Rd, Mifflinburg, PA 17844, USA. Its position off the main road makes it a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle, while still being easily accessible. The drive itself is part of the experience, taking you through scenic Pennsylvania countryside. For those traveling on Interstate 80, the creamery is a worthwhile and easy detour, making it a perfect stop to stretch your legs and enjoy a refreshing treat. The location is ideal for families, with plenty of space for parking and a relaxed setting that invites you to linger and enjoy your time. Its spot along Buffalo Creek Rd is not just a geographical marker; it's a part of the serene, rustic charm that defines the Old Mill Creamery, LLC experience.

Old Mill Creamery, LLC offers a wide range of services designed to satisfy every kind of craving. Their menu goes beyond simple ice cream scoops, providing a full experience for visitors.

• Handcrafted Ice Cream: The star of the show is, of course, the ice cream. With a great selection of flavors, including fan favorites like mint chocolate chip and peanut butter brownie, there's always something new and exciting to try. Each flavor is made with care, ensuring a rich and creamy texture that keeps customers coming back for more.

• Freshly Made Waffle Cones: A highlight of the shop is the fact that they make their waffle cones in-house. This dedication to freshness means every cone is warm, crisp, and fragrant, elevating the ice cream experience to another level.

• Gourmet Coffee and Affogato: For those who love a caffeine fix, the creamery also offers delicious coffee. One of their most popular items is the affogato, a delightful combination of hot espresso poured over a scoop of cold ice cream, creating a perfect balance of flavors and temperatures.

• Carry Out Options: Can’t get enough of their delicious ice cream? Customers can take the flavor home with them. Old Mill Creamery, LLC offers pints and half gallons of their ice cream for carry out, so you can enjoy their treats long after your visit.

• Homemade Potato Chips: In addition to sweet treats, the shop also offers a unique and savory snack. Their homemade potato chips provide a fun contrast to the sweet flavors and are a popular extra item among patrons.

What truly sets Old Mill Creamery, LLC apart are its unique features and highlights that create a memorable experience for everyone.

• Picturesque Outdoor Seating: One of the most beloved features is the outdoor eating area. Situated right by the picturesque Rapid Run Creek, it offers a serene and beautiful setting to enjoy your ice cream. The gentle sound of the creek and the natural scenery make it a perfect spot to relax and unwind.

• Exceptional Customer Service: Customers consistently praise the friendly and efficient service provided by the staff. The team at Old Mill Creamery, LLC is known for being welcoming and attentive, ensuring that every visitor feels valued and has a positive experience.

• High-Quality Ingredients: The delicious taste is a direct result of the high-quality ingredients used. From the ice cream itself to the coffee and waffle cones, the creamery prioritizes flavor and freshness in everything they create.

• Family-Friendly Environment: The creamery's atmosphere is perfect for all ages. It’s a great place for families to spend an afternoon, offering a safe and enjoyable environment for children and adults alike.

For more information, to place an order, or just to say hello, you can easily get in touch with the team at Old Mill Creamery, LLC.

Address: 6542 Buffalo Creek Rd, Mifflinburg, PA 17844, USA

Phone: (570) 966-4143

Mobile Phone: +1 570-966-4143

In conclusion, Old Mill Creamery, LLC is more than just an ice cream shop; it's a true community hub and a local favorite for good reason. For residents of Mifflinburg and the surrounding areas in Pennsylvania, this creamery is the perfect spot for a delicious, high-quality treat in a beautiful, relaxed setting. Its combination of delicious, homemade ice cream, freshly made waffle cones, and a charming creekside atmosphere makes it a go-to destination for families, friends, and solo visitors alike. The friendly service and diverse menu, which includes gourmet coffee and unique snacks like homemade potato chips, ensure there’s something for everyone to love. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply want to brighten your day, stopping by Old Mill Creamery, LLC is a choice you won't regret. It’s a place where every scoop tells a story of local pride and passion, and it’s a sweet part of what makes our Pennsylvania community so special.

We invite you to experience the magic of this local gem for yourself. The next time you're looking for a sweet escape, take a short drive to Old Mill Creamery, LLC and discover why it's a favorite among so many. We're confident you'll leave with a smile and a desire to return again and again.

With its unique blend of delicious food, stunning location, and warm hospitality, Old Mill Creamery, LLC is truly a place for locals, by locals. It's a testament to the fact that the best things in life are often found right in our own backyard.

Old Mill Creamery, LLC

6542 Buffalo Creek Rd, Mifflinburg, PA 17844, USA