Shake No Eight: A Hidden Gem for Decadent Shakes in Columbus, Ohio

Shake No Eight Introduce

In the vibrant and bustling city of Columbus, Ohio, locals are always on the lookout for a special spot to satisfy their sweet cravings. For those in the know, Shake No Eight is the ultimate destination. This "underrated hidden gem" has carved out a unique space for itself, specializing in what customers describe as the "absolute best" milkshakes and hot chocolate they've ever had. Located on North High Street, Shake No Eight isn't just an ice cream shop; it's a creative hub where decadent treats are transformed into "a work of art."

Shake No Eight stands out for its commitment to both quality and creativity. The milkshakes, in particular, are a major draw. They are described as "designer shakes" that are "truly a work of art," indicating that the shop goes far beyond the standard offering. A review from a delighted customer highlights the immersive experience, noting the joy of eating M&Ms even before getting to the main part of the shake. This focus on an interactive and visually appealing product is a key part of the shop's appeal. The consistent quality over the years and the great service are frequently praised, building a strong base of loyal customers who "will always be coming back!"

This article will explore what makes Shake No Eight a must-visit spot in Columbus. We will cover its accessible location, the unique services it offers, and the specific features that make it a local favorite. The emphasis on freshness is another highlight, with a customer noting that the shakes are "made upon order," ensuring a "perfect thickness" and a fresh taste every time. This dedication to craftsmanship is what elevates Shake No Eight from a simple dessert shop to a memorable culinary experience.

The atmosphere and experience at Shake No Eight are as much a part of its charm as the food itself. Customers have been "trying to get down here for years" and are finally making it, a testament to the shop's growing reputation as a destination for something special. The excitement is palpable in the reviews, with customers eagerly planning to bring "family and friends" to share the "decadent treat." This word-of-mouth enthusiasm speaks volumes about the quality and uniqueness of the shop's offerings, solidifying its place as a cherished local favorite.

Beyond the signature shakes, the shop also excels at other offerings, such as its hot chocolate, which is also lauded as "the absolute best." This consistency across different products shows a dedication to excellence in everything they do. For locals, Shake No Eight is not just a place to get dessert; it's a place to create moments and share extraordinary treats with loved ones. It's the kind of spot that becomes a go-to for special occasions or a well-deserved treat, demonstrating its integral role in the community's social fabric.

---

Location and Accessibility

Shake No Eight is conveniently located in a vibrant part of Columbus, making it an accessible destination for many. The address is 1537 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA. This places it on North High Street, a major artery that connects various neighborhoods and is often a hub of activity.

The location is particularly ideal for students from The Ohio State University and residents in the surrounding areas. Its presence on a main street means it is easy to find, whether you are walking, driving, or taking public transit. While one customer noted that "the only issue was parking," they also added that the experience was "still worth it," suggesting that a bit of a challenge is a small price to pay for the delicious treats. The comment about construction potentially making parking "a tad challenging" is also a good reminder for visitors to be prepared and plan ahead, but the promise of a great shake at the end makes it all worthwhile.

Being on North High Street also means Shake No Eight is surrounded by other local businesses, restaurants, and shops, making it a great stop to include in a day of exploring the area. It's a place that fits perfectly into the flow of local life, offering a fantastic and accessible option for a sweet treat. The central location contributes significantly to its status as a local "hidden gem" that is well-known to those in the know.

---

Services Offered

Shake No Eight focuses on creating high-quality, memorable frozen and hot treats, specializing in a few key areas that they have perfected.

Milkshakes: The shop's star offering, milkshakes are described as "the absolute best" and "a work of art." They are made fresh upon order to ensure perfect thickness and taste.
Hot Chocolate: Shake No Eight also excels at hot beverages, with one customer claiming they have "the absolute best hot chocolate." This indicates a high level of quality in their non-frozen items as well.
Designer Shakes: The emphasis on "designer shakes" suggests that the menu includes creative, visually appealing, and decadent options that go beyond the standard milkshake.
Consistent Quality: Customers note "consistent quality throughout years," which speaks to the shop's dedication to maintaining a high standard with every item they serve.

The services offered at Shake No Eight are a testament to their passion for their craft. By focusing on a few core products and making them exceptionally well, they have created a niche for themselves as a go-to spot for indulgent, high-quality drinks and desserts. The fresh, made-to-order approach ensures every customer receives a product that meets their high standards.

---

Features / Highlights

Several key features and highlights make Shake No Eight a standout destination in Columbus, Ohio.

Decadent and Artistic Shakes: The "designer shakes" are a major highlight, described as "truly a work of art." This creative approach to a classic treat provides a unique and memorable experience.
Unbeatable Hot Chocolate: The high praise for their hot chocolate demonstrates that the shop's expertise extends beyond cold treats, offering a warm and equally delicious option.
Consistent Quality and Service: Reviews consistently mention "consistent quality" and "great service." This reliability is a key factor in building a loyal customer base and a strong reputation.
Freshness: The fact that items are "made upon order" ensures freshness and "the perfect thickness," which is a crucial detail for a great milkshake experience.
Hidden Gem Status: Customers call it an "underrated hidden gem," which gives it a special, exclusive feel for those who have discovered it, while also acting as a strong recommendation for newcomers.

These features collectively create an experience that is both delightful and reliable. The combination of high-quality products, a creative approach, and excellent service solidifies Shake No Eight's place as a cherished local business.

---

Contact Information

For those eager to visit Shake No Eight and try their famous treats, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 1537 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

Phone: (614) 429-3600

It's a good idea to contact them by phone to check their hours, especially on weekends or holidays, to ensure they are open for your visit.

---

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

Shake No Eight is perfectly suited for the Columbus, Ohio community because it offers a truly special and high-quality product that goes beyond the ordinary. For locals, it's a "hidden gem" that they can proudly share with friends and family, making it a go-to spot for celebrations or a well-deserved treat. The shop's commitment to making fresh, made-to-order items ensures that customers receive a top-tier product every time.

Its location on North High Street makes it a convenient and accessible choice for many, especially those in the campus area. The consistent quality and great service mentioned in customer reviews show that Shake No Eight is a reliable and trustworthy business. It's the kind of place that fosters community, with customers returning year after year and eagerly recommending it to others.

For anyone in Columbus looking for an indulgent, high-quality, and unique dessert experience, Shake No Eight is a destination not to be missed. It stands as a testament to the fact that with dedication and creativity, a local business can become a cherished part of the city's identity. The passion for their craft is evident in every "designer shake" and "hot chocolate" they serve, making it a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.

Shake No Eight Menu

Dubai Chocolate Desserts
Dubai Chocolate Strawberies Cup
Luxury fusion of Strawberries Kanafah, pistachio cream, and Belgian chocolate in a cup!!
Dubai Chocolate Shake
A decadent blend of creamy pistachio ice cream and our exclusive Kanafah chocolate recipe, perfectly mixed for a smooth yet crunchy texture. When you 8 it up! It gets even better—topped with chocolate-covered pistachios on the rim, a drizzle of pistachio sauce, and whipped Belgian chocolate cream. The finish? Fresh strawberries dipped in velvety chocolate for an irresistible, unforgettable flavor combination.
Dubai Chocolate Sundae
Rich, decadent chocolate sundae with a Middle Eastern twist.
Dubai Chocolate Crepe
Thin, delicate crepe filled with Kanafah, pistachio cream, and Belgian chocolate
Dubai Chocolate Strawberies Cone
Luxury fusion of Strawberries Kanafah, pistachio cream, and Belgian chocolate in a cone!

NO. EI8HT SHAKES
Sweet N’ Salty US$14.76
PEANUT BUTTER SHAKE Chocolate frosted rim with peanut & mini pretzel. Sea Salted caramel flavored ice cream mixed with peanut butter swirl. Dramatically topped with a Reese's peanut butter cup, large pretzels, crushed peanuts, homemade whipped cream & caramel drizzle.
COTTON CANDY MILKSHAKE US$14.76
Vanilla frosted rim with colorful Fruity Pebbles. Cotton candy flavored ice cream topped with homemade whipped cream, rainbow sour strips, unicorn bark topping and a beautiful cloud of freshly spun cotton candy.
THE AFTER EI8HT US$14.76
CHOCOLATE MINT SHAKE The coolest and freshest taste! Mint ice cream with fudge chips. Vanilla frosted rim with a mix of peppermint crunch candy, green and chocolate sprinkles. Topped with homemade whipped cream , an Andes mint , chocolate gourmet mints & white chocolate drizzle.
THE OHIO BLACKOUT SHAKE US$14.76
BROWNIE CHOCOLATE SHAKE Brownie batter ice cream with brownie batter swirls and brownie pieces. Chocolate frosted rim with mini chocolate sprinkles and chocolate covered pretzels. Topped with homemade whipped cream, a large homemade brownie, brownie bits, chocolate sprinkles & chocolate drizzle.
THE OREO SUPREME SHAKE US$14.76
Cookies N’ Cream Our famous cookies and cream milkshake! Vanilla frosted rim with rainbow sprinkles, crumbled Oreo’s, topped with an Oreo Wafer, two Oreo cookies, Oreo dust & chocolate drizzle
THE "O" SHAKE US$14.76
THE COOKIE DOUGH SHAKE Cookie dough ice cream with cookie dough chunks and chocolate chips. Chocolate frosted rim with M&Ms with cookie pieces. Topped with an ice cream cookie sandwich, homemade whipped cream, chocolate drizzle and rainbow sprinkles.
BREWED AWAKENING US$14.76
COFFEE SHAKE - Cold brew coffee ice cream, vanilla frosted rim covered with Biscoff cookie crumbs. Topped with homemade whipped cream, Biscoff cookies, marble chocolate covered espresso beans & caramel drizzle.
S’mores US$14.76
S’mores Shake Our s’mores flavored ice cream topped with graham crackers, toasted marshmallows and chocolate drizzle, Chocolate frosted rim with mini marshmallows.
Shana Banana Milkshake US$14.76
Banana cream pie with a touch of peanut butter and salted caramel. Topped with a whole chocolate cover banana.
BIRTHDAY SHAKE US$18.88
Is it your birthday, or do you wish it was? For whatever you’’re celebration, top any flavor shake with a slice of birthday cake, ballon, and colorful caramel popcorn.

Traditional Milkshakes
BELGIUM CHOCOLATE SHAKE US$7.88
It's a dark, rich chocolate milkshake with additional shaved dark chocolate mixed in. It's so creamy and perfect.
VANILLA SHAKE US$7.88
Classic old fashion vanilla milkshake with a taste reminiscent of soft clouds and a cool summer breeze. Topped with whipped cream, beautiful rainbow sprinkles and your choice of drizzle.
NUTELLA MILKSHALE US$7.88
The perfect dessert for Nutella lovers! A rich and creamy chocolate hazelnut milkshake is a perfect sip on any day. Made with real Nutella topped with homemade whipped cream and Nutella drizzle.
STRAWBERRY MILKSHAKE US$7.88
Our homemade strawberry ice cream recipe of our dreams! It's super creamy and bursting with fresh strawberry flavor. Topped with homemade whipped cream and your choice of drizzle.
CARAMEL MILKSHALE US$7.88
The sweet, creamy and delicious caramel treat! Topped with homemade whipped cream and your choice of drizzle.
BLACK CHERRY SHAKE US$7.88
Black cherry ice cream with black cherries topped with homemade whipped cream and your choice of drizzle.
STRAWBERRY LEMONADE MILK SHAKE US$7.88
It’s a deliciously simple way to treat yourself when you’re in the mood for an iconic summer treat. Topped with homemade whipped cream and your choice of drizzle.
BLUEBERRY CHEESECAKE MILK SHAKE US$7.88
The creamy and dreamy blueberry cheesecake milkshake made with cheesecake pieces, topped with homemade whipped cream and your choice of drizzle.

Dairy-Free Shakes (VEGAN)
Vegan Oreo Supreme US$15.88
Cookies and Cream milkshake made with almond milk.
Vegan Vanilla Milkshake US$11.88
Made with almond milk
Vegan Blueberry Pancake Milkshake US$11.88
Made with oat milk
Vegan Oreo Peanut Butter Shake US$15.88
made with oat milk
Vegan Coffee Milkshake US$15.88
made with almond milk
Vegan Chocolate Milkshake US$11.88
Made with almond milk
Piña colada Milkshakes US$15.88

No. Ei8ht Hot Cocoa
Traditional Hot Cocoa US$4.08
Made with milk and delicious milk chocolate topped with home made whipped cream and chocolate drizzle.
French Vanilla Hot Cocoa US$4.08
French vanilla flavored hot cocoa made with white chocolate topped home made whipped cream and white chocolate drizzle.
Toasted Marshmallow HotCocoa US$4.08
A s’mores hot cocoa made with milk chocolate, toasted marshmallows and milk topped with home made whipped cream, toasted marshmallow and chocolate drizzle.
Peppermint Hot Cocoa US$4.08
A white chocolate hot cocoa made with crushed peppermint and milk topped with home made whipped cream and crushed peppermint.
Tuxedo Hot Cocoa US$4.08
A dark and white chocolate hot cocoa made with half dark and half white chocolate and milk topped with home made whipped cream and both dark and white chocolate drizzle.
White Chocolate Hot Cocoa US$4.08
A white chocolate cocoa made with white chocolate and milk topped with home made whipped cream and white chocolate drizzle.
Dark Chocolate Hot Cocoa US$4.08
A dark chocolate hot cocoa made with dark chocolate and milk topped with home made whipped cream and a dark chocolate drizzle.
Cookie dough Hot Cocoa US$4.08
A cookie dough flavored hot cocoa made with milk chocolate and milk topped with home made whipped cream, chocolate drizzle and cookie dough pieces.

Cold Brew Coffee
Cold Drip Coffee
Fresh coffee brewed for 48 hours with ice for a refreshing chilled taste.
Creamy Cold Brew
A fresh iced coffee with the perfect balance between ice coffee and chilled cream.
Coconut Dutch Coffee
Cow milk not your thing? No problem. This cold brew kicks the pants off the old standby, as it’s cool, refreshing, a bit tropical, and ideal for poolside sipping. Cold brew, coconut milk and coconut flakes.
Almond Milk Dutch Coffee
Cold brew coffee with almond milk.
Dutch Affogato
Scoop of vanilla ice cream topped with cup of cold drip coffee. Simplicity itself and a marriage made in heaven!
S’mores Cold Brew Coffee
S’mores flavored iced cold brew topped with toasted marshmallows and chocolate sauce.
Cinnamon Oat Milk Cold Brew
Iced cinnamon brown sugar cold brew made with oat milk topped with cinnamon.

Speciality Coffee Beverages
Fresh Brewed Coffee US$2.08
Hot freshly brewed coffee made from our house blend “medium dark.”
Pour Over Coffee
Hot water poured over freshly ground coffee beans.
Espresso
A hot shot of espresso “single or double.”
Americano
Espresso and water “iced or hot. “
Double Shot Creamy Espresso
Our signature coffee beverage. A sweet creamy Irish cream coffee on the rocks.
Flat White
Cappuccino
Espresso and your choice of milk or milk alternatives and a thick layer of foam.
Latte
Your choice of milk or milk alternatives and Espresso with a thin layer of foam.
Macchiato
Your choice of milk or milk alternatives and espresso topped with caramel sauce drizzle.
Mocha
Your choice of milk or milk alternatives with espresso and real chocolate.
Chai Tea Latte
Your choice of milk or milk alternatives with our special chai tea topped with cinnamon “with or without espresso”
Hot Cider
Hot apple cider topped with cinnamon.
Hot Teas
Iced Tea

Crepes
The Li8ht Crêpe US$9.88
A delicious warm crêpe topped with cane sugar with a side of fresh strawberries, blueberries and homemade whipped cream.
Only Nutella Crêpe US$9.88
A warm crêpe filled with creamy Nutella topped with fresh berries and toasted almonds and your choice of home made whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream
Oreo Crêpe US$9.88
An Oreo themed crêpe filled with melted white chocolate and topped with melted chocolate Oreo crumbs & ice cream.
Perfect match Crêpe US$9.88
A S’mores themed crêpe made with melted chocolate and toasted marshmallows topped with graham cracker crumbs sided with homemade whipped cream.
The Eight Crêpe
A creamy peanut butter crêpe topped with warm melted chocolate topped with biscoff crumbs and peanuts with a scoop of peanut butter ice cream.

Waffle Stick
Strawberry Cheesecake Waffle Stick US$6.88
A True Belgian Waffle covered in creamy cheesecake spread topped with strawberry puree, white chocolate drizzle and sprinkles with a side of whipped cream.
Chocolate Nut Waffle Stick US$6.88
A True Belgian Waffle covered in melted chocolate topped with peanuts and chocolate. drizzle with a side of whipped cream.
Oreo Waffle Stick US$6.88
A waffle stick covered in melted chocolate topped with broken Oreo cookies , Oreo dust and white chocolate drizzle with a side of whipped cream.
M&M Waffle Stick US$6.88
A True Belgian Waffle topped with melted chocolate, M&M’s and chocolate drizzle with a side of whipped cream.
Peanut Butter Waffle Stick US$6.88
A True Belgian Waffle with peanut butter and peanuts with your choice of caramel or chocolate drizzle with a side of whipped cream.
Marshmallow Waffle Stick US$6.88
A True Belgian Waffle topped with melted chocolate, toasted marshmallows, graham cracker dust and chocolate drizzle with a side of whipped cream.
Cotton Candy Waffle Stick US$6.88
A True Belgian Waffle covered with powdered cane sugar and spun in cotton candy.
Chocolate Waffle Stick US$6.88
A True Belgian Waffle topped with melted chocolate, chocolate sprinkles and chocolate drizzle with a side of whipped cream.

Homemade Desserts
Tiramisu
Tiramisu An Italian dessert made of lady fingers dipped in espresso coffee, layered with Mascarpone cheese and fresh whipped cream, then dusted with Dutch cocoa.
Brownie Obsession US$5.88
The Most Perfect Brownie ever is right here for you to eat every day. These homemade brownies are rich, decadent and full of soul satisfying chocolate! With your choice of Chocolate, Peanut Butter or Toasted Marshmallow.
Cake of the Day
Cookies

SCOOPS
Single Scoop of Ice Cream US$4.58
SUGAR CONE, CAKE CONE, OR CUP
Double Scoop of Ice Cream US$6.48
SUGAR CONE, CAKE CONE, OR CUP
Triple Scoop of Ice Cream US$8.08
SUGAR CONE, CAKE CONE, OR CUP

DISHES
Single Scoop of Ice Cream US$6.48
ANY FLAVOR WITH 2 TOPPINGS, WHIPPED CREAM & A CHERRY!
Double Scoop of Ice Cream US$7.48
ANY FLAVOR WITH 2 TOPPINGS, WHIPPED CREAM & A CHERRY!
Triple Scoop of Ice Cream US$8.28
ANY FLAVOR WITH 2 TOPPINGS, WHIPPED CREAM & A CHERRY

Sundaes
Retro Banana Split US$9.88
The original formula! Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry ice cream between a freshly split banana, topped with chocolate, rainbow sprinkles, crushed peanuts, whipped topping & a cherry.
Brownie Obsession Sundae US$10.88
Two scoops of Vanilla ice cream served over two brownies and topped with fountain chocolate, caramel, whipped topping, chocolate sprinkles and a cherry on top.
Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae US$11.88
Slip into our Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae made from the perfect combination of Cheesecake and Strawberry ice cream drizzled with fresh strawberry topping and covered in whipped topping.
Fettuccine Crêpe Sundaes US$12.88
Crepe, cut fettuccini-style, with 2 scoop of Vanilla ice cream topped with three kinds of Chocolate (Milk, Dark, and White).

DAIRY FREE ICE CREAM
Scoop of Ice Cream US$4.88
Vanilla Cookies 'N Cream Blueberry Pancake Lemon Sorbet

Shake No Eight Details

From the business
Small Business

Service options
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Highlights
Great dessert

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Seating

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free multi-storey car park
Free parking lot
Paid street parking

Pets
Dogs allowed inside
Dogs allowed outside

Shake No Eight Photos

Shake No Eight Location

Shake No Eight

Ohio Franklin County Columbus South Campus North High Street

1537 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

Shake No Eight Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 792 user reviews.

shakeshot chocolateoreocrepebirthdayveganespressocold brewworks of arts'mores milkshake

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The absolute best hot chocolate and milk shakes I’ve ever had. Super underrated hidden gem in Columbus I recommend anyone visiting to try this place. Always great service and consistent quality throughout years. I will always be coming back!
June 03 · Deena Eldaour
I think I just ate half a bag of M&Ms even before getting to the INSIDE of my glass!!! These designer shakes were truly a work of art. We've been trying to get down here for years and finally made it. Cannot wait to bring family and friends for the decadent treat. Would also be a great after Prom kind of spot!! Made upon order made it fresh, the perfect thickness, tasty...and...interactive!! Go try one!! The only issue was parking; maybe the construction made it a tad challenging, but it was still worth it!!!
June 02 · EL C
Great atmosphere, even better desserts! We tried the cookies ‘n cream and sweet & salty shakes. We loved them both! Great for sharing! The gentleman working was so friendly and great to chit chat with- highly recommend this place for the whole experience!
June 03 · Leslie Butler
Absolutely delicious and beautifully crafted ice cream sundaes. I tried the strawberry cheesecake sundae and it was amazing! It was huge! The staff were friendly too. We will definitely go back soon.
June 28 · Kim Van Ness
Yesterday was my second time visiting and it was just as enjoyable as the first! Not only was my order delicious, the people truly make this cozy atmosphere welcoming. Knowing that the owner cares just as much about the beautiful works of culinary art he creates as the enjoyment that it brings his customer makes this place top tier. Great place for a birthday, date or just because. To put a cherry on your sundae top, the prices are very reasonable. Treat yourself to handmade greatness.
January 20 · Alichia Woods