The Tasty Freeze

Hello, Indiana! If you're looking for a classic, community-focused spot that truly delivers on both sweet treats and savory delights, then you absolutely "must try" The Tasty Freeze, located right here in Montezuma. This charming establishment isn't just an ice cream shop; it's a nostalgic local favorite that brings together the best of a classic American roadside stand with a dedicated focus on quality and flavor. As one delighted customer from Lafayette enthused, they "would travel back for it!" This speaks volumes about the memorable experience awaiting you. Whether you're craving a cold, refreshing ice cream concoction or a perfectly crispy side, The Tasty Freeze offers a delightful escape from the everyday.

At The Tasty Freeze, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that caters to all appetites. From indulgent ice cream creations to their much-loved French fries, the food here is often described as "off-the-charts fantastic." Imagine a "banana split shake" that hits all the right notes, or a "bowl full of peanut butter ice cream with hot fudge" that’s both cold and refreshing. The flavors to pick from are extensive, ensuring that everyone in your group finds something to love. Beyond the delicious food, The Tasty Freeze embodies a nostalgic feel, decorated with signs reminiscent of the 1950s and '60s, creating a fun, retro atmosphere. We understand that sometimes, there might be a "quick moment" wait, especially when we're busy, but as customers attest, it's "worth the small wait" for the quality you receive. We're proud to be a part of the Montezuma community, serving up happiness one delicious order at a time, and we can't wait to welcome you!

The Tasty Freeze is conveniently located at 481 E Crawford St, Montezuma, IN 47862, USA. This prime location places us right in the heart of Montezuma, making us easily accessible for residents within the town and surrounding areas of Indiana. East Crawford Street is a central thoroughfare, ensuring straightforward navigation to our beloved shop. Located just a few miles outside Rockville, IN, in Parke County, it's often one of the first things you'll see as you enter Montezuma, situated right across the street from the local baseball diamonds. This makes it an ideal stop after a game or for a casual drive.

The accessibility of our shop is a key aspect of our commitment to serving the local community. The Tasty Freeze operates as a walk-up or drive-through establishment, providing convenient options for ordering and pick-up. While specific parking details aren't explicitly provided, roadside establishments like ours typically offer convenient parking spaces to accommodate visitors. Our aim is to make your visit as smooth and enjoyable as possible, allowing you to quickly immerse yourself in our fun, nostalgic atmosphere and savor your chosen treat. The inviting exterior and prominent location make The Tasty Freeze an easy landmark to spot, drawing you in for a truly delightful and refreshing break. We strive to be a convenient and welcoming spot for all your sweet and savory cravings in Montezuma.

• Wide Variety of Ice Cream Treats: The Tasty Freeze offers an extensive selection of ice cream options, including soft serve and hand-dipped ice cream. Customers praise the "great" flavors to pick from.
• Specialty Ice Cream Creations: Unique and indulgent ice cream options are available, such as the "banana split shake" and custom bowls like "peanut butter ice cream with hot fudge."
• Sundaes, Shakes, and More: Beyond cones and cups, the menu includes classic sundaes, rich shakes, malts, and "Freezee" concoctions (blended ice cream with mix-ins like Snickers or Oreo). They also offer "Boston Shakes" (any shake with any sundae on top).
• Savory Food Menu: Unlike many ice cream shops, The Tasty Freeze also offers a full menu of savory food items. This includes "French fries" (praised for being "so crisp and so good" and generous in portion), burgers (made with "fresh daily" hand-pressed beef), Coney dogs (including a "Bacon Coney Dog Delight"), breaded pork tenderloins (hand-breaded fresh), hot dogs, sandwiches, and kids' meals.
• "Off-the-Charts Fantastic" Food Quality: Many customers rave about the exceptional quality of both the ice cream and the food, describing it as "off-the-charts fantastic."
• Generous Portions: Whether it's the "bowl full of peanut butter ice cream" or the "lot of fries," customers note the generous portion sizes, offering great value.
• Walk-Up and Drive-Through Service: The establishment offers convenient service options, allowing customers to order and pick up either by walking up to the window or using the drive-through.

• Diverse Menu Offering Both Ice Cream and Savory Food: A significant highlight is the extensive menu that combines classic ice cream shop fare with a full range of hot food items like burgers, Coney dogs, and especially their "fantastic" and "so good" French fries. This makes it a complete dining destination.
• Exceptional Ice Cream Quality and Variety: Customers consistently praise the "cold and refreshing" ice cream, noting the "great" flavors and delicious specialty items like the "banana split shake" and peanut butter creations. The ice cream is soft served, allowing for many flavor combinations.
• Generous Portions: Whether it's a large serving of ice cream or a "lot of fries," the generous portions are a highly appreciated feature, offering great value for money.
• Nostalgic and Fun Atmosphere: The shop boasts a nostalgic feel with decor reminiscent of the 1950s and '60s, creating a charming and inviting environment that adds to the overall experience.
• Commitment to Freshness (for food items): For its savory offerings, The Tasty Freeze emphasizes fresh ingredients, with hamburgers purchased and hand-pressed daily, and breaded pork tenderloins hand-breaded fresh. This dedication to freshness elevates the quality of their food.
• Local Landmark and Destination: The Tasty Freeze is recognized as a place people "would travel back for," even from other towns like Lafayette, highlighting its status as a significant local attraction and a worthwhile destination in Western Indiana. It's featured on the "Just Cruisin, Tenderloin Lovers and I Scream for Ice Cream Trails."
• Family-Oriented Business: Having been run by the same family since 2001 (over fifteen years), there's a clear commitment to serving the community and creating a delightful experience for guests.

To indulge in the fantastic ice cream and savory treats at The Tasty Freeze, or for any inquiries, please use the following contact information:

Address: 481 E Crawford St, Montezuma, IN 47862, USA

Phone: (765) 245-2887

The Tasty Freeze is an outstanding choice for locals in Montezuma, Indiana, and indeed for anyone in the surrounding areas of Western Indiana, offering a unique blend of nostalgic charm and satisfying culinary delights. Its convenient location on 481 E Crawford St makes it a highly accessible and recognizable landmark, situated right across from the local baseball diamonds, making it a perfect stop for families and sports enthusiasts. For a community that appreciates local institutions, The Tasty Freeze, with its decades of history under family ownership, truly fits the bill.

What truly sets The Tasty Freeze apart and makes it so suitable for locals is its dual appeal: fantastic ice cream alongside equally delicious hot food. Unlike many ice cream-only establishments, the ability to get a "banana split shake" or a "bowl full of peanut butter ice cream with hot fudge" and pair it with "off-the-charts fantastic" and "so crisp and so good" French fries provides a complete meal solution. The generous portions for both sweet and savory items ensure great value, satisfying even the heartiest appetites. This versatility means it can be a go-to spot for a quick snack, a full meal, or a delightful dessert, fitting seamlessly into various local routines.

Despite occasional busy periods and waits, the overwhelming sentiment is that the quality of the food and ice cream makes it "worth the small wait." The nostalgic, 1950s/60s-themed decor adds to the charm, creating a fun and memorable atmosphere that reinforces its status as a beloved local hangout. The fact that customers "would travel back for it" from places like Lafayette highlights its reputation and the unique experience it offers. For Hoosiers seeking a quintessential small-town eatery that delivers on deliciousness, portion size, and a welcoming, family-friendly vibe, The Tasty Freeze is undoubtedly the perfect choice, ready to create cherished memories for years to come.

The Tasty Freeze

481 E Crawford St, Montezuma, IN 47862, USA