Village Creamery & Sweetshop

In the heart of Valhalla, New York, a local gem has been serving up sweet treats for over a decade. Village Creamery & Sweetshop, established in 2014 by husband and wife team John and Kristin Caldarola, quickly became a go-to spot for residents of all ages. The couple, both deeply involved in the Valhalla community, transformed the space, which once housed the Mount Pleasant Public Library, into a brightly colored store reminiscent of a classic sweet shop. The creamery's core mission is to provide high-quality, homemade ice cream and other delightful desserts in a welcoming and friendly environment. John Caldarola, an avid cook, took on the role of ice cream maker, creating an array of delicious flavors based on his original vanilla recipe. Their commitment to using natural ingredients and avoiding artificial coloring has earned them a strong reputation. The shop has even been recognized for its quality, winning the "DVlicious 'Best Ice Cream In Westchester'" title. This article will provide a comprehensive overview of Village Creamery & Sweetshop, detailing its location, diverse menu, and the features that make it a cherished part of the local landscape. It's a place where families can create traditions, and neighbors can enjoy a moment of indulgence, whether it's a hot summer day or a chilly winter evening.

The story of Village Creamery is deeply rooted in its community. Owners John and Kristin Caldarola, both from the area, wanted to create a business that would be a natural attraction in Valhalla. With Kristin having served as co-president of the Valhalla School District's PTA and both serving on the board of the Kensico Little League, they had strong ties to the community before they even opened their doors. This connection has been a key factor in the shop's success, with a host of local support from the very beginning. The business's focus on homemade, natural products has always been a point of pride. John Caldarola has become an expert at crafting a wide variety of flavors, from classic vanilla and chocolate to more creative concoctions like Captain Crunchberry and "Let's do Brunch," which features a maple base with French toast pieces and bacon. While the shop is celebrated for its ice cream, it has also expanded its menu to include a range of other sweet and savory items, ensuring it can be a year-round destination for locals. This evolution from a simple ice cream shop to a comprehensive sweetshop demonstrates the owners' dedication to meeting the needs of their customers and continuing to be a valuable part of the Valhalla community. The shop's history and its commitment to quality and local involvement are what make it a beloved institution for many residents.

Village Creamery & Sweetshop is located at 32 Broadway in Valhalla, NY 10595. This central location places it in the heart of the village, making it a convenient destination for residents and visitors alike. Broadway is a main street in Valhalla, and the shop's position makes it a popular stop for those walking through the area. One of the most convenient aspects of its location is its proximity to other local establishments. As one customer noted, it is a "dessert stop after eating at Valhalla Crossing across the street." Valhalla Crossing is a unique American restaurant located in the historic Valhalla train station, making the combination of dinner and a dessert from Village Creamery a popular local outing. The shop's location on Broadway is easily accessible by car, and there is parking available, although it may be busy at peak times. The walkability of the area is also a major benefit, allowing families and friends to enjoy a leisurely stroll to the creamery. This prime location, coupled with its proximity to other local businesses, helps to make Village Creamery & Sweetshop a natural part of the local routine for many residents.

Village Creamery & Sweetshop offers a diverse and extensive menu that goes beyond simple scoops of ice cream. Their offerings are designed to cater to a wide range of tastes and cravings, from traditional frozen desserts to more unique and modern treats. The staff is known for being friendly and efficient, ensuring that the service is "super fast" even on busy days.

• Homemade ice cream in a large variety of rotating flavors, from classics to unique creations.
• Soft serve ice cream, available as a standalone item.
• Made-from-scratch sweet crepes and Belgian waffles.
• Italian ices, available in various flavors and sizes.
• Acai bowls with a variety of toppings.
• A selection of hot and cold beverages, including coffee, teas, lattes, and specialty hot cocoas.
• Penny candy by the pound and a variety of other nostalgic candies.
• Hand-packed pints and quarts of ice cream to take home.

Village Creamery & Sweetshop is known for several key features that contribute to its standing as a local favorite. The primary highlight is their homemade ice cream, which is made in-house and without artificial coloring. This commitment to quality and a personal touch is a major draw for customers. The variety of flavors is also a significant feature, with a constantly rotating selection that keeps the menu fresh and exciting. Another standout feature is their menu diversity. The shop is not just an ice cream parlor; it's a sweetshop that offers everything from crepes and Belgian waffles to Italian ices and acai bowls. This wide range of options ensures that everyone in a group can find something they love, regardless of their preference. A customer review highlighted the "amazing" service from specific staff members, such as Michele, Evelyn, and Emily, who were praised for their speed and friendliness. The shop's location directly across from Valhalla Crossing is a great feature for locals, as it makes the creamery a natural dessert stop after dinner. The atmosphere of the shop is also a highlight. It has a charming, old-fashioned feel with a modern twist, which creates a welcoming and fun environment for people of all ages. While one customer noted some inconsistency with the freshness of the ice cream on a couple of occasions, they also mentioned that it was "always a reliable and consistent place to get good ice cream" in the past, showing that the shop has a strong history of quality that customers hope will continue.

For those who would like to get in touch with or visit the Village Creamery & Sweetshop, here is the essential contact information:

• Address: 32 Broadway, Valhalla, NY 10595, USA
• Phone: (914) 421-1300

For the residents of Valhalla, Village Creamery & Sweetshop is more than just a place to get dessert—it's a valued part of the community fabric. Its local ownership and deep roots in the area give it a personal touch that larger chains can't replicate. The shop's commitment to homemade, high-quality products is a major draw, providing a taste that is both familiar and special. The diverse menu, which includes ice cream, Italian ices, crepes, and more, makes it a versatile spot for any occasion. Its convenient location on Broadway, especially as a dessert stop after dining at Valhalla Crossing, has cemented its place in the local routine. Whether you're looking for a treat for a nightly outing, a place to take the kids, or just a sweet escape, Village Creamery & Sweetshop offers a welcoming environment and a delicious product. It's the kind of local business that fosters a sense of community and provides a charming experience that residents are proud to have in their town.

Village Creamery & Sweetshop

32 Broadway, Valhalla, NY 10595, USA