Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw Introduce
Introduction / Overview
For those in Warsaw, Indiana, with a craving for a premium frozen dessert, Ritter's Frozen Custard is a name that stands out. Located at 3845 Lake City Hwy, this local establishment is a beloved destination that specializes in a product that is richer and denser than traditional ice cream: frozen custard. Ritter's has built a reputation on using a proprietary recipe that ensures a creamy, flavorful experience in every cup and cone. The Warsaw location, in particular, is celebrated for its exceptional service and welcoming atmosphere. Customers consistently praise the "friendly and efficient crew" and describe the custard as "excellent." It's a place that caters to families, with one review noting it as "one of our kid’s favorites." While a single review expressed disappointment with a specific item's portion and texture, the overall sentiment from the community highlights a business that delivers on its promise of quality and value. The Warsaw team, as one customer put it, "rocks this location," providing quick service and good-sized portions that make a visit a satisfying experience. Ritter's Frozen Custard offers a classic, community-focused feel with a premium product that keeps locals coming back for more, solidifying its place as a cherished part of the Warsaw landscape.
Location and Accessibility
Ritter's Frozen Custard in Warsaw is strategically located at 3845 Lake City Hwy, IN 46580, making it incredibly accessible for a wide range of customers. Lake City Highway, also known as US 30, is a major road that runs through Warsaw, ensuring that the store is easy to find whether you're a local resident or a traveler passing through. The location is praised for its "easy access on/off the Highway," which is a significant convenience for those who are on the go. The store is situated in a commercial area with ample parking, which helps to alleviate the stress of finding a spot, even during busy periods. This makes it an ideal stop for families and individuals alike. The straightforward address and location on a well-known road make it simple to find using any GPS. The combination of a prime, easily accessible location and a well-designed space for both parking and customer flow ensures a smooth and enjoyable visit for everyone.
Services Offered
- Premium Frozen Custard: The core offering at Ritter's is their fresh, homemade frozen custard, made daily. It's known for being richer, denser, and creamier than regular ice cream, providing a truly unique dessert experience.
- Daily Flavors: In addition to their classic vanilla and chocolate, Ritter's offers a rotating menu of daily specialty flavors. This ensures there is always something new and exciting for customers to try on each visit.
- Concretes and Sundaes: The menu features a wide array of treats, including their popular Concretes, which are thick, blended desserts with a variety of mix-ins. They also offer classic sundaes with different toppings, creating a customizable experience.
- Ice Cream Cakes: For special occasions, customers can order custom-made frozen custard cakes, which are a delicious and unique alternative to traditional ice cream cakes.
- Take-Home Options: Ritter's offers frozen custard in pints and quarts, allowing customers to take their favorite treats home to enjoy later.
Features / Highlights
- Excellent and Efficient Crew: A major highlight of the Warsaw location is the staff. Customer reviews consistently praise the crew for being "very friendly and efficient," even when the store is busy. This level of service creates a positive and welcoming environment that enhances the overall experience.
- High-Quality Custard: The quality of the frozen custard is a key feature. Its rich, creamy texture and dense consistency are a premium alternative to regular ice cream, which is why it is consistently praised as "excellent."
- Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Ritter's is noted as a favorite for families and children. The combination of delicious treats and a welcoming environment makes it an ideal spot for a family outing.
- Generous Portions: Customers have highlighted that the servings are "good sized portions," which provides a sense of value and satisfaction. While one review had a poor experience with a specific item's portion, the overall consensus points to generous servings on most items.
- Seasonal Variety: The rotating daily flavor menu is a strong feature that encourages repeat visits and keeps the offerings fresh and exciting for loyal customers.
Contact Information
For any inquiries about their daily flavors, hours of operation, or to place a custom order, Ritter's Frozen Custard in Warsaw is easy to contact. The physical address is 3845 Lake City Hwy, Warsaw, IN 46580, USA, which is simple to find on a map. You can reach the store by phone at (574) 268-0099. A mobile phone number is also provided at +1 574-268-0099. These contact points are crucial for locals who want to check on a specific flavor or plan a special order. The friendly staff are always ready to assist and provide information, ensuring a smooth and pleasant experience from the moment you call or visit.
Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals
Ritter's Frozen Custard is a perfect fit for the Warsaw community because it provides a premium dessert experience with a genuine local feel. The shop's commitment to high-quality, rich frozen custard, combined with its consistently friendly and efficient staff, makes it a go-to destination for families and individuals. The positive reviews highlighting the excellent service and "good sized portions" speak to a business that genuinely cares about its customers and provides great value. It offers a unique alternative to traditional ice cream, which appeals to a broad range of tastes. The convenient location on a major highway ensures it is an accessible spot for everyone, whether for a quick treat or a planned outing. Ritter's Frozen Custard is more than just a place to get dessert; it’s a community hub where people can gather, enjoy a delicious treat, and feel welcomed by a crew that "rocks this location." This combination of quality products, great service, and a local feel makes it an indispensable and cherished part of the Warsaw community.
Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw Ice Cream
Smoothies
- Specialty And Fruit Blend US$6.90
- Coffee Lovers US$6.90
Signature Sundaes
- Mud Sundae US$8.40
Chocolate frozen custard, chocolate syrup, marshmallow creme & oreo cookies.
- Brownie Sundae US$8.40
Vanilla frozen custard, brownie, and hot fudge.
- Pineapple Upside Down Sundae US$8.40
Vanilla frozen custard, shortcake, pineapple, and hot caramel.
- Grizzly Cub Special US$8.40
Vanilla frozen custard, hot fudge, and Spanish peanuts.
- Banana Split US$9.54
Chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple & toasted pecans.
- Strawberry Shortcake Sundae US$8.40
Vanilla frozen custard, shortcake, and strawberries.
- Peanut Butter Mountain Sundae US$8.40
Vanilla frozen custard, peanut butter topping & reese's cup.
- Strawberry Delight US$8.40
Vanilla frozen custard, strawberries, and sugar wafers.
- Turtle Sundae US$8.40
Vanilla frozen custard, hot fudge, hot caramel, and toasted pecans.
Kids Favorites
- Worms N Dirt US$4.32
Chocolate custard with oreos and gummy worms on top.
- Kids Crunch US$4.32
Vanilla custard with oreos, rainbow sprinkles, and m&m’s on top.
- Cookie Dough Rock Slide US$4.32
Vanilla custard with hot fudge, peanut butter and cookie dough on top.
- Monkey In The Middle US$4.32
Vanilla custard with strawberries and bananas on top.
Dishes
- Dog Dish US$2.82
A kids scoop of vanilla with a dog treat on top.
- Dish Of Custard US$2.82
A dish of your choice of our everyday flavors.
Shakes and Malts
- Create Your Own Malt US$6.04
Create a malt using our frozen custard and your choice of mix ins.
- Create Your Own Shake US$5.04
Create a shake using our frozen custard and your choice of mix ins.
Quarts & Pints
- Quart & Pints US$8.50
Coffee crunch-smooth coffee flavor with layered heath bar waffle nut crunch-similiar to a drumstick crumbled into a scoop. chopped nuts, chocolate chunks, our house made waffle cone crumbles mixed into our creamy vanilla turtle somethin'-caramel, roasted and lightly salted pecans, and chocolate chunks layered into a lucious caramel custard base amaretto cherry chunk-wild cherries and chocolate in a light amaretto base. our most popular fruit flavor by a landslide.
Create Your Own Sundae
- Create Your Own Sundae US$4.32
Comes with one topping of your choice plus whipped cream and a cherry.
Glaciers
- Glaciers US$7.20
Our version of a blizzard, vanilla or chocolate custard with one free mix in all blended together.
Cubby Paws
- Cubby Paws US$3.30
Ice cream sandwiches, vanilla, chocolate or strawberry.
Italian Ice Items
- Gelati US$5.70
Our vanilla custard layered with your choice of Italian Ice flavor.
- Gelati Blend US$6.30
Our vanilla custard and your choice of Italian Ice flavor blended together.
- Italian Slush US$5.70
Your choice of Italian Ice flavor blended with water to make it drinkable.
- Dish Of Italian Ice US$2.82
A dish of our non-dairy option, Italian Ice.
Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Drive-through
- Takeaway
Popular for
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Quiet
- Trendy
Crowd
- Groups
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw Photos










Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw Location
Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw
3845 Lake City Hwy, Warsaw, IN 46580, USA
Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw Reviews
flavorspricesshakesundaebanana splitdrive-thruvanillastrawberry shortcakeglacieritalian ice
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I ordered the Strawberry Delight and was really disappointed with the experience. For $7, I expected a rich, flavorful treat, but instead received something with very little actual ice cream and mostly foam on top. The portion was small, the texture was off, and overall it felt like poor value for money. Definitely not what I imagined or hoped for won’t be ordering this again.
June 12 · Sindu VelishalaVery friendly and efficient crew with excellent custard and one of our kid’s favorites! Easy access on/off the Highway. They are quick and serve good sized portions. The Warsaw crew rocks this location!
August 27 · Kitts CaribsOld fashioned drive-up/drive-in frozen custard place with lots of outdoor seating. My wife loves it and always gets the Bearcub with chocolate custard.
July 21 · Robert LawsonGreat places to get icecream with the family of 6 only spent 28 bucks and everybody got what they wanted. Outside sitting the frozen custard was great.Grace service and staff
June 16 · Adam BelilesUsed to love Ritters, went all the time but I'm tired of ordering extra toppings like hot fudge..and getting almost nothing on my ice cream, we pay a good price for this ice cream and extra toppings, they could at least give us what we pay for!
June 02 · Robin
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

904 Park Ave, Winona Lake, IN 46590, USA

1301 N Detroit St, Warsaw, IN 46580, USA

104 E Esterbrook Dr, North Webster, IN 46555, USA

511 S Main St, North Webster, IN 46555, USA

114 N Main St, North Webster, IN 46555, USA

108 W Main St, Silver Lake, IN 46982, USA

1201 S Huntington St, Syracuse, IN 46567, USA

115 S State St, South Whitley, IN 46787, USA

902 W Indiana 114, North Manchester, IN 46962, USA

113 E Main St, North Manchester, IN 46962, USA

131 E Main St, North Manchester, IN 46962, USA

207 W Van Buren St, Columbia City, IN 46725, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





