Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream

In the historic and vibrant city of Akron, Ohio, a unique and storied establishment has served the community for decades, offering a delightful combination of fine Italian cuisine and classic ice cream. This place is Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream, a local institution with a rich history that dates back to 1937. It is a one-of-a-kind destination that marries the legacy of Mary Coyle's famous ice cream with the authentic Italian recipes of the Trecaso family. This blend of traditions creates an experience that is both nostalgic and delicious, making it a true gem in the heart of Akron. For many locals, it is a place filled with personal history, a spot they have been visiting for years to get their favorite treats. The establishment is a testament to the enduring appeal of quality food and a genuine sense of community. Its reputation is built on a foundation of homemade recipes and a commitment to maintaining the high standards set by its founders. Trecaso’s Mary Coyle offers a dining experience unlike any other, where you can enjoy a hearty Italian meal and then cap it off with some of the best ice cream you've ever had. This duality is a major part of its charm and what makes it a must-visit destination for anyone in the Akron area. It is a place that feels deeply rooted in its location, a cornerstone of local culture and culinary tradition.

The establishment's history is a significant part of its identity. Originally a small lunch counter, Mary Coyle grew into a beloved institution before being purchased by Michael Trecaso in 1987. Having worked there as a teenager, Trecaso brought with him his family's Italian recipes, eventually merging his Italian restaurant with the Mary Coyle location. This pivotal moment in 1996 created the unique combination that exists today. This long and storied past, combined with a dedication to making fresh ice cream daily, sets Trecaso’s Mary Coyle apart from other eateries. The menu is a delightful journey through Italian classics and old-fashioned ice cream creations. While the Italian food, including their award-winning pizza and spaghetti, receives a lot of praise, the ice cream is an undeniable highlight. Customers have raved about specific flavors, such as the "BEST coffee-flavored ice cream we’ve ever had," which speaks to the quality and unique taste of their homemade products. However, the customer experience can sometimes be mixed. While some patrons have had fantastic experiences filled with history from the owner, others have reported negative interactions and perceived rudeness, particularly in relation to dining-in policies with outside food. It's clear that the establishment has a distinct and traditional approach to its operations. Despite some polarizing feedback, the quality of the ice cream and the historical significance of the place remain major draws for many in the community who cherish its unique character and flavor.

Trecaso's Mary Coyle is located at 780 W Market St, Akron, OH 44303, USA, a prime location in the city's Highland Square neighborhood. This position makes it a well-known and easily accessible destination for residents and visitors. The area is a hub of local activity, and the restaurant's presence on West Market Street ensures high visibility and convenient access. For those traveling by car, its location on a major road makes it simple to find, and there is likely parking available nearby, though a customer review mentioned issues with parking and towing in the past, which is something to be mindful of. The ability to find this local gem is a key factor in its appeal, as it feels both central and like a hidden treasure. The surrounding neighborhood is rich with other local businesses, making it a great spot to visit as part of a larger outing. Its long history in Highland Square has made it a community landmark, a place that is deeply woven into the fabric of local life. For many in the area, the address itself conjures up images of delicious ice cream and memorable meals. This geographical rootedness is a major part of its charm, making it feel less like a commercial business and more like a cherished part of the neighborhood’s identity. The accessibility of the location, combined with its unique offerings, ensures that Trecaso’s Mary Coyle remains a destination for anyone seeking a taste of Akron’s culinary history.

The physical space itself, with its classic, old-fashioned diner aesthetic, further enhances the customer experience. The interior feels like a step back in time, providing a cozy and nostalgic environment to enjoy a meal or a dessert. The distinct signage and exterior also make it a memorable building that is hard to miss. Its location on West Market Street makes it a convenient and well-trafficked spot, drawing in a steady stream of customers who are either passing by or making a specific trip to the legendary establishment. This combination of a unique physical presence and a central location makes it a true anchor of the Highland Square neighborhood. Its accessibility and recognizable nature are key features that contribute to its enduring popularity and its status as a local institution. The location is not just an address; it is a key element of the establishment's storied identity and a major reason why it continues to be a go-to spot for so many in Akron.

Trecaso's Mary Coyle offers a dual-service model that includes a full menu of Italian cuisine and an extensive selection of ice cream and dessert items. The offerings are designed to cater to a wide audience with a focus on homemade quality. Key services and offerings include:

• A variety of homemade ice cream flavors, including highly-praised options like coffee.
• A full menu of fine Italian cuisine, with award-winning sauces and classic dishes like spaghetti and pizza.
• A wide selection of sundaes, banana bowls, showboats, milkshakes, and old-fashioned sodas.
• Specialty ice cream items like the "Hot Tin Roof" and "The Original" banana bowl.
• A dessert counter that also offers a selection of candies and other treats.
• An environment that is both a classic diner and an Italian restaurant, offering a unique and versatile dining experience.
• A long-standing history that provides a sense of nostalgia and tradition to every visit.
• Options for both dine-in and takeout, though some customer experiences with dine-in policies may be unique.

The highlights and features of Trecaso's Mary Coyle are what make it a beloved destination in the Akron community. Based on customer reviews and public data, these are the standout elements that contribute to its unique appeal. Here are some of the most notable features:

• The Best Coffee-Flavored Ice Cream: A specific and highly enthusiastic review highlights the "BEST coffee-flavored ice cream we’ve ever had," indicating the exceptional quality of their homemade flavors.
• Rich History and Tradition: The establishment’s deep roots in Akron, dating back to 1937, and the history shared by the owner, are major highlights for many patrons who appreciate the legacy behind the business.
• Unique Combination of Italian Food and Ice Cream: The ability to enjoy fine Italian cuisine and then a scoop of classic ice cream all in one place is a distinct and highly valued feature.
• Old-Fashioned Vibe: The classic "soda fountain" and "diner" feel, complete with a counter of candies, provides a nostalgic experience that is hard to find elsewhere.
• Generous Menu: The extensive menu, from pizzas and pastas to a wide variety of sundaes and banana bowls, ensures that there is a vast selection for every customer.
• Family-Owned Legacy: The business is owned by the Trecaso family, which has a long history with the Mary Coyle brand, giving it a personal touch and a deep connection to the community.

For more information or to place an order, Trecaso's Mary Coyle is located at 780 W Market St, Akron, OH 44303, USA. You can contact them by phone at (330) 253-1511. The mobile phone number is also listed as +1 330-253-1511. This direct contact information makes it easy for customers to inquire about menu items, hours, or any other questions they may have. The physical address is a well-known spot in the Highland Square neighborhood, making it simple for both new and returning visitors to find their way. Whether you're calling ahead for a takeout order or planning a dine-in experience, the team at Trecaso’s is ready to serve you. The accessibility of the contact information and location ensures that this historic local gem is always within reach for the Akron community.

In conclusion, Trecaso's Mary Coyle is an essential local spot for anyone in the Akron, Ohio area. Its combination of a rich, decades-long history, a unique blend of fine Italian cuisine and classic homemade ice cream, and an old-fashioned atmosphere makes it a truly special destination. For locals, it's more than a restaurant; it’s a living piece of Akron history, a place where generations have enjoyed meals and desserts. The exceptional quality of the ice cream, highlighted by specific customer praise, is a major reason for its enduring appeal. While the establishment may have unique policies, its commitment to tradition and flavor is undeniable. For anyone in Akron seeking a culinary experience that is both delicious and steeped in local lore, Trecaso's Mary Coyle is a must-visit. It is a place that offers a taste of the past and a flavor for the present, making it a cherished and irreplaceable part of the community.

Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream

780 W Market St, Akron, OH 44303, USA