Spotted Duck

Welcome to the Finger Lakes, a region of stunning natural beauty, award-winning wineries, and incredible local food. If you're a New York resident or visitor seeking a truly unique and delicious experience, you need to add Spotted Duck Creamery to your must-visit list. Nestled in the picturesque countryside of Penn Yan, this isn't your average ice cream shop. It's a farm-to-table destination that has garnered a loyal following and even national recognition for its exceptional frozen custard.

Spotted Duck Creamery stands out by using a secret ingredient that gives their custard its signature richness and creamy texture: fresh duck eggs from their very own flock of Ancona ducks. This commitment to quality and local sourcing is evident in every bite, as they use a mix of certified organic ingredients and produce grown right on their farm. From freshly baked cookies and hand-rolled cones to fruit compotes and toppings, nearly everything is made from scratch. This dedication ensures a flavor and quality you simply won't find anywhere else.

The atmosphere is as much a part of the experience as the custard itself. You can enjoy your treat while surrounded by the very farm animals that contribute to the magic. It's a place where you can relax at a picnic table, watch the ducks roam, and truly appreciate the connection between the farm and your dessert. Spotted Duck is more than just a place to get a sweet treat; it's a celebration of local farming, fresh ingredients, and simple, wholesome goodness.

Spotted Duck Creamery is conveniently located at 999 NY-54, Penn Yan, NY 14527, making it an ideal stop for anyone exploring the Finger Lakes region. Situated on the west side of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, it’s easily accessible and a perfect detour from a day of winery hopping, hiking, or exploring the historic village of Penn Yan.

The creamery operates as a stand with plenty of outdoor seating, including multiple picnic tables, so you can enjoy your treat with nature. While the line can get long, especially on a beautiful day, customers consistently say the wait is worth it. The friendly and efficient staff work quickly to ensure everyone gets their delicious custard promptly. Plus, the rural setting and animal sightings provide a pleasant distraction. It’s also important to note that the creamery has very clean facilities, which is always a welcome feature.

Spotted Duck Creamery offers a variety of ways to enjoy their unique frozen custard, catering to every preference and appetite.

• Individual Scoops: Choose from a rotating selection of classic and seasonal flavors. Their recipes are inspired by the bountiful Finger Lakes region, featuring local fruits, herbs, and other ingredients.
• Custom Sundaes: Create your own decadent masterpiece with their rich, creamy custard and a variety of house-made toppings.
• Custard Flights: A popular choice for those who want to try it all! The "Keuka Flight" allows you to sample four different flavors, giving you a generous taste of their creative offerings. This is a great option for indecisive guests or for sharing with friends and family.
• Dairy-Free and Gluten-Free Options: They offer delicious dairy-free flavors and gluten-free cones, ensuring that those with dietary restrictions can still enjoy a tasty treat.
• Custom Events and Catering: Spotted Duck can create a custom ice cream flavor tailored to your special occasion, whether it's a wedding, birthday, or other gathering.
• Pet-Friendly: Dogs are not only allowed but are encouraged to visit! The farm setting and outdoor seating make it a great place to bring your furry friend, who might even get some attention from the staff.
• Farm Experience: Visitors can ask for "duck sprinkles" at the pickup window to feed the farm animals, including the ducks, chickens, and a resident peacock.

The unique features of Spotted Duck Creamery are what truly set it apart from other dessert spots in the region and beyond. It's a destination that goes far beyond a simple frozen treat, offering a memorable and educational experience for all ages.

• Duck Eggs: The star ingredient. Using duck eggs instead of chicken eggs gives their custard a richer, creamier texture and flavor that has earned them national acclaim, including being named the "best dessert in New York State" and even the best ice cream shop in the country by a popular online influencer.
• Farm-to-Table Philosophy: Over 95% of their ingredients are either certified organic or grown to the same standards. This includes duck eggs from their farm, fruits from their gardens, and other ingredients sourced from the greater Finger Lakes region.
• Scratch-Made Ingredients: Everything from their sauces and crunchy toppings to their waffle cones and famous chocolate chip cookies are made in-house. When you visit, you can often smell the fresh-baked goods wafting from the kitchen.
• Lively Farm Setting: The presence of ducks, chickens, a peacock, and other animals makes for a fun, family-friendly environment. It's a perfect place for kids and adults to enjoy their dessert while connecting with nature and farm life.
• Eco-Friendly Practices: The creamery is committed to sustainability, offering glass and metal dishes for all on-site consumption to reduce waste. They even compost all leftover ice cream, turning it into protein-rich soil that is sold back to local farmers.
• Local Recommendations: The staff are not just experts on their custard but are also knowledgeable about the Finger Lakes region. They are happy to provide recommendations on nearby wineries, hiking trails, and other attractions.

For more information or to place an order for a custom event, you can contact Spotted Duck Creamery directly.

Address: 999 NY-54, Penn Yan, NY 14527, USA

Phone: (315) 509-3939

For residents and visitors of New York, Spotted Duck Creamery is a must-visit destination that embodies the best of the Finger Lakes region. It's an opportunity to support a local business that is deeply committed to quality, sustainability, and community. The combination of its unique, rich duck egg frozen custard, scratch-made ingredients, and delightful farm setting creates an experience that is both delicious and memorable. Whether you're a local looking for a new favorite dessert spot or a traveler seeking an authentic taste of upstate New York, Spotted Duck Creamery offers something truly special. The rich, creamy custard, friendly atmosphere, and chance to meet the ducks themselves make it a place that will have you coming back for more. It's the kind of place that turns a simple road trip stop into a cherished memory.

Spotted Duck

999 NY-54, Penn Yan, NY 14527, USA