The Main Street Creamery Introduce
Nestled in the heart of Wellsboro, Pennsylvania, The Main Street Creamery stands as a testament to classic charm and delicious, handcrafted treats. More than just a simple ice cream shop, it's a local institution that captures the essence of a bygone era. For those seeking a sweet escape, a refreshing break on a warm day, or a cozy spot to gather with family and friends, this establishment has become a go-to destination. Located in a beautiful, historic two-story house on Main Street, the creamery offers an experience that goes beyond just serving dessert. It's a place where memories are made, traditions are started, and the simple pleasure of a scoop of ice cream is elevated. Locals and visitors from all over the region have come to appreciate its dedication to quality and its unique, welcoming atmosphere.
The Main Street Creamery prides itself on its commitment to creating high-quality products. While some customers have questioned whether all ice cream is made on-site, the overwhelming consensus is that the flavors are exceptional and the quality is consistently high. The shop's extensive menu features a variety of inventive and traditional flavors, ensuring there's something to satisfy every palate. From classic vanilla and chocolate to more unique creations like salted caramel Kit Kat, the selection is both broad and impressive. Each scoop is served with care, reflecting the staff's genuine enthusiasm for their products. The attention to detail and the friendly service are hallmarks of the creamery, making every visit a pleasant one. The shop has cultivated a reputation for being a place where customers can always expect a delicious treat, served with a smile.
The atmosphere of The Main Street Creamery is a significant part of its appeal. Stepping inside feels like taking a step back in time. The interior features beautiful hardwood floors and decor that evoke the early 20th century, creating a nostalgic and inviting environment. The space is thoughtfully divided into different sections, each with its own character. There is an old-fashioned soda bar in one room, and the main ice cream parlor in another. This layout allows for different types of experiences, whether you're looking for a quick cone or a more leisurely sit-down dessert. The seating options are another highlight. Customers can choose to sit inside and soak in the historic ambiance or, on a nice day, enjoy their treat on the charming front porch. The porch seating is particularly popular, offering a prime spot for people-watching and enjoying the vibrant energy of downtown Wellsboro.
The creamery's popularity is not just due to its food and ambiance but also to its role as a community hub. It's a place where neighbors run into each other and families gather after a day of exploring the local area. The friendly and delightful staff play a crucial role in this welcoming environment, making customers feel like they are part of the family. The dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in every interaction. While one customer noted a minor pet peeve about being asked for a tip, the general sentiment is that the service is excellent and the staff are genuinely happy to help. This combination of quality products, a unique atmosphere, and friendly service makes The Main Street Creamery a cherished part of the Wellsboro community and a must-visit for anyone in the region looking for an exceptional ice cream experience. The creamery’s deep roots in the community and its commitment to providing a memorable experience solidify its status as a local gem.
When you're in the Wellsboro area, The Main Street Creamery is not just a place to get dessert; it's an experience. The location is easily accessible, right on the bustling and scenic Main Street. Whether you're driving through town, exploring on foot, or enjoying a local festival, the creamery is a convenient and irresistible stop. The charming exterior of the old house invites you in, and the delicious smells and cheerful atmosphere keep you there. It is a perfect spot for a spontaneous treat or a planned outing.
The Main Street Creamery is conveniently located at 17 Main St, Wellsboro, PA 16901, USA. Its prime spot on Main Street makes it easy to find and a perfect destination for both residents and visitors. Wellsboro is a beautiful and walkable town, and the creamery's location means it is close to other local shops and attractions, making it a great stop during a day of exploration. While the shop is situated in a historic building, its central location ensures it's easily accessible for most people, whether they are walking from a nearby parking spot or strolling down the street.
- Homemade Ice Cream: A wide variety of flavors, including traditional favorites and unique creations.
- Old-Fashioned Soda Bar: A separate room dedicated to classic soda fountain treats.
- Outdoor Seating: A front porch with seating perfect for people-watching on Main Street.
- Indoor Seating: Ample seating in a charming, historic setting.
- Take-out Options: Perfect for grabbing a quick cone or pint to go.
- Historic Setting: Located in a beautiful two-story house with early 20th-century decor.
- Diverse Flavor Selection: An ever-changing menu of delicious and inventive ice cream flavors.
- Friendly and Enthusiastic Staff: Employees are known for their delightful and welcoming service.
- Community Hub: A popular gathering spot for locals and families.
- Unique Ambiance: The combination of an old-fashioned soda bar and ice cream parlor creates a nostalgic experience.
- Quality Ingredients: The creamery is known for the high quality and care put into its products.
Address: 17 Main St, Wellsboro, PA 16901, USA
Phone: (570) 948-9558
The Main Street Creamery is more than just a place to get ice cream; it's a cornerstone of the Wellsboro community. Its blend of high-quality, delicious products, a unique and welcoming atmosphere, and friendly service makes it a perfect spot for locals. It serves as a community gathering place, where neighbors can connect and families can enjoy a simple, sweet pleasure together. The creamery's commitment to creating a memorable experience, from the moment you step into the charming historic building to the last bite of your ice cream, is what truly sets it apart. The staff's genuine delight in helping customers and the broad selection of flavors ensure that every visit is a treat. For residents of Wellsboro and the surrounding Pennsylvania region, The Main Street Creamery is a cherished local gem that offers a taste of nostalgia and a moment of pure joy, all on a convenient and scenic Main Street.
The Main Street Creamery Details
Service options
- Takeout
- Delivery
Popular for
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Table service
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
The Main Street Creamery Photos










The Main Street Creamery Location
The Main Street Creamery
17 Main St, Wellsboro, PA 16901, USA
The Main Street Creamery Reviews
flavorsmilkshakesbuildingpriceslemonwaffle coneraspberrycookieporchcaramel
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1This place has the best ice cream in the game. Honestly I have tried so many of the flavors here and never once have I been disappointed. Everything is made with such care and the staff that they have working here are always so delightful and friendly and they seem like they genuinely enjoy helping you pick out your ice cream. I am telling you if there is one place in wellsboro to stop at it is this ice cream parlor.
July 07 · Jeremy BowlingAtmosphere- 4 stars- located in an old stately two story house on Main Street- this ice cream shop claims to have Homemade Ice Cream. Beautiful inside with hardwood floors and a feel of early 20th century America. There is an old fashioned soda bar in a separate room and ofcourse the ice cream parlor in an adjacent room. Some seating inside or you could sit outside on the front porch and people watch.Service- 3 stars- young lady behind the counter was friendly but when you pay she flips the payment screen and says if you want to leave a tip you can. This is a pet peeve of mine to be constantly expected to tip and I find it inappropriate to basically ask for one.Food- 4 stars- not sure if this is actually Homemade ice cream but either way it was still really good. I got the salted caramel Kit Kat which I have never seen. I enjoyed it while sitting out on the front porch.
September 13 · Honest ReviewsForgot pictures! Sorry. The ice cream was excellent, nothing too crazy flavor wise. I enjoyed Moose Tracks which had a lovely caramel stripe throughout in a fresh, crunch waffle cone. Hubby had a maple ice cream which he said hit the spot. Definitely worth the stop! The building is one of the many well maintained old homes in Wellsboro.
July 05 · Amy MiskiewiczI KNOW I KNOW...it seems really weird to post a picture of the toilet but I got your attention. They have the CLEANEST bathroom. They are super nice and the ice cream and other treats are simply the best. Don't pass this place up. So so good
June 30 · Jonas SternerThey don't charge you for the aromatherapy you receive by walking into this place. It is heavenly.The staff are wonderful: courteous, friendly, and prompt.The interior js filled with warm natural wood tones and comfy places to sit.I felt like I was in a day spa instead of getting ice cream.The ice cream was delicious: well balanced, not too hard, generous portions. I happily ruined my appetite for "real lunch food"- sometimes, as adults, these are the choices we make.Flavors tried: strawberry cheesecake & butterfinger.We did not get to try the floats (pictured) but we really wanted to!
September 02 · Emily Evans
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

11171 PA-287, Middlebury Center, PA 16935, USA

2744 PA-660, Wellsboro, PA 16901, USA

1817 N Williamson Rd, Covington, PA 16917, USA

2206 S Main St, Mansfield, PA 16933, USA

10 W Wellsboro St, Mansfield, PA 16933, USA

315 E Main St, Westfield, PA 16950, USA

130 W Main St, Westfield, PA 16950, USA

PA-287, Tioga, PA 16946, USA

4 W Main St suite 2, Galeton, PA 16922, USA

210 Division Alley, Ralston, PA 17763, USA

20 Main St, Addison, NY 14801, USA

21270 PA-14 N, Troy, PA 16947, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





