Route 16 Ice Cream Introduce
For those living in or traveling through the West Seneca area of New York, Route 16 Ice Cream is a quintessential summer destination. This charming roadside stand has become a beloved local spot for its delicious treats and friendly service, offering a classic ice cream experience that feels both nostalgic and fresh. As a go-to place for cooling off and grabbing a scoop of Perry's ice cream, Route 16 has cemented its place in the community. While some customers have noted concerns about wait times during peak hours, the general consensus is that the quality of the ice cream and the inventive menu are well worth the visit. This article will provide a detailed overview of what makes Route 16 Ice Cream a cherished part of the New York community and why it's a perfect pit stop for a sweet treat.
The main draw of Route 16 Ice Cream is, of course, the ice cream itself. The shop proudly serves Perry's ice cream, a brand that is a local favorite throughout Western New York for its rich, creamy texture and wide variety of flavors. This commitment to a beloved regional product ensures a consistent and high-quality experience. The menu goes far beyond simple cones, offering a range of classic and inventive options. A customer's review highlighted this, noting they "just noticed the inventive specialty sunday menu," which is a testament to the shop's creativity. From traditional sundaes to unique, specially crafted combinations, there is always something new and exciting to try. Whether you're in the mood for a simple scoop of hard ice cream, a swirl of soft serve, or a decadent specialty sundae, Route 16 has an option to satisfy every craving.
The atmosphere at Route 16 Ice Cream is a large part of its appeal. As a roadside stand, it offers a casual and laid-back vibe that is perfect for a quick, refreshing stop. One review mentioned it's a "good pit stop to cool off," perfectly capturing its role for both locals and travelers. The physical location, "literally on rt 16," as one reviewer noted, can be a bit noisy, but this doesn't deter people from enjoying the experience. The classic, no-frills setting allows the focus to remain on the high-quality product. This kind of authentic, local feel is a huge draw for people looking for an experience that is a step above a large, corporate chain. The outdoor setting and the simple charm of a roadside stand are what make a visit to Route 16 feel like a true taste of summer in New York.
The service at Route 16 Ice Cream is generally well-regarded for its friendliness. The staff are known for being pleasant and providing a good experience, though one review did raise concerns about staffing levels and long wait times. The customer noted a "line out to the street" and the frustration of seeing "3 couples leave the line" after a long wait. This feedback is valuable for both the business and potential customers, as it highlights a potential issue during busy periods. However, other reviews praise the staff and the quality of service, suggesting that on a typical day, the experience is positive. The fact that the ice cream is considered "the best around" by the same reviewer who critiqued the wait time shows that the product's quality is strong enough to keep customers loyal, even in the face of minor inconveniences. This blend of great product and generally good service is a key reason for the shop's enduring popularity.
Route 16 Ice Cream has firmly established itself as a beloved local institution in West Seneca. Its reputation is built on a foundation of delicious Perry's ice cream, a creative menu, and a classic roadside stand atmosphere. It's a place where locals can find a reliable and satisfying treat, whether it's a quick cone or a more elaborate specialty sundae. The reviews, while mixed on some operational aspects, consistently praise the quality of the ice cream itself, which is the most important factor for any dessert shop. Its location makes it a convenient stop for anyone in the area, and its unique, nostalgic charm makes it a memorable destination. For anyone in New York seeking a genuine, high-quality ice cream experience, Route 16 Ice Cream is a perfect choice, embodying the spirit of a classic summer treat in the heart of the community.
Route 16 Ice Cream is located at 2820 Seneca St, West Seneca, NY 14224, USA. Situated directly on Route 16, also known as Seneca Street, the shop is a convenient and easy-to-find roadside stand. Its location on a major thoroughfare makes it highly accessible for both local residents and those traveling through the area. While the direct location on a busy road can make for a "tad loud" experience, it also means it's a perfect spot for a quick pit stop. There is outdoor seating available, allowing customers to enjoy their treat right there. The shop's prominence on a well-known road ensures it is a visible and well-known landmark for anyone in the West Seneca and greater Buffalo area.
- Perry's Hard Ice Cream: A wide variety of flavors from a beloved local brand.
- Soft Serve: Classic vanilla, chocolate, and twist options.
- Specialty Sundaes: An inventive and appealing menu of unique sundae combinations.
- Shakes and Flurries: A range of shakes and blended soft-serve treats with various toppings.
- To-Go Options: Offerings like "6 Pack to Go" for customers to enjoy at home.
- Inventive Specialty Menu: The unique and creative sundaes are a major highlight for customers.
- Perry's Ice Cream: Serves a popular local brand known for its quality and flavor.
- Roadside Stand Charm: A classic, nostalgic atmosphere that provides a unique experience.
- Friendly Service: Staff are generally praised for their kind and helpful attitude.
- Convenient Location: An ideal "pit stop" on a main road for a quick and easy treat.
Address: 2820 Seneca St, West Seneca, NY 14224, USA
Phone: (716) 823-3350
Mobile Phone: +1 716-823-3350
For residents of West Seneca and the surrounding New York region, Route 16 Ice Cream is a classic and reliable destination for a sweet treat. The shop's commitment to serving Perry's ice cream, a local favorite, makes it a comfortable and trusted choice. Its inventive specialty sundaes and wide range of soft serve and hard ice cream flavors ensure that there is always something to tempt the taste buds. While a few customers have noted potential issues with wait times during busy periods, the high quality of the product and the generally friendly service keep locals coming back. The shop's quintessential roadside stand atmosphere and convenient location make it a perfect place to pull over and enjoy a moment of summer. Supporting Route 16 Ice Cream means supporting a local business that has become a fixture in the community. It's a place that embodies the simple joy of ice cream, making it a perfect and suitable choice for anyone in the area seeking a classic, high-quality dessert experience.
Route 16 Ice Cream Food & drink
Route 16 Ice Cream
- Soft Custard (Perry’s)
Kiddie (1.5 twists) $2.25, Small (2.5 twists) $3.29, Medium (3.5 twists) $3.99, Large (4.5 twists) $4.79
- Ice Cream (Perry’s)
Kiddie (smaller single scoop) $2.65, Small (single scoop) $3.49, Medium (2 scoops) $4.49, Large (3 scoops) $5.49 Cone Standards: sprinkles (.69), cone dips (.79), waffle cones (.99), sugar cones (.55), dipped waffle cones (1.99), peanuts (.89), sundae crunch (.89)
- Sundaes
** Initial Price Includes 1 Topping, additional ones are priced between .69 - .99 ** Custard Sundae: Regular size $4.49, Large $5.49 Ice Cream Sundae: Regular size $4.99, Large $5.99 TOPPINGS: - Standards: Sprinkles (.69), Whipped Cream (.89), Nuts (.89) - Sauces: Hot Fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch, Marshmallow, Peanut Butter, Choc. Syrup (.89) - Fruit Toppings: Strawberry, Blueberry, Cherry, Pineapple, Raspberry, and Spiced Apple (seasonally). (.89) - Candy: PB Cups, Reece Pieces, Snickers, Kit Kats, Gummi Worms, M&M’s, Sundae Dirt, Heath, Cookie Dough, Butterfinger, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Choc. Chips, Rainbow Nerds, Fruity Pebbles, Oreo’s, Cheesecake Bites, Bubble Gum Bits (.99) - Sundae Crunch: Chocolate, Strawberry, Cotton Candy (.89)
- Arctic Swirl (like a Blizzard)
** Based on 1 candy / item, additional items or extra of the same .55 ** Small $3.99, Medium $4.99, Large $5.99
- Milkshakes
** .55 up charge for hard ice cream flavors ** Small $3.49, Medium $4.49, Large $5.49 Flavors (feel free to mix to create your own): Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Coffee, Mint, Red & Black Raspberry, Cake Batter, Brownie Batter, Blueberry, Rootbeer, Irish Cream, Loganberry, Banana, Peanut Butter, Cherry, Orange, Lime, PinaColada, Oreo (.55 for Malt) And our SPECIALTY “The Red Eye”! A delicious milkshake with 2 shots of espresso, and Served with a whipped cream topper! Served Large size only $6.99
- Smoothies
Made with real fruit, not sugary toppings, and a touch of whipped cream on top! Regular: $4.99, Large: $5.99 Available flavors to mix and match: Strawberry, Blueberry, Pineapple, Raspberry, Cherry, Banana ** Add a scoop of plant based protein for $1.55 * Add plant based protein for $1.55
- Floats
Large size only $4.99 Current soda flavors available: Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Lemon Lime, Orange, Rootbeer ** .55 up charge for hard ice cream flavors
- Slushie
Regular: $2.99, Large: $3.99 Flavors: Fruit Punch, Bahama Mama, Lime, Lemon, Blue Raz, Cherry, Grape, Watermelon, PinaColada, Sour Green Apple, Orange, Strawberry ** add a pump of Sour Shocker for .55 And for a twist try our Kya Kooler! Add some vanilla custard to your favorite slushie for a delicious blended treat! (.99 upcharge)
- Specialty Sundaes (all served in a banana boat) $7.49
Kya In The Sky: Vanilla Custard, sprinkled in rainbow nerds, coated in blue raz cone dip, surrounded by clouds of cotton candy, with sour patch kids dancing around them! This dessert is straight from daughter Kya’s imagination! PeanutButter Jelly Time (go ahead and sing it): 3 scoops of Perry’s Oregon Blackberry Cheesecake Ice Cream, covered in Strawberry topping and PB cups, topped with whipped cream, and some peanut butter to finish off! The Key West: A slice of the life! A slice of Key Lime pie with a side of vanilla custard, drizzled in raspberry topping, and toasted coconut, and finished off with a touch of whipped cream! The Best Banana Split (in our opinions): 3 mounds of custard (vanilla, chocolate, vanilla), resting between a split banana, strawberry and pineapple topping spread across the top, then topped with whipped cream and finished off with chocolate drizzle! The Turtle: Vanilla custard, covered in hot fudge, caramel, and pecans, topped with whipped cream
- Specialty Sundaes continued…
Cookie Monster: Vanilla Custard, topped with cookie dough bites and hot fudge, then topped with whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles, and a couple chocolate chip cookies! Banana Foster Split: A twist on the classic dessert. Vanilla custard between a split banana, sprinkled in cinnamon Graham crackers, then drizzled in caramel, and topped off in whipped cream and cinnamon syrup! Sinful Toast Crunch: Vanilla custard covered in (you guessed it) Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal, drizzled with cinnamon syrup, topped with whipped cream, and sprinkled with mixed nuts for extra CRUNCH! Strawberry Cheesecake: A whole slice of NY style cheesecake served with a mound of vanilla custard, topped with strawberry topping, and crumbled Nilla cookies, and dab of whipped cream Campfire Song: Vanilla custard, served over a warmed brownie, drizzled in caramel & marshmallow, and sprinkled in Graham crackers!
- Specialty Sundaes Cont….
Peanut Butter Lover: 3 mounds of custard, sprinkled in PB cups and Reece pieces, topped with whipped cream, and drizzled in PB sauce & chocolate syrup! Brownie Delight: Twisted custard served over a warmed brownie, drizzled with hot fudge, topped in whipped cream, and finished off with some chocolate sprinkles! Cinco De Mayo: Vanilla custard, covered in Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal and strawberry topping, then topped of with whipped cream, and drizzled in chocolate syrup!
Route 16 Ice Cream Details
Service options
- Takeout
- Delivery
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Great dessert
Popular for
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Dining options
- Seating
- Table service
Atmosphere
- Casual
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
Pets
- Dogs allowed outside
Route 16 Ice Cream Photos










Route 16 Ice Cream Location
Route 16 Ice Cream
2820 Seneca St, West Seneca, NY 14224, USA
Route 16 Ice Cream Reviews
pricessundaescustardflavorsconeselectionmilkshakesummerpicnic tablespup
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1It's good pit stop to cool off and grab some perrys ice cream it was a tad loud ea..ting literally on rt 16 but still a good place ......just did revisit ..6/3/2025 ..place is still great infact i just noticed the inventive specialty sunday menu
June 03 · Rich PembrockThe ice cream is the best around but having one person working and having a line out to the street is going to stop me from coming here. You can go 2 miles up the road to charlaps and they have 3 and sometimes 4 people working the counter.Update: I’ve now watched 3 couples leave the line after the last order was taken now more than 10 mins ago.
July 09 · Chad BlanarI went there looking for a custard place and I LOVED it. Staff was super nice. The options to customize are incredible. The prices are good! This is a hidden gem! I highly recommend.
May 30 · Crystal FerrerGreat place to have an ice cream, sundae, milkshake, you name it, they have a large selection lol. Staff is always super nice, flavors and prices are good, and sizing is just great!
May 11 · Rodrigo SaldanaThis place is fantastic we come here every year. I just stopped in for a hot fudge Sunday which of course tasted great but it looked perfect, like a picture he really took his time making it which is so hard to find people who take pride in what they make .I was truly impressed
April 03 · Michael McNerney
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





