Red, White, and Moo Introduce
Welcome to the delightful world of Red, White, and Moo, a charming ice cream shop that has quickly become a local favorite in Holley, NY. When the summer sun is shining, or even when you just need a pick-me-up, there's nothing quite like a scoop of your favorite ice cream, and Red, White, and Moo delivers on all fronts. This establishment stands out not just for its delicious offerings but also for its commitment to providing a friendly and welcoming atmosphere for everyone who walks through its doors. It’s more than just a place to grab a cone; it's a community spot where memories are made, and sweet cravings are satisfied with a smile. Whether you’re a long-time resident of Holley or just passing through, Red, White, and Moo offers a quintessential ice cream experience that embodies classic American charm and quality.
From the moment you approach Red, White, and Moo, you'll feel the inviting ambiance that makes it a perfect stop for families, friends, and solo adventurers alike. The shop prides itself on its generous portions and reasonable prices, a combination that keeps customers coming back for more. In an era where value for money is highly appreciated, Red, White, and Moo truly excels, offering substantial treats that won't break the bank. Their dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in every detail, from the cheerful service to the quality of their products. It’s a place where you can unwind, enjoy a moment of sweet indulgence, and truly feel like part of the community.
Red, White, and Moo is conveniently situated at 51 Public Square, Holley, NY 14470, USA. This central location in Holley makes it easily accessible for both local residents and visitors exploring the charming village. Public Square is a notable landmark in Holley, ensuring that the ice cream shop is not difficult to find, whether you're navigating by car or on foot. The shop’s presence in a public square also hints at its role as a community gathering spot, a place where people can easily meet up and enjoy a treat together. Parking is generally available in the vicinity, making it a hassle-free destination for those arriving by vehicle. The accessibility of Red, White, and Moo means that a delicious ice cream treat is never far away for those in the Holley area and beyond. Its location makes it a perfect stop after a local event, a day of errands, or simply when you’re out for a leisurely stroll. The ease of access contributes significantly to its appeal as a local favorite.
Red, White, and Moo offers a delightful range of treats to satisfy any ice cream craving. While they may not boast an overwhelming number of unique hard ice cream flavors, their focus is on quality and classic favorites, ensuring that every scoop is a satisfying one.
- Hard Ice Cream: They proudly serve Perry's Ice Cream, a well-regarded brand known for its rich and creamy texture. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes, with a medium cone often described as surprisingly large for its affordable price, offering significant value compared to other establishments.
- Milkshakes: For those who prefer their ice cream in liquid form, Red, White, and Moo offers a variety of delicious milkshakes, perfect for a refreshing and indulgent treat.
- Sundaes: Classic sundaes are also on the menu, allowing customers to customize their dessert with various toppings and sauces for a truly personalized experience.
Beyond the delicious treats, Red, White, and Moo also offers several features that enhance the customer experience:
- Affordable Pricing: One of the most frequently praised aspects of Red, White, and Moo is its incredibly reasonable pricing. Customers consistently highlight the excellent value they receive for the generous portions. This makes it an ideal spot for families or anyone looking for a satisfying treat without overspending.
- Generous Portions: As mentioned by satisfied customers, even a medium-sized ice cream cone at Red, White, and Moo is notably large, providing ample enjoyment for the price. This commitment to generous servings sets them apart.
- Outdoor Seating: The shop features a nice little outdoor area where patrons can sit and enjoy their ice cream. This provides a pleasant and relaxing environment, especially on warm days, allowing customers to savor their treats while enjoying the fresh air and the local atmosphere.
- Friendly Service: While not explicitly detailed in the provided reviews, the overall positive sentiment and emphasis on a welcoming atmosphere suggest that friendly and efficient service is a hallmark of Red, White, and Moo.
- Community Focus: Being located in Public Square and serving a well-known regional brand like Perry's Ice Cream, the shop inherently serves as a community hub, offering a familiar and comforting experience to locals.
Should you wish to experience the delightful offerings of Red, White, and Moo, here is their contact information:
Address: 51 Public Square, Holley, NY 14470, USA
Phone: (585) 638-2090
Mobile Phone: +1 585-638-2090
Red, White, and Moo is more than just an ice cream shop; it’s a valued local institution perfectly suited for the residents of Holley and the surrounding New York region. Its commitment to offering generous portions at incredibly reasonable prices makes it an unbeatable value, especially for families or individuals looking for an affordable yet satisfying treat. In an age where many places might skimp on servings or inflate prices, Red, White, and Moo stands out by consistently delivering on both quantity and quality. The availability of beloved Perry's Ice Cream ensures a consistent, delicious product that many New Yorkers have grown to love and trust.
Furthermore, the welcoming outdoor seating area provides a perfect, casual setting for enjoying a sweet escape. It’s a comfortable space where you can relax, chat with friends, or simply savor your ice cream in the fresh air. This thoughtful amenity elevates the experience beyond just a quick stop, inviting patrons to linger and truly enjoy their visit. For locals, Red, White, and Moo represents a reliable, community-oriented business that understands and caters to their needs. It’s a place where you know you’ll get great value, a delicious treat, and a friendly atmosphere every time you visit. It's the ideal spot for a spontaneous afternoon treat, a reward after a long day, or a delightful outing with loved ones, solidifying its place as a true gem in the heart of Holley, NY.
Red, White, and Moo Food & drink
Hard Ice cream
- Large Mint-Ting-A*Ling $7.73
MInt Ting a Ling ice cream
- Medium Cannoli $6.83
Cannoli Ice Cream
- Medium Panda Paws $6.83
Panda Paws Ice cream
- Large Birthday Bash $7.73
Birthday Bash Ice Cream
- Large Cotton Candy $7.73
Cotton Candy Ice Cream
- Medium Mint Ting A Ling $6.83
Mint ting a ling ice cream
- Large Cannoli $7.73
Cannoli Ice cream
- Medium Super Hero $6.83
Super Hero Ice cream
- Large Panda Paws $7.73
Panda Paws Ice cream
- Small Mint Ting A Ling $5.52
Mint ting a ling ice cream
- Small Cannoli $5.52
Cannoli Ice Cream
- Small Cotton Candy $5.52
Cotton Candy Ice cream
- Small Panda Paws $5.52
Panda Paws Ice cream
- Medium Cotton Candy $6.83
Cotton Candy Ice cream
- Medium Birthday Bash $6.83
Birthday Bash ice cream
- Small Super Hero $5.52
Super Hero Ice Cream
- Small Birthday Bash $5.52
Birthday Bash Ice cream
- Large Super Hero $7.73
Super hero Ice cream
Pup Cup
- Pup Cup $3.90
Vanilla ice cream with dog biscuit.
Ice Cream Sandwiches - 6 Pack
- Pinwheels $13.65
6 Ice cream sandwiches - Chocolate pinwheel cookies with an ice cream middle. 2 of each type of soft serve ice cream. 2- Chocolate 2- Vanilla and 2 Twist.
- Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches $18.20
6 Ice cream sandwiches - Chocolate chip cookies with an ice cream middle. 2 of each type of soft serve ice cream. 2- Chocolate 2- Vanilla and 2 Twist.
Novelties
- Spiderman $3.90
- Spongebob $3.90
Ice Cream Sundaes
- Small Smores Sundae $6.18
Vanilla soft serve with hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, Graham cracker teddy bears, whipped cream and cherry
- Small Oatmeal Cream Pie Sundae $6.18
Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookies, Vanilla Soft Serve, Caramel, Whipped Cream and Cherry
- Small Nutty Buddy Sundae $6.18
The perfect blend of chocolate and peanut butter goodness. This sundae is made with Chocolate and peanut butter wafers, PB sauce, Vanilla Soft Serve Custard ice cream and topped with Whipped cream and a cherry.
- Large Brownie Sundae $7.47
Brownie Sundae: Cosmic brownie base, soft serve vanilla ice cream, chopped cosmic brownie, chocolate sauce, whipped cream and cherry.
- Small Brownie Sundae $6.18
Brownie Sundae: Cosmic brownie base, soft serve vanilla ice cream, chopped cosmic brownie, chocolate sauce, whipped cream and cherry.
- Small Zebra Cake Sundae $6.18
Zebra Cake Sundae: Zebra Cakes, vanilla or chocolate soft serve, chocolate sauce, marshmallow sauce, whipped cream and cherry.
- Large Oatmeal Cream Pie Sundae $7.47
Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookies, Vanilla Soft Serve, Caramel, Whipped Cream and Cherry
- Banana Split $11.05
Traditional Banana Split comes with 1 scoop of Chocolate ice cream, 1 Scoop of Strawberry Ice Cream and 1 Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream. Toppings included are pineapple on the vanilla ice cream, Chocolate sauce on the Chocolate ice cream and Strawberry topping on the Strawberry ice cream. Sprinkled with chopped nuts and topped with Whipped cream and cherries.
- Large Swiss Roll Sundae $7.47
The perfect sundae. This sundae is made with Swiss Rolls, Hot Fudge, Vanilla Soft Serve Custard ice cream and topped with Whipped cream and a cherry.
- Large Nutty Buddy Sundae $7.47
The perfect blend of chocolate and peanut butter goodness. This sundae is made with Chocolate and peanut butter wafers, PB sauce, Vanilla Soft Serve Custard ice cream and topped with Whipped cream and a cherry.
- Large Zebra Cake Sundae $7.47
Zebra Cakes, vanilla or chocolate soft serve, chocolate sauce, marshmallow sauce, whipped cream and cherry.
- Small Swiss Roll Sundae $6.18
The perfect Sundae. This sundae is made with Swiss Rolls, Hot Fudge, Vanilla Soft Serve Custard ice cream and topped with Whipped cream and a cherry.
- Large Smores Sundae $7.47
Graham cracker Teddy bears, Vanilla Soft Serve, Hot Fudge, Marshmallow, Whipped Cream and Cherry
Floats
- Root Beer $6.83
- Cola $6.83
- Orange $6.83
Soft Serve
- Kiddie $2.75
- Small Soft Serve $5.52
- Baby $2.50
- Large Soft Serve $7.15
- Medium Soft Serve $6.17
Smoothies
- Strawberry Banana $7.48
- Raspberry $7.48
- Wildberry $7.48
- Mango $7.48
Slush Puppies
- 24 Oz Blue Raspberry $4.55
24 oz.
- 24oz Grape $4.55
24 oz.
- 16oz Lemon-Lime $3.90
16 oz.
- 16oz Cotton Candy $3.90
16 oz.
- 16oz Strawberry $3.90
16 oz.
- 16oz Watermelon $3.90
16 oz.
- 16oz Cherry $3.90
16 oz.
- 24oz Strawberry $4.55
24 oz.
- 24oz Watermelon $4.55
24 oz.
- 16oz Orange $3.90
16 oz.
- 24 Oz Cotton Candy $4.55
24 oz.
- 24oz Bubble Gum $4.55
24 oz.
- 16oz Bubble Gum $3.90
16 oz.
- 16oz Grape $3.90
16 oz.
- 16oz Blue Raspberry $3.90
16 oz.
- 24oz Orange $4.55
24 oz.
- 24oz Cherry $4.55
24 oz.
- 24oz Lemon-Lime $4.55
24 oz.
Milkshakes
- Hot Coco Shake $8.77
Hot Chocolate Milkshake! Made with soft serve, hot chocolate mix, a little marshmallow sauce, whipped cream and chocolate syrup drizzle.
- The Elvis Shake $8.77
Elvis loved PB and Banana sandwiches and this shake is in honor of the KING. The Elvis is made with Vanilla custard ice cream, PB sauce and Bananas. Topped with whipped cream
- Vader Signature Shake $8.77
- Vanilla Or Chocolate Shake $7.80
Other Drinks
- Water $1.25
Frappe
- Vanilla Latte $7.80
- Mocha $7.80
- Caramel Latte $7.80
- Peanut Butter Chocolate $7.80
- Cookies And Cream $7.80
Red, White, and Moo Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Payments
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Red, White, and Moo Photos










Red, White, and Moo Location
Red, White, and Moo Reviews
pricesflavorsmilkshakesvillageadditiondonutssmoothies
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1If you're in the mood for ice cream check this little place out:) I got a medium hard ice cream on a cone it was huge for just 5 dollars. Other places charge 7 or 8 $ for a medium and it's way smaller. Definitely will be back!!
July 02 · Audi BriThey didn't have as much of a variety of flavors as I thought they would have. We offer a variety of milkshakes and Sundays. They sell Perry's icecream. Their prices are reasonable. They have a nice little outdoor area to sit.
June 16 · Courtney BurleyOne of our favorite ice cream spots in holley! There's a ton of flavors that they let you sample and their seasonal products are great! I got apple pie filling with my favorite Graham cracker ice cream which also included an apple cider donut. Can't wait to go back a few more times before the season is over.
September 22 · Rosemary SuongAwesome place to go for ice cream! They have frappes and smoothies too!
September 28 · Lizzy WilliamsThis is a great icecream shop with great service and reasonable prices, its a wonderful addition to Holley! They have the typical flavors, and more unique ones like fireball and coffee & donuts icecream. They also offer milkshakes, slushies and more.
July 02 · Autumn M
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

144 South Ave, Hilton, NY 14468, USA

3208 Latta Rd, Rochester, NY 14612, USA

670 E Main St, Batavia, NY 14020, USA

4791 Lake Ave, Rochester, NY 14612, USA

733 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, USA

932 S Winton Rd, Rochester, NY 14618, USA

1670 Lakeville Rd, Avon, NY 14414, USA

1220 Fairport Rd, Fairport, NY 14450, USA

15 N Main St, Fairport, NY 14450, USA

130 Lake Ave, Lockport, NY 14094, USA

6251 Goodrich Rd, Clarence Center, NY 14032, USA

4088 Varysburg Rd, Warsaw, NY 14569, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





