Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe Introduce
For many residents of Indianapolis, Indiana, a trip to Ritter's Frozen Custard is a cherished tradition. The Georgetown Rd. Shoppe, located on W 57th St, is a well-known local spot that has been serving up delicious frozen custard for years. This isn't your average ice cream shop; frozen custard offers a richer, denser, and creamier experience due to its unique preparation process. Ritter's has built a reputation on this high-quality product, providing a menu that is both classic and customizable. It's a place where families, friends, and individuals come to enjoy a simple, sweet pleasure that is consistently satisfying.
Ritter's Frozen Custard has long been a fixture in the Indianapolis community, a place that evokes a sense of nostalgia and comfort. The shop’s menu features a variety of classic frozen custard flavors, which serve as the perfect base for an extensive list of sundaes, cones, and other treats. While some customers have noted occasional service issues, with orders not being prepared exactly as requested, the overall loyalty of long-time patrons speaks volumes. Many regulars continue to visit, cherishing the flavor and quality of the frozen custard itself, even when minor mix-ups occur. This dedication to the core product is a key reason why the shoppe remains a favorite among locals.
The experience at Ritter's is centered on the deliciousness of the frozen custard. The menu is designed to offer something for everyone, whether you prefer a simple scoop in a cone or an elaborate sundae with multiple toppings. The shoppe also provides a variety of options to customize your treat, ensuring that each customer can get exactly what they're craving. Despite some feedback about inattentive service and stale waffle cones, the core appeal of the creamy, rich frozen custard remains a powerful draw. This focus on product quality is what has allowed Ritter's to maintain a loyal customer base and continue to be a go-to spot for dessert in Indianapolis.
Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe is conveniently located at 4840 W 57th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA. Its position makes it easily accessible for a large portion of the Indianapolis population, particularly those living in the northwest area of the city. The shoppe's location is a significant advantage, as it is situated in a well-established and easy-to-find area, making a trip for frozen custard a simple and quick outing. The accessibility of the location means that it is a practical choice for a spontaneous treat after work or a planned dessert run on the weekend.
For those who are familiar with the Indianapolis road system, the shoppe is a straightforward drive from major roads and highways. The area provides ample parking, which is a major convenience for customers, as it allows for a stress-free visit. The ease of getting to and from the shoppe is a key factor in its popularity, as it eliminates the hassle often associated with visiting busy commercial districts. This makes Ritter's a reliable and comfortable destination for families and individuals alike.
The strategic location of the Georgetown Rd. Shoppe has helped it to become a true neighborhood institution. It’s a place that is woven into the fabric of daily life for many locals, serving as a familiar and beloved spot for a sweet treat. Its easy accessibility and convenient parking contribute to a relaxed and enjoyable experience, reinforcing its status as a go-to destination for frozen custard in Indianapolis.
Services Offered
- A daily menu of freshly made frozen custard, with a variety of classic and rotating flavors.
- A wide selection of cones, cups, and sundaes, including signature combinations.
- Customizable treats with a large assortment of toppings and mix-ins.
- Takeout options for pints and quarts, allowing customers to enjoy frozen custard at home.
- A variety of other frozen treats, such as shakes, floats, and ice cream cakes.
- A drive-thru option for quick and convenient service.
- A family-friendly environment suitable for all ages.
Features / Highlights
- Known for its rich, dense, and creamy frozen custard, a unique offering compared to traditional ice cream.
- A long-standing local favorite with a loyal customer base in the Indianapolis area.
- Offers an extensive menu with a variety of sundaes and customizable treats.
- A great destination for families looking for a classic dessert experience.
- The shoppe is known for its quick and convenient service options, including a drive-thru.
- Its location on Georgetown Rd makes it a familiar and easily accessible landmark.
- A reliable spot for a high-quality sweet treat, despite occasional service feedback.
Contact Information
Address: 4840 W 57th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA
Phone: (317) 293-1417
Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe is a great fit for the local community in Indianapolis because it provides a high-quality, classic frozen dessert that has become a part of the local culture. For Indiana residents, it offers a reliable and beloved destination for a treat that feels both familiar and special. The shoppe’s dedication to its signature frozen custard, despite some feedback about service, is what keeps customers coming back. Its convenient location and variety of menu options make it a practical and appealing choice for any occasion. A visit to Ritter's is a chance to enjoy a local institution and a delicious dessert that has been a favorite for generations.
Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe Vibe
Signature Sundaes
- Strawberry Shortcake Sundae US$8.10
Vanilla frozen custard, shortcake, and strawberries.
- Pineapple Upside Down Sundae US$8.10
Vanilla frozen custard, shortcake, pineapple, and hot caramel.
- Chocolate Marshmallow Cookie Dough Chunk Sundae US$8.10
Chocolate frozen custard, cookie dough, and marshmallow crème.
- Brownie Sundae US$8.10
Vanilla frozen custard, brownie, and hot fudge.
- Turtle Sundae US$8.10
Vanilla frozen custard, hot fudge, hot caramel, and toasted pecans.
- Grizzly Cub Special US$8.10
Vanilla frozen custard, hot fudge, and Spanish peanuts.
- Peanut Butter Mountain Sundae US$8.10
Vanilla frozen custard, peanut butter topping & reese's cup.
- Strawberry Delight US$8.10
Vanilla frozen custard, strawberries, and sugar wafers.
- Mud Sundae US$8.10
Chocolate frozen custard, chocolate syrup, marshmallow creme & oreo cookies.
- Banana Split US$9.48
Chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple & toasted pecans.
Dishes
- Dog Dish US$2.82
A kids scoop of vanilla with a dog treat on top.
- Dishes US$4.74
Pick vanilla or chocolate, or any of our Italian Ice Flavors!
Kids Favorites Sundaes
- Kids Crunch US$4.32
Vanilla custard with oreos, rainbow sprinkles, and m&m’s on top.
- Cookie Dough Rock Slide US$4.32
Vanilla custard with hot fudge, peanut butter and cookie dough on top.
- Monkey In The Middle US$4.32
Vanilla custard with strawberries and bananas on top.
- Worms N Dirt US$4.32
Chocolate custard with oreos and gummy worms on top.
Smoothies
- Coffee Lovers US$7.20
- Specialty And Fruit Blend Smoothie US$7.20
Hotdogs
- Hotdog Combo 2 US$7.20
ONE create your own hotdog with your choice of chips and a drink.
- Hotdog Combo 1 US$5.40
ONE create your own hotdog with your choice of chips.
- Hotdog US$4.20
Hotdog with your choice of toppings.
- Hotdog Combo 3 US$9.30
TWO create your own hotdogs with your choice of chips and a drink.
Quarts & Pints
- Pint US$8.40
1 pint of either vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and no-sugar-added vanilla.
Cubby Paws
- Cubby Paws US$3.30
Ice cream sandwiches, vanilla, chocolate or strawberry.
Shakes and Malts
- Create Your Own Shake US$6.00
Create a shake using our frozen custard and your choice of mix ins.
- Create Your Own Malt US$7.19
Create a malt using our frozen custard and your choice of mix ins.
Glaciers
- Glaciers US$6.90
Our version of a blizzard, vanilla or chocolate custard with one free mix in all blended together.
Create Your Own Sundae
- Create Your Own Sundae US$6.18
Comes with one topping of your choice plus whipped cream and a cherry.
Italian Ice
- Gelati US$6.30
Our delicious vanilla custard layered with our Italian Ice!
- Italian Slush US$6.30
Our version of a slushy!
- Gelati Blend US$6.30
Our vanilla custard blended up with the Italian Ice flavor of your choice!
Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Drive-through
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Popular for
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Trending
Crowd
- Family friendly
- Groups
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe Photos










Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe Location
Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe
4840 W 57th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA
Ritter's Frozen Custard - Georgetown Rd. Shoppe Reviews
sundaeflavorsdrive thruglacierstrawberry shortcaketurtleitalian icesmoothiespeanut buttershakes
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Ask for a cherry bon bon. Worker said she would have to charge me for the fudge and cherry sauce cause it is a lol??? Then it wouldn’t be a cherry bonbon. Just 2 scoops. Long timeCustomer may have to find another place. I dont like that!!! I kinda still love Ritters on Georgetown. Even if she didn’t fix it like I ordered it. SMH R
April 26 · donna hayesI asked for cubby paws, 3 strawberry, 1 chocolate and 2 vanilla. I also added lemon waffle cone. What he gave me was 4 vanilla and 2 chocolate. Not one strawberry AND he charged me for a pineapple sundae that I didn't ask for. We went over the cubby paws 3 times so he should have had that at least correct! You got to listen and pay attention. Date of visit 6.12.25@545pm. Young man who took order was nice, just didn't pay attention nor listen to orders. Not sure if I'll be back to this location or at all. I'm disappointed. Also the waffle cone was stale and not as fresh as I remembered from previous visits. It was chewy and not in a good way.
June 13 · Sharon LWhen I tell you Ms Mya gives the best customer service she gives the best customer service. She is very professional, kind, detailed and knowledgeable about the products. I even had the pleasure to speak with her about the different choices and her suggestions. I will always come back for the custard but the experience because her attitude needs to be truly applauded. Put her in a class to teach others on how you are supposed to do it. Amazing Ms Mya keep it up Queen💜💜💜🥰🥰
July 01 · Queen TruthI would love to give thus place 5 stars, but the service has really suffered in the past couple of years. Tonight, I waited in the drive thru line behind 3 cars for 10 minutes, before we ever moved. There were 2 boys working, and it still took them 10 minutes to complete 1 order? It is very common to see people pull out of the drive thru line because the wait is too long. Not sure what management's strategy is, but they definitely need to staff the location better or hire people who are more willing to work.
February 23 · Amanda SmileyI love me some ritter's icecream, but lately this store has went down. They can't even turn the cups upside down like they use too because the icecream is so runny now.( glacier)
June 12 · Sharon Crenshaw (Sunflower)
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

5126 W Pike Plaza Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA

4400 W 71st St, Indianapolis, IN 46268, USA

3919 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA

3851 Georgetown Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA

3740 Lafayette Rd a2, Indianapolis, IN 46222, USA

3585 Commercial Dr #201, Indianapolis, IN 46222, USA

Concession, 3585 Commercial Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46222, USA

7850 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268, USA

2802 Lafayette Rd suite #30, Indianapolis, IN 46222, USA

8333 N Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268, USA

6010 W 86th St Ste 142, Indianapolis, IN 46278, USA

4109 Clarendon Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46208, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





