The Yard Milkshake Bar Columbus: Your Guide to Viral Desserts

The Yard Milkshake Bar Introduce

In the bustling heart of Columbus, Ohio, a dessert destination has been captivating the attention of locals and visitors alike with its larger-than-life creations. The Yard Milkshake Bar, a nationally recognized brand thanks to its appearance on the popular TV show Shark Tank, brings a unique and visually spectacular approach to the world of ice cream and milkshakes. Located in the vibrant Short North district, this shop isn't for the faint of heart or those counting calories; it's a place to indulge in colossal, over-the-top desserts that are as much a feast for the eyes as they are for the taste buds.

The concept behind The Yard is simple yet brilliant: take a classic milkshake or sundae and turn it into a decadent work of art. Each creation is piled high with a dizzying array of toppings, from full slices of cheesecake and brownies to cupcakes and edible cookie dough. A customer who visited after seeing it on TikTok described the experience as a fun and memorable one, noting that the "viral milkshakes" were "absolutely delicious and gave us a massive sugar rush." The sheer size and creative presentation of these desserts are a major draw, making a visit to The Yard a highly sought-after experience for many in the Columbus area.

Beyond the show-stopping milkshakes, The Yard offers a variety of other sweet treats. A five-star review highlighted the "delightful masterpiece" of the Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae, which was praised for its "perfect blend of rich cheesecake ice cream, topped with fresh strawberries and a swirl of whipped cream." The review also noted the "stunning" presentation and the friendly, attentive staff who made the visit enjoyable. While the popular milkshakes are a significant investment at around $18 each, they come with a bonus: the branded glass mason jar they are served in is a souvenir for you to take home. This adds an extra layer of value and makes the experience feel even more special and unique.

However, it's important to be prepared for the popularity of this viral sensation. One customer mentioned that when they arrived, the place was "incredibly busy," and they had to wait 30 minutes just to place their order. Their entire visit, from ordering to leaving, took about two hours, which was "definitely not what I was expecting." This suggests that a visit to The Yard is best planned when you have plenty of time and patience. To make the most of the experience, one customer recommended a strategy for tackling the massive dessert: "Drink as much of the milkshake as you can and then scoop all the toppings and sugary goodness into the glass." They also appreciated the convenient station provided to clean up the souvenir glass before leaving, a thoughtful feature for such a messy, decadent treat.

Location and Accessibility

The Yard Milkshake Bar is located at 1055 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA. This is a prime location in the city's Short North neighborhood, a lively and trendy area known for its art galleries, boutiques, and diverse dining scene. The store’s position on North High Street makes it easily accessible for people coming from all over Columbus and surrounding communities.

The Short North is a highly walkable area, and the store is a great destination to visit as part of a larger outing. For those driving, there are various parking options available in the vicinity, including street parking and nearby public lots, though it's important to be mindful of parking meters and time limits. Its central location also makes it accessible via Columbus's public transit system, offering a convenient way for both locals and tourists to get to this popular dessert spot.

Services Offered

Over-the-Top Milkshakes: The main attraction, featuring a wide range of creative and elaborate milkshakes with a huge variety of toppings.
Custom Sundaes: Build your own sundae with your favorite ice cream flavors and toppings, or choose from their pre-designed options like the Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae.
Souvenir Jars: Many of the specialty desserts are served in branded glass mason jars that customers get to keep as a souvenir.
Take-Out and Delivery: For those who prefer to enjoy their treats at home, The Yard offers online ordering for both pickup and delivery through services like DoorDash.
Edible Cookie Dough: The menu also includes delicious, ready-to-eat cookie dough that is safe to consume raw, available in various flavors.

Features / Highlights

Social Media Phenomenon: The Yard's desserts are designed to be "Instagram-worthy," attracting customers who are eager to share photos of their stunning creations.
Wide Variety of Toppings: The extensive selection of toppings, from full-sized cupcakes and slices of cheesecake to brownies and a variety of candies, allows for endless customization.
Keepsake Jars: The ability to take home the branded mason jar adds a unique value to the experience and serves as a memorable memento.
Customer Experience: One review highlighted the friendly and attentive staff who "offered recommendations and ensuring that my experience was nothing short of perfect."
Vibrant Atmosphere: The store is noted for its "vibrant atmosphere" and "clean and inviting environment," making it a fun place to visit.

Contact Information

Address: 1055 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

Phone: (614) 549-7952

Mobile Phone: +1 614-549-7952

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For the residents of Columbus and the surrounding Ohio area, The Yard Milkshake Bar is the perfect destination for a special occasion or a truly unforgettable treat. Its location in the lively Short North district makes it an ideal spot to visit before or after exploring the neighborhood’s many other attractions. While it may require a bit of a wait, the experience is designed to be a memorable event, not just a quick stop. This makes it particularly suitable for families looking for a fun outing or for friends wanting to share an over-the-top dessert adventure.

The creative and massive portions, coupled with the unique souvenir jars, offer a high-value experience that goes beyond a standard ice cream cone. It’s a place where you can indulge your inner child and truly "seize the yay." While the price point may be higher than a typical ice cream shop, the quality, size, and novelty of the desserts justify the cost for many, as it’s often seen as a special treat rather than an everyday purchase. For Ohioans looking to try something new, delicious, and highly Instagrammable, The Yard Milkshake Bar provides an unparalleled dessert experience that is well worth the visit.

The Yard Milkshake Bar Menu

Ice Cream Pint
Ice Cream Pint Jar US$18.00
A full pint of our delicious ice cream served in one of our souvenir glass jars. Select up to 2 flavors!

Cookie Dough Jars
Cookies 'N Cream US$18.00
Our Cookies N' Cream Dough features sweet white sugar dough with piles of crushed chocolate sandwich cookies mixed in. Indulging in the classics never tasted so good!
Salty Caramel Chip US$18.00
Salty Caramel dough paired with caramel ripple and sprinkled with chocolate chips throughout. There's no need to pick between savory and sweet with this dough!
Birthday Dunk A Dough US$18.00
Birthday Dunk A Dough features a birthday dough base with a mixture of vanilla icing, sprinkles, and teddy grahams! Celebrate your birthday all year round with this flavor.
M&M Sugar Cookie US$18.00
Our M&M Dough features a sugar cookie dough base with mini M&M's mixed in, making for simple layers with a taste you know and love!
Chocolate Chip US$18.00
Nothing is better than a Chocolate Chip Cookie... except, Chocolate Chip Cookie DOUGH! Our specialty dough features Hersheys Chocolate Chips in a brown sugar cookie dough base. Consider your sweet tooth thoroughly satisfied!
Chocolate Cookie Craze US$18.00
Chocolate Cookie Craze boasts a chocolate dough base layered with a mixture of chocolate chips and Oreo pieces. Chocolate lovers will find themselves quickly falling for this layered creation!
Oatmeal Dream Pie Dough US$18.00
This dreamy flavor features a cinnamon sugar dough base, marshmallow drizzle throughout, and layers of Oatmeal Cream Pie pieces.
Peanut Butter Monster US$18.00
Peanut Butter Cookie Monster and peanut butter dough make up this specialty blend cookie dough, beautifully layered with Butterfinger pieces, Reese Pieces, M&M's and peanut butter cups. Candy fans, it's your chance to mix some of the classics!

Premium Toppings
Chocolate Chip Cookie (Vegan) US$3.00
You don’t have to compromise your stomach with this chocolate chip cookie, it’s all vegan and all delicious!
Cupcake US$3.00
Soft and perfectly fluffy, add this cupcake as a supporting actor to your shake, or on the side for extra sweetness!
Chocolate Dipped S'more US$3.00
As if a s'more couldn't get any better, we've dipped it in chocolate and sealed the gooey goodness all together!
Fruity Pebbles Treat US$3.00
Perfectly molded with marshmallows and Fruity Pebbles, it doesn't have to be breakfast to add this sweet treat to your order!
Brownie US$3.00
Chocolate lovers will enjoy the addition of this brownie, either with their sweet treat or saved for later to be eaten on its own.
Cheesecake US$3.00
Creamy and decadent, this is the perfect add-on to get a bit of savory and sweet!

Milkshakes
Quart Milkshake (32oz) US$18.00
Try something new, something blue, or something true to you whatever you're looking for, we've got a flavor for you. With 27 flavors to choose from ranging from the classics to the carefully crafted, a blend of perfect flavors awaits you!
Pint Shakes (16oz) US$13.00
Try something new, something blue, or something true to you whatever you're looking for, we've got a flavor for you. With 27 flavors to choose from ranging from the classics to the carefully crafted, a blend of perfect flavors awaits you!

Drinks
Diet Coke US$3.00
20oz Diet Coke in a plastic bottle.
Water US$3.00
Bottled water.
Sprite US$3.00
20oz Sprite in a plastic bottle.
Coke US$3.00
20oz Coca-Cola in a plastic bottle.

Merch
Souvenir Jar US$5.00
Add an extra (empty) souvenir glass mason jar to your collection!

Cookie Dough Pops
Cookies N' Cream US$5.00
Our Cookies N' Cream Dough cookie dough gets dipped in white chocolate before being sprinkled with Oreos and drizzled with chocolate almond bark.
Salty Caramel Chip US$5.00
Our specialty Salty Caramel Chip cookie dough gets dipped in milk chocolate before being sprinkled all over with chocolate shavings.
M&M Sugar Cookie US$5.00
Our M&M sugar cookie dough base is dipped in milk chocolate then topped with M&M's.
Birthday Dunk A Dough US$5.00
Birthday Dunk A Dough features a birthday dough base, deliciously dipped in white chocolate then topped with birthday sprinkles.
Chocolate Chip US$5.00
Our specialty dough is carefully crafted, dipped in milk chocolate, and then sprinkled with chocolate chips.
Peanut Butter Monster US$5.00
Our Peanut Butter Monster cookie dough is dipped in white chocolate then dressed with M&M pieces.
Chocolate Cookie Craze US$5.00
Chocolate Cookie Craze contains a chocolate dough base that is dipped in milk chocolate before being sprinkled with Oreo pieces.
Oatmeal Dream Pie US$5.00
Oatmeal Dream Pie cookie dough is created by mixing cinnamon and white sugar, dipped in white chocolate, and delicately sprinkled with cinnamon sugar.

Layered Sundaes
Peanut Butter Brownie Bliss US$21.00
Made exclusively for The Yard, Fudgy Brownie Sundae ice cream: Chocolate brownie batter ice cream with fudge brownies and a chocolate sundae sauce; layered with peanut butter and a chocolate chip brownie. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert, perfect for those who like a rich and creamy treat!
Milk & Cookies US$21.00
A Blue Bell Classic, Homemade Vanilla ice cream: rich, homemade-tasting vanilla ice cream with a special hand-cranked flavor; layered with a chewy chocolate chip cookie. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert for those who love the nostalgia of bedtime!
Birthday Cake US$21.00
Cake Batter ice cream: Yellow cake batter ice cream that tastes just like licking the batter straight off the spoon; layered with birthday sprinkles and a cupcake. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert that makes every day your birthday -- well, the taste anyway!
Mint Brownie Mudslide US$21.00
Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream: Refreshing, creamy mint ice cream sprinkled with delicious dark chocolate flavored chips, layered with a chocolate chip brownie and chocolate drizzle. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert meant for those who always claim mint chocolate chip as their favorite ice cream!
Strawberries & Cream Cheesecake US$21.00
Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream: Rich cheesecake ice cream with cheesecake pieces, succulent strawberries and swirls of delicious strawberry sundae sauce; layered with a slice of New York cheesecake and strawberry drizzle. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert, for those who like to keep it classic yet elevated!
Cookie Monster US$21.00
Blue Monster : A rockin' blue vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of chocolate creme cookies and chocolate chip cookie dough pieces; layered with chewy chocolate Chips Ahoy cookies. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert beautifully created for every cookie lover!
Unicorn US$21.00
Cotton Candy ice cream: A delicious cotton candy flavored ice cream in shades of pink and blue; layered with a chocolate and sprinkle dipped waffle cone. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert to bring the flavors of the county fair right to you!
Cereal Killer US$21.00
Exclusively made for The Yard, White Chocolate Marshmallow ice cream: marshmallow ice cream with marshmallow swirl and white chocolate flavored chunks; layered with Fruity Pebbles and a Fruity Pebble treat. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert crafted for those who like breakfast all times of the day!
Salted Caramel Cheesecake US$21.00
Sea Salt Caramel ice cream: A creamy vanilla ice cream surrounded by a tasty salted caramel sauce swirl; layered with a slice of New York cheesecake and caramel drizzle. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert for those who like a little bit of savory with their sweet!
Pralines & Dream US$21.00
Flawlessly blended Pecan Pralines 'n Cream ice cream: a combination of praline sauce swirled into a creamy vanilla ice cream sprinkled with praline-coated pecans, and Buttered Pecan ice cream: a rich, butter pecan ice cream with lightly salted, roasted pecan halves; layered with Salty Caramel Chip edible cookie dough. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert for the pecan lover in you!
Cookie Dough Delicious US$21.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie dough ice cream: A rich, creamy ice cream with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough and chips of dark chocolate; layered with chocolate chip cookie dough. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert to safely fulfill your desire to eat cookie dough!
Ultimate OREO® Sundae US$21.00
Originally created by Blue Bell, before anyone else, Cookies 'n Cream ice cream: A creamy vanilla ice cream with tasty chunks of chocolate crème filled cookies; layered with OREO® cookie pieces. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert for those that can appreciate a perfect blend of iconic flavors!
S'mores US$21.00
A blend of Milk Chocolate ice cream: A creamy, smooth milk chocolate ice cream made with a premium cocoa, fresh milk and cream, and The Yard's exclusive flavor, White Chocolate Marshmallow ice cream: marshmallow ice cream with marshmallow swirl and white chocolate flavored chunks layered with a chocolate dipped s'more. Served in a reusable, branded The Yard Milkshake Bar mason jar. A delicious layered sundae dessert to bring back memories of camping and summer nights!

The Yard Milkshake Bar Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Dining options
Table service

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
Family friendly
Groups

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Children
Good for kids

The Yard Milkshake Bar Photos

The Yard Milkshake Bar Location

The Yard Milkshake Bar

Ohio Franklin County Columbus Victorian Village North High Street

1055 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

The Yard Milkshake Bar Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 474 user reviews.

jarcookie doughpresentationsundaewhipped creamglassbrowniebowlcheesecake milkshakesouvenir

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I saw this place on TikTok and just had to add it to our itinerary! When we arrived, it was incredibly busy, and they informed us there would be a 30-minute wait just to place an order. That’s the only reason I didn’t give it a full 5 stars. We decided to stick it out, and by the time we ordered, enjoyed our milkshakes, and left, two hours had flown by—definitely not what I was expecting!We tried the viral milkshakes, which were about $18 each—but you get to keep the glass as a souvenir! They were absolutely delicious and gave us a massive sugar rush. There’s even a station where you can clean up your glass before leaving since things can get a little messy.My recommendation? Drink as much of the milkshake as you can and then scoop all the toppings and sugary goodness into the glass. Be sure to clean off the sides before you head out!If we were to visit again, I wouldn’t wait 30 minutes just to place an order. I’d go for a normal-sized ice cream or milkshake instead, but it was definitely a fun and memorable experience!
April 25 · Abi E. E.
Sure! Here’s the revised 5-star review featuring the Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae:---⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️I recently visited The Yard Milkshake Bar, and it was an unforgettable experience! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere filled with the tantalizing aroma of freshly made treats. The menu is a dream come true for any dessert lover, offering an incredible variety of milkshakes piled high with toppings, but I decided to try the Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae, and it was a delightful masterpiece!The sundae was a perfect blend of rich cheesecake ice cream, topped with fresh strawberries and a swirl of whipped cream. Each bite was like a slice of heaven, combining the creamy texture of cheesecake with the sweetness of ripe strawberries. The presentation was stunning, served in an oversized cup that made it even more enjoyable to indulge!The staff were friendly and attentive, offering recommendations and ensuring that my experience was nothing short of perfect. I also appreciated the clean and inviting environment, which made my visit all themore enjoyable.If you’re looking for a fun place to satisfy your sweet tooth, The Yard Milkshake Bar is a must-visit. I can’t wait to go back and try more flavors! Highly recommend!---Let me know if you need any more changes!
April 19 · JOSHUA Edmondson
Wow they pack the cups full! Kids love it and ice cream is good! I think the best was the Bowl Cookie Dough Delicious! We also tried the Dipped and Whipped Peanut Butter Monster it was ok and the Salty Caramel Chip that was good. The place was kind of empty when we got there maybe 3 orders ahead of us and it took about 1/2 hour to get our order. Not a lot of room for a big group. We sat at 2 different Tables. No biggie though. The bathrooms are nasty 🤢
March 28 · jodi ferguson
This poor poor guy was all alone and HUSTLING. I’m not sure why they are so understaffed and why on one of the warmest days so far this spring they would only schedule one person to work. We waited a good hour the place was packed. This worker did his absolute best handling all of the rude customers and the busy rush. He was extremely kind and efficient. He did the absolute best that he could. The ice cream was great! I hope they can get more staff!
April 18 · Bryanna Taylor
Instead of a cake, I wanted a milkshake for my birthday, and decided to get something special. We arrived right after they opened to avoid it being busy. The people were friendly and the shakes were great - a perfect birthday treat!
May 17 · Linde Bowers