Sweet Acres Creamery: A Farm-Fresh Delight in Geneva, NY

Sweet Acres Creamery Introduce

For those of us living in New York, especially within the scenic beauty of the Finger Lakes region, discovering truly authentic local establishments is always a treat. Sweet Acres Creamery in Geneva is one such place, offering more than just ice cream; it's a destination that promises a charming, "down-to-earth" experience with every visit. Tucked away in the countryside, this creamery embodies a warm, welcoming charm that invites you to slow down, relax, and savor the moment.

Sweet Acres Creamery has quickly become a beloved spot, celebrated for its "amazing" ice cream that is notably "creamy and fresh," with customers able to "tell it’s made right there on the farm." This commitment to farm-fresh quality extends beyond their ice cream, as they also offer a wide array of breakfast, lunch, and barista items, truly making them a versatile local hub. Patrons consistently praise the "super friendly" staff who are "happy to let us sample flavors" and "clearly love what they do," contributing significantly to the positive atmosphere. Whether you're indulging in a dreamy caramel ice cream or a rich orange pineapple, the dedication to quality ingredients and warm hospitality shines through, making every visit a highlight.

Sweet Acres Creamery is idyllically located at 1100 US-20, Geneva, NY 14456, USA. This address places it conveniently on a major U.S. highway, making it easily accessible for both local Geneva residents and those traveling through the beautiful Finger Lakes area. Its "tucked away in the countryside" setting provides a peaceful and picturesque backdrop, a refreshing contrast to bustling city life.

Accessibility to Sweet Acres Creamery is a key advantage. Being on US-20 means it's straightforward to reach by car, with ample space for parking, allowing visitors to arrive without stress. The appeal of its location is further enhanced by the ability to "sit outside at one of the picnic tables, enjoying the peaceful view and the fresh air." This inviting outdoor space encourages patrons to linger and truly immerse themselves in the tranquil rural setting. For New Yorkers looking to escape the ordinary and enjoy a treat in a serene environment, Sweet Acres Creamery offers excellent accessibility coupled with a charming pastoral ambiance.

Sweet Acres Creamery offers a surprisingly extensive range of products and services, making it a multifaceted destination beyond just an ice cream shop. Their offerings include:

Farm-Fresh Ice Cream: Praised for being "amazing," "creamy and fresh," with flavors like caramel and orange pineapple being highlighted. They produce their own homemade ice cream from their traditional herd of cows.
Full Barista Bar: Offering a variety of coffee drinks, including hot and iced lattes, house blend coffee, chai, and americanos.
Breakfast Items: A diverse menu including options like the Sunrise Breakfast Wrap, Deluxe Wrap, Finger Lakes French Toast, Toasted Bagels, Build Your Own Egg Sandwich, and Breakfast Panini.
Lunch Items: Savory selections such as The GrillMaster Panini, Build Your Own Burger, Homemade Fries, Deep Fried Cheese Curds, Sweet Acres Cheesesteak Panini, and Mac and Cheese.
Bakery Items: Notably, the "apple fritter is the perfect thing to bring in fall season," suggesting fresh, local baked goods. They also offer white bread, sourdough bread, English muffins, fresh ground whole wheat bread, and cinnamon rolls.
Local Dairy Products: Selling their own A2 milk (Creamline, Whole, Strawberry, and Chocolate Milk), heavy cream, and butter, all sourced from small family farms.
Local Produce and Honey/Maple: They support local producers by offering a wide selection of items like various types of honey (Clover, Fall Flower, Buckwheat, Blueberry) and local maple syrup.
Bottled Drinks: Including juice, water, and other bottled beverages.

Sweet Acres Creamery boasts several distinctive features and highlights that set it apart as a premier local destination in New York. These elements contribute to its unique charm and draw in customers:

Farm-to-Cone Experience: The most significant highlight is their commitment to freshness, with ice cream made "right there on the farm." This direct connection to the source ensures exceptional creaminess and flavor.
Diverse Culinary Offerings: Beyond just ice cream, the availability of a full barista bar, extensive breakfast and lunch menus, and fresh baked goods makes it a one-stop shop for various meal and treat needs.
Exceptional Customer Service: The staff consistently receives high praise for being "super friendly," "happy to let us sample flavors," and demonstrating genuine hospitality, making visitors feel welcome and valued.
Peaceful Countryside Ambiance: Being "tucked away in the countryside" with "peaceful view and the fresh air" provides a relaxing and serene environment, allowing patrons to "slow down and just enjoy the moment."
Support for Local: Their emphasis on sourcing products from "small family farms" and supporting "small and local producers" aligns with a strong community-focused ethos that resonates with many locals.
Wide Range of Dairy Products: Offering their own A2 milk, butter, and cheese from their creamery reinforces their farm-fresh identity and provides additional high-quality local products.

For those in New York eager to experience the farm-fresh delights of Sweet Acres Creamery, here is their contact information:

Address: 1100 US-20, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

Phone: (315) 878-8710

Mobile Phone: +1 315-878-8710

Sweet Acres Creamery typically operates with the following hours: Monday-Thursday: 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM, Friday-Saturday: 8:00 AM - 7:00 PM. They are closed on Sundays. Their cafe menu is served until 4:00 PM. It is always a good practice to confirm these hours by calling ahead or checking their official website for any seasonal changes or special holiday hours, to ensure a smooth and enjoyable visit.

In conclusion, Sweet Acres Creamery is an absolutely ideal destination for locals in the New York region, particularly those in Geneva and the surrounding Finger Lakes area. Its unique combination of farm-fresh, "amazing" ice cream made right on site, coupled with a full menu of breakfast and lunch items and a comprehensive barista bar, truly sets it apart. For New Yorkers who value quality ingredients, support for local agriculture, and a charming, down-to-earth atmosphere, Sweet Acres Creamery is a perfect fit.

The highly praised "super friendly" staff and the serene outdoor picnic areas with their peaceful views create an inviting environment that encourages relaxation and enjoyment. It's the kind of place that not only satisfies your craving for a delicious treat but also provides a genuine connection to the local community and its agricultural heritage. Whether you're starting your day with a farm-fresh breakfast, grabbing a quick lunch, or indulging in a creamy ice cream cone, Sweet Acres Creamery offers a delightful and authentic New York experience that makes you want to "stay awhile" and "definitely be back."

Sweet Acres Creamery Food & drink

Breakfast
Deluxe Wrap $16.80
Eggs, Bacon, sausage, Hash browns, and grill master cheese.
Breakfast Panini $12.00
Local, Non-GMO, farm fresh eggs, crispy bacon and your choice of Sweet Acres mild or sharp cheddar cheese.
Build Your Own Egg Sandwich $9.60
Local, Non- GMO, Farm fresh eggs, topped with our own Sweet Acres melted cheese along with your choice of ham, bacon, or sausage. Choose from a bagel, English muffin, white or wheat toast.
Finger Lakes French Toast $8.40
Toasted Bagel $4.80
With cream cheese or butter.
Geneva Farmer's Breakfast $19.20
Your choice of meat, cheese, bread, eggs, hash browns or fries, and a drink.
Sunrise Breakfast Wrap $14.40
Burrito made with local, non-GMO, farm fresh eggs, Sausage from local, pastured pork, sauteed peppers & onions with our own Sweet Acres mild cheddar on a tortilla. Served with a side of sour cream and salsa.

Sweet Acres Burgers
Build Your Own Burger ( 1/3 Lb. Patty) $10.80
4 oz. burger patty on a bun. add bacon and a 2nd burger for an additional charge.
Sweet Acres Deluxe Burger (1/3 Lb. Patty) $12.00
Our own Sweet Acres Non- GMO 1/3 lb. burger patty on a bun with bacon, Sweet Acres GrillMaster Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickled red onion, BBQ sauce.

Misc.
Homemade Fries $7.20
Mac And Cheese $7.20
Homemade Soup $7.20
Chef Salad $7.20
Mixed greens topped with peppers, onions, tomato, bacon and cheese curds. served with ranch dressing.
Deep Fried Cheese Curds $7.20
Fresh Sweet Acres cheese curds dipped in a batter and deep fried.

Sweet Acres Panini's
The GrillMaster Panini $15.60
Thin shaved ham, crispy bacon, a tomato slice, our own Sweet Acres Grillmaster Monterey jack cheese, and mayo pressed between two grilled slices of bread.
Turkey Pesto Panini $14.40
Thin Shaved Turkey, tomato, our own Sweet Acres melted cheddar cheese, with basil pesto, and mayo pressed between slices of Italian bread.
Chicken Bacon Ranch $14.40
BLT $12.00
Crispy Bacon, mild cheddar, Fresh Lettuce, and Tomato on Toasted Bread
Sweet Acres Cheesesteak Panini $16.80
Grilled sandwich layered with mayo, our own Sweet Acres shaved steak, sautéed peppers & onions, and Sweet Acres Monterey Jack Cheese Can add bacon and BBQ sauce.

Menu
Americano $4.80
A shot of espresso and a flavor of your choice in a cup of hot water
The Grillmaster Panini $15.60
Thin shaved ham, crispy bacon, a tomato slice, our own sweet acres grillmaster monterey jack cheese, and mayo pressed between two grilled slices of bread.
Chai $4.80
A black tea, honey, and spice chai concentrate with steamed sweet acres a2 milk.
Chocolate Milkshake $9.60
Creamy chocolate ice cream blended with our own sweet acres rich chocolate milk. topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle.
Deep Fried Cheese Curds $7.20
Fresh sweet acres cheese curds dipped in a batter and deep fried.
Sundaes $6.00
Creamy soft serve vanilla ice cream drizzled with your choice of rich chocolate or caramel sauce, topped with whipped cream.
Club Wrap $14.40
Thin sliced turkey and ham, crispy bacon, our own sweet acres monterey jack cheese piled onto your choice of white, wheat, or spinach wrap topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Frozen Fruit Smoothie $7.20
Choose your fruit, peach, mango, or strawberry. blended with our own sweet acres, creamy a2 milk, vanilla, and sweetened with monk fruit sweetener.
House Blend Coffee $2.40
A rich medium brazilian roast.
Soft Serve Ice Cream $4.80
Creamy vanilla, chocolate or twist soft serve ice cream of your choice.
Grilled Cheese $7.20
Perfectly toasted sandwich, made with our own sweet acres cheeses, monterey jack & mild cheddar on your choice of white or wheat bread.
Sweet Acres Cheesesteak Panini $16.80
Grilled sandwich layered with mayo, our own sweet acres shaved steak, sautéed peppers & onions, and sweet acres monterey jack cheese can add bacon and bbq sauce for $1.00
Build Your Own Burger (1/3 1b. Patty) $10.80
Vanilla Milkshake $9.60
Creamy vanilla ice cream, blended with our sweet acres a2 milk, topped with whipped cream.
Homemade Soup $7.20
Sweet Acres Deluxe Burger (1/3 1b. Patty) $12.00
Our own flavorful, Sweet Acres Non- GMO 1/3 lb. burger patty on a bun with bacon, Sweet Acres GrillMaster Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickled red onion, BBQ sauce.
Turkey Pesto Panini $14.40
Thin shaved turkey, tomato, our own sweet acres melted cheddar cheese, with basil pesto, and mayo pressed between slices of italian bread.
Chipotle Wraps $16.80
Latte $7.45
Perfect hot frothy drink, pick from 12oz or 24oz cups. and pick all natural flavors for 75cents

Sweet Acres Wrap's
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Wrap $16.80
Grilled chicken, mild cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, buffalo sauce, ranch dressing
Chipotle Wrap $16.80
Grilled Chicken Strips, our own Sweet Acres mild cheddar cheese, green peppers, lettuce, tomato, onions with sour cream and spicy chipotle sauce on your choice of white, wheat, or spinach wrap
Club Wrap $14.40
Thin sliced turkey and ham, crispy bacon, our own Sweet Acres Monterey jack cheese piled onto your choice of white, wheat, or spinach wrap topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

Ice Cream
Sundaes $6.00
Creamy soft serve vanilla ice cream drizzled with your choice of rich chocolate or caramel sauce, topped with whipped cream.
Soft Serve Ice Cream $4.80
Creamy vanilla, chocolate or twist soft serve ice cream of your choice.

Sweet Acres Burgers
Sweet Acres Deluxe Burger $12.00
4 oz. burger patty on a bun with bacon, GrillMaster Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickled red onion, BBQ sauce.
Build Your Own Burger $10.80
4 oz. burger patty on a bun. Add bacon and a 2nd burger for an additional charge.

Hot Drinks
Americano $4.80
A shot of Espresso and a flavor of your choice in a cup of hot water! 12oz
Chai $4.80
A black tea, honey, and spice chai concentrate with steamed Sweet Acres A2 milk. 12oz
Latte' $7.20
Perfect hot frothy drink, 12oz cup. And pick all natural flavors for $1.00.
House Blend Coffee $3.60
A rich medium Brazilian roast. 12oz
Hot Chocolate $4.80
Our very own Sweet Acres Creamery chocolate milk steamed to its best. 12oz

Sweet Acres Burgers
Sweet Acres Deluxe Burger (1/3lb. Burger) $12.00
Sweet Acres non-GMO, 1/3lb. burger patty on a bun with bacon, our own Sweet Acres GrillMaster Jack cheese, with lettuce, tomato, pickled red onion, BBQ sauce.
Build Your Own Burger (1/3lb. Burger) $10.80
Sweet Acres non-GMO, 1/3 lb. burger patty on a bun. Add bacon and a 2nd burger for an additional charge. Choose your cheese: Sweet Acres Cheddar (mild or sharp), Sweet Acres Monterey Jack, or Grillmaster. Choose your veggies: Lettuce, tomato, onion Choose your dressing: Mayo, BBQ, Ketchup, chipotle sauce, ranch

Cold Drinks
Iced Latte $7.20
Creamy Sweet Acres A2 milk & rich espresso over ice. Add a flavor shot of your choice.
Cold Brew $4.80
A rich bold Medium roast flavor served over ice with cream and sugar and a flavor shot of your choice.
Iced Chai $4.80
A black tea, honey, and spice chai concentrate poured over ice with Sweet Acres creamy A2 milk.
Fresh Lemonade $2.40

Smoothies And Milkshakes
Oreo Milkshake $7.20
A combination of crushed oreo, vanilla softserve, and milk, creates a delicious treat.
Vanilla Milkshake $9.60
Creamy vanilla ice cream, blended with our Sweet Acres A2 milk, topped with whipped cream.
Peanut Butter Milkshake $7.20
We can use chocolate, vanilla, or twist softserve with added peanut butter to make a delicious, mouth-watering cold drink. 16oz.
Maple Milkshake $7.20
A combination of vanilla soft serve icecream and local maple syrup make this milkshake a real treat. 16oz.
Frozen Fruit Smoothie $7.20
Choose your fruit, peach, mango, or strawberry. Blended with our own Sweet Acres, creamy A2 milk, and sweetened with Monk fruit sweetener. 16oz.
Chocolate Milkshake $9.60
Creamy chocolate ice cream blended with our own Sweet Acres rich chocolate milk and topped with whipped cream. 16oz.

Menu
Chai $4.80
A black tea, honey, and spice chai concentrate with steamed sweet acres a2 milk.
Hot Tea $3.60
Enjoy a cup of hot water steeped with a garden mint tea bag
Deep Fried Cheese Curds $7.20
Fresh sweet acres cheese curds dipped in a batter and deep fried.
Vanilla Milkshake $9.60
Creamy vanilla ice cream, blended with our sweet acres a2 milk, topped with whipped cream.
Soft Serve Ice Cream $4.80
Creamy vanilla, chocolate or twist soft serve ice cream of your choice.
Latte $7.20
Perfect hot frothy drink, pick from 12oz or 24oz cups. and pick all natural flavors for 75cents
Chocolate Milkshake $9.60
Creamy chocolate ice cream blended with our own sweet acres rich chocolate milk. topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle.
Sundaes $6.00
Creamy soft serve vanilla ice cream drizzled with your choice of rich chocolate or caramel sauce, topped with whipped cream.
Housemade Soup $7.20
Cold Brew $4.80
A rich bold medium roast flavor served over ice with cream and sugar and a flavor shot of your choice.
Hot Chocolate $4.80
Our very own sweet acres creamery chocolate milk steamed to its best.
Frozen Fruit Smoothie $7.20
Choose your fruit, peach, mango, or strawberry. blended with our own sweet acres, creamy a2 milk, vanilla, and sweetened with monk fruit sweetener.
Americano $4.80
A shot of espresso and a flavor of your choice in a cup of hot water
House Blend Coffee $3.60
A rich medium brazilian roast.
Iced Latte $7.20
Creamy sweet acres a2 milk & rich espresso over ice. add a flavor shot of your choice.
Iced Chai $4.80
A black tea, honey, and spice chai concentrate poured over ice with sweet acres creamy a2 milk.

Lunch
The GrillMaster Panini $15.60
Ham, bacon, GrillMaster Monterey Jack cheese, tomato and mayo.
Club Wrap $14.40
Turkey, ham, bacon, Monterey Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo on a white, wheat or spinach wrap.
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Panini $14.40
Chicken, Bacon, Monterey jack, Tomato, Ranch dressing.
Chipotle Wrap $16.80
Grilled chicken, Smoky Chipotle cheese, green peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion with sour cream and chipotle sauce on a white, wheat or spinach wrap.
Cheesesteak Panini $16.80
Sweet Acres shaved steak, sautéed peppers and onions with melted Monterey Jack Cheese.
Turkey Pesto Panini $14.40
Turkey, cheddar cheese, tomato, basil pesto and mayo.
B.L.T $12.00
Bacon, Mild Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo
Grilled Cheese $6.00
Cheddar and Monterey Jack cheese on your choice of white or wheat.
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Wrap $16.80
Grilled Chicken, Mild Cheddar, Lettuce, Onion, Tomato, Buffalo Sauce, Ranch Dressing.

Kid's Meals
Grilled Cheese $6.00
Perfectly toasted sandwich, made with our own sweet acres cheeses, monterey jack & mild cheddar on your choice of white or wheat bread.

Sweet Acres Creamery Details

From the business
Small business

Service options
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Seating

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Sweet Acres Creamery Photos

Sweet Acres Creamery Location

Sweet Acres Creamery

New York Ontario County Geneva U.S. 20

1100 US-20, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

Sweet Acres Creamery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 154 user reviews.

lunchmilkshakespricesatmospherecheese curdsdairylocal productsareachocolate milka2 milk

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Absolutely loved this place!We stumbled upon Sweet Acres Creamery while exploring Geneva, and it turned out to be one of the highlights of our trip! It’s tucked away in the countryside and has this warm, welcoming, down-to-earth charm that makes you want to stay awhile.The ice cream was amazing—so creamy and fresh, you can tell it’s made right there on the farm. I had the caramel (which was honestly dreamy) and my husband got the orange pineapple —super rich and satisfying.The staff was super friendly, happy to let us sample flavors, and clearly love what they do.We sat outside at one of the picnic tables, enjoying the peaceful view and the fresh air. It’s the kind of place that makes you slow down and just enjoy the moment
July 06 · jigna gandhi
First time here today and I’ll definitely be back. I work in Geneva and love that this tasty place is open. From breakfast to lunch items and drinks ranging from full barista bar to closed drinks like juice, water, milk and other bottled drinks. The apple fritter is the perfect thing to bring in fall season, thank you for the yummy food and hospitality to the barista lady🫡🙌🙏
October 16 · Julian Verdugo
Stopped in on a whim while traveling in the area. I can say the coffee is so good! The cheese curds are lacking something- very dry and not creamy. The location is great and I’ll be back for coffee and to try some of their other menu items. Plenty of parking and very easy to get to. Stopped in today for lunch. It was a quiet afternoon. Such a cozy environment to their grilled chicken panini and coffee. I truly enjoyed the panini as it included red onion and I am a fan! The server was very kind and patient as I decided what I wanted to order. They have soup of the day specials as well as dessert items (in addition to their farm market items in the shop). Eating lunch next to the fireplace completed the ambiance.
February 28 · Tammra Schiller
Our family is here on vacation and stopped in for treats! This is our 2nd creamery we visited, and this is the creamiest and soooo DELICIOUS. We are already discussing when to go back to have more before we return home!A definite stop for the best ice cream in the Finger Lakes.
July 17 · Sheree Allen
I brought my daughter for breakfast the other day she had a English muffin sandwich with bacon no cheese or sauce. And she said it was really good. She also got a Peach smoothie and I got the mixed berry milkshake they had advertised. We tried each others and they were both so delicious. Definitely recommend trying the milkshakes and smoothies.
June 29 · Kayla Pizura